쉐도잉 연습: Top 10 MOST Powerful Negotiation Tips | Black Swan Method | Chris Voss - YouTube로 영어 말하기 배우기
B2
Now let's dive in.
310 문장
문장이 너무 짧거나 길면 Edit를 눌러 조정하세요.
1
Now let's dive in.
2
Number one, is now a bad time to talk?
3
Now we're going to give you several no-oriented questions in a row
4
because they're awesome and they help get you an advantage right away.
5
But one of the things I'm going to underscore on these no-oriented questions is the issue of decision fatigue.
6
Now look, everybody's got the same problem.
7
We all suffer from decision fatigue.
8
You suffer from decision fatigue.
9
What does that mean?
10
What that means is there are only so many decisions you can make in a given day.
11
There are only so many decisions any human being can make in a given day.
12
That's one of the reasons why if you're in prison and you come up for parole,
13
you want to come up for parole in the morning instead of the afternoon,
14
because in the afternoon they're going to give you no decision.
15
They're not going to be able to make a decision.
16
You're more likely to stay in jail.
17
This is not parole and parole board issues.
18
This is human nature issues.
19
There are only so many decisions,
20
there are only so much gas anybody has in a tank to make decisions on a given day.
21
And that's going to be a result of,
22
you know, how much sleep they got the night before,
23
what their diet is, what they ate that day,
24
whether or not they ate carbs,
25
where they are in their circadian rhythm.
26
Everybody hits a circadian low, roughly about 3 a.m and about 3 p.m.,
27
just part of being a human being, decision fatigue issues.
28
However, we found in a black swan group,
29
through practice and application, that people are capable of saying no at pretty much any time of the day.
30
I had an intern a number of years ago,
31
only wanted to ask me how and what questions,
32
because he was horrified about making a mistake.
33
In the middle of the afternoon,
34
he'd be asking me how and what questions,
35
and I just didn't have the gas in the tank to answer him to be able to engage in that deep thinking,
36
as Danny Kahneman would say.
37
So consequently, I'd say, like,
38
I don't know, don't bother me,
39
leave me alone, instead of giving him an answer.
40
Finally, I said, look, don't ever ask me a question after 1 o'clock in the afternoon where the answer isn't no,
41
because I could say no and I can think through the next several steps and give them guidance.
42
We've used this on a regular basis.
43
You got to get into practice using no-oriented questions.
44
And number one is the flip side of the most common thing you're saying on a regular basis,
45
which is wrong.
46
Actually, it's not that it's wrong.
47
It's just not great.
48
You say, have you got a few minutes to talk?
49
Now, I know you mean that respectfully.
50
and we're not throwing respect out the window here.
51
The Black Swan method is actually extremely respectful.
52
It's now a bad time to talk.
53
Test drive it.
54
Use it on a regular basis.
55
Build your know-oriented questions, mental synapses,
56
and experiment with the sort of answers that you get.
57
You're going to like them.
58
And as a side note,
59
I would say to you,
60
anybody that would say yes to that,
61
Do you really want to talk to them then,
62
at that moment, when they've actually said yes to that?
63
No, you don't.
64
All right, number two, is it a ridiculous idea?
65
Use this in place of,
66
is it a good idea for all the same reasons that I just gave you?
67
You've got to get your practice in.
68
Number three, are you against X,
69
Y, Z, whatever it may be?
70
Instead of, are you in favor of?
71
Again, you've got to use this to get into practice.
72
We had a woman in a hospital services company once who was a little skeptical of our no-oriented questions approach,
73
walked out of the room during the training
74
and reached out to the head nurse in a hospital about a program
75
that she'd been trying to get the head nurse to accept that the head nurse had been rejecting.
76
Instead of saying, do you want to agree or would you like to do this?
77
She said, are you against?
78
And then asked the question.
79
The head nurse immediately said no. They came to an agreement and they implemented the program.
80
She came walking back in the room and said,
81
you guys are not going to believe what just happened.
82
I've been trying to get agreement on this for weeks.
83
And I switched from a yes question to a no question and cut the deal.
84
Got to get your reps in.
85
Number four, have you given up on X?
86
Whatever that X may be.
87
This is context driven.
88
What's the context?
89
It has to be something they've already started on.
90
Otherwise, you're using a black swan skill as a manipulative trap,
91
which is not what we advise.
92
They have to have already started on this.
93
Now when do you use this?
94
You use this when they are ghosting you.
95
They've gone silent on you.
96
This will restart your conversation 999 times out of a thousand
97
Don't let the fact that it stops one in a thousand times stop you scare you Nothing works all the time.
98
This works more than anything else does and what makes it work?
99
Well, you got to keep this in mind Your system is perfectly designed to give you the outcome you've obtained.
100
If they've gone silent on you,
101
you've been doing something to contribute to them going silent on you.
102
You've probably been explaining.
103
You've probably been pitching.
104
You've probably been educating.
105
I'm going to stop all these things.
106
Restart the conversation with this one-shot restart.
107
and then your very next move is you've got to get a TR out of them.
108
What's a TR?
109
That's right.
110
How do you get a TR?
111
How do you get a that's right?
112
You've got to summarize their perspective,
113
particularly their reservations, their reasons for not doing it,
114
what they're up against, the difficulty of what they might be facing,
115
and then go dead silent.
116
You do not go, but here's why those aren't good reasons.
117
You got to go dead silent and get a that's right out of them.
118
If you can't get a that's right out of them at that point,
119
you've got to say, it sounds like I've left something out.
120
That's a bonus response for you to use here,
121
which is not on our top 10 list,
122
but helps you get farther in your conversations.
123
Number five, and we're going to get into the category here with letting out know a little at a time.
124
A person that I consider a good friend and I'm really impressed with,
125
Ned Coletti, former GM of the Los Angeles Dodgers.
126
We were sitting around talking about negotiation one time.
127
Ned is a phenomenal negotiator,
128
and he told me the phrase,
129
I like to let out know a little at a time.
130
This is a great attitude.
131
You do not want to let people get blindsided by you
132
suddenly saying no. You've got to let it out a little at a time.
133
And the first way of letting out no a little at
134
a time in a highly collaborative way is how am I supposed to do that?
135
Now many of you know this is one of the most famous lines with the Black Swan Method
136
and it's pretty much the opening story in the book Never Split the Difference.
137
How am I supposed to do that?
138
And we originally conceived of this as a way to passively say no,
139
even passively aggressively against the throat-cutting negotiators that are really trying to kick your backside.
140
And what it is in many other ways is it's an implementation question.
141
How questions are about implementation.
142
It's designed to let the other side realize that there's some implementation issues here.
143
This also falls in the category of what Brandon Voss has labeled forced empathy.
144
It forces the other side to take a good,
145
empathic look at your situation.
146
We use empathy because it works,
147
and we use empathy because we want to get it in return.
148
you're going to use empathy because it works
149
and you're going to use empathy because you want it in return
150
and how am I supposed to do that is a great starting point for that.
151
Now what happens if they turn around and say well that's your problem.
152
Will they put it right back on you?
153
Which will happen occasionally.
154
Once had a woman say I used how am I supposed to do
155
that and it didn't work because because they shot back right at me
156
and told me how I was supposed to do that.
157
Well, number one, the fact is it's not that it didn't work.
158
The fact is, is that it's giving you a better,
159
clearer picture of the situation.
160
They throw it right back on you.
161
They're telling you they're not interested in showing you any empathy.
162
That's an interesting clue that maybe you don't want to do business with them.
163
All right, I'm going to give you two ways to subscribe to the Black Swan Group's negotiation newsletter,
164
which is free.
165
It doesn't cost you anything.
166
I had a colleague with the FBI that used to like to say,
167
if it's free, I'll take three.
168
Here's how you subscribe to The Edge.
169
If you're in the United States.
170
If you're not, I'll give you a method right afterwards.
171
Send a text to, the number is 33777.
172
That's 33777.
173
The text message that you send is Black Swan Method,
174
Black Swan Method 233777.
175
It's concise.
176
It's actionable.
177
That's the most important parts of this.
178
Concise and actionable.
179
Comes to your email inbox on Tuesday mornings when you're ready to rock and roll and get after the week.
180
Now, if you're not inside the United States,
181
you see the Black Swan website, the homepage.
182
You go up on the right-hand side here on this menu here, you see blog.
183
Click on that.
184
Bang, you're at the negotiation edge.
185
On the right-hand side right here, subscribe.
186
First name and email, sign up now.
187
There's a ton of free information on this site,
188
on the Black Swan Group website, home.
189
Look at it.
190
Get everything free that we have.
191
If it's free, you should take three.
192
And in the model of letting out no a little at a time,
193
here's the next no that you let out,
194
which is number six on our list.
195
And it is, your offer is very generous.
196
I'm afraid that just doesn't work for me.
197
Now, here's the beauty aspects of this.
198
You mentioned generous.
199
You want to encourage generosity on their part.
200
That's a good thing for you to throw into this statement.
201
Second part, it just doesn't work for me.
202
That removes the problem of external criteria.
203
Now, my academic brothers and sisters like to talk about,
204
well, let's agree on an external criteria.
205
Why should you agree to the external criteria?
206
Maybe the external criteria is okay and appropriate in a neutral situation or in situations other than yours.
207
Well, why should external criteria apply to you?
208
In many cases, it doesn't.
209
You want to remove an agreement on external criteria from the conversation
210
because they're only going to agree to external criteria that works against you.
211
And you don't want to put yourself in that corner.
212
This is a great way to come back with a much stronger no.
213
One of the students in our class at Georgetown said they used that phrase,
214
your offer is very generous,
215
but I'm sorry it just doesn't work for us.
216
And he said the people on the other side of the table looked at each other
217
and then looked back at them and said,
218
you're right, it is high.
219
Now that's an interesting response because you want to have an impact on what you say.
220
What you say and what they hear.
221
You want them to get across in their brain.
222
If stuff doesn't work, there's a pretty good chance it's too high.
223
You don't want them to feel backed into a corner when you're letting out Noah a little at a time.
224
And this is a great way to do that.
225
Don't back people into a corner.
226
they will disagree even when it's not in their interest to disagree.
227
Taking away their autonomy is a bad idea,
228
and that's what happens when you back people into a corner.
229
Now, number seven.
230
This is another counterintuitive response,
231
and you use it for when somebody calls you and says,
232
how are you today?
233
Instead of saying, fine, you know, how are you?
234
Or my back hurts, or it's a wonderful day.
235
When they're calling you and saying, how are you today?
236
What are they really trying to find out?
237
Well, they're really trying to find out,
238
are you in a mental place to talk about what I want to talk about?
239
So here's how you short circuit this conversation in a way that builds rapport,
240
that they appreciate, gathers information,
241
and preserves your most precious commodity and theirs, which is time.
242
It sounds like you've got a place you want to start.
243
They are going to love this.
244
Of course they have a place they want to start.
245
They've thought about it before they called you.
246
Now every now and then somebody's gonna say to you,
247
yeah I do have a place I want to start,
248
but I really want to know how are you today.
249
Cool.
250
Then engage in the conversation and then you can get back to the place they wanted to start.
251
Everybody wins.
252
Number eight, another counterintuitive response.
253
And this is how you should respond to questions when you're asked a question.
254
So the first way to respond to questions and number eight on our list is,
255
what makes you ask?
256
Just like that.
257
Now, when somebody asks you a question,
258
what's more important is the question behind the question.
259
What makes you ask? For two reasons.
260
Number one, most people are not good at asking questions.
261
That question may be a result of a committee decision.
262
You know how good a committee is?
263
Well, let me give you an example.
264
A giraffe is a horse designed by a committee.
265
So committee decision questions are going to be off.
266
Well, number two, what's really driving at what make them ask is far more important than what they actually asked.
267
So you got to find out,
268
and this is not disrespectful.
269
They're going to be happy to tell you.
270
And if they're not, well,
271
that tells you a lot about them, too.
272
And how can you respond if they say, just answer the question?
273
your response is I want to make sure
274
that I answer what you're really asking me I'm just trying
275
to dial in to what you're really after more respect
276
if they don't like respect from you that tells you a lot about them
277
and whether or not you should continue to be in business with them now what happens
278
if it's a middle of the afternoon their decision fatigue they're having trouble coming up with an answer.
279
It's too in-depth.
280
The alternate to great calibrated questions and what makes you ask is a calibrated question.
281
You want to ask an alternative label,
282
an asking label, if you will.
283
And so number nine on our list is the alternative to what makes you ask.
284
And that is, it seems like you have a good reason for asking that.
285
Or it seems like you have a good reason for asking that.
286
I gave you both inflections there.
287
Make sure you shut the front door right after you use that label.
288
What does that mean?
289
Go silent.
290
Count thousands to yourself if you have to.
291
Let them break the silence.
292
You won't get past three.
293
Be prepared to count to ten and wait respectfully.
294
This is a respectful dynamic and respect is one of your best choices.
295
Finally, number 10 on the top 10 list of black swan negotiation bullets.
296
You're going to use this when the other side is failing to perform,
297
when they're not living up to an agreement, what do you say?
298
It seems like you have a reason for not doing and then whatever it is that they didn't do,
299
X, Y, perform, finish the contract,
300
finish the work, call me back.
301
They're going to have a reason.
302
They're probably afraid to tell you
303
This is the best way to re-engage a collaborative approach to whatever the problem is so that they feel safe and respected.
304
Always the keys to a long-term relationship.
305
So these were the 10 most powerful negotiation bullets of the Black Swan Method.
306
Share this video across your network.
307
Share with the people that are on your side.
308
Remember, if you want to go fast, go alone.
309
If you want to go far, go as a team.
310
And let the Black Swan Group continue to help you up-level your negotiation skills.
앱 다운로드
당신이 말하는 모든 문장을 AI가 채점
TRENDING
인기 동영상
이 수업에 대하여
이번 수업에서는 효과적인 협상 기술에 대해 배워보겠습니다. 특히, 결정 피로와 관련된 '아니요' 중심의 질문들을 다룰 것입니다. 이 질문들은 상대방에게 우위를 제공하고 대화를 효과적으로 이끌어낼 수 있는 강력한 도구입니다. 영어 쉐도잉 연습을 통해 이러한 질문들을 자연스럽게 사용할 수 있는 능력을 기르게 될 것입니다.
핵심 어휘 및 구문
- 결정 피로 (Decision fatigue) - 한 사람의 결정 능력이 감소하는 현상
- 아니요 중심의 질문 (No-oriented questions) - 상대방이 쉽게 '아니요'라고 답할 수 있는 질문
- 햇볕의 주기 (Circadian rhythm) - 생체 시계에 따른 신체의 일주기적 변화
- 심리적 장벽 (Psychological barrier) - 결정을 내리기 어렵게 만드는 요인
- 협상 (Negotiation) - 두 당사자 간의 의견 조정 과정
- 융통성 (Flexibility) - 상황에 맞춰 생각이나 행동을 조정하는 능력
연습 팁
이 영상을 통해 영어 쉐도잉을 할 때, 말하는 속도와 톤에 주의하세요. 전문가가 이야기하는 내용을 반복하여 발음을 교정하고, 자연스러운 흐름을 익히는 것이 중요합니다. 영상에서 소개된 '아니요 중심의 질문'들을 심상으로 떠올리며 똑같이 말하는 연습을 해보세요. 특히 영상의 속도가 빠를 수 있으므로, 처음에는 속도를 줄여서 따라 하다가 점차 원래 속도로 빠르게 말해보는 것이 좋습니다.
또한, IELTS 스피킹 준비를 위해 자신의 목소리로 질문과 대답을 주고받는 연습이 필요합니다. 매일 10분씩 영어 쉐도잉을 통해 발음 교정과 대화 능력을 함께 향상시켜 보세요. 'shadowspeaks' 기술을 활용하여 더 많은 실력을 쌓을 수 있습니다.
쉐도잉이란? 영어 실력을 빠르게 키우는 과학적 방법
쉐도잉(Shadowing)은 원래 전문 통역사 훈련을 위해 개발된 언어 학습 기법으로, 다언어 학자인 Dr. Alexander Arguelles에 의해 대중화된 방법입니다. 핵심 원리는 간단하지만 매우 강력합니다: 원어민의 영어를 들으면서 1~2초의 짧은 지연으로 즉시 소리 내어 따라 말하는 것——마치 '그림자(shadow)'처럼 화자를 따라가는 것입니다. 문법 공부나 수동적인 청취와 달리, 쉐도잉은 뇌와 입 근육이 동시에 실시간으로 영어를 처리하고 재현하도록 훈련합니다. 연구에 따르면 이 방법은 발음 정확도, 억양, 리듬, 연음, 청취력, 말하기 유창성을 크게 향상시킵니다. IELTS 스피킹 준비와 자연스러운 영어 소통을 원하는 분들에게 특히 효과적입니다.
☕ 커피 한 잔 사주기
ShadowingEnglish는 여러분의 지원 덕분에 100% 무료로 운영됩니다. 서버 및 AI 유지 비용이 많이 듭니다. 여러분의 커피 한 잔이 큰 힘이 됩니다! ��