쉐도잉 연습: Ranking Killers by Whether Patrick Jane Could Catch Them - 영상으로 영어 말하기 배우기
레슨 만드는 중...
1
What is going on everybody and welcome to the second installment of Ranking Killers by Patrick Jane's chances of catching them.
2
Now I made the first part of this video about a year ago and it ended up doing pretty well.
3
So with the mentalist now starting to trend again on TikTok and I mean it's going viral viral, I figured that this was the perfect time to bring the idea back.
4
And the first time around I only included around 6 serial killers
5
or just killers which really isn't enough when there are so many interesting matchups we could throw Jane into.
6
So for part two, I gathered some of the most mainstream and dangerous killers from your favorite TV shows and movies,
7
and we're going to rank them based on just how difficult they would be for Patrick Jane to identify, expose, and ultimately catch.
8
So without further ado, let's get right into it.
9
Now the tiers are pretty self-explanatory.
10
Coming in at the top, we have They Escape, Elite Survivalists, which kind of means they'll evade Patrick Jane for quite a long time, but eventually Patrick Jane will catch them.
11
It'll take some time and then at the last one we have Easy.
12
So coming in first we have Roman Bridger from Scream 3.
13
And right off the bat I just have to put him in Easy.
14
And now before somebody says
15
that Roman literally orchestrated the entire massacre from behind the scenes from the first movie all the way to the third.
16
I know Roman is easily one of the more intelligent ghost faces.
17
He successfully manipulated events, operated alone for most of his killing spree
18
and managed to convince basically everyone around him that he wasn't the person behind the mask.
19
The problem is that Patrick Jane is almost the worst possible detective you could put against a ghostface killer.
20
Ghostface investigations depend heavily on misdirection.
21
Everybody has secrets and the killer tries to turn the group against itself.
22
Jane lives for that kind of environment.
23
He would barely care about the physical evidence at first.
24
He'd sit in a room with everyone connected to the murders and start talking.
25
He'd intentionally accuse innocent people, tell lies about evidence that doesn't exist, and watch everybody's reactions.
26
Now Roman is a good actor obviously, but Jane has spent years detecting tiny behavioral changes from people specifically trying to deceive him.
27
His entire motivation is purely personal in Scream 3.
28
He isn't just killing randomly, everything he does goes back to Sidney, Maureen Prescott, and the life Roman believes was stolen from him.
29
Once Jane realizes the killer isn't simply obsessed with the stab movies but has a very specific emotional connection to Sidney Prescott,
30
that suspect pool gets dramatically smaller.
31
Roman could absolutely fool the police for a while
32
but I think Jane eventually gets underneath his skin and then forces him into making a move.
33
So yes, of course, Roman Bridger stays at the last tier at easy.
34
Coming in next we have Paul Spector from The Fall.
35
Now, Paul Spector is extremely careful.
36
He stalks his victims, studies their routines, understands police procedure surprisingly well and lives an outwardly normal life as a husband, father, and a grief counselor.
37
Now that normal appearance helps him tremendously
38
because he doesn't walk around looking like the stereotypical serial killer even though he kind of has the stereotypical serial killer traits, you know living a double life.
39
But Patrick Jane has dealt with people exactly like this his entire career.
40
Now the normal family man persona probably wouldn't impress him very much.
41
Jane would be more interested in the contradictions.
42
Spectre wants to appear emotionally controlled, but underneath that control is obsession and enormous amount of narcissism.
43
The biggest problem Specter has against Jane is that his murders reveal too much about him.
44
His victim preferences, stalking behavior, and desire to revisit what he's done will give Jane something to work with.
45
Jane would probably construct an extremely accurate picture of Specter before knowing his name.
46
From there, Jane starts baiting him.
47
is disciplined enough that he might initially ignore it but Jane would eventually find the right nerve.
48
Once Jane gets physically close to Spectre I think it becomes even worse.
49
Spectre is excellent at maintaining appearances around ordinary people
50
but Patrick Jane obviously is not an ordinary person and eventually Jane would see right through Spectre.
51
Now I don't know but I mean like I just feel like this would be another easy catch for Patrick Jane.
52
Maybe I'm underestimating him here but I would put him below Roman Bridger.
53
I don't know, maybe I'm turbo underestimating here, but this is just what I think.
54
Coming in next, we have John Kramer from Saw.
55
Now, this is where things get considerably harder because Kramer isn't operating like a normal serial killer.
56
Because Jane can't just build a profile and watch for someone fitting
57
that behavior because John has constructed an entire philosophy around what he does.
58
Now, he considers his victims responsible for their own deaths, uses abandoned locations, and eventually recruits multiple acquaintances.
59
Now that creates a massive investigation problem because even if Jane understands Jigsaw's psychology, understanding him and locating him are completely different things.
60
But John also gives Jane something incredibly useful, an ego disguise as a philosophy.
61
Now Patrick Jane would recognize almost immediately that Jigsaw doesn't simply want victims, he wants to build an audience and the second Jane understands that, he now has leverage.
62
Now Jane would attack the philosophy instead of chasing the engineering.
63
He might even intentionally misrepresent Jigsaw's message
64
because he knows John would hate seeing his work misunderstood because at the end of the day, because at the end of the day,
65
without this philosophy, John Kramer would not be putting people in traps because if he threw his philosophy out the window, then he would become a true cold-blooded killer.
66
His workshops are hidden, his traps can be prepared long before they're activated, and depending on which point in the Saw timeline we're using,
67
Jane might actually be investigating multiple people without realizing it.
68
Now Amanda could carry out one game and then Hoffman could carry out another, while Kramer remains nowhere near the crime scene.
69
But untangling that entire network would definitely have to take some time.
70
I don't think this would be one episode and I do not think this would be very easy for Patrick Jane.
71
I kind of just want to go with elite survivalists.
72
Next we have Walter White from Breaking Bad.
73
Walter is low-key one of the strangest matchups here because technically he isn't a traditional killer.
74
As we all know, he's part of a drug cartel operation, and he does kill sometimes.
75
And in this case, that actually kind of helps him here, because Patrick Jane really, because Patrick Jane doesn't really necessarily, you know, investigates drug lords,
76
but I mean, like, he definitely could.
77
Now, if Patrick Jane were investigating Heisenberg without knowing Walter personally, Walter's biggest advantage would be how absurd he looks as a suspect,
78
Because he's just a high school chemistry teacher with cancer
79
and suddenly becoming one of the most dangerous meth manufacturers in the southwest sounds pretty ridiculous.
80
But to Patrick Jane, that would make him more interested rather than less.
81
Once Walter enters Jane's orbit, I think Jane notices very quickly that there's something underneath the awkward exterior that he possesses.
82
Jane would become convinced Walter is suspicious long before the CBI has enough evidence to arrest him.
83
Or in this case, you could just say the DEA.
84
Now, Walter is incredibly resourceful when cornered.
85
And unlike many killers Jane deals with, Walter is willing to suddenly become extremely violent when survival demands it.
86
I mean, for God's sakes, he literally blew up a whole entire building.
87
Jane would need Lisbon and the rest of the team watching him carefully because one mistake could actually get somebody killed.
88
Ultimately though, Walter's ego destroys almost every perfect situation he creates.
89
Jane is basically an expert in weaponizing ego and I think he eventually gets Walter White to expose himself, but Walter would make him earn it.
90
But I don't know, we're talking about an entire drug operation, but then again, Jane wouldn't really need to expose the entire operation.
91
You would just need to expose Walter White as Heisenberg and for that specific reason, I think it'll take some time.
92
Next we have the Trinity Killer from Dexter.
93
Now, before we continue this video any further, if you haven't already subscribed, it would mean the world to me if you did.
94
I am currently on the road to 100,000 subscribers and if you've been enjoying these videos, there's plenty more content like this on the way.
95
Every new subscriber helps me get one step closer to that goal.
96
So thank you guys so much for the support and let's get back to the video.
97
Now Trinity is almost perfectly designed to be difficult for law enforcement.
98
He literally operated for decades without getting caught.
99
He also moved through different jurisdictions, maintained a family, held a respectable position in his community,
100
volunteered with charities, and developed a murder cycle that investigators didn't even fully understand for years.
101
And by the way, while they were investigating him, they got it wrong.
102
Well, they didn't get it completely wrong.
103
They just forgot one step.
104
If Jane joins the investigation without Nexter Morgan already pointing toward Arthur, finding Trinity would take a very long time.
105
And what makes Arthur especially dangerous is how convincing his public persona is.
106
Now, Patrick Jane would probably see through Arthur once he actually spends enough time around him.
107
But getting Arthur into that room is the actual problem.
108
Now, there are thousands of respectable middle-aged men who could theoretically fit the profile
109
because Trinity doesn't need to constantly communicate with investigators and he doesn't intentionally leave some grand message specifically designed for law enforcement.
110
Now Jane could determine
111
that the killer is recreating some kind of traumatic family structure especially after the full cycle becomes understood
112
but turning that insight into Arthur Mitchell's name is pretty difficult.
113
The only reason Dexter found out who Trinity was was
114
because he stole Frank Lundy's private research files
115
and then he uses basic deduction skills to then pinpoint who could be the next possible suspect.
116
Now for this one, I'm not going to lie, the Trinity Killer for me definitely would be an elite survivalist.
117
I feel like it's pretty hard to pinpoint Arthur Mitchell as the Trinity Killer.
118
So yes, I feel like he's an elite survivalist.
119
Next we have Lalo Salamanca.
120
Lalo is both socially brilliant and completely comfortable with violence.
121
Now Jane's greatest strength is recognizing when someone's external behavior doesn't match what's happening internally.
122
But Lalo is one of those rare characters where knowing he's dangerous doesn't necessarily give you a practical way to stop him.
123
Jane would almost certainly dislike Lalo immediately.
124
Maybe not because he instantly knows he's a cartel killer, but because that charm is too controlled.
125
Because once Lalo decides Patrick Jane is an actual threat, this stops becoming a detective story and starts becoming a survival problem for Patrick Jane.
126
And if Jane, and I'm not gonna lie, Jane isn't beating Lalo in a physical confrontation at all.
127
His best chance is coordinating with law enforcement and setting an airtight trap before Lalo knows he's the target.
128
Because hey, eventually if Patrick Jane knows that Lalo's gonna come after him, maybe he could just tip off law enforcement and be like, yo, this is the spot where he's gonna try to kill me at,
129
send the SWAT team, or I don't know, something like that.
130
Lalo 100% goes in elite survivalists.
131
Next, we have Johan Liebert.
132
Now, Johan is almost the anti-Patrick Jane.
133
Now, Jane manipulates people by understanding them, But Johan does essentially the exact same thing at an even more disturbing level.
134
Johan can enter someone's life, discover their insecurities, fears, guilt,
135
and desires and then completely reshape their behavior without needing to personally commit the crime himself.
136
People will kill for him or he could just manipulate people to unalive themselves.
137
And if anything Johan might become interested in Jane's trauma and start manipulating that instead.
138
maybe figure out the truth, but figuring out Johan Liebert and actually catching Johan Liebert, I mean, brother, I'm not gonna lie, you're not catching Johan Liebert, brother.
139
No, I think Johan disappears before Jane could even build a strong case enough to even stop him.
140
So 100%, Johan Liebert is the first person in this video that would escape Patrick Jane.
141
And last but not least, we have Light Yagami.
142
Now, Light isn't necessarily impossible for Jane to psychologically understand.
143
In fact, I think Jane would probably find Light suspicious much earlier than most investigators.
144
But understanding that light might be Kira doesn't solve the fundamental problem.
145
I mean, L had this problem as well.
146
Because Patrick Jane has absolutely no logical reason to conclude
147
that a supernatural notebook exists
148
that can kill somebody anywhere in the world as long as the user knows their name and face.
149
Well, actually, maybe he could because he kind of dabbles with quote-unquote magic himself.
150
Now, for L to actually know that the supernatural exists, he had to conduct extremely specific experiments just to establish basic rules surrounding Kira's power.
151
Jane might eventually determine that Kira needs information about his victims and that the police information is somehow being leaked, but getting from there to Light Agami owns a notebook given
152
to him by a Shinigami is almost impossible without supernatural evidence appearing directly in front of him.
153
And Jane has another enormous problem.
154
His identity is public.
155
Patrick Jane is famous within the world of the mentalist.
156
He literally appeared on television as a psychic and later publicly worked major cases and if Light decides Jane is becoming dangerous,
157
dude Jane will literally die 100%.
158
He would be dead by daylights.
159
Now Jane might be able to protect himself
160
if he somehow learns Kira's rules quickly enough but realistically I don't think he gets that opportunity.
161
So Light Yagami if I could just make a new tier I would say he kills Patrick Jane.
162
I don't even think he just escapes him.
163
He definitely kills Patrick Jane 110%.
164
So yeah, let me know what you guys think about this video.
165
And if you guys want a part three, let me know in the comment section down below.
✨ 추천 영상
B21
198 문장
Could Patrick Jane Prove Light Yagami Is Kira?
High School StudentsUniversity Students
B22
261 문장
The BEST Dead Rails WEAPON TIER LIST (UPDATED)
TeensHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B12
58 문장
Daniel Radcliffe surprises himself with his Harry Potter film rankings
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B2352 문장
Jenna Ortega Doesn’t Flinch While Eating Spicy Wings | Hot Ones
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B21
93 문장
You Missed THIS After Episode 9 - The Amazing Digital Circus
TeensHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B25
252 문장
The Mentalist being a comedy show for MORE 10 minutes
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
447 문장
I read Stephen King for the first time... while home alone 😳
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B22
297 문장
Code name SEVENTEEN🕶️ 조슈아, 버논 요원의 특별한 만남 | '미션 임파서블: 데드 레코닝 PART ONE' INTERVIEW🎙
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B2298 문장
I Actually Went to The Appalachian Mountains *WARNING*
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B22
262 문장
ROBLOX GAMES Based on SERIAL KILLERS..
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B13
63 문장
How to Survive Leatherface
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B24
297 문장
10 Worst In-Game Decisions I Shouldn't Have Made
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
이 비디오, 영어 회화 연습에 완벽한 이유
이번 비디오는 shadowing site에서 자주 찾는 실용적인 발음과 표현을 풍부하게 담고 있어요. 특히 IELTS 스피킹 준비생들에게 좋은 연습 소재로, 일상적이지만 살아있는 대화체를 배울 수 있습니다. 화자는 자연스러운 억양과 패턴을 사용하며, 복잡한 주제도 쉽게 풀어내는 방법을 보여주기 때문에 shadow speech 연습에 최적입니다.
자연스러운 표현, 깊게 분석하기
- "He'd sit in a room with everyone connected to the murders and start talking." - "He'd"는 "He would"의 축약형으로, 일상 대화에서 자주 사용됩니다. "connected to"는 "관련된"이라는 뜻으로, 복잡한 관계를 간단히 표현할 때 유용해요. 이 문장은 자연스러운 어순과 축약형을 통해 구어체의 느낌을 살리고 있습니다.
- "Spectre wants to appear emotionally controlled, but underneath that control is obsession." - "appear emotionally controlled"는 "감정적으로 통제된 것처럼 보이다"로, 부사구의 위치가 자연스럽습니다. "underneath that control is..."는 문장 구조를 뒤집어 강조하는 표현으로, 글의 리듬을 다양하게 만듭니다. 이렇게 구조를 바꾸면 말이 더 생동감있어 보입니다.
- "Jane would probably construct an extremely accurate picture of Spectre before knowing his name." - "construct an accurate picture of"는 "정확한 모습을 그리다"로, 구체적인 상황을 표현할 때 사용됩니다. "before knowing his name"은 시간 순서를 명확히 하면서도, 문장을 길게 늘리지 않고 자연스럽게 연결합니다. 이 표현은 논리적인 흐름을 유지하면서도 구어체의 자유로움을 잃지 않습니다.
실전 연습 루틴: Repeat-and-Record
shadowspeaks 연습법을 활용해 보세요! 1분 분량의 대화를 선택해 다음 단계로 연습하세요:
- 비디오를 2-3번 듣고, 억양과 강세를 주의깊게 관찰하세요. 특히 "He'd", "isn't" 같은 축약형의 발음을 확인하세요.
- 한 문장씩 멈추고, 따라서 말해보세요. 목소리 높낮이와 속도를 최대한 비슷하게 맞춰요.
- 자신의 목소리를 녹음한 뒤, 원본과 비교해 봅니다. 발음이 어긋나는 부분이나 억양이 부족한 곳을 찾아 수정하세요.
- 5분씩 매일 연습하면, 1주일 만에 자연스러운 표현이 늘어날 거예요!
이 비디오는 영어 회화 연습뿐만 아니라, 논리적인 사고와 표현 능력도 기르는 데 도움이 됩니다. 꾸준히 연습하다 보면, IELTS 스피킹에서도 자신감 있게 답변할 수 있을 거예요!
이 영상의 문법
화자가 가장 많이 쓰는 문형을 영상 속 실제 표현과 함께 정리했습니다.
| 문형 | 영상 속 표현 |
|---|---|
| 조건문 if + 절, will/would + 동사 — 조건과 그 결과 | if you haven't already subscribed, it would mean |
| 수동태 be + 과거분사 — 누가 하는지보다 무슨 일이 일어나는지에 초점 | was stolen · isn't simply obsessed · is disciplined |
| 현재완료 have/has + 과거분사 — 과거의 일이 지금도 관련이 있을 때 | has spent · has dealt · has constructed |
쉐도잉이란? 영어 실력을 빠르게 키우는 과학적 방법
쉐도잉(Shadowing)은 원래 전문 통역사 훈련을 위해 개발된 언어 학습 기법으로, 다언어 학자인 Dr. Alexander Arguelles에 의해 대중화된 방법입니다. 핵심 원리는 간단하지만 매우 강력합니다: 원어민의 영어를 들으면서 1~2초의 짧은 지연으로 즉시 소리 내어 따라 말하는 것——마치 '그림자(shadow)'처럼 화자를 따라가는 것입니다. 문법 공부나 수동적인 청취와 달리, 쉐도잉은 뇌와 입 근육이 동시에 실시간으로 영어를 처리하고 재현하도록 훈련합니다. 연구에 따르면 이 방법은 발음 정확도, 억양, 리듬, 연음, 청취력, 말하기 유창성을 크게 향상시킵니다. IELTS 스피킹 준비와 자연스러운 영어 소통을 원하는 분들에게 특히 효과적입니다.