Pratique du Shadowing: Anna Lembke on Pleasure, Pain, and Recovery in a Dopamine-Driven World - Apprendre l'anglais à l'oral avec la vidéo

Choisissez un mode d'entraînement

Chaque mode ouvre une salle d'entraînement en plein écran.

510 phrases
Si les phrases sont trop courtes ou trop longues, cliquez sur Edit pour les ajuster.
1
Some platforms have been engineered to optimize clicking and scrolling independent of content.
2
Dr. Anna Lembke is a psychiatrist and professor at Stanford
3
and one of the leading voices helping us understand addiction in the modern world.
4
Many people with very severe addictions can get into recovery at every stage of life
5
and sustain that recovery for years to decades.
6
As medical director of addiction medicine and author of the best -selling Dopamine Nation, She explores how our brains seek pleasure, why it's so easy to overdo it,
7
and what it takes to find balance.
8
The way that we tell our stories is really essential.
9
We can tell healing stories or we can tell stories that keep us stuck in our suffering.
10
In our conversation, she shares fresh insights on managing desire, discomfort, and the search for real joy.
11
Welcome to Stanford Department of Medicine's Inside Look at the Future of Medicine.
12
Anna, welcome to the future of medicine.
13
Thank you for inviting me.
14
I'm delighted to be here.
15
It's been amazing to see the ripples
16
that have happened after you gave the medical Grand Rounds just a week or two ago, and to hear people talk about the topics that you discussed.
17
And so it's really great to spend a few minutes just talking about it.
18
Oh, well, thank you.
19
Yes, I've had a number of people reach out to me who are at the Grand Rounds.
20
I've been able to meet with them, graduate students, medical students who are excited about the ideas
21
and want to contribute to helping people recover from addiction and the full range of compulsive overconsumption.
22
So that's been nice.
23
Dopamine Nation was such an amazing book, really landmark, but also very enjoyable and informative.
24
I love reading popular science books even better when they come from my colleagues here at Stanford.
25
And that one has had such an impact.
26
It is a very personal book as well.
27
It is, yes.
28
More so than many of the books that our colleagues write.
29
Yes, it is.
30
And I wondered, what led you to be kind of so open about your own life, even really from the beginning of the book?
31
Well, thank you for that question.
32
I think that's a really wonderful question.
33
You know, the book is an interweaving of science with patient stories
34
and I had to get permission from my patients to include their stories
35
and they were so generous in you know their willingness to talk about these very personal subjects
36
but I got to a point in kind of crafting the book where I realized
37
that on some level would be disingenuous
38
if I didn't also include you know my own experiences with addiction
39
and compulsive overconsumption So I sort of took a leap of faith
40
that people would be okay with me admitting to having these areas in which I lack self -control.
41
It's been wonderful to see how people have resonated with that and really appreciated sharing on that level.
42
I also think when you look at books written by doctors, there are so many wonderful books, including many of our colleagues.
43
But I have to say, many of them, like the physicians just seem so sort of saintly.
44
So I thought, maybe it's time for us to kind of admit, like, we've got problems too.
45
Yeah, we're real people too.
46
Yes, that's right.
47
And I think as a reader, it really, I mean, it draws us in immediately
48
and allows us to identify with you not just as the doctor
49
and the world expert in this area that we're interested in learning about, but as a human being.
50
And we all have these flaws and challenges.
51
And so it was really, I think, a moving part.
52
And you mentioned this really wonderful interweaving of science and patient stories.
53
That's hard to do.
54
And in particular, the stories that you tell, as you say, are very personal.
55
And the sorts of challenges, I mean, there's lots of medical books that talk about challenges maybe
56
that for things we talk about more often in the public domain cancer
57
and heart disease but your patients are telling you stories
58
that they probably have not told anyone else
59
and yet they've given you permission to share broadly so others can learn that that's just an amazing thing.
60
It is amazing and it's interesting
61
because you know they wanted to share their stories in many instances as a way to help other people
62
and I I found that incredibly moving.
63
And of course, what's very gratifying is that the book has been read by a lot of people
64
and has actually helped a lot of people.
65
I know that because I get scores of emails every day from readers all over the world,
66
readers who otherwise wouldn't have had access to some of the basic science about addiction,
67
but also just having this like.. de -shaming experience of realizing, wow, I'm not the only one struggling with this particular type of problem.
68
So, yeah, my patient's generosity has really transformed some people's lives, which is great.
69
Yeah.
70
You talk a bit in the book about radical honesty, and I wondered if that was also somewhat connected to the personal nature of the book,
71
in that you were feeling that such an important part of the recovery process
72
that it might also be an important part of your book writing process.
73
Yes, very true.
74
And thanks for jumping to radical honesty.
75
It comes in the latter half of the book and I don't often get asked about it.
76
But it's the idea that by committing to telling the truth about things large and small, we can improve our lives and the lives of other people.
77
It's actually hard to do that because the average adult tells about one to two lives per day.
78
I was trying to decide if that was me when you were writing that in the book.
79
Yeah, and you know it's usually little things that we kind of discount like false flattery
80
or just small ways that we cover up you know some selfishness
81
that we think is insignificant like why we were late for a meeting or why we can't go to a particular event.
82
But one pattern I kept seeing again
83
and again in my patients who were able to get into
84
sustained recovery from very severe addictions was this kind of commitment to radical honesty or what Alcoholics Anonymous calls rigorous honesty.
85
And I just found that absolutely fascinating.
86
And so I do explore that in the book.
87
But yes, you're right, this kind of telling my story
88
and patients being willing to tell their stories is in a way an homage to this idea
89
that by opening up and being transparent,
90
we're really better off and other people come closer, right?
91
We foster intimacy.
92
The danger is this sort of disclosure porn,
93
you know, that we just sort of try to use intimate stories to manipulate other people
94
or on social media to get followers or posts.
95
So, I mean, there's a potential dark side here.
96
But I think when we genuinely, you know, allow ourselves to be vulnerable with other people, the rewards are great.
97
And yet we're so terrified to do it.
98
To do it, yeah.
99
Yeah.
100
You mentioned Alcoholics Anonymous there.
101
It does recur in the book a little bit.
102
And I was really interested in coming to the book, sort of in a way where you would come down, or what the nuance was of your view,
103
coming from a scientist's perspective and a doctor's perspective of their program.
104
But in a way, maybe I was a little surprised how positive you were about many elements of it.
105
Yeah, so I'm not surprised that you're surprised, because we are living in an era of AA and 12 -step bashing,
106
and I'm not exactly sure why that is.
107
But, you know, 12 Steps, Alcoholics Anonymous, and all the offshoot groups have been around for almost 100 years now.
108
And it's evidence -based.
109
So there's a wonderful article by my dear friend and colleague, Keith Humphries, along with John Kelly from Harvard,
110
where they basically compared active participation in 12 Step groups like Alcoholics Anonymous to professionally mediated treatment
111
and found that they're really comparable.
112
And in fact, the longer you follow patients out, the better AA looks.
113
Really?
114
Yeah.
115
And there's even evidence that for the most severely addicted, AA may work the best.
116
Wow.
117
So, you know, of course it's not for everybody.
118
And of course you have to actively participate and engage in the program for it to work.
119
But we do know for those who actively participate, it can be incredibly effective even when they're mandated to participate,
120
which is also interesting.
121
So yes, it's evidence -based.
122
You can recommend it with confidence based on the evidence.
123
But just like all of our medical treatments, they're going to work for some people and not others.
124
There are many paths to the top of the mountain.
125
So it's good that people have access to many different types of treatment.
126
Yeah, I thought it was interesting that it lives sort of in the same world, that this mild skepticism lives in the same world as a knowledge
127
that there are people who are years out who are counting the days and can tell you how many days it's been.
128
That's also in the public domain and those two things almost don't quite add up, right?
129
What do you mean?
130
Well I think that whether it's characters on television
131
or people in the real world that there's this sense
132
that people who've been through a 12 -step program sort of
133
know to the day how many days they've been sober and they can recount.
134
So there's a sense that that's a commonly recurrent feature, there are people out there who've been very successful,
135
but at the same time that coexists with the sense that maybe there's a mild skepticism of the scientific basis of it, which I think you explode in the book,
136
and I think you show that that's not true, and that there is real scientific underpinnings.
137
Yeah, I mean I think the biggest point of resistance around 12 Steps is actually not whether
138
or not there's an evidence base for it, it's the whole higher power and God thing.
139
And we're just living in a time when people are so polarized on issues related to secular versus spiritual.
140
It's become so politicized, unfortunately.
141
And even that politicization has infiltrated 12 -step groups,
142
which is fascinating and also somewhat discouraging.
143
So now you, whereas 12 -step groups used to be sort of the bastion of secular spirituality
144
and a place where people who were both highly religious
145
and people who were atheists could come together and self -define their higher power.
146
What we're seeing now, based on actually a study that's ongoing, is
147
that now you have like some 12 -step groups where you can't really go unless you have a certain type of faith,
148
right, or others where you're not welcome if you do have faith.
149
You know, it's really interesting.
150
Yeah.
151
One of the central themes of the book, one that I think resonates with everybody, but maybe is somewhat surprising to them, is this idea of pleasure and pain being sort of two sides of the same coin.
152
And I was particularly interested in maybe have you explore a little what we know about the neurobiological basis of
153
that because I think people understand there's a yin
154
and yang in the world but I'm not sure they necessarily think it's so closely connected in their brain.
155
Yeah I mean what was so fascinating to me as I was researching the book
156
and let me emphasize I'm not a neuroscientist I'm not the
157
one in the lab doing these detailed experiments that's the work of my amazing colleagues
158
but what fascinated me is the discovery that pleasure and pain are co -located in the brain,
159
so the same parts of the brain that process pleasure also process pain, and that at some fundamental level they work through this opponent process mechanism,
160
kind of like a teeter -totter or a seesaw.
161
And that became sort of a metaphor for me to think about the ways in which pleasure and pain are relative,
162
and also the ways in which with the relentless pursuit of pleasure, ever more potent intoxicants, not just traditional drugs,
163
but things that are new to the world altogether like digital media, that we ultimately, our brain adapts to whatever pleasure we get
164
and kind of down -regulates that whole hedonic system such
165
that now when we're not engaging in this pleasurable pursuit were very unhappy.
166
And the more pleasure we get, the less happy we get.
167
To me, that was absolutely fascinating and also beautifully mirrors what we see clinically.
168
And I think that's what I was really trying to do, take some of these fundamental, very basic neuroscience concepts and say,
169
what does that look like for real people in the real world?
170
You know, how does that manifest as people are in their addiction when they try to first, when they first try to stop using, how that, like, they slam down to the side of pain,
171
that's withdrawal, this kind of countermechanism, and how with continued absence and treatment, they can gradually come out of that.
172
But it's tough because there's that euphoric recall and those triggers, and it takes a long time, and it's limited by neuroplasticity and all of those things.
173
Yeah, I think I love the way you sort of brought
174
this in you actually described at the very beginning of the book into your consult room.
175
Yeah.
176
I think the description of that was beautiful.
177
And then it meant for the rest of the book we could see ourselves sitting there with you.
178
And then describing how you would work through this idea with some of the patients
179
that it would take them the first two weeks or so and they were going to feel worse.
180
Yes.
181
Helping them get to the other side so that they could eventually feel better.
182
Tincture of time, T -I -M -E, just having faith and waiting.
183
When we first stop our drug of choice, the cravings not only are intense, but they actually initially get worse with each successive day.
184
And it feels like, oh, my goodness, I can't live like this.
185
But the longer we can go without using, the faster we'll get to that point where the cravings start to abate.
186
We begin to be able to take pleasure and other more modest rewards, and that whole cycle and the world kind of opens up.
187
Yeah.
188
The other part I loved, and in medicine here, we are thinking maybe more often on the physical side, and you're obviously thinking more often on the mental side, but you brought up this concept of hormesis.
189
Yeah.
190
And I talk about this a lot, actually, because of work we do with exercise, actually.
191
briefly on exercise.
192
So I was actually, as I mentioned a moment ago, running as I was listening to your book.
193
But the concept that something that causes a little bit of pain, a modicum of stress, if you like, could ultimately cause,
194
create significant benefit is something that I was really interested in because we often think of exercise in that dimension.
195
And we're actually involved in a variety of different studies to try
196
and work out what the molecular basis of that might be.
197
I can't wait.
198
Yeah. So exciting.
199
But also then to hear, you talk about it in the context of addiction and the context of mental health.
200
I thought it was very interesting.
201
Can you say a bit more about that?
202
Well you know it's kind of a radical idea because
203
so much of mental health today is really focused on this idea that pain is dangerous, that we have to make ourselves comfortable, that we can't be stressed,
204
that we have to be safe, that there are triggers, that any kind of stress may leave a kind of psychic scar
205
that sets us up for future stress in the form of post -traumatic stress disorder.
206
And so, you know, those ideas to some degree, you know, can be helpful for people to conceptualize their suffering.
207
But I think we've gotten too far away from what is our natural resilience and our,
208
you and nature's ability to instigate our own internal healing mechanisms.
209
And this is essentially what hormesis is.
210
Hormesis is a Greek word that means to set in motion.
211
And when an organism is exposed to the right -sized pain,
212
the body senses injury and starts to upregulate our own feel -good neurotransmitters like dopamine,
213
but also endogenous opioids, endogenous cannabinoids, serotonin, norepinephrine.
214
And that's essentially the runner's high you know and you're going to elucidate more with that mechanism and that's super exciting
215
but this idea that um you know
216
that we have to constantly sort of hide from the world
217
and sort of walk around with a big bubble i think we really have to get away from because
218
our brains were really wired for pain you know we evolved for friction
219
and in fact especially
220
when it comes to reward seeking we evolved for a world of scarcity in
221
which we would have to do a whole lot of work to get a little bit of reward, right?
222
But that's not the world we live in now.
223
We can sit back, swipe right, swipe left, and have instantaneous, you know, reinforcers delivered digitally right to our brains, not to mention to our doorsteps.
224
So yeah, kind of flipping that
225
and saying it's better to get your dopamine in directly by paying for it up front and doing that hard work.
226
That's also more resistant to the problem of addiction.
227
It's not completely insulated from that problem but it is more resistant to that problem.
228
Yeah, yeah.
229
I think runner's high is really interesting.
230
I've been interested in that for a long time.
231
I benefit from a significant runner's high which is what drives me out of my bed in the morning.
232
Yes.
233
But I was interested years ago and you just touched on it a moment ago, for years I think we all used the word endorphins
234
and believed it to be mostly an opioid effect
235
and as you know of course there's some data now suggesting it might be primarily a cannabinoid effect.
236
Interesting.
237
Which, I mean, very hard as always to really tease the analogy of that out.
238
But in some ways that makes even a little more sense from just what we know about the mechanism of infection.
239
Yeah, and it really, I think, makes sense for people intuitively when I try to explain to them what's happening in addiction, right?
240
It's like, hey, your brain makes its own endogenous cannabis, right?
241
But it makes a tiny little bit after you've done a
242
whole lot of something else to earn it right now you're
243
in a world where you can have this exogenous source of this incredibly potent cannabis
244
which totally lights up your reward pathway instantaneously your brain is going to respond to
245
that and say hey I don't need to keep making my own endogenous cannabis
246
because I have this enormous external system right
247
and then you get this neuroadaptation this you know overcompensation I think
248
when people hear
249
that there's sort of like this aha moment like oh oh
250
I get it that's why I need to abstain to kind of reset reward pathways
251
and so you've referenced a couple of times
252
and of course the idea of modern digital media yeah it's such a big topic and it's
253
so important we have a center for digital health here can't
254
think about digital health without thinking about both the pros and
255
and obviously the cons and I mean you've described these phones these media outlets as syringes full full of dopamine.
256
I think there isn't anybody now, there's six billion phones and more in the world.
257
And so to some extent I think that the global resonance of your work and your writing was because of that.
258
We're all sort of experiencing that.
259
I mean a smaller number have experienced really the extreme addiction and you describe amazing stories in the book about that.
260
we've pretty much all experienced the scrolling phenomenon.
261
Right, right.
262
How did you come to that sort of revelation?
263
Was it obvious or did it take some time?
264
And then how do you build a construct around that
265
and deriving what you've learned from these more extreme scenarios to ones
266
that are relevant for literally every day and for our children?
267
Yeah, yeah.
268
You know, it was really through clinical observation.
269
I mean, as clinicians, we're really on the front lines.
270
So we're going to see these sentinel signals way before you're going to read about it in the literature.
271
And my career was characterized by the early 2000s was just the very beginning of the prescription opioid
272
and more broadly prescription drug epidemic.
273
But then within about a decade,
274
people started coming in with completely out of control pornography and compulsive masturbation addictions.
275
And they made a clear and direct line between their problem and the advent of mobile technologies and the internet.
276
And then there was video games.
277
And then there was social media.
278
And now it's sort of like everything under the sun.
279
So because I was sort of on the front line, seeing the people for whom digital media was problematic almost immediately,
280
I was able to see that it was going to be an enormous problem.
281
You know, I always say, like, most people who drink alcohol won't become addicted to alcohol.
282
Most people who use digital media, which is most of us, you know, we're not going to develop a life -threatening addiction to digital media.
283
We're going to have our problems, but we're going to manage to correct.
284
But there is a subset of individuals, and we must take this very seriously as a society,
285
who will very quickly be incredibly compromised because of their inability to get off of the internet.
286
And that is real.
287
That is real.
288
And it looks exactly like addiction to drugs and alcohol.
289
It cannot be minimized.
290
And to answer the latter part of your question, how did I draw that from that then to sort of the everyday compulsive overconsumption?
291
Well, I saw myself in it, right?
292
So I talk about my own addiction to romance novels, which started innocently enough until I got my e -reader
293
and then all of a sudden I was a chain reader staying up later
294
and later taking my e -reader to work reading in between patients
295
and it and you know I didn't even see it happening as it was happening
296
but it basically developed into like a very mild sort of
297
addiction not not to compare what happened to me to the life threatening addictions of many of my patients
298
but but it was really on the same spectrum yeah yeah Yeah, we can all, I think, then draw a line from this very extreme case,
299
your personal story, through to our own every day.
300
I mean, whether it's like scrolling before bed or in the morning and suddenly 20 minutes, 30 minutes have gone by.
301
Yes, exactly.
302
And you think, was that of any benefit to my life the last 30 minutes?
303
Right, so true.
304
And getting at really the heart of what are we losing when we compulsively over -consume digital media.
305
We're losing the most valuable commodity of our lives, which is our time, our lived time.
306
What's your sense, though, about what we should, as a society, and also as a medical community, do about that?
307
We can diagnose the problem in a way.
308
So I'm optimistic because probably it's just in my nature to be optimistic long term about humans' ability to solve problems.
309
I think it's a little bit like any of the human -made problems that we encounter now.
310
It's going to take both bottom -up and top -down intervention.
311
We can't just leave it up to individuals or even individual families.
312
We all need to kind of come to the table schools, the corporations that make and profit from digital media and digital devices,
313
you know, government entities.
314
I think coming together and experimenting with what works, or at least experimenting and seeing what works,
315
is really going to be the key.
316
And I think we need to conceptualize the developing brain, that is the child and teenage brain, as uniquely vulnerable and set that aside.
317
You know, what in a liberal democracy consenting adults, consenting and informed adults want to do is one thing.
318
But what we expose kids' brains to and how we need to inform and warn parents about the risks,
319
that's where there's an enormous amount of work that needs to be done and can be done and should be done.
320
And it sounds like I think you're arguing for some level of individual responsibility, certainly for adults.
321
But around kids, it's schools, it's governments, it's medical community, it's really everybody.
322
Yeah, absolutely.
323
Kids are uniquely vulnerable for all kinds of reasons having to do with their own developmental trajectory.
324
And there's just no doubt that the digital medium is highly addictive and harmful for kids in other ways, right?
325
Addiction is the medium through which we are spending more time than we ought or than we want to.
326
But then once we're there, you know, there's exploitation, there's cyberbullying.
327
There's the invidious social comparisons that lead to the body dysmorphia, the eating disorders, the just feeling less than,
328
the isolation, the lack of movement, the sleep disturbance.
329
I mean the list just goes on and on.
330
Do you think of it as a peculiarly digital phenomenon?
331
In the sense that you could just use your phone for reading books or doing things that you used to do.
332
I often contrast this idea if you see two people, let's say on a Sunday morning at a coffee shop, let's call them husband and wife, but it could be any two friends,
333
and they're both watching their phones, we have an immediate negative reaction to that.
334
If they were both holding newspapers, somehow, oh, there's two people having a nice cup of coffee in the morning.
335
And I wonder, is that real?
336
Because the two of them could be also just reading the newspaper on their phone.
337
So to what extent is it the things that are on the phone, which include of course social media and clickbait and all the other things you mentioned,
338
and to what extent is it truly just that a digital bomb, if you like, that can hold all those things in it is part of the challenge?
339
Yeah, I think that's a great question.
340
And what I would say is that it is the design features of the medium itself that make it addictive.
341
And we definitely neither should nor can sort of throw the baby out with the bath water
342
or put the genie back in the bottle or what have you.
343
This technology is here to stay, but it's very clear that some platforms have been engineered through their algorithm
344
and other design features to optimize for watch time and keep people clicking and scrolling independent of content.
345
And I think that's really what we need to zero in on, are these design features that really exploit our motivation and reward system.
346
So, you know, it's one thing to be on your phone and be reading a book.
347
Now, I had my problems with books, yes.
348
But, you know, or to be reading the newspaper.
349
And it's really something else to be getting your news through a social media platform
350
that now has comments and likes and shares
351
and is algorithmically optimized to keep feeding you in an endless stream stuff that you've watched before.
352
Now we're really talking about, you know, the medium is the massage.
353
This is the Marshall McLuhan famous quote, the medium is the message.
354
But at one point, I guess there was a typo when he actually wrote the medium is the massage.
355
It's like, it's perfect.
356
Yes, the medium is the massage.
357
It's the brain massage, which is exactly the thing that we need to worry about.
358
But when commerce is involved and we're driven towards shareholder value, I think about also the shelves of our supermarkets,
359
and there may be the bomb is sugar bombs.
360
Right.
361
But we're dealing with a similar phenomenon.
362
Exactly.
363
I mean, you know, food has been drugified, right?
364
It would be made more accessible, more potent, more novel with the addition of salt, fat, sugar, flavorants.
365
This is the same thing with social media, right?
366
We've drugified a human connection.
367
So really, it's those design features that we have to really kind of target and think about limiting,
368
especially, again, when it comes to children.
369
Yeah.
370
I wanted to jump back to maybe the more severe end of the spectrum for a moment.
371
We see within our department here at Stanford in the hospital many victims of addiction,
372
particularly methamphetamine, who end up with essentially failing hearts or pulmonary hypertension.
373
And it's obviously a tragedy on so many different levels.
374
But I, as a physician myself, feel personally quite helpless.
375
We can prop those individuals back up.
376
We can, of course, call our addiction services colleagues in the hospital to come.
377
But I feel really important to do anything meaningful for those patients
378
and I think I can only remember one in all of the time I've been practicing
379
that I believe I might have had a meaningful effect on their underlying problem as opposed to their cardiac presentation.
380
Right, right.
381
And I wonder, since this is the world you live in and the one you think about, can you give us some hope that there might be a way
382
that we can sort of break through or break that cycle a bit?
383
Because it seems like it's one of the, I think, I'm an optimistic person, but this...
384
But it's hard to find optimism for some of those individuals.
385
Yes, but many people with very severe addictions can get into recovery at every stage of life
386
and sustain that recovery for years to decades to lifetimes.
387
And we have a lot of reason for optimism,
388
one of which is just the simple fact that we have now at Stanford an addiction medicine inpatient consult service, right?
389
So you have your area of expertise.
390
It's wonderful that you were able to reach this individual
391
that you recall to target his addictive behaviors as well as help his heart.
392
But on the other hand, we don't really expect you to have that expertise.
393
But when people are hospitalized for the downstream health effects of their addiction,
394
it's a very important moment to focus on behavior change.
395
And we used to just ignore it.
396
We would patch them up and send them out.
397
Now something like the consult service, they can be consulted.
398
They can come and they can do bedside motivational interviewing.
399
They can connect them to resources.
400
For a patient with opioid addiction, they can start them in -house on buprenorphine, right, or refer them to a methadone maintenance clinic.
401
Methamphetamine is uniquely difficult because it's so available, it's so cheap, and there are no FDA -approved medications to treat it.
402
But there are other strategies.
403
There's contingency management strategies that work.
404
So I think we have to, you know, remain upbeat.
405
I do think that even in medicine, there is kind of this pervasive notion that, oh, there's nothing you can do.
406
You know, it's hopeless.
407
And that's just not true.
408
People, there are so many people walking the planet in sustained recovery from addiction that maybe we don't hear about, right?
409
We only hear about the people who aren't doing well.
410
And in the hospital, we see the ones who are coming back because they're not doing well.
411
And the other thing I always say to my students and trainees is, you know, something that you say to a patient today, you may think it had no impact.
412
But I can tell you that a year from now, two years from now, they may recall that conversation.
413
That may be the very thing that propels them into treatment.
414
Why do I think that?
415
Because I've had patients come back two and three and ten years later and said, you know, when you said X, I thought about this.
416
So we don't necessarily get to see their movement into recovery.
417
We're just seeing the acute crisis here in the hospital.
418
There's a parallel with transplant patients because the ones who are back in the hospital are having a problem.
419
The vast majority who are doing well are out there.
420
Right, and this bias exists where you and I are in the business of medical education.
421
And so this bias really exists also in training medical students, residents who are just in the hospital setting.
422
Of course, it's very wonderful training.
423
It's vital.
424
It's dynamic.
425
You can make a huge impact in someone's life.
426
But on the other hand, you can get kind of cynical, right?
427
That people never get better.
428
They keep coming back, all that stuff.
429
But that's why I think it's important to get these outpatient continuity experiences where you see, oh, no, you know, people do, they do get...
430
It's possible.
431
Yeah, it is possible.
432
That's great.
433
Well, I love that optimism.
434
Another area that's changed a lot, you touched just briefly on it, I think, in the book, but we do have newer pharmacological tools you mentioned some a moment ago.
435
Two that have been allotted in the news are ketamine on one hand,
436
but also GLP -1 medications that for weight management also appear to have this potent effect, still being tested in large -scale studies.
437
But how are they, obviously in different ways, changing your world?
438
Yeah, well, we always need to look for new treatments.
439
So it's always exciting when there's something new that comes along and there's promising evidence.
440
Most of our treatments, and I think this is true across medicine, are only going to work for a subset of individuals, right?
441
So in psychiatry, our medicines work for about a third of folks, or you can just say they work about a third of the time.
442
But for that one third, you know, they can be life -changing.
443
And so, you know, something like ketamine,
444
which has been shown to be helpful for treatment refractory depression and is now being explored in the treatment of addiction.
445
Importantly, as an adjunct to psychotherapy.
446
And the reason that's important is because, of course, all these ideas, they have legs and they run off.
447
And now you've got a lot of folks who are sort of self -dosing ketamine to self -treat their depression,
448
and that is not good because the evidence is not based on the molecule itself.
449
It's based on the molecule as kind of a jump start or an augmentation strategy to a psychotherapeutic model.
450
I urge listeners to go look up the Montreal model because it was spearheaded by one of my former students,
451
but it's a wonderful way to understand how ketamine can be
452
an adjunct to an intensive course of psychotherapy for treatment refractory depression, but also, you know, potentially other mental health disorders.
453
That's very exciting.
454
Yeah.
455
And then the GLP -1s, also very exciting, right?
456
Yeah.
457
So we know that not only do they change sort of gut hormones and responses, it looks like they also work on the dopamine reward pathway by decreasing the dopamine
458
that is released in response to highly appetitive foods.
459
And now they're being researched not just for food addiction, but also for alcohol addiction, opioid addiction, nicotine addiction, cocaine addiction.
460
So this is exciting.
461
And again, I always just emphasize and encourage moderation.
462
It's not going to be the cure -all and end -all.
463
It's not going to be solve all of our addiction problems.
464
But for a subset of individuals, it might actually be a miraculous kind of adjunct.
465
Yeah, it's great to have a wider range of armory tools.
466
Yes, right, because different things are going to work for different people.
467
Yeah.
468
It's obvious that a story is an important thing for you, obviously, in telling the stories in your book, telling your own stories.
469
It's also part of how we as doctors both listen to stories and treat patients.
470
And I wonder just in closing if you have any thoughts about the role of story in medicine.
471
I love your questions.
472
This has been really fun.
473
And so, you know, if you think about what a psychiatrist does, we work in stories.
474
That's our medium, right?
475
You collect a kind of lifetime of stories.
476
And I have concluded, probably based on the work that I do, that the way that we tell our stories is really essential to our ability to heal.
477
And that we can tell healing stories or we can tell stories that keep us stuck in our suffering.
478
Language is a tool, and our stories are really not just a way that we organize past experience.
479
They actually become our roadmap for the future.
480
Stories are absolutely critical, and we need to do more,
481
I think, thinking about what makes for a healing story.
482
And I think I talk about this in Documentation, but what I've noticed, at least in people with addiction,
483
is that when they're telling a story where it's always somebody else's fault,
484
I know immediately those people are not in recovery and not close.
485
Yeah.
486
Right?
487
Right, right.
488
But when people get into recovery, the story changes, and it's fascinating.
489
And all of a sudden it's like, well, yes, this happened to me, and that happened to me, and that was hard, and that contributed probably to my risk for addiction.
490
But here's also what I do that's making this problematic, and here's what I could change.
491
And that ties then to radical honesty, right?
492
Like being honest with ourselves and others about really what we've contributed to the problem.
493
And I think this is really key, telling these truthful autobiographical narratives,
494
again, allow us access to more data to make better informed decisions.
495
Yeah, that makes sense.
496
What about your own story?
497
Is there another book in there? what's coming next?
498
Oh gosh.
499
You know, I don't want to talk about it because it's sort of gestating, but yeah, I mean, the writing is something that I've really, it's sort of like my little creative side project.
500
So much of our work is collaborative and people intensive, which I love, but it's nice to have like a little creative thing on the side.
501
Yeah, and meanwhile, I'm just sort of doing my clinical work, my teaching, really enjoying it,
502
feeling like I'm sort of really in my career.
503
Kids are mostly grown, and so I have more time, and it's nice.
504
Well, your patients and students, thank you.
505
And the rest of us, also thank you for writing so eloquently and so wonderfully, and thank you for visiting us here at the Future of Medicine.
506
Thanks, Anna.
507
Thanks so much.
508
The preceding program is copyrighted by the Board of Trustees of the Leland Stanford Junior University.
509
Please visit us at med .stanford .edu.
510
Thank you.

Télécharger l'application

Tout pour parler couramment

Prononciation IAChaque phrase notée
Phonétique (IPA)Maîtrisez chaque son
VocabulaireEnrichissez votre lexique
Jeu de vocabulaireApprenez en jouant
FOR YOU

Vidéo recommandée

Vocabulaire et conseils d’expression pour cette leçon

Cette vidéo contient 510 phrases et 6637 mots à répéter en shadowing. La partie parlée dure 39:15. Le locuteur parle à un rythme naturel d’environ 169 mots par minute, proche d’une conversation courante. 85 % des mots font partie des 3 000 mots les plus courants en anglais ; le reste mérite d’être vu avant de commencer.

Vocabulaire clé de cette vidéo

15 mots de la vidéo à retenir, avec leur prononciation et leur sens :

MotPrononciationSens
addiction nom/əˈdɪkˌʃən/dépendance, addiction
reward nom/ɹɪˈwɔɹd/récompense, salaire
reader nom/ˈɹi.dɚ/lecteur, lectrice
radical nom/ˈɹædɪkəl/racine
heal verbe/ˈhiːl/guérir, assainir
honesty nom/ˈɑ.nɪ.sti/honnêteté
colleague nom/ˈkɒliːɡ/collègue, confrère
incredibly adverbe/ɪŋˈkɹɛdɪbli/incroyablement
massage nom/məˈsɑ(d)ʒ/massage
sustain verbe/səˈsteɪn/maintenir
potent adjectif/ˈpəʊt(ə)nt/puissant
extent nom/ɪkˈstɛnt/mesure
essentially adverbe/ɪˈsɛnʃəli/essentiellement, en essence
participate verbe/pɑːˈtɪs.ɪ.peɪt/participer (à), prendre part
recall verbe/ɹɪˈkɔl/rappeler

Les verbes à particule que vous entendrez

MotPrononciationSens
come back verberevenir
come together verbe/ˈkʌm tʊˈɡɛðɚ/affluer, s’assembler
open up verbeouvrir
add up verbeadditionner
back up verbereculer
break through verbepercer
bring up verbeélever
come along verbeaccompagner, venir

Prononciation à surveiller

Le locuteur utilise 89 contractions et formes réduites, comme we're, I'm, you're. Prononcez-les sous leur forme courte, telles que vous les entendez.

  • Les sons « th »: threaten /ˈθɹɛt.n̩/, pathway /ˈpæθˌweɪ/, bath /bɑːθ/, altogether /ɔl.tuˈɡɛð.ɚ/
  • Les sons « sh » et « zh »: addiction /əˈdɪkˌʃən/, massage /məˈsɑ(d)ʒ/, essentially /ɪˈsɛnʃəli/, medication /mɛdɪˈkeɪʃən/, prescription /pɹəˈskɹɪp.ʃən/
  • Mots longs — placez bien l’accent: incredibly /ɪŋˈkɹɛdɪbli/, essentially /ɪˈsɛnʃəli/, participate /pɑːˈtɪs.ɪ.peɪt/, experiment /ɪkˈspɛɹ.ə.mənt/, mechanism /ˈmɛk.ə.nɪ.zəm/

Comment s’entraîner avec cette vidéo

  1. Écoutez la vidéo en entier une fois sans parler et notez les mots que vous ne connaissez pas.
  2. Commencez à la vitesse 0,75×, répétez phrase par phrase, puis revenez à la vitesse normale quand cela devient facile.
  3. Enregistrez-vous et comparez avec l’original, en faisant attention à des mots comme addiction, reward, reader.

La grammaire de cette vidéo

Les structures que le locuteur utilise le plus, avec les mots exacts de la vidéo :

StructureDans la vidéo
« Used to » used to + verbe — une habitude ou un état passé qui n’est plus vraiused to be · used to do · used to just ignore
Present perfect have/has + participe passé — une action passée qui compte encore maintenanthave been engineered · have happened · I've had
Voix passive be + participe passé — l’accent est mis sur ce qui arrive, pas sur qui le faithave been engineered · has been read · is exposed
Propositions relatives who / which + proposition — une précision sur une personne ou une chosestudents who are · lives, which is · those who actively

Qu'est-ce que la technique du Shadowing ?

Le Shadowing est une technique d'apprentissage des langues fondée sur la science, développée à l'origine pour la formation des interprètes professionnels. Le principe est simple mais puissant : vous écoutez de l'anglais natif et le répétez immédiatement à voix haute — comme une ombre suivant le locuteur avec un décalage de 1 à 2 secondes. Les recherches montrent une amélioration significative de la précision de la prononciation, de l'intonation, du rythme, des liaisons, de la compréhension orale et de la fluidité.

Technique du shadowing : lire le guide complet étape par étape →