Shadowing Practice: The Science That Finally Explains the Dyatlov Pass Incident - Learn English Speaking with Video

Choose a practice mode

Each mode opens a full-screen practice room.

520 sentences
If sentences are too short or too long, click Edit to adjust them.
1
In February 1959, a group of nine cross -country skiers disappeared while on a hiking trip in the Siberian backcountry.
2
A recovery crew eventually discovered their bodies arranged across the mountainside in a heartbreaking scene.
3
The hikers had severe injuries that seemed… difficult to explain.
4
Broken ribs, missing eyes, skull fractures… oddly, a few of them were even radioactive active.
5
The mountainside was renamed Dyatlov Pass after the leader of the expedition that ended in tragedy,
6
and the Dyatlov Pass incident has become one of the most famous cold cases of all time.
7
Maybe you've heard this story before.
8
There are dozens of YouTube videos about it, many of them with millions of views,
9
and there are at least as many conspiracy theories trying to explain what happened.
10
But today I'm going to tell you a different story.
11
I want to tell you a story about snow.
12
So much of the mystery surrounding Dyatlov Pass really comes down to just how little we know about snow.
13
Snow has incredibly complicated material properties and ways of moving that continue to baffle physicists, even after decades of experiments and simulations.
14
Snow is surprisingly hard to understand.
15
But physicists have made a breakthrough in modeling how it moves, and in the process may have solved the Dyatlov Pass case.
16
All it took was one movie with a singing snowman, and years of digging deep into snow.
17
The Nine Hikers hadn't returned yet.
18
Their trip into the Siberian backcountry was meant to take several weeks, but when four days had passed since their scheduled return,
19
their worried friends and families requested a rescue search.
20
One week after the group should have been back, a party was sent to retrace their route.
21
On the first rescue mission in late February 1959, they found five bodies scattered between their tent and a nearby stand of trees.
22
Georgi and Doroshenko were discovered first.
23
Igor was nearby, buried under the snow and clinging desperately to the branch of a small tree.
24
A few scorched tree branches nearby suggest they attempted to build a fire in the bitter cold.
25
Zina was found several meters away, face down in the snow.
26
And when the rescuers returned a week later, they found Rustic, who had collapsed while trekking back to the tent.
27
Mysteriously, all five of these hikers were in various states of undress and without shoes, utterly unprepared to withstand the brutal
28
Sub -Zero night.
29
In May, when the snow finally melted, a new recovery party found the other four.
30
Somehow, these bodies were even more mysterious.
31
They were at the bottom of a ravine, lying in a creek.
32
these four were better dressed than the first five
33
but in a mismatch of layers nearby searchers unearthed a stash
34
of shredded fabric possibly the remnants of a snow cave the remaining hikers dug
35
and lined with their dead companions clothes to insulate the temporary shelter
36
but these four were also mostly shoeless an autopsy determined that kolyvatov died of hypothermia as did the first five.
37
But Kolya had fractures and hemorrhaging in his skull.
38
Sasha and Luda had cracked ribs and internal chest bleeding.
39
Several of the hikers' faces were injured or mutilated, and inexplicably, Luda had no tongue or eyeballs.
40
All nine hikers had finally been recovered, but their bodies left their families and the investigators with nothing but questions.
41
Just a few months prior, this group of university students was brimming with youth and energy, eager to set out on the expedition.
42
They were some of the strongest hikers in their school, and this trip would finally earn them their grade 3 certification,
43
a huge honor as the highest distinction for recreational hikers in the Soviet Union.
44
They were as prepared for this expedition as any group could ever be.
45
Yet, they never came back.
46
For the families of these young people, the initial investigation was infuriating.
47
In the hasty search for survivors, a lot of the campsite was disturbed.
48
Valuable snow tracks were trampled, and evidence was prematurely packed up.
49
The case was closed abruptly, and the official cause of the incident was ruled an unknown compelling force.
50
Such a vague explanation felt deeply unsatisfying to the families, especially because from the chaos of the scene, baffling clues continued to emerge.
51
For one, the canvas walls of their tent had been slashed from the inside, side, suggesting that whatever happened that night,
52
the hikers were determined enough to flee that they damaged their only tent.
53
But the investigators found nine sets of mostly shoeless footprints walking from the tent to a stand of trees down the slope.
54
Despite their desperate tent exit, the evacuating footprints seemed oddly calm and orderly.
55
And since there were nine sets of footprints, it appears that everyone was capable of walking away from the tent,
56
despite the severe blunt force traumas that contributed to three of the hikers' eventual deaths.
57
An avalanche was the most obvious explanation.
58
If they had feared an oncoming cascade of snow, their training would have compelled them to quickly exit the tent to seek the forest,
59
where the trees could take the brunt of the avalanche's force.
60
Avalanches are dangerous in a couple different ways.
61
For one, the high -speed snow cascade could sweep you downslope,
62
or the ground might start sliding out from beneath your feet as the layers of snow give way to gravity.
63
You might be swept off a cliff, or into a tree, or carried so far away from where you started
64
that you'd be lost and at the mercy of the elements.
65
But most people who die from avalanches suffocate, buried under the flow of snow.
66
The Dyatlov group would have been extensively trained on these risks, and wary of any signs of an avalanche.
67
If they had heard one barreling down the slope toward their tent, evacuating to the tree line would have been their best chance of survival.
68
So Occam's Razor tells us the unknown compelling force from that night was most likely an avalanche.
69
But there's one major problem with this theory.
70
Based on everything the investigators knew about avalanches, there was no plausible way for one to have formed on the gradual slope at Diatlov Pass.
71
There are two broad types of avalanche, loose snow and slab.
72
A loose snow avalanche is the kind you've probably seen in action movies.
73
When these happen, the snow has trouble sticking together, and like grains of sand spilling down a sand dune, the snow cascades down the slope.
74
As the snow tumbles, it can trigger other loose snow to fall as well.
75
They're dangerous if you get caught directly in the snowfall, as you could be swept downslope or buried.
76
Another danger of a loose snow avalanche is
77
that it could cause a large chunk of snow to detach as a slab avalanche.
78
As the name suggests, a slab avalanche occurs when one big slab of stuck -together snow detaches all at once.
79
Like, imagine how your roof looks after really big snow.
80
A couple weeks later, when it warms up a bit, half the snow on the roof might detach in an instant, falling as one big slab.
81
I was almost hit by one of these once.
82
I was walking through Chicago in late winter
83
and this massive chunk of snow snow fell from 30 stories
84
and shattered right on the ground in front of me at my feet.
85
It was so scary, I can't imagine how much it would have hurt to get hit by that.
86
When a slab does break loose, a crown fracture is usually left behind at the detachment site.
87
It typically begins when a weak, buried layer of snow collapses, then a small crack forms in the slab above
88
and grows until the remaining cohesive forces between individual snow crystals can no longer hold the slab in place.
89
The slab fragments and crashes toward an unsuspecting pedestrian, leaving the crown fracture as evidence that it occurred.
90
But as you might have guessed, all this sliding snow doesn't happen unless there's a slope.
91
Avalanches are what you get when the internal stickiness of the snow loses the battle against gravity's downward pull.
92
And that's the problem with the avalanche theory of the Dyatlov Pass incident.
93
The slope where the group staked their tent was too shallow to trigger an avalanche.
94
To help tell this story, I talked to Alexander Puzrin, a professor of geomechanics at ETH Zurich.
95
He normally studies soil and landslides, but he has occasionally lent his expertise to avalanches.
96
They said that the slope was too mild, you know, for the avalanche.
97
And indeed, every slope was around 23 degrees.
98
And the rule of thumb says that if it is lower than 30 degrees, you shouldn't really worry.
99
Then, you know, we know how the terrain looks after an avalanche.
100
I mean, there must be a source area, and then there should be a huge deposit and stuff like that.
101
And people, when they came and found the tent, they just saw some blocks of snow, a few blocks of snow on top of the tent.
102
In addition to the shallow slope of the hill, there was another problematic detail for the avalanche theory.
103
The footprints near the tent were still visible, even after several weeks' worth of weather.
104
It seems unlikely that there was enough wind or new snow to erase an entire avalanche.
105
For everyone involved in the investigation, it was difficult to imagine something like that had happened on the mountain that night.
106
But without any solid answers at all, the case was abruptly closed.
107
Shortly after the final four bodies were recovered, the lead investigator was pressured by his superiors to terminate the investigation.
108
Even though he still had a long list of unresolved questions, especially concerning the final four bodies which had been found in the stream.
109
It's not clear what compelled him to do this, but he ordered that these hikers' clothing be tested for radiation.
110
The case was closed before he received the results, but it turned out the clothing had abnormally high levels of radioactivity.
111
With no one around to follow up on these results...
112
was added to the pile of puzzling evidence.
113
Honestly, it's as if officials were following a recipe for how to spawn conspiracy theories.
114
They classified all the investigation files, were super controlling and disrespectful about the details of the funerals for the young hikers,
115
and the lead investigator was called away and then came back seemingly disinterested in the case.
116
He only spoke out again about his experience working on the case decades later when the Soviet Union began to collapse.
117
So can we really be surprised that imaginations ran wild and the gaps left by such a resounding, I don't know?
118
There were speculations about a lover's quarrel gone wrong or an animal attack.
119
People accused the indigenous community who lived nearby of assaulting the hikers.
120
There were whispers of the government covering up KGB business, weapons testing, or a secret military base in the mountains.
121
Some people close to the case, including the former lead investigator, still harbor theories about UFOs or a Yeti.
122
For decades, this nonsense dominated the discussion of the incident.
123
Then in the 1980s and 90s, many of the case files were made public as the Soviet Union thawed its policies of secrecy.
124
Books and documentaries followed.
125
Then by the 2000s, web forums were basically gasoline on the fire.
126
I was born and grew up in Russia.
127
I left a long time ago.
128
Actually, when I I left in 1991, so at that time we didn't know anything about the Dyatlov Pass case.
129
It was a bit of a state secret.
130
This case is so tragic and confusing and strange that it's hard not to be obsessed.
131
I'm not even into true crime, but when I learned about the Dyatlov Pass incident, the inconsistencies really started to keep me up at night.
132
In 2019, the Russian government conceded the family's lingering discontent, and formally reopened the case.
133
The new investigation named 75 official hypotheses, and immediately discarded 72 of them as conspiracy theories.
134
The remaining hypotheses were an avalanche, a hurricane, or a slab avalanche.
135
So, three official theories and countless questions.
136
My first question here is, a hurricane?
137
Did I hear that right?
138
See, when all those old case files were declassified, so were the weather reports from mountainside measurement stations.
139
The weather that night, in February 1959, was much worse than anyone had originally estimated.
140
Of course, it would have been cold.
141
On nights leading up to the incident, the overnight temperature on the mountain was about minus 15 degrees Celsius.
142
But the night the hikers fled their tent, it got as low as minus 30.
143
I can't even fathom being that cold there's also the wind to consider.
144
Near the pass that night, wind speeds were between 4 and 10 meters per second, perhaps with gusts up to 15 meters per second.
145
The U .S.
146
National Weather Service classifies hurricane force as more than 33 meters per second, and 10 meters per second is considered a fresh breeze.
147
So not really hurricane -worthy, and we can probably rule that hypothesis out.
148
But while the winds measured nearby weren't hurricane force, it is possible gust of wind blew some snow onto the tent roof frightening them
149
and prompting their evacuation
150
or maybe there was a freakishly small avalanche the other weird thing about cold this extreme is
151
that it changes the texture
152
and structure of snow making
153
it very hard for the snow to stick to itself as
154
we will see snow is weird ultimately the reinvestigation concluded
155
that the unknown compelling force that caused the Dyatlov Pass incident must have been a slab avalanche.
156
Case closed again, time to wrap up the video.
157
I'm kidding of course, we've got a lot of video left.
158
Because as I'm sure you'll remember, an avalanche of any sort had previously been ruled out.
159
The slope of the mountain near the campsite was too shallow for an avalanche.
160
No one really thought there could have been an avalanche.
161
But the investigators were convinced that of the three remaining hypotheses, only a slab avalanche was possible,
162
despite the absence of a plausible mechanism for triggering one, let alone one so small it hardly left a trace.
163
In typical Dyatlov Pass incident fashion, the reinvestigation case ended somewhat abruptly.
164
The lead investigator was reassigned, and no one involved with the case ever gave a follow -up press interview the cold case was closed once again,
165
60 years later, but without any new answers.
166
So much of the mystery surrounding the Dyatlov Pass incident comes down to just how little we know about snow.
167
That's because snow is really difficult to study.
168
Not as much was known about snow yesterday.
169
So the snow science has advanced a lot.
170
But in the past 60 years, we've learned a few things.
171
That's partly thanks to more experiments, more analytical models, the usual progression of science.
172
But at some point, experiments and equations can only take you so far.
173
When the problems get really complicated, and for snow, they definitely do, you need computational power.
174
I think we've benefited a lot from the progress, particularly in numerical methods and in snow physics.
175
The problem is that snow is just...weird.
176
Sorry, there's just no other word for it.
177
Sometimes it flows like sand, sometimes it's solid like a brick, and most of the time it's somewhere in between.
178
This massive range of properties starts at a microscopic scale.
179
Snowflakes aren't actually always flakes.
180
Sometimes they're little needles or columns or plates.
181
The exact shape depends on the temperature and humidity at which they form.
182
And their shape determines how snowflakes interact with each other as they fall, pack, and age.
183
Okay, for example...
184
If it is wet snow, it's again something very different.
185
You can build castles from it, you know?
186
Wet snow melts a little as it falls.
187
So by the time it's in contact with other snowflakes, there's water to fill in the gaps and stick the flakes together.
188
The cohesion that lets you make a snowman
189
or igloo is due to the capillary force of water creeping between all those snowflakes.
190
On the other hand, dry snow grains slide over each other because there's nothing but air between them.
191
Sure, there's a small amount of friction, but no sticky water clinging on to every surface.
192
If you don't have much firsthand experience with snow then maybe
193
you have some experience with sand in some cases snow
194
and sand have really similar properties like
195
if sand is a little wet it can stick together enough to build a sand castle but
196
if you walk down a dry sand dune
197
you might trigger a big cascade of loose sand grains that's equivalent to a loose snow avalanche
198
when snow is really dry
199
and powdery with small lightweight crystals you could study it with the kind of simulations that also work for flowing sand
200
And there are two different methods you could use for that.
201
The first option is to simulate every single snowflake or grain of sand, and run the simulation based on the friction and collision forces between them.
202
This is a nice option because those are pretty simple rules of physics to derive.
203
Not all that much different from what you might learn in an introductory physics course.
204
This might work well for a couple dozen particles, but if you're interested in simulating thousands of particles,
205
well, it's going to get really complicated really fast.
206
That's a lot of particles for your computer program to keep track of,
207
and that isn't even close to the billions or trillions of snowflakes stacked on the mountainside.
208
So that brings us to option two.
209
You could simulate a fluid that has similar overall properties as flowing snow or sand.
210
For this method, you bundle up all those friction and collision forces and call it viscosity.
211
Viscosity describes how resistant a fluid is to flowing.
212
For example, water has pretty low viscosity, but honey is very viscous.
213
Modeling snow as a fluid means you can ignore all the microscopic details.
214
But sometimes those microscopic details end up being really important and interesting.
215
And it also means you have to go out to the mountain
216
and measure the viscosity of real snow at whatever temperatures and humidities you're interested in studying.
217
Weather conditions affect snow's behavior, but time and pressure can change it a lot too.
218
Like, anyone who's ever been beamed in the head by a snowball knows that snow can definitely stick together.
219
When they do that in clouds or as they fall, it's called aggregation.
220
And uh, side note, apparently scientists still don't know how flake aggregation works.
221
Like what?
222
Why haven't we figured that out yet?
223
Snow is too mysterious.
224
We have other things to focus on.
225
We have to ignore aggregation for this video.
226
Because what we care about is sintering.
227
That's the slow congealment that happens when flakes land and stick together in a snowbank.
228
The water molecules in snowflakes often have extra dangling bonds, so the molecules tend to rearrange and rebond whenever they can.
229
In order to reduce the number of loose wires, so to speak, the molecules shuffle into more energetically favorable configurations.
230
Put a lot of ice crystals close to each other, and they'll start swapping around water molecules so that the overall crystal has fewer unbound portions.
231
Eventually they succeed in lowering the total energy of the ice chunk by settling into mostly spherical ice balls.
232
Spheres have the least surface area per volume.
233
Less surface area means fewer dangling bonds.
234
Once they get to that point, they'll move to the next stage of sintering, recrystallization.
235
As they start forming a more perfect ice structure, the snow gradually transitions from individual flakes into a solid block of ice.
236
Over time, you end up with a structure that's semi -solid.
237
It'll have chunks of ice crystal that are weakly bonded to each other, but still with a lot of small holes interspersed.
238
This irregular microstructure makes the whole chunk pretty brittle.
239
That's why snow that was fluffy when it fell feels a little crunchy and porous a couple weeks later.
240
The older the snow is, and the more pressure it's under, the more ice cube -like it becomes.
241
Have you ever had really old ice cubes in your freezer that kind of congealed into one big chunk,
242
even if they never had the chance to partially melt?
243
Well, that's censoring for you.
244
All these snow types are difficult enough to study independently, but in the real world,
245
snow accumulates, building a snow cake with each layer made from a different type of snowflake, depending on the atmospheric conditions at the time.
246
Each slab -like layer is its own degree of sticky or powdery, and as new layers pile on,
247
older layers get compressed and the sintering process accelerates.
248
The longer the snowbank sits, the more its composition can change as it melts, refreezes, and sinters.
249
Just like snowflakes, every snowbank is unique.
250
If you dig in, the stratification gives you an idea of the weather conditions
251
that shaped each snowfall and can reveal structural weaknesses in the pile.
252
We went to Swiss Alps and over there we digged into snow
253
and we found this weak layer where you have a snow that is like your normal snow.
254
Then all of a sudden you come to a layer which looks like sugar.
255
This is so -called depth whore and it's really like sugar.
256
You know, small crystals of ice.
257
You cannot even call it snow.
258
Layers of hoar crystals form when water vapor crystallizes into ice, either on the surface of the snow or within the bulk of a snowbank.
259
And these sugar -fine crystals are so dangerous because they're so weak,
260
particularly to shear motions where layers are sliding against each other or a material is being pulled sideways.
261
Whether it's due to hoar crystals or a particularly dry and slippery layer or some other structural weakness,
262
avalanches happen when a layer of the snow cake gives out and the slab starts sliding.
263
Understanding how different kinds of layers form and interact with each other is absolutely essential for predicting avalanches.
264
But it's impractical to take measurements of every possible kind of snow cake.
265
You'd have to spend decades going out on dangerous slopes to measure snow's properties under all these atmospheric conditions.
266
People have been taking these measurements for decades, but there's still so much we can't know.
267
And that's exactly why scientists make models.
268
With a good model, we can study how snow layers form, age, and fail.
269
But the flowing, fluid -like snow models we discussed earlier do not work very well for the layers of our snow cake, and vice versa.
270
Basically, for the same reason that the ways we describe lava are totally different from how we talk about rocks.
271
They're just totally different things.
272
A snow slab behaves more like a brittle, solid material, which crumbles and cracks.
273
Those kinds of deformations are really difficult to study using equations, so simulations can step in to fill those gaps.
274
But simulations take a lot of computational power
275
and still require field measurements to serve as a realistic benchmark for the simulation parameters.
276
Plus, if you want to use simulations to study an avalanche, you need to model solid snow that breaks up and starts to flow.
277
For a long time, bridging that gap was something of a white whale for physicists.
278
Everything that has kept us from fully understanding snow,
279
temperature, wind, humidity, precipitation is also what has kept us from finding answers about the Dyatlov Pass.
280
Sometimes, technology is the factor limiting scientific progress.
281
With so many variables, you need massive amounts of computing power to model all these details about snow.
282
It's only in the past couple decades that new algorithms and more powerful computers have allowed us to do that.
283
But sometimes, you need a little luck, too.
284
And in 2017, a physicist's trip to the movies forever changed how the field thought about snow.
285
Grab some popcorn, because we're headed over to Los Angeles, where Disney had been trying to make a story like
286
Frozen for nearly 75 years, starting with Walt Disney himself.
287
Frozen is based on a classic story called the snow queen
288
by hans christian anderson he's the same guy who wrote the little mermaid the emperor's new clothes
289
and the ugly duckling to name a few lots of great stories from
290
that guy anyway classic fairy tales were disney's original bread
291
and butter so the snow queen was a natural target for the silver screen treatment
292
but over the years it kept getting developed, shelved, and canceled.
293
Around 2008, it was finally greenlit again and scheduled as a hand -animated film.
294
That's the classic, old -school animation style with every frame drawn by hand, like Snow White or Beauty and the Beast.
295
But by the 1990s and 2000s, computer animated films were starting to look really good, and they were performing well at the box office.
296
A new era of animation had arrived,
297
where animators could use computer programs to create 3D models of characters and scenery and to calculate all that motion.
298
So when the Snow Queen got delayed once again, Disney rescheduled it to be computer animated and renamed it Frozen.
299
Now, in a lot of ways, computer animation is faster than hand animation,
300
but it still takes a lot of hands and effort to create an entire movie.
301
Dale Maeda, one of the heads of effects for the Frozen movies, told me all about it.
302
He's been at Disney Animation Studios for about 27 years and has worked on some of my favorite movies ever.
303
Most people, when you ask them about animation, they're probably very familiar with the character animators,
304
but they're just like one small part of making this whole movie.
305
Every table and every chair has been designed by someone.
306
It didn't just appear, then they have to be rigged so that an animator can actually animate it.
307
And then there's someone that makes, designs the look of it and the textures and how light responds to it.
308
There's our department that does all the environmental things
309
and then there's like the lighting department that tries to make it look as
310
if it was all shot with one camera all at the same time and they make it look beautiful.
311
A core feature of movies is that, you know, they move.
312
In hand animated cartoons, you might notice that the background and much of the scenery is static, with only the main characters rigged for animation.
313
I always felt so smart as a kid
314
when I could tell what object the character was about to pick up
315
because it had like a slightly different art style than the rest of the background.
316
But wouldn't it be nice if you could use the principles of physics
317
and the power of mathematics to create motion for thousands of elements in any given movie scene?
318
If you put all that together, then you've got yourself a simulation.
319
In our department, we use simulations quite a bit for everything.
320
So we use it for, you know, fire or water or snow.
321
We're not trying to make it like completely physically plausible.
322
We rarely just go, okay, we just ran the numbers.
323
This is what you get.
324
You know, it's always like, okay, let's fine tune it.
325
We're constantly trying to bend the physics to do whatever's going to make
326
it the most appealing for every single shot and tells the story.
327
By 2012, when Frozen finally thawed from its development deep freeze,
328
Disney's mathematicians started experimenting with existing simulation frameworks for snow.
329
There was like two methods that we could do at the time.
330
There was like flip simulations, which is usually used for water, but snow is not really usually like that.
331
And then we tried also using rigid body dynamics.
332
It was just like tons of like little clumps of stuff.
333
And when you just watched it, it was like, that doesn't look like snow.
334
But then they came across a framework that physicists had been using to study systems like plasma, fluid, and sand.
335
We had a software developer, his name was Andy Selley.
336
Somehow he had gotten together with a team at UCLA, one of which his name is Alexei Stomach,
337
and they all worked together and they thought, hey, there's this method called material point method.
338
It's really only been used for scientific stuff to do like real stuff, but it had never been used for film because it's just too slow.
339
With a lot of clever math, the team was able to transform the material point method, or MPM, into an industry standard animation tool.
340
MPM is now used to animate materials from dirt, to sand, to ice cream, to snow.
341
In particular, MPM is really good at replicating snow's ability to pack, or compress, and its tendency to fracture, crack, and flow.
342
But these simulations weren't designed to map to the real parameters of snow, or predict a real -life avalanche.
343
Their job was to create beautiful animation.
344
That's part of what made this model so successful.
345
The development team was willing to sacrifice scientific accuracy for creative flexibility and computational speed.
346
I also got to speak with Marlon West, the other head of effects on Frozen.
347
He's been with Disney for over 30 years.
348
To make our magic, our movie magic, has to be rooted in something real, some science behind it.
349
We did a lot of research on different natural phenomena.
350
But one thing on Frozen, because they knew the characters were going to be going through this really deep snow, they actually sent Marlon and I,
351
along with the anim supervisors to Jackson Hole, Wyoming.
352
We were studying the snow.
353
We were like moving it, pushing it, seeing how it looked and how did the light affect it.
354
But it's a romanticized version of what it is.
355
So even our simulations are helping try to tell the emotional story of our characters.
356
And I gotta say, as a simulation physicist myself, these simulations are really impressive, artistically and technically.
357
I'm not the only simulation physicist who is impressed.
358
So was Alexander Puzern's collaborator, snow physicist Joan Gome.
359
When Joan watched
360
Frozen, he said, this cannot be, you know, the snow looks so natural.
361
These guys are geniuses who draw it like that.
362
And then he discovered that these are not drawings.
363
These are actually NPM simulations.
364
Gome had been working on snow simulations for quite a while.
365
His research group had been working primarily with a simulation model called Discrete Elements Method, or DEM.
366
The basic idea is that you take a big chunk of material, that you want to have a certain stiffness or brittleness,
367
etc., then you break the big chunk into small spheres.
368
You can use math
369
and physics to determine how the spheres should interact with each
370
other in order to reproduce the bulk properties of the overall material.
371
The more spheres you use, the better resolution you have to look at what's going on inside the material.
372
But the more spheres you use, the slower your simulation runs.
373
Gohm was interested in understanding how slab avalanches form, especially what kinds of weaknesses in the snow layers can trigger a dangerous slab avalanche to detach.
374
The DEM model is pretty good at this.
375
Any time the force between two adjacent spheres gets too strong, they break apart and form a crack.
376
And his team had used DEM to study a lot of interesting snow scenarios.
377
But there were still some questions that were difficult to study with DEM.
378
And it was clear that DEM simulations could only get so good.
379
When he saw the snow simulations in Frozen, well...
380
It has been inspired by Hollywood, so to say.
381
Then he worked on it to make snow being mechanically, not only visually realistic, but also mechanically realistic. In 2017,
382
GOM flew out to Los Angeles to collaborate with the researchers from UCLA and Disney who developed the snow MPM for Frozen.
383
Together they refined the model to be useful for scientific study by creating rigorous benchmark tests
384
that compared simulation results against physical snow measurements.
385
Through their collaboration, the snow physics community added a veritable power drill to their simulation toolbox.
386
Because while the MPM had been around for a while, the UCLA Disney team figured out how to make it fast enough,
387
and with GOM involved, they were also able to make it accurate enough for practical applications.
388
The material point method is so great for snow in particular, because its mathematical framework is slightly different from previous snow modeling techniques.
389
Remember, what makes snow tricky is that it often starts as a solid -ish material and then shatters or flows when disturbed.
390
Other simulation methods used for studying solids might divide the material into chunks
391
and then keep track of how those chunks move with respect to one another.
392
But when a slab detaches and turns into a sliding avalanche, the distances between snow chunks gets enormous because,
393
well, the whole thing is breaking up into tiny pieces.
394
MPM is called a hybrid particle grid method because it's made of particles,
395
or rather points, from within the material that move across a reference grid that stays fixed,
396
which allows you to calculate how the material moves with respect to the background rather than the neighboring chunk of snow.
397
If the snow slab breaks into a bunch of small pieces, it's no problem to calculate because the background is always there as a reference point.
398
It's a subtle difference, but it changes the mathematical techniques you can use to solve the enormous set of equations that describes the material.
399
MPM is less useful for materials like rubber that stretch a lot, but ultimately keep their shape and rarely break apart.
400
But it's a revelation for something like snow, where the material is cracking, falling apart, flowing, and then crashing back together again.
401
MPM is also able to handle properties like compression.
402
Snow has a lot of air in it, and we know that compressibility is an essential feature of snow,
403
or else I wouldn't be able to bean my brothers in the head with snowballs.
404
While MPM is far from solving every single one of snow's mysteries,
405
it's really changed the game for snow physicists and made it possible to study snow in a lot of new ways.
406
I came across this research and this connection because I was actually looking into some papers that use MPM to do physics,
407
snow physics simulations of avalanches.
408
I was digging through the literature and I was like, where did this model come from?
409
It seems like it came out of nowhere.
410
And I realized that it came from Frozen.
411
So I think it's, it's such an incredible example of how art and technology and science all speak to each other.
412
I mean, I think from the beginning of of disney studios
413
i mean like walt disney was always not only interested in like the amazing you know beautiful artwork and everything
414
but he was also very interested in like the cutting edge technology of the time it is good to know that
415
hard sciences coming into the building to help us create fun images and believable images for general audiences.
416
And then what we accomplish is going back out into the world.
417
One way Gome ended up applying this new simulation framework was to the Dyatlov Pass cold case.
418
When the case was reopened by the Russian government, it was actually the New York Times who reached out to
419
Gome to get his expert opinion on the plausibility of a slab avalanche having occurred.
420
Gome called up his collaborator, Puzrin.
421
We gave New York Times a bit of a vague answer.
422
Maybe yes, maybe not.
423
But then we discussed it, read a bit more about it, and decided to look into this.
424
Because if it was an avalanche, it would be a very unusual one, a very interesting one.
425
And as researchers, as we look for cases like that.
426
See, photos from the hikers' final roll of film showed
427
they had pitched their tent by cutting into the snow slope to create a flat platform.
428
Gome and Puzrin used maps, topographical measurements, and photos to reconstruct the campsite's terrain,
429
and estimated the snow quality based on the weather conditions that night.
430
From these scant clues, they identified a plausible range of parameters that would have influenced any potential avalanches,
431
and it became clear that the hikers cutting into the snow probably couldn't have caused an avalanche on its own.
432
If it was an avalanche, it was probably a delayed avalanche.
433
It was about 10 hours should have passed between this and the avalanche release.
434
And I could see that for the geometry of the Dyatlov Pass, for inclinations and the size of the potential slab,
435
you could not get a delay of several hours, just based on the typical relaxation times of snow.
436
Because the snow has this viscous behavior,
437
you cut it and it takes time for it to relax and for the crack,
438
the basal crack to grow.
439
And in these 10 hours, there was no snowfall.
440
This would be an easy story. So next, Gohm and Puzrin accounted for the 4 to 10 meters per second wind speeds
441
that were measured on the nearby mountainside that night.
442
The wind transfers the snow.
443
It removes the snow from the top of the mountain and deposits it on the slope.
444
It was not the property of the material which was time -dependent, but the loading which was time -dependent.
445
So you have the time dependence of the snow just being a weird material, but then also something more mechanical going on as well.
446
Absolutely.
447
Within the range of plausible wind speeds, measured weather conditions, and verified tent positioning, their mathematical model demonstrated
448
that a small slab avalanche could have detached hours after the hikers pitched their tent once they were all asleep inside.
449
When they cut into the snow bank, it would have placed stress on the snow layers there.
450
Strong winds that night likely transported snow from the mountain ridge onto the drift overhanging the hiker's tent.
451
And several hours later, this additional loading, along with the slow relaxation properties of snow likely caused a crack to form
452
and a small slab avalanche could have landed on the tent.
453
Gome and Puserin's mathematical model confirmed this plausibility.
454
Their next step was to deploy the MPM to understand the impact of the avalanche on the sleeping hikers.
455
Gome simulated the slab avalanche predicted by the mathematical model and measured the bodily injury it could have caused.
456
Could have this avalanche in principle, would it be sufficiently fast and heavy to cause these injuries
457
and the answer was yes in principle
458
that this could have happened the simulation revealed
459
that the avalanche could have been heavy enough to cause blunt force trauma to the hikers inside
460
trauma equivalent to being hit by a car
461
and within the same the same computer environment we were able to to model it measure deformations
462
and to identify the possible injuries
463
and they were consistent with the autopsy reports." The simulated avalanche
464
was also big enough to partially collapse the tent without completely burying it,
465
but still small enough that its crown fracture could have been smoothed the way by wind or filled in with new snowdrift.
466
Starting only with the fact that could be reasonably known, Gohm and Puzrin used math,
467
physics, and a bit of movie magic to finally offer the first truly plausible explanation of the Dyatlov Pass incident.
468
Unless you go not only to Dyatlov Pass, but also 60 years back in time, you're not going to get the same conditions.
469
You know, because every year, the snowpack is going to be different.
470
A plausible explanation is certainly not the same as definitive proof.
471
But this answer might be as close as we can ever get.
472
So what might have happened that night?
473
Well, we know the hikers cut into the snowbank, pitched their tent, and carefully organized the inside.
474
They ate some dinner and laid down to sleep.
475
While they slept, wind likely heaped snow on the ridge directly above their tent.
476
An abnormally strong wind might have swept down to destabilize the slab, or the gradual snow accumulation, combined with the stress of cutting into the slope,
477
caused a crack to form that slowly grew until the slab detached.
478
Disoriented by the threat of an avalanche and potentially injured by the falling snow, the hikers slashed a hole in the side of their collapsed
479
tent to quickly exit without pausing to put on their shoes or don more layers.
480
But they were expert mountaineers, trained to remain calm and take action in the face of disaster,
481
so they might have walked calmly to the nearest tree line to seek shelter.
482
There they probably tried building a fire for warmth, and upon realizing that no full scale avalanche was on the way,
483
likely attempted to return to the tent for supplies.
484
But in such intense cold, the underdressed hikers were hopelessly doomed.
485
As several of them succumbed to hypothermia, the others would have taken their fallen friend's clothes as a desperate bid to stay warm.
486
When both the fire and return attempt failed, the remaining hikers might have tried digging a snow cave, another emergency survival tactic.
487
They would have insulated it with a layer of clothes to better preserve their body heat and share warmth.
488
Perhaps a few hours later, they might have left the cave together
489
and on their trek encountered a particularly weak layer of snow that gave way as they walked over it, dumping them several meters into a ravine.
490
Buried beneath meters of snow, with severe bodily injuries from either the slab avalanche or the fall,
491
the remaining hikers would have died slowly in the cold.
492
Their faces may have been mangled by scavenging animals we tried to treat it as a purely scientific problem
493
but in reality it is not it is not purely scientific
494
because these were these young people who went there
495
and encountered the tragedy and it seems that if the avalanche hypothesis is correct,
496
then it's also kind of a story of a friendship because others could have saved themselves if they just left them there.
497
And they didn't, you know.
498
They took care of them and they lost a lot of time because of that.
499
This reconstruction of the Dyatlov past incident can still only ever be a guess.
500
There are countless things we will never know.
501
I mean, for one, I'm still pretty baffled about how scientists don't quite know how snowflakes stick together when they aggregate in the sky.
502
But, right, focus on the case.
503
This simulation can't explain why their clothes tested as radioactive.
504
There were also several eyewitness reports of bright orbs flying through the sky that February.
505
Dozens of legitimately inconsistent details remain unexplained, enough that even the most outlandish conspiracy theories will likely never die.
506
But somehow, despite being unable to go back in time to February 1st,
507
1959, we have actually produced a plausible explanation for the Dyatlov Pass incident.
508
Technology and science improved enough over the past 60 years
509
that we're finally able to show how an avalanche could form where people were sure one couldn't exist.
510
I think what science could answer, it answered.
511
It says that physically, this avalanche does not violate the laws of physics.
512
We also, in a way, saw this as a bit of a tribute to them, this work.
513
It's not purely rational, cold, analytical solution.
514
So that's why we were so much engaged.
515
And we really worked everybody who gets in touch with this, you know, works very hard on it.
516
Snow will likely continue to elude physicists.
517
Even as our simulation methods get faster, bigger, and more accurate, there will always be avalanches we can't predict, and tragedies we can't prevent.
518
Nature is inherently messy and complex, but the story of the Dyatlov Pass reminds us that unknown doesn't always mean unknowable.
519
Sometimes the answers are out there waiting for science and technology to catch up, as long as we don't let it go.
520
And sometimes we're just waiting for the right story to inspire us.

Download App

Everything you need to speak fluently

AI PronunciationScore every sentence
IPA PracticeMaster every sound
VocabularyBuild your word bank
Vocab GameLearn while playing

Same Channel

FOR YOU

Recommend Video

Vocabulary and speaking notes for this lesson

This speaking lesson is built on the video “The Science That Finally Explains the Dyatlov Pass Incident”. The speaker keeps coming back to these words: snow, avalanche, simulation. This video has 404 sentences and 7438 words to shadow. The speech runs for 44:44. The speaker talks at a natural 166 words per minute, close to everyday conversation. Only 78% of the words are among the 3,000 most common in English, so the vocabulary is demanding.

Key vocabulary in this video

15 words from the video worth learning, with pronunciation and meaning:

WordPronunciationMeaning
simulation noun/ˌsɪm.jəˈleɪ.ʃn̩/Something that simulates a system or environment in order to predict actual behaviour.
tent noun/tɛnt/A pavilion or portable lodge consisting of skins, canvas, or some strong cloth, stretched and sustained by poles, used for sheltering people from the weather.
layer noun/ˈleɪ̯ɚ/A single thickness of some material covering a surface.
sand noun/sænd/Rock that is ground more finely than gravel, but is not as fine as silt (more formally, see grain sizes chart), forming beaches and deserts and also used in…
slope noun/sloʊp/A surface that either inclines or declines in a regular manner from the perspective of an observer.
chunk noun/t͡ʃʌŋk/A part of something that has been separated; a generally squat, thick, irregular piece of something, e.g. wood or stone.
physics noun/ˈfɪz.ɪks/The branch of science concerned with the study of the properties and interactions of space, time, matter and energy.
freeze verb/ˈfɹiːz/Especially of a liquid, to become solid due to low temperature.
crystal noun/ˈkɹɪstəl/A solid composed of an array of atoms or molecules possessing long-range order and arranged in a pattern which is periodic in three dimensions.
animation noun/ˌæn.ɪˈmeɪ.ʃən/The act of animating, or giving life or spirit.
loose adjective/lus/Not fixed in place tightly or firmly.
meter noun/ˈmitəɹ/A device that measures things.
investigator noun/ɪnˈvɛs.tɪˌɡeɪ̯.təː/One who investigates.
plausible adjective/ˈplɑ.zɪ.bəl/Seemingly or apparently valid, likely, or acceptable; conceivably true or likely.
crack noun/kɹæk/A thin and usually jagged space opened in a previously solid material.

Phrasal verbs you will hear

WordMeaning
stick together verbTo physically combine or join together by adhesion.
break apart verbTo dismantle something into its base components.
come across verbTo change sides; to cross over to work for the opposition.
come back verbTo return to a place.
come down to verbTo reach by moving down or reducing.
end up verbTo bring to a conclusion.
break up verbTo break or separate into pieces.
call away verbTo summon; to cause to depart.

Sentences worth repeating

Short, complete lines from the video that you can reuse in everyday conversation:

  • Maybe you’ve heard this story before.
  • Did I hear that right?
  • I can’t even fathom being that cold.
  • Why haven’t we figured that out yet?
  • There's our department that does all the environmental things.

Grammar in this video

The structures the speaker uses most, with the exact words from the video:

StructureIn the video
Present perfect have/has + past participle — a past action that still matters nowhas become · you've heard · have made
Passive voice be + past participle — the focus is on what happens, not who does itwas renamed · was meant · was sent
Relative clauses who / which + clause — extra information about a person or thingpeople who die · guy who wrote · simulations, which is

Pronunciation to watch

The speaker uses 61 contractions and reduced forms, such as can't, I'm, they're. Say them the short way, as you hear them.

  • The “th” sounds: mathematical /ˌmæθ(.ə)ˈmæt.ɪ.kəl/, hypothesis /haɪˈpɒθɪsɪs/, math /mæθ/, clothing /ˈkloʊðɪŋ/, beneath /bɪˈniːθ/
  • The “sh” and “zh” sounds: simulation /ˌsɪm.jəˈleɪ.ʃn̩/, animation /ˌæn.ɪˈmeɪ.ʃən/, explanation /ˌɛkspləˈneɪʃən/, measurement /ˈmɛʒ.ə.mənt/, shallow /ˈʃæloʊ/
  • Long words — get the stress right: animation /ˌæn.ɪˈmeɪ.ʃən/, investigator /ɪnˈvɛs.tɪˌɡeɪ̯.təː/, explanation /ˌɛkspləˈneɪʃən/, mathematical /ˌmæθ(.ə)ˈmæt.ɪ.kəl/, hypothesis /haɪˈpɒθɪsɪs/

How to practise with this video

  1. Listen to the whole video once without speaking and note the words you do not know.
  2. Start at 0.75× speed, shadow it sentence by sentence, then go back to normal speed once it feels easy.
  3. Record yourself and compare with the original, paying attention to words like simulation, tent, layer.

What is the Shadowing Technique?

Shadowing is a science-backed language learning technique originally developed for professional interpreter training and popularized by polyglot Dr. Alexander Arguelles. The method is simple but powerful: you listen to native English audio and immediately repeat it out loud — like a shadow following the speaker with just a 1–2 second delay. Unlike passive listening or grammar drills, shadowing forces your brain and mouth muscles to simultaneously process and reproduce real speech patterns. Research shows it significantly improves pronunciation accuracy, intonation, rhythm, connected speech, listening comprehension, and speaking fluency — making it one of the most effective methods for IELTS Speaking preparation and real-world English communication.

Shadowing technique: read the full step-by-step guide →