シャドーイング練習: Self-Help: What Went Wrong? - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ

This video is brought to you by Keeps.

- Hey Wisecrack, Michael here.

You don't have to own an exploding candle, scented like Gwyneth Paltrow's nether regions, to know that the self -help industry is booming.

Americans seem to be fundamentally obsessed with the mission of improving ourselves.

We want life hacks, four -hour work weeks, desert retreats, Then I went to the desert to seek answers, and now...

- I have them.

- And someone to tell us of microdosing at the office is okay.

Is it, Alec?

And in some ways, teaching people how to lift themselves up by their bootstraps has become a celebrity -worthy job in its own right.

- It's all like laddering up to one thing, which is optimization of self.

Like we're here one time, one life.

Like how can we really like milk the out of this?

- Goopiness aside, there are plenty of people eager to help you milk the hell out of this thing called life.

telling you that nine -tenths of your work week is unnecessary, so long as you outsource most of your administrative tasks to third world secretaries,

or any slew of productivity bloggers promising to somehow quintuple your productivity overnight with nootropics.

Now, the quest to be a better, more functional member of society isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Like, I want to improve my sleep hygiene and to quiet the existential dread that hangs over me like a dark cloud.

And I'm really making progress on that first one.

But what if the industry surrounding these kinds of goals to do with why we need help in the first place.

We'll explain in this Wisecrack Edition on self -help.

What went wrong?

But before we continue, I want to give a shout out to this week's sponsor, Keeps.

I love wearing hats.

They're pretty much a part of my identity.

You probably feel the same way about your hair.

It's something people recognize, and it's probably one way you express yourself.

If you have ever been scared of losing it, then Keeps can put your mind at ease.

Keeps is an affordable hair loss treatment program that provides FDA -approved prescription and over -the -counter medication.

With Keeps, there's no trip to the doctor or awkward pharmacy pickup involved.

You can do everything right from the comfort of your own home.

you can get the medication delivered right to your door.

Keeping your hair is all about prevention.

So the sooner you take action, the more hair you can save.

With Keeps, some men even report hair regrowth.

Find out why Keeps has more five -star reviews than any of its competitors, and why hundreds of thousands of men trust Keeps for their

hair loss prevention medication by clicking the link in the description or by going to keeps .com /wisecrack.

If you use our link, you can get 50 % off your first order.

Stop stressing and keep your hair.

Now, back to the show.

how self -help went from a very cool set of ideas

that really meant to transform the world into a bunch of

self -proclaimed gurus promising to manifest a better you for just $395, we need to start with the founding father of the modern American self -help movement.

Believe it or not, this dude was a failed car salesman slash failed actor slash failed novelist turned YMCA public speaking coach.

No, really.

Dale Carnegie, who was born to dirt poor farmers in the late 19th century,

arguably created the modern American self -help industry "How to Win Friends and Influence People." Now, the book is pretty much what it sounds like.

The guidance is all rooted in the idea that success in business and in life is primarily the result, not of smarts, not even of super hard work, but of personality.

Though in Carnegie's defense, he couldn't have anticipated the rise of supremely likable Mark Zuckerberg.

Anyway, Carnegie's success wasn't exactly random.

It had a lot to do with the times he lived in before and during the Great Depression.

From the turn of the century onwards, community ties and religious institutions were buckling,

as the pressures of modernity led to vast migration into cities leaving many people alienated and alone.

Without family or community to turn to, people looked inward instead.

This inward turn was also greatly facilitated by the rise of psychology, with dozens of popular books tying the emerging field,

perhaps dubiously, to all aspects of life.

There was psychology in sex life, psychology in the Christian day school, psychology of fasting, psychology of murder,

psychology of your name, but my personal favorite is psychology of group insurance.

Carnegie biographer, Steven Watts notes the birth of what sociologist Philip Reif famously called the psychological man, who bolstered by the popular craze,

sought to solve their problems by solving their minds, often with the assistance of self -help books.

It makes sense.

If your mom can't give you reliable Bitcoin investment advice, why not trust this bestselling author?

This burgeoning field would serve as a springboard for Carnegie to launch his own philosophy.

And it worked.

He would go on to be named one of Life Magazine's most seconds.

"And his writing, with all its folksy wisdom "and wholesome anecdotes established core stylistic elements "of the modern self -help book." Of course,

the rise of self -improvement as a means to unlock your wildest dreams, if anything, was a little surprising given what came before.

Now, the idea of self -help can be spotted as far back as ancient Greek mentors

and Nigerian house folk tales and Ben Franklin's self -improvement happy autobiography,

but Carnegie arose in the wake of a culture That is, he came of age as Victorian America was dying.

Remember, one of the guiding forces of American culture was the Protestant work ethic, meaning you had to work yourself to death while not enjoying anything,

lest you end up in the bad place.

We're trying out the new butthole spiders.

They're enormous.

- And in general, middle and upper class Victorian values idealize self -denial, i .e not getting laid, and not eating that extra chocolate chip cookie.

This culture, however, imploded in part due to the ever expanding reach of mass manufacturing.

America went from a producer oriented society, where you or your neighbors made everything you needed to survive, to a consumer oriented society,

where you and your neighbors spent all your money trying to impress one another with dope consumer goods.

Instead of constantly repairing and maintaining the one nice shirt your mother made you 15 years ago, you could now get cheap and disposable threads that were cranked out in a factory.

Over time, mass -manufactured trinkets and toys and chocolates and hamburgers and dishwashers proliferated.

Eventually, America became a place where it was very easy to blow your paycheck on an 80 -piece china set

According to historian Warren I.

Sussman, while this consumer -happy shift was happening, the Western world simultaneously saw another massive cultural change.

From the Victorian ideals of crafting an upstanding character based on public propriety, stern morality, and a supreme work ethic,

to the modern individualistic idea of cultivating a great personality.

This idealized personality was, according to Sussman, particularly characterized in self -help books of the time as fascinating,

stunning, attractive, magnetic, glowing, masterful, creative, dominant, forceful, and various other adjectives I've used on dating profiles.

And Carnegie's book promised that cultivating such a personality was possible for anyone, even your boring Uncle Colin.

This must have been, ah, we're talking it, half it.

- For I was halfway through me dinner.

- Carnegie also called upon a different movement, which wanted to harness your mind power to improve your lot in life, new thought.

Basically it was the secret, except you were supposed to tell God what you wanted most.

Within just a few decades, an opportunistic reverend spun mind power into a literal, think yourself rich ethos.

Carnegie merged these two intellectual movements in a way

that was perfectly suited for a culture newly defined by mass consumption and individualism.

His methods explicitly created to help you, I mean you, advance, were perfect for an increasingly self -absorbed society.

His rise also luckily coincided with the rise of the corporate management class, people whose very living depended on,

well, befriending and influencing people above and below them.

But that still doesn't fully explain the phenomenon of how to win friends.

Carnegie's biographer, Stephen Watts, credits one more crucial force for Carnegie's massive It wasn't just social alienation.

100

"It was economic devastation." The Great Depression left people devastated financially and emotionally.

101

As Watts recounts, Americans were almost universally humiliated at the sudden onset of poverty they experienced when the stock market crashed.

102

More than blaming a lack of banking regulations or reckless speculation for their suffering, people, especially the insecurely middle class, blamed themselves.

103

In this time of crisis, rather than advocating for revolutionary agitation, most were in favor of the simple reinforcement of basic institutions institutions as Watts explains.

104

These panicked folks doubled down on preserving a mystical, American way of life, and were determined to seek out their piece of the proverbial pie.

105

And there was Carnegie promising that his book could help you rise above your station

106

and succeed in this uncertain climate so long as you really wanted to.

107

In a time when people desperately needed the wholesale support of their communities and country, Watts goes so far as to argue that Dale Carnegie saved the culture of individualism.

108

You can see it from his marketing, which was rooted in ideals of personal responsibility for success nevermind that plenty of people still couldn't afford to feed their families.

109

In one ad, he cautions prospective students that "if you have sincere desire to improve yourself, come along.

110

But if you haven't a real urge to improve yourself, save your time and money, for no one can help." Harsh.

111

And again, it makes sense why people want to read a book about how to ascend to the managerial class

112

so they can not spend all day in food lines.

113

But this mentality also does a great job at refocusing attention away from, say, the causes of the Great Depression, which an ordinary person couldn't do much about anyway, towards the thing you could do something about.

114

yourself.

115

But ironically, This egocentrism was implanted into a philosophy that just 100 years earlier had sought to do the exact opposite.

116

One that wanted to take the logic of self -help and revolutionize the world.

117

And not in the corny "join -an -MLM" kind of way.

118

Because long before Carnegie, the foundation of today's self -help industry was created by a Anarchists.

119

Well, anarchists, socialists, and other revolutionary types.

120

See, despite its association with $66 jade yoni eggs and $500 online courses, the self -help industry actually has deeply working class roots.

121

Once upon a time in early to mid 19th century England, self -help meant blue collar workers collectively helping one another.

122

This was epitomized by secularist and radical George Jacob Holyoake's book from 1857,

123

"Self -Help by the People," which like some of the earlier self -help material in America,

124

urged folks to learn useful skills they could then employ to help their communities and fellow workingmen.

125

Writings like these grew out of British mutual improvement societies.

126

Groups where working class folks would gather, sometimes in dingy old garden sheds, to learn reading, writing, and arithmetic in hopes of improving their conditions.

127

Born around the end of the Napoleonic Wars, these groups especially blossomed during the mid -19th century and continued to operate through World War I.

128

They were often established by political radicals and in their heyday, existed in many industrial towns and villages in England.

129

Now, these were the same decades when Britain was desperately trying to banish illiteracy.

130

"offering adult education in the form of mechanics institutes.

131

"However, such institutes were funded "by middle -class sponsors, who mainly saw the schools as vessels for imposing their own values onto the working class.

132

And mutual improvement societies emerged as an alternative education option, even in places where there were plenty of mechanics.

133

According to Harrison, this suggests that workers were dissatisfied with the institutionalized formal education, perhaps because students were often not allowed to discuss politics or religion in class.

134

Basically, mutual improvement societies were what Harrison calls the working man's solution to his own educational needs.

135

"The self -help legacy of cooperation didn't vanish overnight.

136

Even in America." Scholar Beth Blum notes, "Up until the 70s, self -help still commonly referred to groups of people working together

137

to improve themselves." This was epitomized by the feminist self -help collective that compiled the book, "Our Bodies, Ourselves," to teach women medically taboo information about their bodies.

138

That's a far cry from the self -centered philosophy of something like lean in.

139

So what does this have to do with Tony Robbins

140

and Sheryl Sandberg and the thousands of dollars of credit card debt NXIVM classes put me?

141

Enter Samuel Smiles who visited some mutual improvement societies in Leeds and was impressed by their admirable self -helping spirits.

142

The Scottish author

143

and then editor of a radical newspaper would give them inspirational lectures about successful men who had risen up from poverty.

144

Eventually, each lecture would become a chapter in his bestselling book

145

from 1859 called "Self -Help." This officially gave a name to the fledgling industry that would spawn a million Tim Ferrises.

146

But from the time he first visited mutual improvement societies in 1845 to the time he published his book, to have evolved.

147

In the book, the working class roots of English self -improvement seem to have merged with middle -class values of individualism.

148

Smiles, for his part, took the collective, self -advancing ideology he admired and essentially boiled it down to individual work ethic,

149

going so far as to caution that poverty could be a great motivator, and institutional support a great demotivator.

150

It's important to note that some think Smile's rejection of government aid is often misunderstood and conflated with laissez -faire conservatism.

151

But either way, while his book proved inspirational for working folks all over the globe,

152

Smile's ideology essentially functioned as a middle -class reply to workers' demands for better social conditions.

153

He argues that anyone could improve themselves without the help of the government, simply if they wanted to.

154

In that vein, it arguably implied that working class people who remained poor and ignorant were basically morally deficient.

155

After all, they just needed to try harder to rise in the ranks by studying arithmetic

156

when they got home from work, right?

157

While the self -improvement methods that Smiles expounded upon - hard work, hyper diligence, and frugality - would differ drastically from Carnegie's charismatic approach to getting ahead in life,

158

his book furthered an individualistic image of self -help that would prove incredibly salient to this day.

159

Which is how the idea of self -help went from a

160

collectivist dream of a better world to essentially an ideology of personal betterment spurred by individual ambition.

161

Smiles would be a major influence on Orison Swett Marden, author of a shocking 50 or more

162

booklets including "Pushing to the Front" or "Success Under Difficulty." Martin would become a central inspiration for one Dale Carnegie,

163

cementing the transition of self -help from collective working class advancements to an ethos of "manipulate your co -workers

164

so you can get a raise and buy more sh *t." Since then, self -help has retained this laser focus on the individual and their personality,

165

frequently in relation to improving their worth in the labor market.

166

It's also explicitly sought to help people adjust to sweeping social changes.

167

Like when Helen Gurley Brown counseled women on how to succeed in a deeply sexist 1960s workplace, or when Jane Fonda taught nearly middle -aged baby boomers how to hang on to the physiques of their youth.

168

- Are you ready to do the workout?

169

- But our favorite era of late 20th century self -help started in the early 70s, a time of economic contraction and widespread anxiety.

170

Self -help books emerged with super chill titles, like "Looking Out for Number One" and "Winning Through Intimidation" to urge just what it sounds like.

171

"Ruthless Self -Interest and the Gospel of Greed." Some books had even bleaker titles, like "You Can Profit from a Monetary Crisis"

172

and "How to Prosper During the Coming Bad Years." A kind of blatant appeal to self -interest admits widespread suffering

173

that makes Dale Carnegie look almost communitarian in contrast.

174

What's more, as scholar Mickey McGee notes, "Within self -help culture, values from the competitive world of the marketplace have been transplanted

175

to the personal world of intimate life." Never has this been more apparent than in the 1980s relationship advice books

176

that urged women to see their relationships as a matter of maximizing profit, not cynical at all.

177

And what about today?

178

Self -help has found a lucrative niche in helping Americans cope with

179

and survive in an increasingly unstable labor market and social climate.

180

While Victorian advice books were about being successfully married and employed, today's advice books are about the struggle to remain marriable and employable forever.

181

In keeping with the trend of previous decades, self -improvement books treat the self as your most valuable commodity, maximizing its value.

182

If I can help people feel more in control of their life,

183

more stable, that will minimize their interest in doing those negative things.

184

Books like "You Are a Badass" function as "How to Win Friends

185

and Influence People" for the shitty flexible gig economy where nobody's labor is particularly valued

186

and everyone's goal is to become their own boss via their Etsy wooden wind chime store.

187

Self -help has never been more profitable or more popular constituting in a $11 billion industry, as underpaid workers seek out new skills and tips,

188

in hopes of making their way up the socio -economic ladder.

189

Many workplaces, especially MLMs, even employ self -help vernacular to keep people motivated in spite of their paychecks.

190

With the right mindset, you can rise above your station, or so the saying is gone since the fateful day Carnegie loaded up his typewriter.

191

But as in the Great Depression, we're living in extraordinarily horrible times for getting ahead.

192

And it's understandable that people would take advice from these finance gurus who promised them unheard of wealth,

193

that they follow simple tips like tape coupons together so they're worth twice as much, put double -sided tape on your dog's paws so he picks up quarters when he walks around the street,

194

and join 10 churches, take some money out of the tithe bucket each week.

195

And a lot more where that came from.

196

But as we all struggle to manifest new mindsets or be more badass or package our personalities on five social media platforms, it's worth asking: Are we,

197

like folks during the Great Depression, turning to self -help because we blame ourselves for our struggles, rather than blaming blatant institutional failures like massive student debts,

198

stagnating wages, and so on.

199

Don't get us wrong.

200

There's nothing nefarious about wanting to improve yourself.

201

It's admirable even.

202

And most studies on the topic even show that people do find self -help books to be, well, helpful.

203

But we think it's only healthy to question something that's become as institutionalized as the self -help industry.

204

And it's worth wondering why the message, much like Carnegie's back in 1936 remains, if you read this inspirational book and don't become massively successful,

205

That's because you didn't try hard enough.

206

But what do you guys think?

207

Is the self -help industry just trying to make us better people, or is something a lot uglier going on?

208

Let us know in the comments.

209

Big thanks to our patrons for all your support.

210

Hit that subscribe button with the force of a Victorian suppressing their libido, and be sure to ring that bell.

211

And as always, thanks for watching.

212

Later.

✨ おすすめ動画

372 文

シャドーイングとは？英語上達に効果的な理由

シャドーイング（Shadowing）は、もともとプロの通訳者養成プログラムで開発された言語学習法で、多言語習得者として知られるDr. Alexander Arguelles によって広く普及されました。方法はシンプルですが非常に効果的：ネイティブスピーカーの英語を聞きながら、1〜2秒の遅延で声に出してすぐに繰り返す——まるで「影（shadow）」のように話者を追いかけます。文法ドリルや受動的なリスニングと異なり、シャドーイングは脳と口の筋肉が同時にリアルタイムで英語を処理・再現することを強制します。研究により、発音精度、抑揚、リズム、連音、リスニング力、そして会話の流暢さが大幅に向上することが確認されています。IELTSスピーキング対策や自然な英語コミュニケーションを目指す方に特におすすめです。

シャドーイングのやり方: ステップ別の完全ガイドを読む →

シャドーイング練習: Self-Help: What Went Wrong? - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ

i read a self-help book every day for a WEEK -- now i'm more confused than ever

How to Stop Taking Things Personally

YOU can FIX your LIFE in 20 minutes, here’s how YOU do it (2026)

Where did all the minimalists go?

THE DISCLAIMER: Let It Breathe

Talk Back: Why Arguing With Yourself Can Help You Flourish

Why your best work happens when you stop taking it too seriously

How to actually get smarter (again)

What to do when willpower doesn't work

The Confidence Hack Nobody Tells You 🤫

Video

Watch this to Improve your Self-Concept and Get the Life of your Dreams! | S2E1

この動画は誰におすすめ？

覚えておきたい単語とイディオム

発音を良くするコツ

シャドーイングとは？英語上達に効果的な理由