シャドーイング練習: Google Maps Directions That Killed People - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ

In Eastern Russia, Sergei Ustinov and Vladislav Istomin were planning a big trip.

The pair of friends were going to drive all the way from Yakutsk to the port city of Magadan, situated on the Sea of Okhotsk.

Considering this was November 2020, the pair may have been hoping to escape the creeping restlessness brought on by COVID lockdowns,

or perhaps they simply seeking adventure like 18 year olds often do.

Either way, their parents were not pleased when they heard about their plans.

Sergey's mother in particular tried to talk them out of the trip, citing how dangerous a 1900 kilometer route would be.

She wasn't exaggerating.

Sitting in the deep reaches of eastern Siberia, their starting point Yakutsk is the most remote major city on the planet.

It's also the coldest, with temperatures regularly reaching below minus 40, so cold that cars need to be left running all the time or else they simply won't be able to start up.

If you're Canadian like me, the best way to describe Yakutsk is

that it's like one of those towns way up north that's only accessible via winter roads when bodies of water freeze.

Except it's not a town.

It's a city with 300,000 people, all of whom have to take a ferry across the Lina river

if they want to drive out of it before the winter freeze sets in.

This is where Sergei and Vladislav began their journey.

After making their way across the river, they'd have only one road ahead of them that could lead them away from the city, the Kolyma Highway.

To locals, the route bears a nickname.

The Road of Bones.

It was built during the Stalin era by gulag prisoners in the extreme conditions of northeast Siberia.

Historians frequently mention that for roughly every meter of road built, one prisoner would die, leading to hundreds of thousands of deaths in total.

With so many bodies and being in such a remote place, the guards overseeing the construction would usually just leave the corpses in the foundation of the road itself,

making the route's nickname an accurate description of what the road was physically built from.

This is a highway Sergei and Vladislav are now pulling onto.

While local customs dictate

that vehicles driving along this incredibly remote route should travel in pairs due to the risk of hypothermia a breakdown could present,

the pair of teenagers didn't follow this advice.

In fact, they hadn't brought any proper winter clothes with them, only opting to wear puffer jackets and sneakers.

They had originally planned their trip using Yandex maps, but they instead decided to use this Russian platform's American equivalent,

Google Maps, which had shown them a shortcut the other platform didn't appear to pick up on.

The Yandex route had followed the Kalima Highway, which first leads north to the town of Usnara, and only then head south down to Magadon,

an indirect trip that would take a day and a half of driving.

Google on the other hand showed a more direct looking route that instead passed through the town of Tomtor,

preventing the need to needlessly drive north and shaved off 170 kilometers and a few hours of driving.

If only they knew.

The route Google showed wasn't as convenient as it may have appeared.

The path that would take them on wasn't part of the maintained federal Kalima Highway.

It was a stretch of the road of bones which had been abandoned for more than a decade.

As the boys began driving down this unmaintained highway in the middle of the taiga forest,

they likely slowly noticed the bumps in the road getting more extreme the further they went.

Their families began to grow alarmed when they failed to check in with them, and after a few days, they contacted the police who would start a missing persons investigation.

It would take a week of searching through abandoned roads and villages when a policeman finally came across an ice-covered Toyota chaser,

50 kilometers away from the nearest currently inhabited settlement.

Inside was the body of Sergei Ustinov, and a barely clinging to life Vladislav Istomin, who was quickly airlifted to a hospital in Yakutsk.

Doctors would find him suffering from acute hypothermia, with severe frostbite on his arms and legs.

He'd tell his rescuers that the pair had struck.. something on the road while driving, leading to the car's radiator being punctured, and ultimately disabling the vehicle.

While they managed to build fires to keep warm, they still weren't properly dressed for an early arctic winter that saw temperatures reach as low as minus 50 degrees celsius,

and the cold would unfortunately lead to Vladislav's friend dying, leaving him alone in the isolation of deep Siberia with almost no supplies,

just a sliver of hope that somebody might eventually find him.

He'd later end up losing both hands and both legs below the knee after spending two months in hospital.

But after a successful crowdfunding campaign, he was luckily able to have custom prosthetics made for him.

Journalists investigating this story would report that some of the cartography Google based their maps on was from the Soviet era, meaning it was decades out of date.

While the Russian authorities decided they likely wouldn't have the basis they needed to pursue legal action against Google, the company would fix the outdated data the same month Vladislav was rescued.

The world of Google Maps directions gone wrong is a a unique kind of digital terror, one where software bugs lead to people dying in real life.

It highlights the total trust we have in often faulty online platforms, but believe it or not, we used to be much more skeptical about being directed by a computer.

Before the internet, people primarily used to rely on paper maps acquired from gas stations to find their way around new places.

If you're old enough, you likely remember a parent having to pull over after getting lost on the road,

and then struggling to unfold a giant sprawling paper map that seemed to cover the entire front half of the car.

These maps actually used to be given away for free, with the map makers still able to turn a profit by selling ad spots to local businesses.

One company producing these tiny folded atlases was called Geosystems.

They'd been making paper maps since 1967, but in 1996 they launched a new venture that would not only skyrocket the company's growth,

but would also forever change the way people navigate in unfamiliar places.

MapQuest.

Everybody who's old enough to remember the 2000s also undoubtedly remembers MapQuest.

Instead of having to plan a route yourself by carefully reading through a paper map, MapQuest allowed you to simply type in a starting point and an ending point,

and the website would plan the optimal route for you.

The problem was, computers and internet access were still relegated to the home in this era, so these directions had to be physically printed out.

If you were traveling with a passenger, they could just read out the directions to you, If you're alone, you'd have to be rifling through the pages yourself,

something one blogger described as the 1990s version of texting and driving.

If you happen to mix up the order of the pages, too bad, now you're lost.

Miss a turn, unless you pull a Yui and go back, you are now lost.

Come up on a blocked road due to construction, your printed directions can't offer an alternative route, and you are now lost.

These are all problems you wouldn't have by simply using paper maps, which led to MapQuest being seen more as a novelty than a reliable navigation tool.

If you're in your early 30s, you may remember one of your parents being enthusiastic about using MapQuest while the other was sort of groan about it, eventually getting a bit of satisfaction out of saying,

I told you so, when the printed directions eventually went wrong.

But these were just the early days.

While MapQuest was spending its time in the spotlight as a primitive rail planning tool

that had essentially remained unchanged since the 90s, Google was working on their own modern alternative that would offer much more functionality.

And in 2007, it would come pre-installed on the first iteration of this century's most important technological innovation.

The iPhone and other smartphones with their built-in GPS systems would provide Google an avenue to deliver the ultimate navigation tool,

one that combined the strong points of both Paper Maps and MapQuest.

Google Maps could account for road closures and missed turns in real time, all while audibly reading out directions to you.

While this sort of functionality was already present in cars by the 2010s in the form of dashboard GPS systems, those often relied on maps that quickly became outdated as your car aged.

Google on the other hand was always updating their maps and they could offer some advanced crowdsourced functionality car GPS systems couldn't,

like estimating traffic levels and warning of upcoming speed traps and road closures.

Before we knew it, online navigation tools had gone from being an unreliable novelty to becoming our primary tool for planning road trips.

Paper maps disappeared from gas stations, and we instead put our complete trust in their online equivalents.

But even if Google Maps and similar platforms seemed like the most reliable choice, they still weren't 100% accurate.

And with so many people relying on these tools to direct them around unfamiliar places, it was only a matter of time until something would go horribly wrong.

It's the afternoon on October 3rd, 2015, and 70-year-old Regina Murmura is getting ready to meet some family for dinner at a pizzeria.

She's a businesswoman living in the Brazilian city of Rio de Janeiro, and as her and her husband Francisco get into their car, she proposes using a new app she had downloaded to figure out their route.

Waze, a Google Maps alternative also owned by Google.

She opens the app and begins typing in the restaurant's address, which happened to be on a beachfront avenue in the affluent city of Nidoroy, just across the bay from Rio.

It's unknown whether or not Regina simply made a typo or

if the app mistakenly resolved wrong address

but in any event the route the couple were now following

on ways wasn't exactly directing to any beachfront avenue as a

couple crossed the bridge to nidoroy something began to feel off

they were heading away from the coastline rather than towards it in fact it seemed as

if they were heading away from the city altogether eventually the app instructs them to pull off highway 104

100

and onto an unassuming street in the hills and it's here where things go horribly wrong As Francisco is driving,

101

the couple hear what sounds like a gunshot.

102

Then they hear another one, and then several more.

103

Holes start appearing everywhere in the car, and the elderly driver steps on the accelerator in an attempt to get away.

104

The streets grow narrower, and they begin twisting and turning wildly, making it impossible for Francisco to figure out where he's going.

105

Eventually, he comes up to a dead end.

106

Behind him, a group of armed men block his exit.

107

He pleads with the gunman to let him and his wife leave, but one of them strikes him in the head with the butt of their gun.

108

They fire at the car another four or five times before they finally decide to let the couple leave.

109

Francisco immediately drove to the hospital as Regina had been struck in the back by one of the many bullets

110

that had passed through the car.

111

While they would make it to the emergency room, she unfortunately passed away shortly after arriving.

112

They hadn't known it then, but the Waze app had mistakenly directed them into the Caramujo Favela, an informal neighborhood notorious for housing violent drug trafficking groups.

113

of the streets in the favela happened to have a very

114

similar name to the coastal avenue Regina had intended to travel to.

115

Shockingly, it wasn't the first time the Waze app would mistakenly direct unsuspecting drivers into Caramujo,

116

with actress Fabiana Carla also being shot at after accidentally turning into the favela just weeks before the death of Regina Murmura.

117

Police would eventually hunt down and arrest the leader of the armed group that had been shooting out lost drivers, a man by the name of Rodrigo da Silva Rodriguez.

118

He'd get 60 years in prison.

119

Waze would issue a statement explaining that while the company was saddened by Regina's murder, they wouldn't change the app's design, as a countless regular people who lived in the Caramujo favela

120

also should be able to use online navigation tools to help find their way home.

121

This wouldn't be the last death in Brazil, TaiTui map platform direct to users through favelas.

122

A year later in December 2016, In 2016, Italian tourist Roberto Bardella was touring around the country on a motorcycle with his cousin,

123

using one of the many available online navigation tools to help find his way around.

124

After visiting the Chrysler Redeemer statue, the pair began making their way towards the beach.

125

It's never been reported which app they were using, but whichever one it was, decided to route the cousins through Moro dos Prozeras, another favela home to armed criminal groups,

126

the members of whom assumed that Bardella and his cousin were plainclothes police officers.

127

They would kill Roberto, but would leave his cousin alive.

128

Three months later, Argentinian tourist Natalia Capetti was shot in the back after Google Maps had directed her through the same favela.

129

She would die three weeks later from her injuries.

130

You would assume somebody would do something about this, whether it was the Brazilian authorities or the mapping platforms themselves.

131

But other than prosecuting the people who had pulled the triggers, nothing would change to fix this ongoing problem.

132

And it would only get worse.

133

In 2024, a whopping 19 people will be shot after mistakenly entering favelas, whether it was unsuspecting tourists, lost locals, or Uber drivers.

134

Google has repeatedly declined to comment on this pattern.

135

With all these map platforms being primarily developed here in North America, the concept of risk zones may be a bit of a foreign concept to the people who run them.

136

While a lot of effort is put into the things that pose risk to us, like weather warnings, it seems like the more dire dangers

137

that exist in other parts of the world are little more

138

than an afterthought to the people who call the shots on Google Maps.

139

It would be one thing if stuff like this was only happening in Brazil, then Google could point at this being a Brazil problem rather than a Google Maps issue.

140

But that's unfortunately not the case.

141

It's June 2026, and Pakistani businessman Ali Jamil is busy planning his family's first ever road trip.

142

Him, his wife, and two daughters are going to drive from their home in Karachi to the naturally beautiful city of Kedah.

143

His father had warned about the potential danger in traveling so close to the Afghan border, but Ali disregarded these fears and to his credit,

144

the family did make it perfectly fine to Kedah and they reportedly enjoyed their vacation in the mountains.

145

Ali had to choose Google Maps to find his way on the road, with the first leg of the trip mainly sticking to a national highway.

146

On the return half though, Google would decide, for whatever reason, to divert Ali off the the highway and onto a smaller road.

147

Perhaps the app thought it found a shortcut or maybe it was just a glitch.

148

Regardless, this back road would lead Ali and his family through the Dasht area of the Mashtung district.

149

Dasht is a Persian word that refers to an arid plain, and that's very much the landscape Ali is now driving through.

150

It's a bare and rocky landscape surrounded by tall mountains in the distance,

151

but Ali and his family likely wouldn't have been able to see them considering they were driving through this area at night.

152

All they would have been able to make out was the immediate stretch of road laying ahead of them.

153

At some point, they pull up on a man standing in the road blocking their way.

154

Brightly illuminated by the car's headlights, it's obvious he's carrying a gun.

155

More men start walking into the light.

156

One of them begins to approach the driver's window but Ali steps on the accelerator, prompting the men to start shooting at the car.

157

The vehicle would soon stop just a ways ahead of the gunman.

158

Ali had been struck.

159

He would die shortly after.

160

His wife had also been hit five times, but she'd managed to cling on to life and do her best to calm down her daughters, who were luckily both uninjured.

161

The authorities wouldn't arrive to rescue them until the following morning.

162

The family had to spend the entire night in this dark and barren plain, knowing that the the gunmen may be out looking for them.

163

After being brought to the hospital, Ali's wife would thankfully be stabilized and she'd arrange a funeral for her husband at the end of June.

164

Ali's murderers would never be identified, and nobody knows what those gunmen were doing in this isolated and barren region so late in the night.

165

Once again, Google wouldn't issue any sort of public statement on this case, although it's worth noting that most of the public pressure in this instance was directed towards the Pakistani government.

166

Still, Google had taken a family off of a well-traveled highway

167

and onto a back road that led through was essentially a conflict zone

168

that frequently sees ambushes and militant violence from insurgent groups.

169

No matter where the public decides to lay blame here, it's tough to argue against the fact that Ali wouldn't have driven onto that back road had Google not told them to,

170

which Which is exactly what happened to all those people in Brazil.

171

You could argue that it's up to the person using a navigation app to do their research

172

and know where they should and shouldn't go on a road trip.

173

But then again, how is someone like Ali supposed to know where every single back road leads to on a 680km journey?

174

Maybe he could have pulled over and did some googling about the area he was now being rooted through, but I think it's easy to understand why he may have just went with it.

175

I don't know if you've noticed, but drivers on the road have a tendency to just sort of go with the flow.

176

you or me obviously, we're both great drivers.

177

I remember this video on Reddit a few years ago where

178

a line of cars was just kind of mysteriously driving off a highway and into the grasp, seemingly into nowhere.

179

I really wanted to find it to show you, but I unfortunately couldn't track it down.

180

If you happen to remember it, let me know.

181

The point is, people have a tendency to not be very mindful while they're driving.

182

They're thinking about work or what they're going to make for dinner

183

and they end up not fully paying attention to the things they're doing on the road.

184

Like if the slow line of traffic they're following happens to randomly veer into the grass.

185

It's not just that we have total trust and navigation tools like Google Maps, but we're simply not always thinking critically when one of them tells us to do something on the road.

186

And that can sometimes lead to horrible outcomes.

187

Like countless others, Navy veteran Phillip Paxson relied on Google Maps to help direct him on the road

188

when he and his family moved states in 2022.

189

They had relocated to Hickory, North Carolina.

190

In the September of that year, Phillip and his wife Alicia threw a birthday party for one of their daughters at a friend's house.

191

At the end of the evening, Alicia took the kids home while Philip decided to stay behind to assist in the clean-up.

192

By the time he left, the sky had grown dark and it was pouring rain.

193

He begins his drive home on 24th Street, Place, Northeast.

194

He likely didn't notice, but at one point, the street turned into a private road, right as he entered a wooded area.

195

Seconds later, he experiences a jarring feeling of weightlessness.

196

He's falling.

197

The next morning, authorities would find a flipped jeep submerged in a creek.

198

They'd pull it out, and sadly, Philip was still inside.

199

He had accidentally driven off a collapsed bridge, one that had apparently fallen a whole nine years prior.

200

With the road and bridge being on private land that was owned by a long-defunded company, There was no clear ownership of the destroyed infrastructure, and thus it was never fixed.

201

There were, however, several signs on 24th Street Place Northeast warning that the road ahead was closed.

202

Or at least there were in this 2019 Google Maps screenshot.

203

Philip either hadn't noticed them, or they had been taken down in the years since these photos were taken.

204

While it's unknown whether or not the warning signs were still there, we do know that the barriers that were normally physically blocking the way to the collapsed bridge had been completely removed.

205

meaning there was nothing in the way to stop somebody from driving straight into the creek.

206

Google Maps hadn't worn Philip either.

207

In fact, multiple users had previously complained that the platform was treating the bridge as if it was still intact.

208

Google didn't do anything about it though and they continued to direct drivers across a collapsed bridge.

209

While most likely either noticed the barriers, the signs, or the fact that a section of the road ahead of them was missing,

210

It was only a matter of time before someone drove off the bridge and into the creek.

211

Even after Philip died, despite being notified multiple times, Google was still directing drivers across the fallen bridge as late as April 2023,

212

a full six months after the fatal accident.

213

It would take a lawsuit to actually get them to finally flag the small stretch of road as impassable.

214

I think this case perfectly captures the gist behind all these stories.

215

While some might say the issues posed by Google Maps in

216

dangerous regions of the world remain unaddressed due to some form of discriminatory ignorance, I personally think is much more simple than that.

217

These massive platforms simply aren't going to make a change unless they're forced to, whether it's because of legal or regulatory action.

218

The fact that Google willingly swapped out those outdated Soviet maps in

219

that first case without being forced to is actually a bit of an outlier.

220

The problems in every other case I could find, whether they're in this video or not, were either completely ignored or addressed only after a lawsuit was filed.

221

Anyways guys, thank you very much for watching, I hope you enjoyed the video.

222

If you're not already subscribed, you should change that!

223

Especially if you enjoy watching immersive dark videos like this.

224

Engaging with this upload will teach the algorithm to recommend you more content like this.

225

And of course, have a good night.

📺 同じチャンネル

How the Location of the Backrooms Photo Was Finally Discovered

University StudentsWorking Adults

✨ おすすめ動画

674 文

Travel Stories | English Podcast - B1/B2 Level | English Listening Practice - English Conversation

Travel EnglishTeensDaily Conversation

280 文

Trump berates Canada during White House event | CTV National News for Sept. 30, 2026

IELTS PrepDaily ConversationUniversity Students

98 文

Russian Roulette - Studio C

TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students

このレッスンの語彙とスピーキングのポイント

この動画には、シャドーイング用の文が225文、単語が3921語あります。音声の長さは20:44です。話す速さは速く、1分あたり約189語です。音のつながりや弱く発音される音が多くなります。英語の頻出3,000語に含まれる単語は81%だけなので、語彙は難しめです。

この動画の重要語彙

動画に出てくる覚えておきたい単語15語を、発音と意味つきで紹介します。

単語	発音	意味
navigation 名詞	/nævɪˈɡeɪʃən/	ナビゲーション, 航法
avenue 名詞	/ˈæv.əˌn(j)u/	大道り, 並木道
cousin 名詞	/ˈkʌz(ə)n/	いとこ, 従兄弟
remote 形容詞	/ɹəˈməʊt̞/	遠い, 遠隔な
creek 名詞	/ˈkɹiːk/	小川
stretch 動詞	/stɹɛt͡ʃ/	伸ばす
rely 動詞	/ɹɪˈlaɪ/	頼る, あてにする
collapse 動詞	/kəˈlæps/	潰える, 崩壊する
northeast 名詞	/noːˈθɪjst/	北東, 東北
functionality 名詞		機能性
outdated 形容詞	/aʊtˈdeɪtɪd/	古臭い
rescue 動詞	/ˈɹɛs.kjuː/	救う, 助ける
bone 名詞	/boʊn/	骨
argue 動詞	/ˈɑɹ.ɡju/	議論する, 論ずる
custom 名詞	/ˈkʌstəm/	習慣, 風俗

動画に出てくる句動詞

単語	意味
pull over 動詞	道の脇に寄る, 道の脇に寄せる
calm down 動詞	落ち着く
clean up 動詞	掃除する
go back 動詞	戻る, 帰る
pass away 動詞	逝く, 亡くなる

この動画の文法

話し手がよく使っている文型を、動画の実際の表現とともに紹介します。

文型	動画での表現
「used to」 used to + 動詞 — 今はもう違う過去の習慣や状態	used to be · used to rely
受動態 be + 過去分詞 — 誰がするかより、何が起きるかに焦点を当てる	be left · was built · had been abandoned
関係詞節 who / which + 節 — 人や物について情報を加える	people who lived · people who had · people who run

注意したい発音

話し手はwouldn't, they're, you'reなど、短縮形や弱形を55回使っています。聞こえたとおりの短い形で発音しましょう。

「th」の音: northeast /noːˈθɪjst/, altogether /ɔl.tuˈɡɛð.ɚ/, algorithm /ˈælɡəɹɪðm̩/
「sh」と「zh」の音: navigation /nævɪˈɡeɪʃən/, shortly /ˈʃɔɹtli/, essentially /ɪˈsɛnʃəli/, ownership /ˈoʊnɚʃɪp/, vacation /veɪˈkeɪ.ʃən/
長い単語（アクセントの位置に注意）: navigation /nævɪˈɡeɪʃən/, primarily /ˈpɹaɪ.mə.ɹə.li/, essentially /ɪˈsɛnʃəli/, accidentally /ˌæk.sɪˈdɛnt(ə)li/, unfamiliar /ˌʌnfəˈmɪli.ə(ɹ)/

この動画での練習方法

まず声を出さずに動画を最後まで聞き、知らない単語をメモします。
まず0.75倍速で一文ずつシャドーイングし、慣れてきたら通常の速度に戻します。
自分の声を録音して元の音声と比べます。navigation, avenue, cousinなどの単語に特に注意しましょう。

シャドーイングとは？英語上達に効果的な理由

シャドーイング（Shadowing）は、もともとプロの通訳者養成プログラムで開発された言語学習法で、多言語習得者として知られるDr. Alexander Arguelles によって広く普及されました。方法はシンプルですが非常に効果的：ネイティブスピーカーの英語を聞きながら、1〜2秒の遅延で声に出してすぐに繰り返す——まるで「影（shadow）」のように話者を追いかけます。文法ドリルや受動的なリスニングと異なり、シャドーイングは脳と口の筋肉が同時にリアルタイムで英語を処理・再現することを強制します。研究により、発音精度、抑揚、リズム、連音、リスニング力、そして会話の流暢さが大幅に向上することが確認されています。IELTSスピーキング対策や自然な英語コミュニケーションを目指す方に特におすすめです。

シャドーイングのやり方: ステップ別の完全ガイドを読む →

シャドーイング練習: Google Maps Directions That Killed People - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ

How the Location of the Backrooms Photo Was Finally Discovered

Surviving the Deadliest Islands that are Forbidden to Visit!

Her post turned into an internet legend | Campfire Stories with MrBallen

A Rural American Childhood

Can I survive the LONGEST Regional Train in the UK?

Visiting the COLDEST CITY in the World (-71°C, -96°F) YAKUTSK / YAKUTIA

hiking up to the ice caves

I Actually Went to The Appalachian Mountains *WARNING*

Part 4

Death Note ENG Dub Episode 01