Shadowing Practice: The Impact of Alberta's Referendum Results - Learn English Speaking with Video

Choose a practice mode

Each mode opens a full-screen practice room.

157 sentences
If sentences are too short or too long, click Edit to adjust them.
1
Hey everyone, it's Richard, you're watching
2
The Plain Bagel.
3
Big news for the True North, strong and free this past week.
4
As you might have known, Alberta held a referendum on Monday over whether the province should remain a part of Canada.
5
The vote followed months of independence rallies across the province and a series of controversies over U .S involvement,
6
including members of Trump's administration speaking in favour of Alberta separating
7
and even suggesting they join the U .S in recent news coming out
8
that some separatists had offered oil royalties and water to American officials in exchange for independence support,
9
which fairly made a lot of people anxious.
10
Well, the day of the referendum finally came this October 19th,
11
with the early count showing that Alberta has voted to not bother with a vote,
12
since the referendum was technically over whether to even have an independence referendum.
13
And even if this was a proper referendum, the Clarity Act prevents any province from unilaterally seceding.
14
Not to mention that with all of Alberta being covered by treaty lands, there'd have to be the negotiations with various indigenous groups.
15
But the event was still a widely watched bellwether for sentiment in Alberta,
16
with the province voting overwhelmingly in support of unity with the rest of Canada.
17
And today, I figured since I've covered the economic impact of Albertan independence, I would cover the consequences of this
18
Remain vote, since there are quite a few, not to mention the results for the other nine questions,
19
since this wasn't the only question posed on the referendum.
20
And as of the current tally, around half of them have garnered majority support.
21
And I want to cover some research
22
that came out just last month leading up to this referendum over what Albertan independence would mean for the province
23
and the rest of Canada.
24
Because while this vote has put this issue to bed for the time being, separatism in Canada isn't going away anytime soon.
25
In fact, just before this referendum, the separatist party Quebecois won a minority government in the province of Quebec, their first victory since 2014,
26
with the leader promising a Quebec independence referendum at some point in the future.
27
So we'll try to touch on all that in today's quick update video.
28
Now, the official results for the referendum won't be released until October 29th,
29
so do be aware that some of the tallies here might change a little bit,
30
but the early count shows that regarding the question of whether Albertans would like to remain or hold an independence referendum,
31
three quarters came out in favor of staying a part of Canada, while only about 25 % voted for having an independence referendum,
32
which is largely in line with what many people were expecting
33
and what many polls were pointing towards leading up to this referendum. But you never know.
34
We all saw Brexit.
35
I think a lot of people were still holding their breath.
36
Now, while this question was by far the most attention grabbing of the referendum, you can see that it's listed first here in the results,
37
despite being the 10th question.
38
It again was not the only question brought forth.
39
And while it's not being as widely covered, most of the other questions, despite some of them being quite controversial,
40
ended up being really close with very slim majorities
41
that in some cases have already seen the result flip as more votes have been counted.
42
The first four questions all involved restricting immigration and the government programs new and temporary immigrants can participate in,
43
all of which were voted in favor of,
44
including a proposal to charge non -permanent residents a fee to use publicly funded health care and even schooling systems.
45
The fifth question, which saw slightly more support, asked about requiring proof of citizenship to vote rather than, say, just a standard driver's license.
46
And the remainder involved restricting federal influence over the province and even abolishing the Senate, all of which just narrowly missed majority support.
47
So some pretty hot button issues being voted on with this referendum.
48
However, because the referendum was explicitly not binding, it didn't really result in anything.
49
No laws have changed as a result of this vote.
50
All the referendum really did was help
51
Premier Daniel Smith gauge public sentiment on these different issues to help inform her mandate.
52
Whether anything will change as a result of these votes is questionable, given A, the province doesn't have authority over a number of these things,
53
and B, a lot of these things will require introducing new laws and negotiating with the federal government.
54
In 2021, for example, the province actually voted in favor of amending the constitution to end equalization payments,
55
a program that's a commonly cited grievance for those looking to leave the country,
56
with Albertan tax dollars having consistently funded the program for the benefit of other provinces.
57
However, because no individual province can amend the Canadian constitution, it didn't go anywhere.
58
And in this case, because of the slim majority a lot of these issues have,
59
it's even questionable whether Daniel Smith will pursue any of these changes.
60
Especially given that while Alberta is certainly one of the top destinations for international immigrants coming to Canada, the country has already changed some immigration policies
61
that's caused Alberta immigration to fall meaningfully from where it was a few years ago.
62
All of which is why most of the attention has been on that independence question.
63
Yes, that itself wasn't a binding referendum.
64
And even if there was overwhelming support for independence, there'd still be a long legal process and negotiations involved with actually seceding,
65
but it still would have signaled the province's intent to move forward with independence if this referendum was successful.
66
And while many might look at Monday's vote and assume that nothing's really changed for Alberta with it, the no vote might still prove incredibly consequential.
67
You see, as I highlighted in my original Alberta independence video,
68
businesses and investors do not like the uncertainty that comes with these sorts of separatist movements.
69
Uh, what we saw with Quebec back in the seventies,
70
when the party Capicot took power was hundreds of businesses moving their head offices out of the province.
71
And while certainly a part of that was around new language laws
72
that were putting a higher burden on companies to operate in French.
73
We've even seen this Alberta separatist movement have negative impacts on business operations.
74
A recent survey by the Alberta Chambers of Commerce found
75
that 44 % of businesses reported that the independence discourse was actually affecting their business, the vast majority in a negative way.
76
With 79 % of that group reporting the issue affecting their planning and forecasting, 61 % reporting an increased concern over a recession,
77
50 % considering relocating or expanding outside of Alberta, and 44 % reporting that they had delayed,
78
scaled back, or canceled major investments or projects because of the separation movement.
79
We also saw that recent report by the University of Calgary's School of Public Policy
80
that tried to project how Alberta would be impacted by independence across different conditions,
81
a smooth transition and a more difficult one where negotiations don't go well.
82
And even under a smooth transition scenario, GDP, employment, income per person,
83
and the government budget would all take a hit in the short term within that first five -year period,
84
with the tax burden per person also actually increasing.
85
Numbers that, as you'd expect, become much more severe under the difficult scenario,
86
where GDP could contract by a tenth and taxes per person could increase by over $5 ,000.
87
Now, in the long term, under that smooth transition scenario, there is a situation where Alberta could see higher GDP,
88
employment, and wage income per person in addition to lower taxes.
89
But if you look at the range of outcomes over the long term between the different scenarios,
90
the downside from an economic standpoint seems to well outweigh the upside, with the difficult transition potentially resulting in a long term GDP
91
impairment of 16 .2 % compared to the favorable 3 .4 % upside.
92
Now, of course, people are going to contest whether Alberta separation is a good or a bad thing,
93
but most of the research we saw on this topic leading up to this referendum seemed to suggest that economically speaking,
94
Canada really dodged a bullet here.
95
The same report also highlighted that Albertan secession would contribute to a weaker Canadian dollar, higher interest rates, loss of investment,
96
weaker productivity, higher taxes, and higher pension funding requirements for the rest of Canada, in addition to the impacts on Alberta.
97
Which brings us to the positive side of this development.
98
Beyond the fact that the country has seemingly avoided a pretty meaningful economic headwind,
99
they also now face the opportunity to rebuild investor and business confidence in the country and specifically Alberta.
100
In part because, as highlighted by TD, with the issue having been brought under the citizen initiative framework,
101
another similar referendum question can't be posed in Alberta under the same structure for at least another five years.
102
Which means that companies who are avoiding investing
103
because of the separatism movement now have a more stable environment for
104
that forecasting and projecting operations that might encourage more of
105
that type of activity which is pretty vital given the circumstance the country currently finds itself in.
106
Amid the current trade war with the United States, Prime Minister Mark Carney has of course been courting investors
107
and pushing for major infrastructure projects across the country to help diversify trade away from the United States,
108
and Alberta is set to play a big part in that.
109
The province is a vital economic contributor, representing about 15 .5 % of the country's GDP, despite only making up about 12 % of the population,
110
and the province is an energy powerhouse representing over 80 % of Canada's energy production
111
and single -handedly hosting more proven oil reserves than the entirety of the United States.
112
However, Alberta is also the province that's most dependent on the United States for its trade.
113
The vast majority of Albertan oil exports flow south of the border.
114
Because that's what most of its infrastructure is built for.
115
So to better diversify that energy trade, and certainly in part to appease part of the Alberta voter base,
116
who have largely been frustrated with the federal government's previous shunning of the province's oil and gas industry,
117
the Liberal Party has done a bit of a 180 here on its energy policy,
118
with the Prime Minister pushing for more rapid approval of oil and gas projects, including the recently announced, or more specifically named, Pacific Link Project.
119
A proposed pipeline that would bring 1 million barrels of oil per day,
120
just under a quarter of the country's current exports to the West Coast for international shipment.
121
Canada is also trying to improve its productivity, which hasn't really improved over the past decade and requires investor dollars to help fix.
122
All of which made it a pretty bad time for Alberta to explore becoming independent.
123
So much so that many believe that the U .S was actively trying to interfere to weaken
124
Canada's trade position.
125
Something Prime Minister Mark Carney himself alluded to in a rally leading up to the vote.
126
There are some outside our borders who are working to break us so they can own us.
127
With the province voting to remain, however, Mark Carney's likely breathing a sigh of relief.
128
As for Premier Daniel Smith, however, things are probably going to be pretty challenging from here.
129
The Premier has been pretty successful in annoying most people.
130
Those who wanted to remain are pretty frustrated that this vote even happened in the first place,
131
with many viewing the Premier as having catered to fringe parts of this movement, changing rules to help make this vote easier to have.
132
And those who wanted to separate are probably pretty mad, given that leading up to this referendum,
133
Danielle Smith actually campaigned in favor of unity with the rest of Canada.
134
All to say there's likely more political turmoil to come from Alberta, but at least for now,
135
the larger issue has been put to bed. But what about Quebec?
136
Well, while anxieties are certainly heightened in Quebec, given the Parti Québécois' victory in the recent election, the support for independence there,
137
according to recent polls, while higher than Alberta, is still only around a third,
138
which is less than it's been in the past with some even suggesting
139
that the Parti Québécois lost a majority government because of its push for a new referendum.
140
And the incoming premier, Paul St -Pierre Plamondon, has stated that he won't push for a referendum until Trump leaves the White House.
141
Which, yes, probably for the best.
142
Now, because of the minority government, the party would have to work with Quebec Solidaire, the only other separatist party in the National Assembly.
143
And given that most minority governments last less than two years in Quebec, we may not make it past
144
Trump's presidency to see a Quebec referendum.
145
And of course, Quebec faces the same
146
Clarity Act as Alberta that prevents that unilateral provincial secession,
147
with the law actually having been introduced because of previous Quebec separatist attempts.
148
However, Quebec's separatist movement has much deeper roots, given that it's predominantly a culture -based movement.
149
And with the province representing a fifth of the population and GDP, independence there would naturally be pretty impactful.
150
So it will be an issue to watch closely.
151
Thanks for watching.
152
I hope you found this video helpful.
153
If you did, please do make sure to like, subscribe, all that good stuff.
154
It does help the channel tremendously.
155
And let me know your thoughts on Alberta independence or Quebec secession, whether you think that's a real risk the country faces in the near term.
156
Thanks again for joining.
157
And as always, be safe out there.

Download App

Everything you need to speak fluently

AI PronunciationScore every sentence
IPA PracticeMaster every sound
VocabularyBuild your word bank
Vocab GameLearn while playing

Same Channel

FOR YOU

Recommend Video

Vocabulary and speaking notes for this lesson

This speaking lesson is built on the video “The Impact of Alberta's Referendum Results”. The speaker keeps coming back to these words: Alberta, referendum, province, independence, vote. This video has 157 sentences and 2318 words to shadow. The speech runs for 13:25. The speaker talks at a natural 173 words per minute, close to everyday conversation. Only 80% of the words are among the 3,000 most common in English, so the vocabulary is demanding.

Key vocabulary in this video

15 words from the video worth learning, with pronunciation and meaning:

WordPronunciationMeaning
referendum noun/ˌɹɛfəˈɹɛndəm/A direct popular vote on a proposed law or constitutional amendment.
province noun/ˈpɹɔv.ɪns/A region of the earth or of a continent; a district or country.
transition noun/tɹænˈzɪʃ.ən/The process of change from one form, state, style or place to another.
scenario noun/sɪˈnɛəɹioʊ/An outline or model of an expected or supposed sequence of events.
investor noun/ɪnˈvɛs.tə(ɹ)/A person who invests money in order to make a profit.
immigration noun/ˌɪmɪˈɡɹeɪʃən/The act of immigrating; the passing or coming into a country of which one is not native born for the purpose of permanent residence.
minority noun/maɪˈnɒɹ.ɪ.ti/The state or condition of being smaller, inferior, or subordinate to something or someone else; lesserness.
smooth adjective/smuːð/Having a texture that lacks friction. Not rough.
highlight verb/ˈhaɪˌlaɪt/To make prominent; emphasize.
negotiation noun/nɪˌɡəʊ.ʃiˈeɪ.ʃən/The process of achieving agreement through discussion.
vast adjective/væst/Very large or wide (literally or figuratively).
infrastructure noun/ˈɪnfɹəˌstɹʌkt͡ʃə/An underlying base or foundation for a building, organization, or system.
vital adjective/ˈvaɪtəl/Relating to or characteristic of life.
poll noun/poʊl/A survey of people, usually statistically analyzed to gauge wider public opinion.
rally noun/ˈɹæli/A public gathering or mass meeting that is not mainly a protest and is organized to inspire enthusiasm for a cause.

Phrasal verbs you will hear

WordPronunciationMeaning
lead up to verbTo set in motion; to act as a causal or preparatory event or sequence of events.
come out verb/ˌkʌm ˈaʊt/To be discovered; to be revealed.
bring under verbTo make (someone or something) subject to (something else); to place (someone) in a state of (something).
come out in verbto be afflicted by (a visible disruption of the body)
end up verbTo bring to a conclusion.
go away verbTo depart or leave a place.

Grammar in this video

The structures the speaker uses most, with the exact words from the video:

StructureIn the video
Present perfect have/has + past participle — a past action that still matters nowhas voted · I've covered · have garnered
Passive voice be + past participle — the focus is on what happens, not who does itbeing covered · won't be released · have been counted
Relative clauses who / which + clause — extra information about a person or thingactivity which is · Those who wanted

Pronunciation to watch

The speaker uses 18 contractions and reduced forms, such as didn't, there'd, wasn't. Say them the short way, as you hear them.

  • The “th” sounds: smooth /smuːð/, bother /ˈbɑðɚ/, breathe /bɹiːð/, tenth /tɛnθ/, bellwether /ˈbɛlwɛðɚ/
  • The “sh” and “zh” sounds: transition /tɹænˈzɪʃ.ən/, immigration /ˌɪmɪˈɡɹeɪʃən/, negotiation /nɪˌɡəʊ.ʃiˈeɪ.ʃən/, separation /ˌsɛp.əˈɹeɪ.ʃən/, potentially /pəˈtɛnʃ(ə)li/
  • Long words — get the stress right: referendum /ˌɹɛfəˈɹɛndəm/, immigration /ˌɪmɪˈɡɹeɪʃən/, minority /maɪˈnɒɹ.ɪ.ti/, negotiation /nɪˌɡəʊ.ʃiˈeɪ.ʃən/, infrastructure /ˈɪnfɹəˌstɹʌkt͡ʃə/

How to practise with this video

  1. Listen to the whole video once without speaking and note the words you do not know.
  2. Start at 0.75× speed, shadow it sentence by sentence, then go back to normal speed once it feels easy.
  3. Record yourself and compare with the original, paying attention to words like referendum, province, transition.

What is the Shadowing Technique?

Shadowing is a science-backed language learning technique originally developed for professional interpreter training and popularized by polyglot Dr. Alexander Arguelles. The method is simple but powerful: you listen to native English audio and immediately repeat it out loud — like a shadow following the speaker with just a 1–2 second delay. Unlike passive listening or grammar drills, shadowing forces your brain and mouth muscles to simultaneously process and reproduce real speech patterns. Research shows it significantly improves pronunciation accuracy, intonation, rhythm, connected speech, listening comprehension, and speaking fluency — making it one of the most effective methods for IELTS Speaking preparation and real-world English communication.

Shadowing technique: read the full step-by-step guide →