تدريب Shadowing: Accent-uate, Don't Compensate: Why Clarity Matters More Than Perfection - تعلم التحدث بالإنجليزية عبر الفيديو

When we communicate, we not only communicate our ideas, we communicate our identity.

My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.

Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.

Today, I look forward to speaking with Peter Novak.

Peter is a former vice provost at the University of San Francisco and former dean at Yale University.

He is the founder of the Strictly Speaking Group.

Peter leverages his doctorate and background in linguistics and acting to help non -native speakers master clear communication.

He has an award -winning LinkedIn learning course on public speaking for non -native English speakers.

Welcome, Peter.

I am really excited to bring you to the show and to share what you've shared with my students here with everybody.

Thanks for joining.

Thanks so much.

I've been so looking forward to this conversation.

All right.

Shall we get started?

Absolutely.

Great.

On the show, we've often spoken about how word choice affects the strength of our messages

and the impressions people form of us.

Your work highlights the impact accents can have on people's perceptions.

Can you share a bit about this?

And please make sure you define what you mean by accent bias, because I think this is really important for what we'll talk about today.

Absolutely.

Let me start with the definition of accent bias.

So accent bias is essentially that reflex that we have to trust people who sound like us.

And this happens a lot with people who are the in -group and people who are part of the out -group.

The idea of accent bias, of who's in and who's out, and what that means, it really affects the workplace, too.

It can affect hiring decisions.

It can affect promotion decisions.

It often affects how people feel about leadership qualities.

And so all of these aspects of accent bias creep into our workplace without us really understanding

or knowing the full impact of it.

We could have our career and our trajectories be affected by something we don't even know.

That's right.

Have you found that there are advantages to having an accent

or that non -native speakers bring to their communication maybe through the focus of the specific words

or the way they speak versus those who don't have an accent in a given environment?

Or who don't have the accent of the majority in the specific group.

Absolutely.

And I love the framing of this question around the advantages that non -native speakers have,

because so often they come to the table thinking it's a disadvantage to have an accent when they're speaking.

And so I think what's fun about that is that when you think about multilingual speakers,

75 % of people in the U .S and Canada and Australia and Great Britain don't speak another language.

And so when you've got multilingual speakers, their skills in being able to code switch between language and cultures, in being able to be more intentional,

which is part of your question, I think, about that focus that they have about the language choice that they're having is really, really profound.

And I think it's up to native speakers to recognize

that non -native speakers are doing a hell of a lot more work in the workplace than native speakers are.

We tend to take our proficiency in English for granted.

We don't think about how we use it.

We don't think about ways to use it more clearly for non -native speakers.

And I like to say, remember Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire, the dancers from the 1940s and 50s?

Everyone said that Ginger Rogers did everything Fred Astaire did, only backwards and in high heels.

And in many ways, that's what non -native speakers are doing too.

They are, in the moment, involved sometimes in translating what was said into their first language,

oftentimes, translating what they want to say from their first language or another language, thinking about tone, thinking about word choice,

thinking about all these other things that native speakers don't have to.

And I think we need to give them credit for that

and then create the structures around that that enable a greater linguistic flexibility in the workplace.

Yeah.

And just recognizing that the difference even exists and that you should take the time to reflect and accommodate.

I have found that the folks I know who speak multiple languages, some of whom who have accents and some who don't,

their ability to listen and discern subtlety is far superior to mine.

Really interesting.

Agreed.

I have heard you say in my class and in things you've written, it's not an accent, it's an identity.

What do you mean by this, and how can it help someone who is concerned about their accent to reframe it in this way?

Sure.

You know, language carries with it culture.

It carries identity.

It carries individual stories.

And so why would we want to try and fix that?

There's no reason to really fix that.

The goal, actually, is clarity.

And I think sometimes there was a great episode of Modern Family with Eva Longoria, was that, who said, do you even know how smart I am in Spanish?

And this is what happens if you ask a multilingual speaker,

do they feel like different personality traits emerge with the different languages that they speak? they will say, absolutely.

I am so much funnier in my first language, and I don't have access to the same type of comedy in English

or in a second language that I do in my first.

And so really, there's this interesting part of identity that shifts because of the different languages that we speak.

And I think that needs to be celebrated.

It needs to be brought into the workspace a lot more than it normally is.

Yeah, you just reminded me, I was coaching a very senior leader of an institution we all know, who was a native French speaker.

And in English, he was a little more stilted, a little more buttoned up.

But when I actually had him say the same thing in French, he became much more lively, much more connected.

And we were able to use that as a tool, as a guide to allow him to feel more free speaking in English.

It really is interesting how we have these different compartmentalizations based on language.

Before I ask you to share some specific techniques that those with accents can take to feel more confident in their communication,

I'd love to ask you to define some foundational principles that I know you refer back to.

And in fact, these principles apply not just to people who are speaking in a language other than their native language.

They apply to all of us.

So can you help us understand what you mean by processing fluency, intelligibility, and comprehensibility?

Absolutely.

So in a nutshell, processing fluency is the ease with which we understand something.

And I think the goal of every speaker is to try

and make what they say as easy as possible to understand for the listener, for your audience, whoever that audience is.

And it really means getting to know your audience as well as possible.

And so processing fluency is essentially that.

Processing disfluency is anything that gets in the way of that message being understood.

100

That could be content, right?

101

You ramble or you don't have a good structure.

102

It could be delivery, right?

103

Things that make it difficult for people to hear and understand.

104

And that brings us to the linguistic ideas around intelligibility and comprehensibility.

105

Intelligibility is how much I understand of what you say, right?

106

Comprehensibility is how hard I have to work to understand you.

107

It's the effort that I put in to understanding you.

108

Let me put this into an example.

109

Let's say you're on a Zoom call.

110

It's a little glitchy on the other end.

111

But maybe you understand what the person said, but still there was, I'm losing you a little bit.

112

And so you have to work harder to do it.

113

That's the difference between intelligibility and comprehensibility.

114

And the best part about this is

115

that there were major studies done 20 years ago and more that say that people who speak English as a second,

116

third, or fourth language can improve both their intelligibility and their comprehensibility with no noticeable shift in accent.

117

Oh, interesting.

118

Exactly.

119

Wow.

120

Exactly.

121

And so there are some really interesting things to focus on to help you do

122

that without worrying about what your accent really is.

123

Processing fluency is the ease with which we take in the information.

124

That's right.

125

And there's a whole bunch of things we can do, making sure we know our audience so it's easier for them.

126

We're using relevant concepts and ideas that they can connect to, structuring the information, making it more concise.

127

And then intelligibility is the understanding and the comprehensibility is how hard we work to understand that.

128

And anything we can do to reduce comprehensibility, I would assume, helps with processing fluency.

129

Absolutely.

130

Excellent.

131

So let's get very tactical and practical.

132

What are some techniques

133

and approaches you recommend to help people who want to work on their accents

134

or increase their intelligibility while not increasing the comprehensibility of what they're saying?

135

Yeah.

136

Well, they want to do both.

137

They want to have both high intelligibility and high comprehensibility.

138

And so what I would say is that the goal is clarity.

139

That's number one.

140

First and foremost, the goal is clarity.

141

So clarity of meaning.

142

Clarity of meaning, right?

143

And then clarity also of delivery.

144

I see.

145

Got it.

146

And what that can mean.

147

So I clearly understood you, but I also clearly heard you.

148

That's right.

149

Okay.

150

Very good.

151

And so there was an interesting study from McGill University in Canada.

152

And basically it said this your car breaks down in a city

153

that you don't know very well and your phone is out of juice

154

and so you're trying to find a garage that you can go to and

155

so you ask the first person they tell you to go

156

one direction you ask a second person the first person is a native speaker Sounds like you.

157

Right.

158

You ask a second person, they tell you to go in the opposite direction.

159

And they have an out -group speech or accent.

160

Right.

161

Foreign or something you don't recognize.

162

Who are you going to trust more?

163

And in essence, the study found that you trust people who sound like you more.

164

That's what accent bias is.

165

However, if the person who speaks with a different accent than your own speaks with confidence, then it reduces that gap.

166

I see.

167

And so the question becomes, what does speaking in English with confidence actually mean?

168

What are people who speak English as their first language listening for that tells us that that person is confident?

169

We know this.

170

We know what some of those elements are.

171

And some of them are all related to prosody.

172

So prosody is an element of speech that thinks about the musicality of the language,

173

which thinks about volume and pacing and the power that you lend to certain words and inflection.

174

It's all of the things outside of the words and the sentences that carry meaning that we often don't think about.

175

When we had Lerone Martin on talking about Martin Luther King Jr., we talked a lot about prosody and how he was able to leverage

176

that as part of one of the many things that made his orations really powerful and meaningful.

177

Absolutely.

178

And every language has its own musicality.

179

That's the biggest return on investment is understanding and really working on prosody of the language.

180

Not individual words, not individual phrases, and if you've got the pronunciation just right, you don't need to worry about any of that.

181

It's really more about the paralinguistic features outside the language itself that carry more meaning,

182

that make us relate better when we're communicating.

183

Right.

184

Can you give me an example or two of maybe an activity

185

or a thing you would coach people to do to really touch on that?

186

I'm going to give some advice that is often the opposite of what a lot of speech coaches give.

187

and that is to if you're giving a presentation or

188

if you're talking over zoom even to prepare by recording yourself into a speech to text app okay

189

and that speech to text app will give you a transcript of what you're saying

190

so you just have to rehearse it once

191

and then all of a sudden you've got a script of

192

what you're doing you can then put it through ai

193

if you want you can put it through ai

194

and say i need this to sound like me still

195

so keep my syntax keep the way that it

196

so it sounds authentic to you and once you have a script you score it

197

and use one of the best techniques

198

that i can think of is to underline what are called content

199

or focus words in a sentence okay

200

if i have the sentence uh for you um i never said you should have hired him

201

if i stress a different word it means something different i never said you should hire him

202

I never said you should hire him.

203

I never said you should hire him.

204

I never said you should hire him.

205

Every time you say the sentence and you put a stress on a different word, it changes the context.

206

And if you look at your words and your sentences in your prepared speech

207

and you start to underline or bold just those three or four content words per second and focus on those words,

208

the meaning of what you're going to say will come across regardless of anything else.

209

And so if you're stressing just those words, all of a sudden you get a really clear picture of what's being said.

210

So that's one thing that you can do to score your script for what are called operative

211

or focus words or content words.

212

The second thing is to put in slash marks for small pauses.

213

Because people forget to pause when they're speaking.

214

And oftentimes, non -native speakers get told to slow down.

215

Yes.

216

When that's not always the best advice, what's more helpful is to take a sentence and divide it into thought clusters,

217

groups of speech that have complete meanings on their own, but don't often have the punctuation to make you pause.

218

And these are phrases, simple phrases in a sentence, like even when I was just saying a thought group is a group of words

219

that has a complete set meaning on its own, right, that we don't give meaning to.

220

And so when you break up a sentence into those thought groups, it becomes easier to understand and follow.

221

And so putting those slash marks into a script can help do that.

222

And then the third way that you can really help is to provide intonation assistance in a script, in a scoring a script, using sort of downward inflections,

223

which words to focus on in different ways, how to use inflections.

224

And we have three basic inflections in English.

225

The upward, where I'm asking a question.

226

The downward, where I'm making a statement.

227

And we do that in two different ways.

228

And then the sustained inflection, which I really like, which is so...

229

It's all on one note.

230

And you're waiting for me to either go up or down.

231

And when you learn to incorporate some of those inflections, you're really tapping into, I think, the power of the language in ways that native speakers are listening to.

232

Paralanguage.

233

The things that happen around the words are so powerful in so many ways.

234

And I love these activities.

235

Using a script as a tool to help you plan and prepare your paralanguage, I think is beautiful.

236

I love this idea of getting a transcript of what you're saying.

237

Not to say that you're going to say it exactly that way.

238

But to begin to look at what are those words of inflection, of focus, of the vocal highlighting that need to stand out.

239

And this is a tool that I think will help everybody, not just non -native speakers.

240

That's right.

241

Thinking about clustering of the key concepts and how to punctuate them in terms of pace and rate, really important.

242

In fact, I believe they found some versions of the Declaration of Independence

243

that had weird marks on them that they finally concluded were actually marks for oration.

244

That's amazing.

245

That people would read it.

246

Yes.

247

Because so much of the population at the time was not able to read.

248

That's right.

249

So giving yourself these little cues and clues of what to do.

250

And then finally thinking about how you end phrases and words.

251

That's right.

252

Many of us will swallow what we say and get quiet.

253

That's right.

254

Some people have up talk where everything sounds like a question and just being able to strategically think about it.

255

And as a question, although I believe I know the answer, the more you do this, the more it becomes a habit where you don't need to do it.

256

That's right.

257

You have extensive training in phonetics.

258

For our listeners who feel their voice doesn't always carry authority, whether native speaker or not,

259

what are some vocal adjustments that we can make to come across with the gravitas and clarity that we look for?

260

There are so many different things that we can do.

261

First and foremost, one of the things that I recommend is to really understand, that I talked about earlier, intonation and how we end sentences.

262

In English, we do that in two ways.

263

One is we either step down, like on the words, I'm a professor.

264

We notice we go up on the penultimate sound and then come down.

265

I'm a professor.

266

I teach math.

267

And so we either step down or we glide down at the ends of sentences.

268

And oftentimes people will swallow their last few words.

269

They don't end with strength.

270

And let me talk about what that means.

271

And so if you combine the strong downward inflection in speaking with slowing down your last few words when you're done speaking,

272

it signals that you've completed your thought.

273

It signals a strength in the end of your communication.

274

And you can use it almost any time you're finished speaking to make sure that people know you've finished speaking.

275

Yes.

276

And it works really, really well.

277

And you can either score that on a script that you've got for a text, or you can think about ending just by slowing down and using that downward inflection.

278

I love that technique, and I loved how you role modeled it.

279

Thank you.

280

And we can all record ourselves on audio, voice memo, and listen to hear how we're doing it and to become more sensitive to what others are doing.

281

We can work on these skills through reading out loud.

282

I often encourage people, reading out loud allows you to focus on how you're saying something

283

because the words are right in front of you.

284

So I'm not saying reading your script to give a presentation.

285

I'm saying just read your emails out loud, read anything, and notice how you can do that to train your brain to be more comfortable doing it.

286

Behind all of it, I believe, is also this notion of breath and breath control.

287

That's right.

288

You know, when we get nervous, we breathe shallow and up.

289

So we have to remind ourselves that your voice is a wind instrument

290

and that you have to have the breath behind it.

291

So I often tell people we need to build vocal stamina through breath work as well, which could be reading out loud, just becoming aware of where it is.

292

You have provided so much rich information.

293

Thank you.

294

Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.

295

One, I make up just for you, and two, I've been asking everybody for a long time.

296

Are you up for that?

297

You bet.

298

Excellent.

299

You created a national curriculum regarding alcohol abuse and sexual violence prevention that reached over a million students.

300

When you're communicating about such sensitive, high stakes and emotionally charged topics,

301

how do you balance clarity with the necessity of being empathetic and concerned?

302

A lot of us are in situations where we have to talk about emotionally charged issues.

303

What advice do you have that came from that experience?

304

And by the way, thank you for creating a curriculum like that.

305

It's my pleasure.

306

I was, you know, the Stanford graduate students actually took our program, which is great.

307

And it was throughout, I think over now, 2 ,000 universities have used it.

308

Fantastic.

309

And it was deeply important work for me.

310

But you're right, it is very emotionally charged.

311

And I think you have to create, first and foremost, is a psychologically safe space for people to be able to speak.

312

And that requires a great empathy and understanding what happens with trauma.

313

Once you've created a psychologically safe space, the goal is to not re -traumatize with your language

314

or to re -traumatize by asking people to contribute their story

315

when they don't feel psychologically safe to do so

316

and to build in a system of the way that you communicate that has its foundation in trauma -informed ways of communicating.

317

And I think that's an incredibly helpful tool

318

that has empathy at its core and that really helps us understand communicating on a very human -to -human level.

319

So it starts with empathy.

320

It does.

321

Which builds to psychological safety

322

that then requires some intentional thought about how to allow for the kind of dialogue

323

that needs to happen in these emotionally charged situations without re -triggering or causing people to become defensive.

324

Tricky, but possible.

325

Tricky, but possible.

326

And you also have to build the structure of all of that into your policies, into your procedures.

327

So it's not just the one -on -one communication.

328

It's also the larger support structure also needs to be framed that way.

329

I like to talk a lot about people, process, and infrastructure.

330

You need all three of those to come together when you have emotionally charged issues.

331

Question number two, who's a communicator that you admire and why?

332

I love Trevor Noah.

333

I think his cultural discussions,

334

his ability to see different cultural dynamics and how they manifest, not only from his native country and the way he speaks,

335

but to the U .S and to Europe and to every place that he tours and he brings different stories.

336

And he does it in a way that is enlightening, that is approachable, that is funny.

337

And he has a lot of humility, believe it or not, in the way that he communicates, too.

338

And so I think he's one of my favorite people to listen to.

339

He's got some great stories around accents.

340

He does take on some accents sometimes and talks about them.

341

But he's got some really profound things to say around language

342

and accent and accessibility and what is considered a standard sound and what isn't.

343

There is no standard for English.

344

There are world Englishes.

345

And I think Trevor Noah gets to that really clearly.

346

He is a very engaging speaker, a great storyteller.

347

And he does a really nice job with some of these paralanguage clues and cues that you're talking about.

348

Final question.

349

What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?

350

The first is comfort.

351

yeah feeling comfortable in being able to

352

and that's where the psychological safety i think comes in as well the second would be conversational

353

and this is all delivery by the way this isn't content this is delivery i would say

354

so the second part is really making it sound conversational you're actually talking to someone not talking at someone

355

and the third i would say is conviction or people will say confidence,

356

but having the passion behind what it is that you're saying so that you're making a connection that is important to you.

357

I love things that are easy to remember.

358

The three C's, comfort, conversational, conviction.

359

That's right.

360

And those are all helped by the techniques that you have taught us and that you teach on a regular basis.

361

Peter, thank you so much for your time.

362

I appreciate you highlighting the value that people who speak another language bring

363

and the tools that can help all of us feel more comfortable in our communication.

364

Thank you.

365

Thank you so much, Matt.

366

It was great being here.

367

Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.

368

To learn more about communication best practices, please listen to episode 82 with Nancy Duarte.

369

This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.

370

Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.

371

Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.

372

Be sure to subscribe and rate us.

373

Also, follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.

374

And check out Fastersmarter .io for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.

375

Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes, AMAs, and much more at Fastersmarter .io slash premium.

376

You'll also find value by joining our Think Fast, Talk Smart learning community at fastersmarter .io slash learning.

377

You'll find video lessons, learning quest discussion boards, my AI coach, and book club opportunities.

378

Again, that's fastersmarter .io slash learning to become part of our think fast, talk smart learning community.

ما هي تقنية التظليل الصوتي؟

التظليل الصوتي (Shadowing) تقنية تعلم لغة مدعومة علمياً، طُورت أصلاً لتدريب المترجمين الفوريين المحترفين. الطريقة بسيطة لكنها قوية: تستمع لصوت إنجليزي أصلي وتكرره فوراً بصوت عالٍ — كظل يتبع المتحدث بتأخير 1-2 ثانية. تُظهر الأبحاث تحسناً كبيراً في دقة النطق والتنغيم والإيقاع وربط الأصوات والاستماع والطلاقة.

تدريب Shadowing: Accent-uate, Don't Compensate: Why Clarity Matters More Than Perfection - تعلم التحدث بالإنجليزية عبر الفيديو

حول هذا الدرس

ما هي تقنية التظليل الصوتي؟