쉐도잉 연습: What is History? E.H. Carr - 영상으로 영어 말하기 배우기
연습 모드 선택
각 모드는 전체 화면 연습실로 열립니다.
106 문장
문장이 너무 짧거나 길면 Edit를 눌러 조정하세요.
1
What is history?
2
How should history be written?
3
E.H.
4
Carr, the historian, diplomat, journalist, philosopher and author of a 14-volume history on the Soviet Union,
5
set out to answer this question in 1961.
6
The book is considered a a classic.
7
Carr starts by discussing the common sense view of history.
8
In essence, that history is about facts and simply collecting as many facts as possible.
9
In this view, facts are like fish on a fishmonger's slab, ready to be chosen and cooked.
10
There are basic facts, raw materials, but the facts only speak when the historian calls on them.
11
Carr compares the fact that the Battle of Hastings happened in 1066,
12
with the fact that in 1850 a gingerbread vendor was killed by an angry mob.
13
The latter is not well known, it is unimportant.
14
One is selected over the other because it's considered useful.
15
We use the fact to understand something larger.
16
So on the one side we have the historian in the present making a judgement about what facts to select.
17
On the other side, there are documents, letters, diaries, treaties, etc. These are facts of a certain kind,
18
but tell us no more than what the author thought and are of course invariably one-sided.
19
Carr says that the classical liberal view of history, popular across the 19th century, proposes that, like the hidden hand of the market,
20
Letting historians pick from this fishmonger's slab of facts would result in a universal harmony.
21
The truth would emerge.
22
Carr starts to point out a few problems with this view.
23
First, the facts of the past are only accessible through the present.
24
He says of the historian, the very words which he uses, words like democracy, empire, war,
25
have current connotations from which he cannot divorce them.
26
A historical event looks very different through the eyes of a 17th century Frenchman than it does to a 21st century American.
27
But does this lead to what Carr calls total skepticism?
28
If there are different views at different times, how can any of them be the right one?
29
Is there no objective position from which to view history?
30
To answer the problem of total scepticism, Carr starts with the common view of historical work.
31
That is that 1 the facts are collected and 2 they are interpreted and written into a narrative.
32
For Carr, though, this isn't accurate.
33
It's much more likely that the process is reciprocal.
34
Some facts are collected, a tentative interpretation is made, more facts are collected, the interpretation is revised, and so on.
35
He says the historian is engaged in a continuous process of moulding his facts to his interpretation, and his interpretation to his facts.
36
It is impossible to assign primacy to one over the other.
37
This process is a dialogue between facts in the past and the historian contextualised in the present.
38
He says the past is intelligible to us only in the light of the present, and we can fully understand the present only in the light of the past.
39
He then goes on to say that the process is not just an individual one.
40
The men whose actions the historians studies were not isolated individuals acting in a vacuum,
41
they acted in the context and under the impulse of a past society.
42
He argues then that this means it's obvious we must look at social forces, class vested interests as well as individuals.
43
So as well as history being a dialogue between the past and the present, it's now a dialogue between the individual and society.
44
He's painting a picture on multiple axes – past and present, individual and societal.
45
But how then do we retain any sense of objectivity?
46
How do we know where to look and which facts to pick up?
47
To begin to get out of this predicament, Carr moves to compare the process of the historian to the process of the inductive method in science.
48
He says scientists no longer really spend their time searching for the laws of nature, but instead come up with a hypothesis,
49
test whether it's a fact, then reassess.
50
Science is also driven by a back and forth, and by values in the present.
51
He explores a number of objections to history being a science, problematising them in turn.
52
For example, it is said that science deals with the general and history with the particular, with unique events.
53
But he argues that history is also general.
54
For example, the historian looks for the causes of the phenomenon of war or revolutions.
55
These are general categories.
56
Another objection is that history is unable to predict the future.
57
But he points out that although science predicts, it only predicts probabilities.
58
Gravity might predict how an apple falls from a tree, but it can't predict things getting in the way or someone catching it before it hits the ground.
59
He also notes that modern physics after Einstein is also relative, not as universal as was once thought.
60
Ultimately, he says that the word science already covers so many different branches of knowledge, employing so many different methods and techniques,
61
that the onus seems to rest on those who seek to exclude history rather than on those who seek to include it.
62
Carr's view of history as a science is probably the view that would receive the most criticism today.
63
He moves on to look at causation.
64
For a long time, historians and philosophers looked for universal laws of history, to try and make it more scientific.
65
Historians now look for multiple causes.
66
The Bolshevik revolution, for example, might be said to be caused by the failure of the Tsar, the impoverished proletariat, Lenin's character,
67
etc. Usually a primary cause is given, then maybe a hierarchy of causes.
68
Carr draws an analogy.
69
Driving back from a party, a man who has drank too much,
70
in a a car with defective brakes kills a man crossing the road to get cigarettes at a blind corner.
71
What was the cause?
72
And what is our motivation in finding out what the cause is?
73
To make roads safer?
74
To reduce drinking?
75
Maybe he was killed because he was desperate for cigarettes, but by intuition we distinguish between rational and accidental causes.
76
Carr's point here and he quotes the German historian Friedrich Meineck,
77
is that, "...the search for causalities in history is impossible without reference to values.
78
Behind the search for causalities there always lies,
79
directly or indirectly, the search for values." We are always trying to learn something from history.
80
This leads Carr to argue that,
81
to avoid total scepticism, the facts and interpretations historians choose should be organised around the idea of progress.
82
Maybe not as an unbroken straight line without reverses and deviations, as he says, but progress all the same.
83
Ultimately he says that a belief in progress means belief not in any automatic
84
or inevitable process but in the progressive development of human potentialities.
85
Being objective, choosing the facts and the hierarchy of causes, means considering the future.
86
He says when we call a historian objective we mean I think two things.
87
First of all we mean
88
that he has the capacity to rise above the limited version of his own situation in society and in history.
89
Secondly, he means
90
that he has the capacity to project his vision into the
91
future in such a way as to give him a more profound
92
and more lasting insight into the past than can be attained
93
by those historians whose outlook is entirely bounded by their own immediate situation.
94
In other words, historians should work to transform society as much as other disciplines do.
95
Carr has been criticised for having a relativistic view of history.
96
That the facts and questions are determined by the present, so that no objective reading of the past is possible.
97
But through an optimism about the future, Carr also tries to draw a route back to objectivity,
98
picking facts through the value of progress.
99
It's a unique argument and many have claimed it doesn't hold today, but the text, both short and rich,
100
is still held as a classic introduction to the question, what is history?
101
If you want to support Then and Now then please subscribe below
102
and most importantly click the bell here to receive notifications when I upload a new video.
103
You can also follow me on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram in the links in the description below and
104
if you're feeling really generous then this channel only exists through
105
the support of pledges on Patreon where you can support new content with as little as a dollar for each new video.
106
Thanks for watching, see you next week.
앱 다운로드
유창하게 말하는 데 필요한 모든 것
AI 발음 평가문장마다 점수 확인
IPA 발음 연습모든 소리 마스터
단어 학습나만의 단어장 만들기
단어 게임놀면서 외우기
FOR YOU
추천 영상
이 레슨의 어휘와 말하기 포인트
이 영상에는 섀도잉할 문장 106개와 단어 1442개가 있습니다. 말하는 구간의 길이는 9:47입니다. 화자는 분당 약 147단어의 일정한 속도로 말해서 섀도잉하기에 편한 속도입니다. 단어의 82%가 영어에서 가장 많이 쓰이는 3,000단어에 속합니다. 나머지는 연습 전에 미리 확인해 두세요.
이 영상의 핵심 어휘
영상에 나오는 덜 흔한 단어 15개를 발음, 뜻과 함께 정리했습니다.
- historian /hɪˈstɔɹi.ən/ (명사) — 역사학자, 력사학자. A writer of history.
- interpretation /ɪnˌtɜːpɹəˈteɪʃən/ (명사) — 통역. An act of interpreting or explaining something unclear; a translation; a version.
- predict /pɹɪˈdɪkt/ (동사) — 예언하다, 예측하다. To make a prediction: to forecast, foretell, or estimate a future event on the basis of knowledge and reasoning; to prophesy a future event on the basis of…
- collect /ˈkɑlɪkt/ (동사) — 수집하다. To gather together; amass.
- objective /ɒbˈd͡ʒɛk.tɪv/ (명사) — 목적. A material object that physically exists.
- universal /ˌjunəˈvɜɹs(ə)l/ (형용사) — 우주(宇宙)의, 우주적. Of or pertaining to the universe.
- argue /ˈɑɹ.ɡju/ (동사) — 논하다, 의논하다. To show grounds for concluding (that); to indicate, imply.
- dialogue /ˈdaɪəˌlɑɡ/ (명사) — 대화, 회화. A conversation or other form of discourse between two or more individuals.
- belief /bɪˈliːf/ (명사) — 믿음. Mental acceptance of a claim as true.
- compare /kəmˈpɛɚ/ (동사) — 비교하다, 비유하다. To assess the similarities and differences between two or more things [“to compare X with Y”]. Having made the comparison of X with Y, one might have found it…
- select /sɪˈlɛkt/ (동사) — 고르다. To choose one or more elements of a set, especially a set of options.
- cigarette /ˈsɪɡəɹɛt/ (명사) — 담배, 궐련. A small cigar consisting of tobacco or another substance, wrapped up in a thin roll with paper, intended for smoking.
- hierarchy /ˈhaɪ.ə.ɹɑː(ɹ).ki/ (명사) — 계층. A body of authoritative officials organized in nested ranks.
- objection /əbˈd͡ʒɛkʃən/ (명사) — 반대, 이의. The act of objecting.
- philosopher /fəˈlɑsəfɚ/ (명사) — 철학자. A lover of wisdom.
영상에 나오는 구동사
- look for (동사) — 찾다, 구하다. To seek.
- point out (동사) — 가리키다. To identify among a group of similar subjects, or in a scene where the subject might not be readily seen or noticed, with a gesture of the body.
- pick up (동사) — 줍다. To lift; to grasp and raise.
주의할 발음
화자는 can't, doesn't, isn't 같은 축약형과 약화된 형태를 4번 사용합니다. 들리는 대로 짧게 발음하세요.
- “sh”와 “zh” 소리: interpretation /ɪnˌtɜːpɹəˈteɪʃən/, objection /əbˈd͡ʒɛkʃən/, motivation /ˈmoʊ.tə.veɪ.ʃən/, rational /ˈɹæʃ(ə)nəl/, notification /ˌnoʊtɪfɪˈkeɪʃn̩/
- 긴 단어 — 강세 위치에 주의: historian /hɪˈstɔɹi.ən/, interpretation /ɪnˌtɜːpɹəˈteɪʃən/, universal /ˌjunəˈvɜɹs(ə)l/, hierarchy /ˈhaɪ.ə.ɹɑː(ɹ).ki/, philosopher /fəˈlɑsəfɚ/
이 영상으로 연습하는 방법
- 먼저 말하지 않고 영상을 끝까지 듣고 모르는 단어를 적어 둡니다.
- 보통 속도로 한 문장씩 섀도잉하고, 화자의 리듬과 맞을 때까지 반복합니다.
- 자신의 목소리를 녹음해 원본과 비교하고, historian, interpretation, predict 같은 단어에 특히 주의합니다.
이 영상의 문법
화자가 가장 많이 쓰는 문형을 영상 속 실제 표현과 함께 정리했습니다.
| 문형 | 영상 속 표현 |
|---|---|
| 수동태 be + 과거분사 — 누가 하는지보다 무슨 일이 일어나는지에 초점 | be written · is considered · be chosen |
| 현재완료 have/has + 과거분사 — 과거의 일이 지금도 관련이 있을 때 | has been criticised · have claimed |
| 관계절 who / which + 절 — 사람이나 사물에 대한 추가 정보 | those who seek · man who has |
쉐도잉이란? 영어 실력을 빠르게 키우는 과학적 방법
쉐도잉(Shadowing)은 원래 전문 통역사 훈련을 위해 개발된 언어 학습 기법으로, 다언어 학자인 Dr. Alexander Arguelles에 의해 대중화된 방법입니다. 핵심 원리는 간단하지만 매우 강력합니다: 원어민의 영어를 들으면서 1~2초의 짧은 지연으로 즉시 소리 내어 따라 말하는 것——마치 '그림자(shadow)'처럼 화자를 따라가는 것입니다. 문법 공부나 수동적인 청취와 달리, 쉐도잉은 뇌와 입 근육이 동시에 실시간으로 영어를 처리하고 재현하도록 훈련합니다. 연구에 따르면 이 방법은 발음 정확도, 억양, 리듬, 연음, 청취력, 말하기 유창성을 크게 향상시킵니다. IELTS 스피킹 준비와 자연스러운 영어 소통을 원하는 분들에게 특히 효과적입니다.











