Shadowing Practice: Answering Questions About Time Travel, Solar Sailing & Galaxy Collisions - Learn English Speaking with Video

Choose a practice mode

Each mode opens a full-screen practice room.

775 sentences
If sentences are too short or too long, click Edit to adjust them.
1
Let's dive into some fascinating questions, if you do say so yourself.
2
We'll be the judge of that.
3
Yeah, we'll be the judge of that.
4
Yuba City, California.
5
What kind of city?
6
Yuba. Yuba.
7
It's right next to Yabba Dabba Dooba.
8
Did you ever see the alien take a poop?
9
Is the human connection scientifically essential for learning?
10
I love that.
11
Ismic Asimov Foundation, it is awesome.
12
Oh, yes, yes.
13
Gravitational entropy.
14
Flatlanders and 4D space.
15
Okay, now I'm confused.
16
This is Star Talk: Cosmic Queries.
17
I got with me Chuck Nice.
18
Chuck. Hey, what's happening, Neil?
19
All right. This is a grab bag.
20
Yes, it is.
21
What's the verdict on how long it takes me to answer a question?
22
Believe it or not, because they put out this to the audience, they like the longer answers.
23
The producers- Well, the producers- got data on this.
24
want us to go, want us to go as quickly as possible as they wanna get more answers in.
25
Yeah, but- That was the But, they asked the people, and the people liked the long answers.
26
And people spoke.
27
Yes. The people have spoken.
28
They have risen up.
29
That's right.
30
All right. The voice- I won't do it on purpose, it just, um, it's- it's- it's organic- You gotta- when it happens.
31
It's the passion.
32
The passion of the universe flowing through me.
33
This is Alex K who says, "Hello, Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice.
34
Alex from Bucharest, Romania here." Bucharest?
35
Bucharest. "What keeps me up at night is flatlanders and 4D space.
36
I often hear-" Ah, I love That's some geeky stuff right there.
37
Yeah, man. That's, that We gotta give him a geek award for that.
38
There you go.
39
Okay? He says, "I often hear that dark matter or dark energy could be the 4D leaking into our 3D space.
40
But living in 3D space, can we ever actually observe a truly 2D space?
41
And if not, wouldn't that mean 4D beings couldn't interfere with our world either, just as we don't notice any real 2D beings?" I see where he's coming from.
42
Yeah. I think.
43
What he's saying is, if there were 2D creatures in our world, how would we ever know?
44
Right. All right.
45
So, holding aside the fact that if you're 2D you have no thickness.
46
Right. If you have 0 thickness, how does any light or matter even interact with you?
47
'Cause light and matter- Reflect.
48
Re- y- yeah.
49
Okay. And, and Right. But, so let's just ignore that very real complication.
50
But let's ignore it for the moment.
51
Okay. Okay?
52
There was a cartoon back when the internet was a fun place to just explore humor and cat videos.
53
Oh, yeah. There was a- Those were the days.
54
There were 2 illustrated creatures, and one of them was 2D.
55
I forgot their names.
56
It's like, "Hey, Joey, I just became 2D." And he's looking at him, he looks a little flat.
57
But, but he wasn't sure.
58
And all he did was turn sideways- Turns and disappears.
59
Disappears.
60
He turn, he turns sideways towards your sight line.
61
Right. And, and then they laughed, and they were just having a good time.
62
Those were the days on the internet.
63
Man Yeah. Man.
64
Now it's nothing but Nazis.
65
Exactly. It's, it's Nazi yattee.
66
No, I'm kidding.
67
So So, it implies that even if you're invisible edge on, that the light is somehow still reflecting off of you face on.
68
Right. Okay?
69
So, a 2D world in front of us would be completely visible.
70
You would see light reflecting off of their substance.
71
Right. Their 2D substance, whatever that is.
72
Right. Only when they go sideways do they disappear.
73
Okay. From your view.
74
Right. Because they have no thickness.
75
So, we 3dimensional creatures, what would w- Would 4dimensional, spatial dimensional creatures be able to see us?
76
It means there must be some orientation we can take where we disappear to them.
77
Right. Just following this, this sequence.
78
I don't, I can't picture what that would be.
79
Uh Yeah, well, yeah.
80
N- you know, I, I can't either because I'm 3D, so I'm looking around, everything's 3D.
81
So how, wh- You know, what do I look like to a 4D guy?
82
I don't know, you know.
83
I don't know how a 3D person would hide from a 4D person, which way to orient ourselves, the way a 2D person can do that to us.
84
Mm-hmm. I don't know how you'd do that.
85
I have to think about it some more.
86
What I do know is, and we've said this before, if you're looking at a 2D creature, you can see inside their organs, their inner organs.
87
2D people can't see, 'cause they have skin, this line- Right.
88
which is their 2D skin, they can't see through the line.
89
But we can see directly into their bodies.
90
So I, I look really ugly to a 4D person.
91
A 4D person, they see, they'll see all your guts.
92
Mm, they just see guts and, yeah.
93
And I think the first thing we do when we have 4dimensional beings is to make them medical doctors and have them perform surgery.
94
Right. 'Cause- With- it's a game of Operation for them.
95
There's nothing to it.
96
Take out, wrench ankle.
97
Good to go.
98
I forgot about that game.
99
Operation. Uh, I wonder how many people became doctors outta that.
100
Uh. You know, that's a proba- If they did, they're probably pretty bad doctors.
101
I'm just saying.
102
Like, if the game Operation was your inspiration, you know- they're standing over the operating table with a pair of tweezers.
103
"I don't know what to do." Uh Or they're trying to settle, uh, malpractice suits.
104
Right. So, that's what I know.
105
And for me, that's the most intriguing thing.
106
Yeah. That you can see inside of somebody who's otherwise completely enclosed in skin.
107
in the same way the 2D person is completely enclosed by a line.
108
Right, and you can see what's inside that line.
109
Inside that line.
110
Right. So that's the best I can give them on that question.
111
Yeah, okay, yeah.
112
Well, that's cool.
113
Yeah. Uh, otherwise, yeah, I n- I don't know where to take it.
114
Yeah. Mm-hmm.
115
All right, well, this is Jeff Drumsites, and Jeff Drumsites says, uh, "Greetings, Dr. Tyson, Lord Gneiss.
116
I recently began watching Apple TV's version of Ismic Asimov's Foundation.
117
It is awesome." Oh, yes, yes.
118
That's the one where they have the, the, the her- hereditary rulers- Correct.
119
who are clones of each other.
120
Clone, the clones.
121
That's the limit of heredi- of heredity.
122
That's it. Tha- that's it, you know?
123
All the lineage is just a cloned line that you have- Precise, right.
124
Dawn, Day, and Dusk.
125
Mm. So there's- And Day is the ruler.
126
Day is the ruler.
127
Yeah. Da- Da- Dusk is the wisdom.
128
The wisdom, and Dawn is learning.
129
And who's And Dawn is learning.
130
Okay. And they are in that constant, cyclical state- Mm-hmm.
131
of replacing one another.
132
Right. And at a certain time, they have to be destroyed and move on.
133
Mm-hmm. It's pretty wild.
134
Uh, but anyway, he says this.
135
"When I was a child in the '50s, my dad's Popular Science magazine depicted the idea of a space elevator," which they have in, uh, Foundation.
136
Um, Trantor is the planet on which the rulers live, and the way you get to Trantor is from a space elevator.
137
So anyway, "My question is" Oh, he says, "Is the Trantor star bridge or any type of space elevator technically conceivable?" Jeff Sites in Gallatin, Tennessee.
138
Okay. Or Gallatin, Tennessee.
139
The answer is yes.
140
Yes? Yes. Yes?
141
But, so th- some things to take note of.
142
Okay. The motivation for a space elevator is you can get to an orbit without ever firing a rocket.
143
Yeah, there you go.
144
You just All right.
145
You just get on the elevator.
146
Get on the elevator.
147
Uh, third floor, women's lingerie, and, "Where are you going, sir?" Oh, okay.
148
And is that still a joke, lingerie?
149
That, that was the big I got it from Bugs Bunny.
150
R- okay. The real question is, what is an entire floor doing of just lingerie?
151
Yeah, exactly.
152
That's a, that's the Nobody's asking that question.
153
Right. So, I have a friend who composes space music, and she created an album called Space Elevator Music.
154
That's funny, right.
155
Right? On Earth, a space elevator would take you to the geosynchronous orbit because that's the only orbit that hovers, appears to hover over Earth- Right.
156
its corresponding spot on Earth.
157
Any orbit that's closer, it will speed up ahead of the orbit of the Earth.
158
Right. Okay?
159
So to have an elevator go from a position on Earth's surface to a position in orbit, it has to go to geosynchronous.
160
And on Earth, that's 23,000 miles.
161
So you'd be sitting in an elevator going 23,000 miles.
162
Wow. If your elevator were going a thousand miles an hour, how long would it take you to get 23,000 hours.
163
No, no. I mean, a thousand miles an hour, 23 hours, that's a full day.
164
It's still a full day.
165
It'd take you one day to get a And we, we already get to space quicker than that.
166
Yeah, I know.
167
That's right.
168
Okay, so the idea was getting to space must be so hard with all these rocket engines and things that we need another way.
169
And, but access to space now is routine.
170
Mm-hmm. And the price continues to drop, especially because of innovations in SpaceX, um, Elon Musk and i- it was a big mission statement of his with regard to SpaceX.
171
You hardly hear talk of a space eleler- elevator today.
172
Right, anymore.
173
Right. It was a solution to a non-problem.
174
And you know what fuel we're using?
175
Hydrogen and oxygen.
176
Right. Well, there's some solid rocket boosters, but the main tank is hydrogen, twice as big as the oxygen tank.
177
You And it's liquified.
178
You put them together, they will combine in H2 and O.
179
Oh, okay. So the exhaust is what?
180
Uh, drinkable.
181
So, yeah, the exhaust is just water, but it's highly exothermic.
182
Right. So space elevator is a, a cool technological achievement, but I don't see it- Highly impractical.
183
uh, I don't see it happening.
184
All right. Mm-hmm. Well, there you go.
185
That's Uh, but also the That series is It starts off boring as hell.
186
Mm-hmm. But then it really gets great, so.
187
Nope, that's lame.
188
Ready? Do you harbor questions about the universe?
189
Some long-held bit of cosmic curiosity lingering within you?
190
Or questions about anything at all?
191
can become a Patreon supporter of Star Talk.
192
You have access to our exclusive question line on our website.
193
Those are where we draw our questions for our cosmic queries.
194
Some of the most extreme objects in the universe.
195
Star Talk is a work in progress, where we, every month, come up with some new way, some new idea, some new understanding of how to bring the universe down to Earth.
196
We could not do that without your support.
197
Thank you. And as always, keep looking up.
198
All right. This is Raphael, who says, "Hello." Raphael Vigod, or Vigod, uh, in Toronto, Ontario.
199
"If a super intelligent extraterrestrial offered to grant you the answer to one specific question, what would you ask?" Now, don't think too long, because, uh, you have to give your, uh, immediate response.
200
Um, and we're only here for a few more minutes before their next interstellar train leaves.
201
Okay. So. There's a question I have every night.
202
Go ahead. Is the human brain sufficiently smart to figure out the entire universe?
203
Wow. That's a question I want answered, because if it's not, then I'll buffer my expectations.
204
Right. But if it is, then onward we march.
205
We can go, we can go from there.
206
Right. The whole The, the universe is your oyster- Right.
207
at that point.
208
That's a really interesting question, because basically, are we too stupid?
209
Yeah. That's I ask that every night.
210
Like, we might just beat, like, the whole quantum thing, and we're like, "Quantum, quantum-" Right, right.
211
"quantum." Like, maybe we're just dumb.
212
And, and, and it wouldn't be mysterious if we weren't so dumb.
213
Right. I mean, yeah, it's obvious- Yeah.
214
for, for these reasons.
215
Wow. But we can't even understand the reasons.
216
So, yeah. So that I, I wanna know.
217
Inquiring minds wanna know.
218
It's a good question.
219
Mm-hmm. I mean, that's a That I like it.
220
Me? Uh, I would like to know ha- ha- h- uh, are there cheaper eggs, uh, somewhere in the universe than, uh, where I buy mine right now?
221
'Cause they are hugely expensive.
222
No. I That's That's Really?
223
That's your quest- That's it.
224
My son, you can ask any question in the universe.
225
Right. I need some cheaper eggs.
226
Yeah. No. Uh, what would I ask if I really wanted to know anything?
227
Um, mine would be what happened before the Big Bang?
228
Really? Yeah.
229
Okay. Like, and I don't mean what happened.
230
I mean, like, 'cause we know what happened before the Big Bang.
231
Who, who You know, the Big Bang happened.
232
So what, what caused it to happen?
233
What was there before?
234
Give me, give me the lay of the land before the Big Bang.
235
Okay. All right. That'd be kinda cool to know.
236
Uh-huh. It's an origins problem.
237
An origins.
238
Yeah. And origins questions are always the most challenging in science, 'cause you don't have other examples to compare it with.
239
Exactly. And until you do, you're kinda making stuff up.
240
Exactly. Right.
241
Yeah. I mean, what's the origin of the Earth?
242
No one knew until we saw planetary systems getting formed.
243
Right. Then we'd say, "Oh, it takes this long, uh, uh, with that timeframe-" Yeah.
244
" and this distance from the host star." You can formulate questions- Right.
245
that have value.
246
But- Yeah. But it'd be kinda cool if the aliens were, or the terrestrials were just, extraterrestrials, were just like, "Yeah, you know, yeah.
247
This Your, your universe is just one of 15 million that we've been to thus far." "You know?
248
And before your This is what happened.
249
Uh, 2 other universes got together after a night of drinking, and bang." "Your your universe was born." So, anyway, um I can't believe you included alcohol ref- reference to that.
250
This is Marcus, uh, Munzlinger.
251
And Marcus Munzlinger says, "Hello from Germany." Or should I say, "Hello" No, nevermind.
252
I'm not gonna do it.
253
I'm not gonna do it.
254
Uh, "Did you ever think, uh, in my alt- in my accent, pronounced sink, about the alien in Alien not needing any digestive organs since its blood is acid, so all human flesh it eats is directly dissolved into molecules, so the alien doesn't need to produce poop since it can use 100% of its food?
255
Or did you ever see the alien take a poop?" Love your show.
256
Who knows about digestive tracts?
257
I mean, we, we played with Superman's digestive tract, and he was an alien.
258
Yes. Right?
259
That's right.
260
And we solved that one, I think.
261
Yes, we did.
262
He has a super digestive tract.
263
He has a super digestive tract.
264
And so what that means is- And everything about it is super.
265
Including the gaseous effluents.
266
In- in That's right.
267
Right. A plant-based alien, however, wouldn't have any such waste products.
268
Well, its waste product would be oxygen.That's pretty good.
269
Right. Right.
270
Right. Right, right.
271
So I don't You know, I'm cool with it.
272
Yeah, yeah.
273
It doesn't make a difference.
274
Right, right.
275
A poopless alien is totally fine.
276
That's right.
277
You know? I mean, there's nothing wrong with a poopless alien, you know?
278
But then they have to rewrite that, that book, that kids book.
279
Which one? Everybody Poops?
280
Everybody Poops. Everybody Poops.
281
This is an old This is an old bad dad joke.
282
Go ahead. What Italians call suppositories?
283
No, I don't know.
284
Innuendo. Oh, no.
285
No, please.
286
No. Yes. You know that's good.
287
Oh, no. You You know it's good.
288
That is Oh, man.
289
All right, here we go.
290
This is, uh, Matthew Landreth who says, "Greetings, StarTalk.
291
My name is Matt, a globe-trekking teacher-" Nice.
292
" who has lived and taught around the world." Teacher in the house.
293
There you go.
294
"Through these experiences, I have seen how much learning depends on human connection.
295
Dr. Tyson, as a fellow teacher and science communicator, you know how ideas ignite in others.
296
Science fiction imagines AI tutors or digital replicas guiding future generations.
297
If an AI could replicate a teacher's knowledge, style, and personality, would that truly be teaching, or is the human connection scientifically essential for learning?" I love that.
298
So a couple things.
299
If you are teaching today- Mm-hmm.
300
with methods, tools, and tactics, and then I clone that, I'm not given any reason to think that your clone would not be as effective as you are in those situations.
301
Right. You have a life experience, a training, where if someone whose profile doesn't fit that of other students, you will readjust and repackage what you know works so that you have a new pathway to reach the intellectual curiosity of that student.
302
I don't know that AI can do that just now.
303
Right. AI can, you know, ape your style.
304
It can, you know, dig up some content.
305
But it can't intuit something different that might be happening in a student- Correct.
306
and then make an adjustment.
307
And make an adjust- Especially if students change or they mature, they- Right.
308
Or they regress.
309
Right. Right.
310
So I think that frontier, at least from my foreseeable future, that is the future that I can foresee, is Remains in the realm of the inventive, creative teacher.
311
Interesting.
312
Yeah. Yeah, very cool, very cool.
313
The human condition is, uh, still a very important part of teaching.
314
No, no, it's the ever-changing human condition.
315
Oh, the ever-changing.
316
Yes, exactly.
317
Yeah, yeah, 'cause otherwise I can memorize everything- Right.
318
in that moment- Right.
319
and then that's watching it go forward in time and be nimble enough to navigate that.
320
That's the real test.
321
There you go.
322
All right, this is DJ Sipe.
323
He says, this is DJ from Maine.
324
"I've been curious about the properties of spacetime and gravity.
325
We know that gravity is the result of objects with mass bending spacetime.
326
To me, this implies that spacetime is naturally flat, but doesn't explain why.
327
Is there some force or property of spacetime acts to restore its natural flat state once an object and its gravitational field move away?
328
Perhaps some form of gravitational entropy?" Ooh, I like that idea.
329
The idea of gravitational entropy.
330
Oh, yeah, yeah.
331
Right? So he's looking at this whole rubber sheet type Yeah, yeah.
332
So I mean, all we can say is And by the way, it's not just matter that will bend space.
333
It's energy as well, 'cause matter and energy are equivalent- That's right.
334
through E equals MC squared.
335
Nice. So just be brought Be more complete addressing it that way.
336
If the Since the curvature of space and time is the manifestation of matter and energy, if you remove the matter and energy, there's no reason for the spacetime to be the matter and energy, there's no reason for the space-time to be, to be curved at all.
337
to be curved at all.
338
I'm given no reason to think that space would have any shape other than flat after you remove the, the items that would curve it.
339
Right. Keep in mind, however, the expanding or contracting universe itself has a shape unrelated to the gravity of objects it contains.
340
Right. And this is why we talked about is it an open universe, a closed universe, or a flat universe.
341
And those are large-scale properties that are not related to just one galaxy or another.
342
Yeah. There you go.
343
Mm-hmm. Very cool, man.
344
That's a great question, DJ.
345
Yeah. I know, know.
346
These people are thinking.
347
I love it. This is Keith Johnson, uh, from NorCal, and Keith says, uh, "Can we think of a universal now, based on the point of view of an observer?
348
In other words, my now.
349
Can we analyze a particular star in the night sky and determine its probable lifespan, and then say that this particular star does not, in all probability, exist anymore, in my now?
350
Its ghost is seen as a shadow of light arriving billions of light years after its demise." So what's the question in there?
351
So I guess he's saying, is that the case?
352
Like, when we look up, are we seeing stuff that's not there?
353
We, we see things not as they are, but as they once were.
354
Hmm. We're not worried if they're no longer there, because that's not a real thing we can interact with.
355
We're interacting with a light that is currently reaching us.
356
And when that light was emitted, it was alive, whatever it was.
357
Right. So So we're looking back in time, but we're looking at that time.
358
At that time. So it doesn't make a difference.
359
Not So- 'Cause we're looking at that time.
360
Correct, correct.
361
It doesn't make a difference.
362
Right. So might as well speak of it in the present.
363
Right. This star exploded last night, and though it was 1,700 years ago, but what, what do you gain by that, right?
364
Right. Other than, like a nerdy kid saying, "Yo, n- you got it wrong." Right. "It's not really in the now." So the fun part would be, find a galaxy 33 light years away.
365
Uh, sorry. Find a galaxy 33 million light years away.
366
Okay. And then if they all held up mirrors, and you looked at those mirrors, you would see the dinosaurs going extinct.
367
Oh, wow. Because it's 33 light years, years there- There- and- and 33 light years back.
368
that's 66 years- So into the past.
369
Look at that.
370
Yeah, yeah.
371
So, yeah, it's fun to think that way.
372
Right. But we You know, our speeds are not high enough to generate significant relativistic All right.
373
Well, there you have it.
374
Still a fun question, though.
375
Mm-hmm. Thanks, thanks for the fun question, buddy.
376
All right. Um, that was Keith, and this is Anthony Calameni.
377
Calameni. Tony Calameni.
378
Tony Calameni.
379
Everyone with a Italian voice does not come from Brooklyn, okay?
380
Ah. Just Uh, they do in my world.
381
All right. This is, uh, uh, this is Anthony, and he says, "Greetings from Seattle, Dr. Tyson, Lord Nice.
382
My 11-year-old son and I were discussing the pitfalls of fictional time travel within the space-time continuum-" Okay.
383
" understanding that you have pointed out on many occasions that one would have to calculate not only the space-time location on the target on Earth as it rotates on its axis, revolves around the sun, and the trajectory of our solar system moving through space, but also as our galaxy moves through the universe." Well, he covered it all.
384
Look at you, man.
385
Well This was way to go.
386
"Our question is- Yeah.
387
would one have to know the center or origin point of the universe to guarantee an accurate space-time coordinate, or would relative distances be enough, even if the universe is even if the universe isn't expanding in uniform fashion?" So he's taken into account the expansion of the universe- Yeah.
388
in the time travel equation as well.
389
Yeah, but I don't I'm trying to figure out what he's getting at.
390
So So he's saying, "I'm gonna go and come back." That's what he left out.
391
So I gotta go back, and then I gotta come back to my time.
392
So- Is he going into the past?
393
Into the past.
394
So my coordinate, okay, what am I gonna need?
395
Can I, can I accurately predict, with not only rotation of the Earth, but the solar system and the galaxy moving, and also the expansion of the universe, can I accurately pre- accurately predict the point where I gotta go back and be back in time I traveled at the speed of light, and, or faster than the speed of light, went back in time, and then come- back to that same point where I left.
396
All right. Can I do that?
397
Rich Gott, I think, would say you can.
398
Okay. Using sort of mathematical trajectories in the vicinity of black holes.
399
I have to trust him on that, 'cause I can't duplicate those calculations.
400
Okay. He's a He's studied this stuff, like professionally.
401
Okay. So he In fact, he wrote a book, Time Travel in Einstein's Universe.
402
All right. So in principle, yes.
403
But is there a no disruption conjecture, where you're not allowed to prevent your parents from meeting, thereby preventing you from being born, thereby preventing you from coming back?
404
to try to rectify things.
405
Mm-hmm. So Hey, Marvin.
406
What? Oh. Shh.
407
I think I got that sound you were looking for, Marvin.
408
No, it's me, your cousin.
409
So, Marvin?
410
Was that- No, that's right, uh, oh, he was calling Chuck Berry.
411
He's Marvin.
412
He's Marvin, right.
413
"It's me, your cousin, Marvin." Yeah. Hey, Chuck.
414
It's me, your brother, Chuck.
415
"Hey, Chuck." Right.
416
Yeah, yeah, yeah, Chuck Berry, Marvin Berry.
417
Marvin Berry.
418
Yeah, from Back to the Future- Right, yeah, yeah.
419
if you're living under a rock.
420
Uh, so And by the way, I, we, I think we talked about this on another episode, about gin particles.
421
Yes, we did, which I loved.
422
And so that's a gin song.
423
No, we did a, um, we did an explainer.
424
Explainer. So that'd be a gin song.
425
Gin song, that would be a gin song.
426
A gin song.
427
Because it didn't exist until Marvin Berry put the phone out and let Chuck Berry hear Johnny B.
428
Goode. The song that he wrote- Wrote, he wrote.
429
that he wrote, and then Marty picks it up later.
430
Right. Right. So Marty gets it in the future, but Chuck gets it in the past.
431
Right. Yeah.
432
And s- and so that song was never actually written.
433
Never actually written.
434
Right, it just lives in a time loop.
435
It j- it lives in a time loop.
436
Yeah, yeah.
437
I love that whole gin particle thing, man.
438
It's a gin, it's a gin- That's, it's gin, the, the gin stuff.
439
It's a gin song.
440
Yeah. So- What was the other movie we did that is- Oh, it was Somewhere in Time.
441
Somebody, a, a woman with a- Yeah, Somewhere in Time.
442
with a piece of jewelry or something?
443
Somewhere in Time.
444
Somewhere in Time, that's the name of it?
445
Yeah. Okay, cool.
446
It's a, it's a, it's a romantic story.
447
Oh, that's why I don't like it.
448
Okay. So anyway I was gonna say rom-com, but it's not a com.
449
Oh, okay. It's just a rom.
450
Just a rom.
451
But it had, it had Christopher Reeve in it.
452
Oh, okay. You know, Superman.
453
All right. After Superman.
454
Yeah. After he did it.
455
All right, well.
456
But, but he's a handsome guy, you know?
457
Yeah, I mean, listen, y- y- they can't all be winners.
458
He, he did Superman.
459
So anyway, uh, Rich Gott says that this can happen.
460
Yeah, yeah.
461
So I don't I can't follow his math.
462
Okay. Uh, but I mean, I'd follow it, but I couldn't derive it.
463
Right, right. I mean, he's, he's in it.
464
You gotta repeat, right.
465
He does it.
466
He does it.
467
He, he, he figures it out.
468
So I just recommend that book of his.
469
Okay. Time Travel and Einstein's Universe.
470
Time Travel and Einstein's Universe.
471
Yeah, mm-hmm.
472
Very cool. Great question, and, uh, wh- and I just like the fact that you're talking to your 11-year-old about- the universe and time travel and such specif- specificity.
473
Right. Yup.
474
Which is fantastic.
475
All right, this is Todd Chambers, who says, "Hello, Dr. Tyson.
476
This is Todd Chambers here from Yuba St- City, California." What kind of city?
477
Yuba. Yuba.
478
It's right next to Yabba Dabba Dooba.
479
Well, what's the 12:10 from Yuba?
480
Or Yu- what's that?
481
The train? Uh, I don't know.
482
No, Yuma. 12- Yuma.
483
Yuma, Yuma, not Yuba.
484
3:10 to Yuma.
485
3:10 to Yabba Dabba Dooma.
486
Okay, go on.
487
So he says, "I'm a retired naval officer and Earth science teacher." Nice.
488
Uh That's a nice combo right there.
489
That's a great combo.
490
Yeah. He says, "Does light ever do any work?" Well, it does light work.
491
No, um, he says- I'm sorry, I couldn't resist.
492
I had to do it.
493
He says, uh, "Does light ever do any work?" But it does do windows.
494
Right. And what would that look like to an observer of the night sky?
495
All right. So there's something called a solar sail.
496
Yes. Where you have a big sort of Mylar, a low-mass, high-reflective S- Mylar is, like, what they wrap around the, um- The balloons.
497
Oh, balloons, My- Mylar balloons.
498
Yeah. And I think Mylar might be what they wrap around the, the, um- The marathon runners.
499
the marathon run- the marathon run- Yeah.
500
There might be some Mar- Mylar variant.
501
Yeah. Flexible, shiny, highly reflective, so it ref- it keeps your radiant heat in.
502
Right. So it can be warm without it being a blanket.
503
Blanket, yeah.
504
Right. Right? Because that's all a good blanket does, is prevent your heat from getting out.
505
Yeah. We did a whole explainer on that.
506
Yeah, we did.
507
Like 100- On blankets.
508
Uh, uh, on blankets, 100 years ago.
509
Yes. Blanket, I love you, blanket.
510
Okay. Right.
511
'Cause many people think if you put a blanket on something, you'll make it warm.
512
Right. But no.
513
This has actually been built by funds of membership of The Planetary Society.
514
That's right.
515
A good friend of, uh, Star Talk.
516
That's right. They funded, built, and launched a solar sail.
517
And w- the way it worked is, 'cause it was a test, it was a test prototype.
518
So it's orbiting the earth, and if you wanna see if light can do work, you open up the solar sail, angle it in ways that to your advantage, and see if sunlight can press on that solar sail and increase your orbit around the earth.
519
And it did.
520
Oh, snap. So the light is doing work.
521
Light is doing work.
522
Yes. Wow. Okay?
523
And Reflection as propulsion.
524
Yes. That's amazing!
525
Yes. That's amazing!
526
Yes. Reflection as propulsion.
527
Yes. That's awesome.
528
And there's a And there's something called the Breakthrough Initiative.
529
Mm-hmm. Which is a chunk of money, some billionaires participated in this.
530
Mm-hmm. Where it gives awards for new, new inventions that we think we need, but it just takes some innovative people to do it.
531
Someone wanted When are we gonna have a tricorder?
532
Right. Just a portable thing, go And then you have all the readings.
533
Then you have Yeah, yeah.
534
Okay? That's a useful thing.
535
Why not? So cool.
536
All right. So one of them is these nanoprobes.
537
Mm-hmm. So nano means a billionth of.
538
So people have abused the word.
539
Right. They just use it for anything small.
540
Well, that's 'cause Apple came out with the nano and that was- You the end of it.
541
That's it. That was the end.
542
Yeah. Yeah.
543
There you go.
544
That was it.
545
They have these nano sails, so, so they're like They fit in your palm.
546
They're like the size of a postage stamp.
547
Attached to it is a huge Mylar sail.
548
Okay? They get deployed in a rocket launch, then you have ground-based gigawatt lasers- Oh, that is amazing.
549
beaming these things in the direction you want them to go.
550
And that propels them forward.
551
Correct. Be- And it And the goal is to send these to Alpha Centauri.
552
And you can accelerate it up to like 20% the speed of light.
553
Yes, because like there's nothing to impede it 'cause you're in the vacuum of space.
554
Noth- You're in the vacuum of space.
555
And so the laser is pushing on it the whole- And the thing doesn't weigh very much.
556
That's amazing. And the, and the sail is huge, and the laser is powerful.
557
That's awesome.
558
Right. So And you can pack a lot on a postage stamp chip.
559
Right. Okay? Yeah.
560
Like, uh, you know, temperature and, and, and radiation field and- Yeah.
561
and magnetic field.
562
They can do And so that's the goal.
563
And so let's see how good you are at math.
564
I'm not. Okay.
565
Don't Let's not.
566
If it goes If, if it reaches 20% the speed of light- Mm-hmm.
567
and Alpha Centauri is 4 light years away.
568
Oh, okay. So- How long does it take to get there?
569
Um, it'll take 20 Wait. It's 4 light years away.
570
Mm-hmm. And it's at 20%.
571
So one light year would be one year, so that's 4 times that, right?
572
No, 5 times that.
573
Is that your final answer?
574
Right. So it's 20.
575
20 years, right?
576
Okay, now I'm all confu- Yes.
577
Yes. 20 years.
578
Yes. Now you know how this craziness works.
579
Okay. Okay.
580
'Cause that's how I do math when I just did.
581
We just exposed the wiring of your brain- Yes.
582
You see how- in that moment.
583
Fuck. I'm not I'm sorry.
584
You see how freaking nuts it is- Okay.
585
up in there, but I come out to the right stuff.
586
Yeah, yeah.
587
But anyway, 20 years.
588
Yeah, if you go one5th the speed of light- Right.
589
and you're 4 light years, it'll be- Right.
590
It's 20. 5 times 4 is 20.
591
Right. So 20 years, that's within people's lifetime who are funding the thing, and so that was the goal.
592
That's wow. Okay?
593
However- Uh-oh.
594
it gets there, now it has to send a signal back.
595
Oh, well, that's crazy.
596
Well, that's at the speed of light.
597
Right. So when do you know what it found there?
598
After how much time?
599
24 years. Check.
600
Yeah. Super cool. We'll give you an honorary degree- just for just being on the show.
601
Yeah, I wa- I was gonna say yes.
602
Uh Well, you can.
603
You got like 30 of 'em up there.
604
No, 27. This 1 Okay.
605
You Nobody's counting.
606
No. Stop. Stop.
607
All right. So- This is Dusty Rock, uh, Dusty Rock Creations.
608
And Dusty Rock Creations says, "Hello from Quebec, Canada." Quebec.
609
Quebec. And he says This is Jean Francois Rock who says, "Here from Dusty Rock Creations." Oh, he's- You think?
610
He's dropping names.
611
He says, uh, "Mr.
612
Tyson, Lord Nice, let's dive into some fascinating questions, if you do say so yourself." Uh, he says- We'll be the judge of that.
613
We'll be the judge of that.
614
All right. He says, "Super massive black holes at the heart of galaxies hold the key to understanding how galaxies become uh, come into being." Maybe.
615
Yes. Maybe.
616
Is it- Wait, let me tell you why it's a maybe.
617
Okay. Because the super massive black hole has like The big ones, like a billion solar masses.
618
Give him 10 1000000000.
619
But 1000000000.
620
We can Carl Sagan-ify it.
621
1000000000.
622
1000000000.
623
Right. So the mass of a galaxy, however, is hundreds of billions times the mass of the sun.
624
So maybe the black hole nucleated some things to begin with, but the mass of the galaxy swamps the mass- The mass of the black hole.
625
of the black hole.
626
Right. So there's a limit to how much you're gonna credit the black hole for the whole damn The, the ki- and the caboodle.
627
Gotcha. Okay.
628
I think that- So continue.
629
That's a good That's a very good point.
630
He says, um, "Is it fair to say" that entire galaxies will inevitably end up being swallowed by their own black holes and disappear forever.
631
No. No. There you go.
632
Look, no, no- Thank you for being my everyday source of wonder.
633
Oh, thank you.
634
I love that.
635
"Chuck, did you get my name right?" I don't know.
636
Okay, what's the, what's the name?
637
I don't know if I got anybody's name right, wait.
638
Wait, so how did, how did you I said his name was Jean-Francois Roque.
639
But R-O-Q-U-E?
640
R-R-O-C-K. Oh, Rock.
641
Yeah. Rock. But, uh, Jean, it's Z-G-E-A-N, dash, F-R-A-N-C-I-O-S.
642
Francois. Francois.
643
Yep. Right?
644
Roque, so maybe I got it right.
645
It's probably Rock.
646
Rock. Right. I bet.
647
Yes. I bet it is.
648
Exactly. Okay. Hey, you did pretty good.
649
I'll give you a B+ on that.
650
I mean, I did the best I could, but, you know.
651
Listen, truth is, if I mispronounced your name, I did you a favor.
652
Okay? Why? 'Cause now, now you got an alias.
653
Okay? You got a StarTalk alias.
654
So here's the thing, a black hole is really tiny relative to the gal- They're big, they're like the si- The billion solar mass black holes are like multiples of the size of the solar system.
655
But that's still tiny in the middle of the galaxy.
656
Okay. Right.
657
If it's gonna eat the galaxy, the s- The matter that's orbiting it has to stop orbiting and fall straight in.
658
Right. And that's just not gonna happen.
659
No, it's not.
660
Okay? All right.
661
Maybe stuff nearby.
662
Here's what'll happen.
663
A star will come nearby and it'll Tidal forces will stretch it out and you'll get this wispy stream of gas spiraling in down to the black hole.
664
Then it can make an accretion disk.
665
Mm-hmm. That's what we call them.
666
This is where s- That's the holding place.
667
This is It's taxiing, ready to go into the black hole.
668
Mm-hmm. As it's falling towards the black hole- Mm-hmm.
669
it's slowing down from the friction of all the other material there, and that energy has to go somewhere, and it goes to heating the accretion disk.
670
Okay. So hot, millions of degrees, that it radiates ultraviolet and X-ray light.
671
So the X-ray telescopes were the first telescope to discover black holes.
672
Because we did the math- Mm-hmm.
673
of what that should look like.
674
Right. Point is, you only get these accretion disks from things that are very close.
675
Right. That can be That, that trip on the meta- on the matter that'll slow them down.
676
Anybody else doesn't even care that there's a black hole- Right.
677
there. Right.
678
Yeah. That's like when you explain that even if our sun became a black hole- Correct.
679
we would still just be orbiting a black hole now that is our sun.
680
Correct. It doesn't have extra gravity to get this Correct. It doesn't have Right.
681
'Cause the gravity is due to the mass.
682
The total mass.
683
And the mass does not change.
684
Uh, yeah, if you turn our It, it, it wouldn't happen naturally, but if you- Right.
685
magic hands to do it- Right.
686
uh, yeah, it would just be a black hole, and it was if it's the same mass, we'd just still orbit around it.
687
We'd just orbit around that.
688
Mm-hmm. So now- We'd freeze to death.
689
I got Yeah. We'll freeze to death.
690
Um, but Jean-Francois actually has made me have a question.
691
Francois. So when 2 galaxies collide- Mm-hmm.
692
do the black holes then actually fall into one to another and become one giant black hole around that galaxy?
693
They will very likely eventually find each other.
694
Ah. Okay? They will probably You look at the dynamics of colliding galaxies.
695
Galaxies are mostly empty, by the way.
696
Right. Yeah. I had in one of my Merlin One of the questions in the Merlin book were, "What are the chances of 2 stars colliding just in the galaxy?" Mm-hmm.
697
And I said, "If there were 4 bumblebees in the continental United States, the chances are greater that 2 of them would accidentally bump into each other than 2 stars collide in our galaxy." Damn.
698
Then my brother drew 2 That's- 2 bumblebees that hit each other.
699
They had like, you know Like little bumblebee hickies.
700
No. Just, you know, bumblebee stunned- Right.
701
uh, clouds over their heads.
702
Uh, so it's empty.
703
So when the star when the galaxies collide, they will pass through one another.
704
Right. It'll be this cosmic ballet choreographed by the forces of gravity.
705
And it'll pulse like that as they pass through each other, come back, collide again, and they keep doing this until it settles down because there's energy dissipated each time that happens.
706
And the settling down puts the heavy stuff in the middle, uh, the heavy, slow-moving stuff in the middle and the faster, lighter stuff in the outer region.
707
That's when the system is settling.
708
Right. And the black holes, they're the heavy thing in the middle.
709
Of course. So they'll find each other- They find each other.
710
in the middle.
711
They'll con- they'll merge, and you'll get a black hole twice the size you had before.
712
Wow. Yeah. We got time for one more question.
713
Oh. This is a very grab bag.
714
I love it. Yes, this was a great one.
715
It's good. Mm-hmm.
716
Uh, yeah. This is Patrick, he says, "Dr.
717
Tyson, Lord Nice, just another science nerd here from Texas." Love him.
718
"What if space-time itself is a super solid lattice where defects create natural time loops that erase paradoxes and the so-called mystery echoes LIGO is hearing are actually the fingerprints of that lattice?
719
Meaning, we've already stumbled onto evidence of a new state of reality and missed it because we were looking through the wrong lens?" Ooh.
720
Ooh. Wow, Patrick.
721
I like that.
722
What I like about it is he's thinking of space, the fabric of space-time, as a medium.
723
You're right.
724
Okay? Mm-hmm.
725
And if you think of it as a medium, we sort of already do, but we think of it as sort of fabric rather Lattice is a stronger entity than just fabric.
726
Right. All right?
727
If it's a lattice, then you can think about, like, crystal lattices.
728
Right. And crystal lattices, things happen within them, you know?
729
You can have, like, uh, light behaves in certain ways in one direction versus another.
730
Sound goes in different way, because the lattice forces energy to pass through it differently depending on the direction that the energy goes through it.
731
And so we would have to propose a series of experiments to check whether phenomena that unfolds within the lattice is different when viewed at different angles.
732
Hmm. That would be, I think, if, based on my understanding of lat- of, of the geology of a lattice, you know, the, the rock, rock science- Right.
733
uh, of, of lattice, of, of what a, of what a crystal would be.
734
So I think he's saying without saying it that maybe the entire fabric of the universe is a crystal.
735
Hmm. I think he's saying that without saying it.
736
Wow. And it, we, we invented in our lifetime liquid crystal.
737
That's right.
738
That, that's your, your, your, your wristwatches used to have it.
739
That's your computer and, I mean, not your computer.
740
Your- Screens.
741
Yeah, all your screens.
742
Yeah, yeah.
743
Liquid crystal screens.
744
TVs. So this, hmm.
745
Yeah, I don't have a good answer to that other than that's intriguing.
746
Yeah. Yeah.
747
Well, the universe is a television.
748
There you go.
749
We're just- Back in the day, nobody had No, the, the, el, c The L- They're LEDs now.
750
EDs, EDs. Well, not, not LCDs.
751
They're light emitting diodes which are better.
752
Not liquid crystal displays.
753
Yeah. Right, right.
754
No more LCD TVs.
755
Right. Yeah. So anyhow, I like it.
756
It's a great, it's a great thought. It's very creative.
757
Very creative.
758
Very creative.
759
Yeah. Maybe he can develop it further.
760
Yeah, I doubt that.
761
Why do why?
762
Ah, I'm just, I'm just hating.
763
If you came up with that question, why- No.
764
Of course, no, no, I think it's brilliant what he's came up with.
765
No. Then we're gonna find out he's a 10-year-old kid.
766
Now that would be impressive.
767
Yeah. No, it's very cool, man.
768
All right. So we gotta end it there.
769
Oh, man. Oh, that's sad.
770
That was a good one.
771
That's sad. These people, you people, you're amazing.
772
Chuck, always good to have you, man.
773
Always a pleasure.
774
Yeah, another installment of Star Talk: Cosmic Queries, Grab Bag Edition.
775
Neil deGrasse Tyson wishing you to keep looking up.

Download App

Everything you need to speak fluently

AI PronunciationScore every sentence
IPA PracticeMaster every sound
VocabularyBuild your word bank
Vocab GameLearn while playing

Same Channel

FOR YOU

Recommend Video

Vocabulary and speaking notes for this lesson

This speaking lesson is built on the video “Answering Questions About Time Travel, Solar Sailing & Galaxy Collisions”. This video has 773 sentences and 7450 words to shadow. The speech runs for 44:25. The speaker talks at a natural 168 words per minute, close to everyday conversation. Only 80% of the words are among the 3,000 most common in English, so the vocabulary is demanding.

Key vocabulary in this video

15 words from the video worth learning, with pronunciation and meaning:

WordPronunciationMeaning
galaxy noun/ˈɡæl.ək.si/Any of the collections of many millions or billions of stars, galactic dust, black holes, etc. existing as independent and coherent systems, of which there are…
orbit noun/ˈɔɹ.bɪt/An elliptical movement of an object about a celestial object or Lagrange point, especially a periodic elliptical revolution.
elevator noun/ˈɛləˌveɪtɚ/Anything that raises or uplifts.
blanket noun/ˈblæŋ.kɪt/A heavy, loosely woven fabric, usually large and woollen, used for warmth while sleeping or resting.
crystal noun/ˈkɹɪstəl/A solid composed of an array of atoms or molecules possessing long-range order and arranged in a pattern which is periodic in three dimensions.
gravity noun/ˈɡɹævɪti/Of an activity such as a ceremony, a person's conduct, etc.: the quality of being deeply serious and solemn, especially in a dignified manner; seriousness…
sail noun/seɪl/A piece of fabric attached to a boat and arranged such that it causes the wind to drive the boat along. The sail may be attached to the boat via a combination…
bang noun/ˈbæŋ/A sudden percussive noise.
disappear verb/dɪsəˈpɪɹ/To vanish.
cosmic adjective/ˈkɑz.mɪk/Of or from or pertaining to the cosmos or universe.
clone noun/kloʊn/A living organism (originally a plant) produced asexually from a single ancestor, to which it is genetically identical.
math noun/mæθ/Arithmetic calculations; (see do the math).
rocket noun/ˈɹɑk.ɪt/A cylindrical projectile that can be fired to a great height through combustion, (specifically) a type of firework of this form, typically exploding with light…
fabric verb/ˈfæb.ɹɪk/To cover with fabric.
quantum noun/ˈkwɑntəm/The total amount of something; quantity.

Phrasal verbs you will hear

WordPronunciationMeaning
come back verbTo return to a place.
come up with verbTo manage to produce, deliver, or present (something) by inventing, creating, thinking of, or obtaining it.
look up verb/ˌlʊk ˈʌp/To have better prospects.
pass through verbTo go through, to travel through, to transit or lie across a place or from one place to another.
figure out verbTo come to understand; to discover or find a solution; to deduce.
go ahead verb/ˌɡoʊ əˈhɛd/To proceed with; to begin.
go back verbTo return to a place or state after having been there at a previous time.
settle down verbTo make or become quiet and calm after a period of disturbance or restlessness.

Sentences worth repeating

Short, complete lines from the video that you can reuse in everyday conversation:

  • Did you ever see the alien take a poop?
  • Do you harbor questions about the universe?
  • That's a really interesting question, because basically, are we too stupid?
  • Is that your final answer?
  • "Chuck, did you get my name right?" I don't know.

Grammar in this video

The structures the speaker uses most, with the exact words from the video:

StructureIn the video
Conditional sentences if + clause, will/would + verb — a condition and its resultif it's not, then I'll buffer · if it's the same mass, we'd just
Present perfect have/has + past participle — a past action that still matters nowhave spoken · have risen · we've said
Passive voice be + past participle — the focus is on what happens, not who does itis completely enclosed · be destroyed · was born
Relative clauses who / which + clause — extra information about a person or thingfriend who composes · diodes which are

Pronunciation to watch

The speaker uses 173 contractions and reduced forms, such as don't, I'm, you're. Say them the short way, as you hear them.

  • The “th” sounds: math /mæθ/, marathon /ˈmæɹəθən/, thickness /ˈθɪknəs/, thereby /ðɛɹˈbaɪ/
  • The “sh” and “zh” sounds: dimensional /daɪˈmɛn.ʃə.nəl/, lingerie /ˌlɑn.ʒəˈɹeɪ/, passion /ˈpæʃən/, fiction /ˈfɪkʃən/, shadow /ˈʃædəʊ̯/
  • Long words — get the stress right: elevator /ˈɛləˌveɪtɚ/, dimensional /daɪˈmɛn.ʃə.nəl/, accurately /ˈæk.jə.ɹɪt.li/, naturally /ˈnæt͡ʃ.(ə.)ɹə.li/, curiosity /ˌkjʊɹ.iˈɑ.sə.ti/

How to practise with this video

  1. Listen to the whole video once without speaking and note the words you do not know.
  2. Start at 0.75× speed, shadow it sentence by sentence, then go back to normal speed once it feels easy.
  3. Record yourself and compare with the original, paying attention to words like galaxy, orbit, elevator.

What is the Shadowing Technique?

Shadowing is a science-backed language learning technique originally developed for professional interpreter training and popularized by polyglot Dr. Alexander Arguelles. The method is simple but powerful: you listen to native English audio and immediately repeat it out loud — like a shadow following the speaker with just a 1–2 second delay. Unlike passive listening or grammar drills, shadowing forces your brain and mouth muscles to simultaneously process and reproduce real speech patterns. Research shows it significantly improves pronunciation accuracy, intonation, rhythm, connected speech, listening comprehension, and speaking fluency — making it one of the most effective methods for IELTS Speaking preparation and real-world English communication.

Shadowing technique: read the full step-by-step guide →