Shadowing Practice: My 6-Step Morning Protocol for a Better Day - Learn English Speaking with Video
Ders oluşturuluyor...
1
Is morning hard for you?
2
When you wake up, do you find that you've got some tough feelings and maybe a little more stress than you'd like?
3
That describes a lot of people.
4
That will tell you about your emotional baseline, how you wake up feeling in the morning on an average day, not a day where you've slept nothing or God forbid that you're hungover.
5
I'm talking about a normal day when you've gotten enough sleep, but you wake up and you're kind of out of sorts.
6
You might say to yourself, okay, sure, sure, buddy, I'll get up at 4.30 in the morning, but I'm hitting the espresso machine first.
7
That's my first stop, right?
8
No, I don't recommend that.
9
I have used all of my background in behavioral science
10
and everything I've learned about biology as well to put together a morning protocol
11
that is enhancing of my wellbeing by managing the negative side of my affect profile and you can do it too.
12
Hi friends, welcome to Office Hours.
13
I'm Arthur Brooks.
14
I'm a professor at Harvard University.
15
I'm also the author of How to Build a Life, a column in The Atlantic about happiness.
16
I'm a behavioral scientist dedicated to lifting people up
17
and bringing them together in bonds of happiness and love using science and ideas.
18
And this podcast is intended to help you to do exactly the same thing, to become a happier person and to bring more happiness to the world around you.
19
Thank you for watching my podcast and for subscribing and liking and leaving comments.
20
Thanks also for recommending this show.
21
I know a lot of people are recommending it to others, and I appreciate that a lot.
22
We need as many people as we can looking at content about happiness and applying it to their lives.
23
Please do leave a review or a rating and a comment.
24
We look at all the comments, and we appreciate them a lot.
25
Also, if you have any questions or comments or criticisms or any other way that you want to interact with us,
26
the email to the show is officehours at arthurbrooks.com.
27
We're looking forward to hearing from you.
28
This week, I want to talk about how to start your day in the best possible way to set you up for well-being.
29
Now, what I'm going to do today is to talk to you about how I do that.
30
My life is based on protocols.
31
My life is based on a tremendous amount of discipline.
32
And the reason for that is because happiness doesn't have to be left up to chance.
33
I mean, a good deal of it depends on what's going on around you, to be sure.
34
But there's a lot more of it in your hands than you probably ever understood.
35
And if you follow my work, you know that there are many habits that you can adopt that will make you happier today.
36
Also less unhappy.
37
I'll talk about that distinction in this episode.
38
Really, today is about the protocols that I've developed over the years that have tremendously improved my life, that have made my life so much better than it had been in the past.
39
And I'm going to tell you why that is
40
and exactly how you can adopt these ideas and adapt them to your routines as well.
41
Today, a mad scientist's morning well-being protocol.
42
Now, I've just referred to myself as a mad scientist, and let me tell you why.
43
In a past episode, I talked about positive and negative emotions.
44
The fact is that the limbic system of the brain produces positive and negative emotions for very specific reasons.
45
You need both.
46
You need positive, you need negative.
47
And if you don't have one or the other, your life isn't going to work right.
48
A lot of people say, I want good feelings and I don't want bad feelings.
49
And I say, that's wrong.
50
There's no such thing as bad feelings.
51
If you didn't have negative emotions, you'd be dead in a week.
52
They're an alarm system for what's going on around you.
53
Fear, anger, disgust, and sadness.
54
The trouble is that for a lot of people, they have very intense negative emotionality.
55
As a matter of fact, as makes perfect sense, half of the population is above average in the intensity of the production of their negative emotions.
56
We're not all the same.
57
One of the things that I do, and I've talked about a little bit in the past, is the categorization of the intensity of emotions that people feel.
58
Above average positive, above average negative, below average positive, below average negative.
59
Now you know that you can interact these two things, and you get four kinds of people.
60
Some people, they're really above average positive and below average negative.
61
Isn't that great?
62
We call them cheerleaders.
63
Some people are low on both sides.
64
These are low affect people.
65
They're low positive and low negative in intensity.
66
They're judges.
67
Some people are high negative and low positive.
68
We call them poets.
69
And then there are the people who are intense on both high negative and high positive.
70
Those are the mad scientists.
71
And that's me.
72
I feel things very intensely.
73
And that's great on the positive side, but I need to manage the negative side.
74
Today, I'm going to tell you how I do that, because a lot of you watching, Well, one of the reasons that you're watching this content
75
and you're interested in it is not just because you're trying to feel more joyful every minute, but you're trying to manage negative emotionality,
76
which actually has a negative impact from time to time on your happiness.
77
I'm not talking about clinical problems here.
78
I'm talking about ordinary life.
79
And you may have noticed that you have some ups and that's great, but some downs that are pretty intense as well.
80
what can you do every day to manage the intensity of your negative emotions such
81
that it doesn't feel dysregulated and obstruct your quality of life?
82
I'm going to give you a whole bunch of ideas
83
that I follow and the schedule on
84
which I follow these ideas every single day that has dramatically improved my quality of life.
85
During the coronavirus epidemic, when almost everybody was locked down, me included, I thought I could use the time well by experimenting on myself a little bit.
86
That led to a lot of research that I talk about in this show and that I write about as well.
87
But it also included some experiments that I did on my health.
88
I was looking for new ways to get multivitamins that were easy to absorb, pre and probiotics which are great for my health, antioxidants, superfoods.
89
And I made a great discovery during those years.
90
I found AG1.
91
It's an all-in-one-place daily health drink that gives me all the things that I need.
92
And I've been a paying customer ever since.
93
That's why I'm so pleased that AG1 Next Gen is now a sponsor of Office Hours.
94
So head on over to www.drinkag1.com for a free welcome kit.
95
You'll get a bottle of vitamin D and five free starter packs of AG1.
96
That's a $76 value when you subscribe.
97
So drink AG1.com slash Arthur Brooks to try AG1 today.
98
Now, let's start off with a couple of questions.
99
Is morning hard for you?
100
When you wake up, do you find that you've got some tough feelings and maybe a little more stress than you'd like?
101
That describes a lot of people.
102
That will tell you about your emotional baseline, how you wake up feeling in the morning on an average day, not a day where you slept nothing or God forbid that you're hungover.
103
I'm talking about a normal day.
104
when you've gotten enough sleep, but you wake up and you're kind of out of sorts.
105
People with highly intense negative affect, which is what we call mood in my business, they tend to be these people with this high negative emotionality,
106
and that includes me.
107
Now, part of the reason is because I'm a high affect person, because I am this mad scientist.
108
Part of it is because when you wake up in the morning, especially a few, well, more like 45 minutes after you wake up, you get a spike of cortisol,
109
which is a stress hormone, and that kind of, that pours fuel on your high level of negative effect.
110
And I'll top that off in my own case by being a pretty poor sleeper.
111
It's not because I have bad sleep hygiene.
112
It's because I come from a long line of insomniacs.
113
I remember as a kid, any time that I would wake up, it was weird.
114
If I would get up and go downstairs, I always found my dad.
115
And he was always drinking a cup of, you know, postum or hot chocolate or something.
116
Two o'clock in the morning, he was up.
117
Four o'clock in the morning, he was up.
118
Until it finally occurred to me by the time I was about 11 years old, he never sleeps.
119
I asked him about it.
120
He said, yeah, my dad never slept either.
121
He said, good luck to you, son.
122
And sure enough, by the time I hit 40, it became a real problem.
123
So the result of it is that I'm always battling sleep issues.
124
I've got cortisol spikes in the morning like everybody, and I'm a high negative affect person.
125
That all adds up to a big need for me to manage mood in the morning more than any other time.
126
I have used all of my background in behavioral science
127
and everything I've learned about biology as well to put together a morning protocol
128
that is enhancing of my well-being by managing the negative side of my affect profile.
129
And you can do it too.
130
This is a six-part management protocol on negative affect.
131
Here's what it starts.
132
Now, Now this is going to be a hard one.
133
You're not going to necessarily like this.
134
But to understand what I'm about to tell you, I want to take you not to some laboratory here in the United States, but from ancient wisdom across to the other side of the world.
135
And I want to introduce the concept of Brahma Muhurta.
136
That's two words in Sanskrit that means creator's time.
137
It's an ancient idea.
138
It's probably about 6,000 years old.
139
Now, Brahma, it refers to God or the Godhead.
140
Muhurta is a specific period of time.
141
48 minutes to be exact.
142
And so the Brahma Muhurta specifically is two Muhurtas and that adds up to an hour and 36 minutes.
143
Now, what is that all about?
144
The idea of the Brahma Muhurta, the creator's time, is to get up an hour and 36 minutes before dawn.
145
The idea was in ancient Vedic wisdom that you'd have a particular kind of insight into the mind of the Godhead.
146
You'd have a special enlightenment.
147
You'd have clarity of thinking an hour and 36 minutes before dawn.
148
So don't miss it, is what they were saying.
149
Now, of course, there are no good treatment control experiments, peer-reviewed studies talking about exactly an hour and 36 minutes before dawn.
150
And a lot of you are not going to get up an hour and 36 minutes before dawn, so you can have this special connection to God.
151
I know that.
152
And especially if you live pretty far north in the middle of summer, there's no way you could get up an hour and 36 minutes before dawn.
153
I was talking about this summer, this last summer when I was in Helsinki, and I was there at the end of June, and somebody pointed out that it doesn't get dark.
154
So, you know, good luck to you on the Brahma Makorta.
155
That's not the point.
156
The basic point is that modern research shows that whether
157
or not you can connect to the divine at this time or not, that if you get up before dawn, And this is based on treatment and control experiments.
158
Again, all of this research is going to go into the show notes.
159
Don't worry.
160
But this is Kumar and Raghavendra and Mujanath in 2012 in the Indian Journal of Physiological Pharmacology.
161
This is an excellent study that shows where students are in treatment and control.
162
One gets up at seven o'clock in the morning
163
and the other gets up something like an hour before dawn and gets to work, that the earlier group has significantly higher attentiveness and recall throughout the day.
164
There's also higher levels of creativity and focus.
165
If you get up before dawn, your work is gonna be better.
166
Now, that's not just a question of higher performance.
167
It's also the case that people who witness the dawn, who are up before dawn and fully conscious and witness the dawn, they have lower levels of negative affect.
168
This is especially true for people who have seasonal affective disorder, people who have a lot of trouble with depression come January or February.
169
It's actually pretty easy to get up before dawn in February because the sun is coming up so late.
170
My advice is to use the happiness effect of this and the effectiveness,
171
the productivity effects of the brahman-mukhurtah getting up before dawn in a way that will significantly change your life.
172
Now, let me talk a little bit more about the science of how this works and how to use that time.
173
I get up at 4.30.
174
4.30 is my time to rise from bed, but I travel a lot too.
175
And so there are times when I'm really jet lagged and I have to alter that a little bit, But I always try to get up before dawn because of these good effects, which I've noticed in my life.
176
I've seen in the research and I've been able to witness in my own life as well.
177
Now, you might be saying to yourself, yeah, man, good for you.
178
You're obviously a morning lark.
179
No, I'm not.
180
And there's a lot of research on chronotypes.
181
Chronotypes are the different kinds of people who are either night-oriented people or morning-oriented people.
182
And the morning lark versus the night owl.
183
And there's interesting research on that, by the way, that shows that people who tend to have trouble going to sleep and want to sleep in,
184
they probably have a circadian rhythm where the day in their brain, the day is not 24 hours, it's a little bit longer.
185
And so the result of that is that they're not tired at night.
186
They're chronically a little bit not tired at night.
187
And that's possibly the case.
188
And if it is, it's almost certainly genetic.
189
but we also have a ton of research out there that chronotype is also extremely environmental.
190
For the longest time, I never saw the sunrise.
191
I didn't.
192
All the way through my 20s, I was making my living as a professional musician, and I got up when the sun was warm.
193
I went to bed when it was nice and late, and I always thought I was a night owl.
194
Well, looking back on it, no, I was just a musician who drank too much.
195
Now, I don't drink at all, and it turns out it's easier to get up.
196
Not super easy.
197
I'm not one of those people who gets up without an alarm clock.
198
No, I use an alarm clock every single day.
199
I did this morning.
200
It went off at 4.30 and I didn't like it.
201
I said, because that morning alarm is something I would like to sleep through.
202
But winning the day is a big deal as the first battle in fighting negative affect and raising my wellbeing.
203
And it's so effective that I jumped out of bed as I ordinarily do.
204
Now, when does this morning at 4.30 start?
205
The answer is last night, right?
206
The truth is
207
that the most important way to be able to wake up early in the morning is to go to bed on time.
208
And I try to be in bed by 9.15.
209
And for me, if I'm getting seven hours of sleep, that's a great night.
210
And I feel great.
211
I don't fall asleep at the wheel.
212
I'm not falling asleep during meetings.
213
I never take naps.
214
And I have plenty of energy.
215
Right now, I'm taping this in the middle of the afternoon, and I hope it's clear that I'm wide awake.
216
One of the reasons that people aren't able to get to bed, especially in their 20s, I've written about this a little bit, is called nighttime procrastination.
217
And what this is is a phenomenon where you're sort of rebelling against yourself, especially as a young adult.
218
You remember, you have this vestigial memory being put to bed, and you didn't want to be put to bed, and so you rebel against it by, even though you're the one setting the rules, it's unproductive.
219
Remember, be metacognitive.
220
I've talked about that in past episodes.
221
Think about what is actually motivating you and you can manage yourself better.
222
That's the first battle is getting to bed, waking up.
223
For me, it's 4.30.
224
Now, the first thing that I do when I wake up, 15 minutes after I wake up, I'm in the gym.
225
I'm very lucky.
226
I have a gym in my house.
227
That's a must have for me.
228
I've had a gym in my house for a long time, precisely because I get up so early.
229
I don't feel like getting in the car.
230
I want to go downstairs.
231
I go down to my basement.
232
I've got a real nice setup there, all the things that I actually need because I've been working out almost every day for the past 30 years.
233
I'm a bonafide gym rat.
234
Now, what do I not do?
235
I don't ingest anything except for a little bit of electrolytes, creatine monohydrate, which is the thing.
236
I used to take five grams a day and creatine monohydrate.
237
I'm now taking 10 or even 15 because of the new research that shows that it has incredibly powerful neurocognitive benefits,
238
as well as the physiological benefits with respect to muscle protein synthesis, or at least volumizing muscles when you're doing resistance training.
239
And so the result of it is that that's all I'm taking.
240
I'll talk to you in a minute about why I'm not taking anything else besides that when I start my workout.
241
I work out 60 minutes a day, and I work out seven days a week.
242
Now, you might be thinking, that sounds insane.
243
You do you.
244
You gotta figure out actually how much rest you need.
245
But if you're working out seven days a week, You're obviously not working out the same muscles seven days a week.
246
I'm 61 years old.
247
I would be bent over and hurting all the time if I did that.
248
I have all kinds of splits that I've been working on, and I have routines, and I have cycles that I've been doing for years and years.
249
My protocols for exercise are something I'm going to cover in a future episode of the show.
250
But boil it down to I'm doing a combination of zone two cardio.
251
That's the cardio where you can actually talk.
252
You're breathing hard, but you can actually talk.
253
You're not that out of breath.
254
and serious resistance training.
255
So I'm either doing half and half or I'll do resistance training and then half an hour of zone two cardio,
256
or more likely I'll actually warm down with zone two cardio and I start with 45 minutes of serious resistance training.
257
I'm lifting weights is what it comes down to.
258
Later in the day, I always do a lot of steps.
259
I get a lot of walking.
260
Esther and I, we go out for a walk for about 40 minutes every night after dinner.
261
We live in a nice neighborhood where we can walk around.
262
We're unlikely to get run over by a car and it's certainly not dangerous.
263
And that's a real privilege, I have to say.
264
But also it's really good right after dinner to do that.
265
It's good for your digestion.
266
It has a lot of protective benefits.
267
And it's one of the practices that my friend Dan Buettner has talked about, that people walk after meals are some of the healthiest, longest lived people in the world.
268
Probably you've seen some of the science on that.
269
Maybe I'll drop some of that in the show notes as well.
270
Okay, so I'm starting my day at 4.30.
271
Beep, beep, beep, beep, beep with the alarm clock.
272
Side note, I don't use my phone to wake me up part of digital detox is detoxing from digital all night long,
273
starting an hour before I go to bed and an hour after I wake up.
274
And that means I got to wake up a different way.
275
I have this incredible device.
276
It's called a $5 alarm clock that I got off Amazon and it always works.
277
So I'm not using my phone.
278
Very important, especially for a poor sleeper like me, I recommend it.
279
Then within 15 minutes, I've got my workout drink and I'm down in the gym and I'm doing that for an hour.
280
Okay.
281
Now there's a lot of research that suggests that, that for different goals, different times of day for exercise might be better.
282
Example for muscle, for muscle hypertrophy, it's probably a little bit better to work out later in the morning, middle of the day, sometimes even in the afternoon.
283
I don't recommend working out right before you go to bed
284
because I can stimulate a lot of cortisol and that can keep you awake.
285
And you don't want that.
286
You want your melatonin, your cortisol to cross so that you can go to sleep.
287
But when we're talking about mood, you need to do your exercise when you need the exercise for mood management.
288
This is the most powerful tool I've got over the course of the day.
289
Okay, what do I know?
290
People who have high levels of negative affect, intense negative affect.
291
Again, we're not talking about clinical problems here.
292
We're not talking about mood disorders of clinical depression or generalized anxiety.
293
We're just talking about above average negative affect, intensity of negative emotion.
294
There are some really bad ways to manage it, and there's some really good ways to manage it.
295
The single worst way for you to manage your negative affect is drugs and alcohol.
296
If you're numbing yourself, you're going to have problems.
297
The second worst way to lower your negative affect is workaholism, just staying really, really distracted from your own feelings.
298
Don't do that.
299
You're going to ruin your relationships.
300
You're going to lower your quality of life.
301
What are the good ways to do it?
302
Well, to begin with, go pick up heavy things and run around.
303
That's a great way to manage negative affect.
304
And here's the interesting point.
305
I have found in my research that people who can't stay in the gym
306
and who hate exercise and find real trouble with the discipline to stay in the gym, they almost always have below average intensity of negative affect.
307
They're not mad scientists.
308
What they are is cheerleaders, generally speaking, and God love them.
309
but that's what I find for the people who struggle with this.
310
The people who say, yeah, I love getting in the gym.
311
I get in the gym every day.
312
This is not hard for me.
313
That's because they notice that they feel better, even though they can't quite articulate what's happening with their bodies.
314
This is actually happening.
315
They're regulating stress hormones and they didn't know it.
316
So if you struggle with it, congratulations, you probably don't have a high negative affect issue, but you still got to stay in the gym because it's good for you.
317
Me, on the other hand, I'm going for an hour a day at 4.45 every day for the rest of my life.
318
And I hope that's a bunch more years.
319
That's step two, get physical.
320
When people ask me about happiness, I usually outline four areas of life, faith, family, friendship, and meaningful work.
321
But there's a fifth element that's also really important for well-being, something that I pay a lot of attention to myself, and that's your health and fitness.
322
Every morning, my happiness routine starts with a workout.
323
And it's not just because I'm obsessed with bigger biceps and abs, that chip has sailed.
324
Well, unhappiness and getting a better quality of life, exercise and nutrition actually will do more for your well-being than most people imagine.
325
That's why I love the Pump Club app.
326
It's actually not about hacks and trends that promise a lot but don't deliver very much as we all know.
327
The app, which was built by Arnold Schwarzenegger, is called the Positive Corner of the Internet because it brings people together to become healthier,
328
fitter, and create better habits and a more joyful life.
329
As a listener of Office Hours, you can get 50% off the monthly price and get an annual membership for just $79.
330
That's just a little more than $6 per month for your health.
331
Visit thepumpclub.com and use the code OFFICEHOURS at checkout.
332
That's the type of investment that you want to make in your future.
333
The next step, well, since we call that last step Get Physical, Step three is get metaphysical.
334
And I learned this one from my extensive work with His Holiness, the Dalai Lama.
335
Those of you who followed my work for a long time know for the past 13 years now, I've been working quite closely with His Holiness.
336
And I go every year to Dharamsala in the Himalayan foothills where His Holiness has His monastery.
337
And we've done a lot of programs together.
338
We've written together on a future episode of this show.
339
I think a series of episodes on this show.
340
We're going to show you content from one of my last interactions with him.
341
So we'll do probably four episodes in a row where you'll meet the Dalai Lama and hear the conversations that we've had, which are very deep and very meaningful.
342
But in one of my first trips, I asked him about how he starts his day.
343
I'm really interested in how people in different walks of life actually structure the day, how their discipline works.
344
He gets up super early, earlier than me, like 3.30 in the morning.
345
He pedals on his bike.
346
He has a bike.
347
He has an exercise bike.
348
I mean, he's got to stay in shape too.
349
And then his metaphysical experience starts with analytical meditation.
350
Now, I know when you think meditation as a Westerner, you're probably thinking about single point meditation where you're trying to focus, trying to focus.
351
And for most people, that are early in the morning, if they're doing that, even if you exercise first, you're going to fall asleep, you're going to feel really groggy.
352
Analytical meditation in Tibetan Buddhism is much like what Roman Catholics call mental prayer.
353
And what it is, is you're contemplating a little passage in scripture or a saying or something wise and thinking about it,
354
deeply, deeply thinking about what it means to you in your life.
355
That's how the Dalai Lama starts.
356
A couple of hours of that after his exercise.
357
I thought to myself, yeah, that's really good because what do we need?
358
We need body and soul.
359
This is to manage your negative affect, to increase your happiness, and to make yourself more productive for the course of the day.
360
This is a really good idea.
361
I adopted that myself.
362
Now, I'm a Catholic and it's really important to me.
363
So what do I do?
364
After I exercise for an hour, by this point it's 5.45 in the morning, I go and I take a shower and by about 6.10, I'm in the car because I go to church.
365
I go to mass every day.
366
When I'm on the road and there isn't a church nearby, there's not a 630 mass.
367
I pray an ancient, venerable Catholic meditation called the rosary,
368
which is a series of repeated prayers over contemplation of certain mysteries in the life of Jesus.
369
It's great.
370
That's 25 minutes in the mass.
371
The daily mass is 25 minutes.
372
The rosary takes about 25 minutes.
373
And that's that metaphysical state where I'm calibrating the work of the soul.
374
I could also tell you actually what's probably going on the hippocampus of the brain, because there's brain science that accompanies all of the metaphysics,
375
all of the spiritual work.
376
Of course, these two things work together.
377
The net net result is I'm ready to work when I'm done.
378
And I'm a lot less on edge as a result of that, because I've done those two things together.
379
I've worked my body.
380
I've worked my mind.
381
I've worked my soul.
382
I've worked my heart.
383
And that's done at seven.
384
That's part three.
385
Now, you're not Catholic and you're not a meditator, you can still do this.
386
You find your way.
387
Some people will talk about this by journaling for 20 minutes or half an hour.
388
Doing something that's contemplative, that's what you need.
389
Something that's calm, that's focused, that's centering, that's highly metacognitive, where you're thinking about thinking.
390
That's what you actually need.
391
That's what your brain needs.
392
Why?
393
Because when you're in a naturally high level of negative of emotional affect,
394
you need to pay attention to that, to manage that.
395
You need to be in an active posture of managing your limbic system so your limbic system isn't managing you.
396
That's what I'm doing when I'm in mass or when I'm praying my rosary.
397
That's what the Dalai Lama is doing in analytical meditation.
398
That's what you can do using any of these metacognitive techniques from journaling to prayer to any form of meditation
399
that you like.
400
find something that you get really good at.
401
And that my friends is step three, getting metaphysical.
402
There's a lot of research behind, uh, in the neuroscience and benefits.
403
Let me drop some of that stuff in the, in the, in the show notes as well for meditation, even by the way, among completely inexperienced meditators,
404
a lot of people beat themselves up.
405
It's like, I'm terrible meditator.
406
You're really going to judge yourself on that.
407
Even for very short periods, it significantly lowers negative effect because of the metacognitive effects that we're talking about here.
408
Really good study.
409
That's in behavioral brain research from 2019.
410
I'll drop that in the show notes that gives you treatment and control experiments that actually how that works.
411
Interestingly, one of the neural effects that we see in studies of the brain are that people who are more depressed,
412
they have lower hippocampal volume.
413
And what we find is that both exercise and meditation,
414
people who are exercisers over the long period and people who are meditators over the long haul, they actually have higher hippocampal volume.
415
In other words, this is neurophysiologically protective.
416
This induces changes, biological changes to the brain, almost certainly.
417
Okay.
418
Now, one thing you might have noticed is I haven't said anything about psychostimulants.
419
I don't use any imagination on that.
420
I mean, coffee.
421
I haven't had any coffee yet.
422
You might say to yourself, okay, sure, sure, buddy, I'll get up at 4.30 in the morning, but I'm hitting the espresso machine first.
423
That's my first stop, right?
424
No, I don't recommend that.
425
I actually strongly recommend against doing that.
426
And I know it makes it harder, but trust me, When you get used to this, you're going to love the results of what we do.
427
Now, I'm not one of those guys who just doesn't hear about coffee.
428
On the contrary, I grew up in Seattle.
429
And I was a kid in middle school when there was one Starbucks.
430
I'm talking about the 70s, 1978.
431
It was near my house, near enough to my house.
432
I could walk there because I didn't have a driver's license, obviously.
433
And I would walk down to the first Starbucks.
434
And I've been drinking Starbucks dark roast coffee since I was 14 years old, 13 years old.
435
Yeah, man, I've got a grizzled adrenal system.
436
Yeah, a little respect here.
437
I've been doing that for the longest time.
438
And that's one of the reasons I love dark roast coffee, because Starbucks coffee was traditionally like super, super like burnt.
439
It doesn't taste burnt to me.
440
You could introduce something called Indonesian ashes and I would buy it and I would drink it because I love that stuff.
441
So yeah, I love coffee for sure, but I don't drink it when I first wake up.
442
And there's a whole bunch of reasons for that.
443
As a matter of fact, I don't have my first cup of coffee until 7.30 in the morning.
444
Sounds early.
445
Not if you're waking up at 4.30.
446
I don't drink it for the first three hours.
447
And there's a lot of research that talks about why that might be the case.
448
Now, if you watch a lot of other fitness and biology-based kind of shows on this, you know that caffeine works by blocking adenosine receptors.
449
Adenosine is an inhibitory neurochemical.
450
What it does is it kind of, your brain is always in a state of homeostasis between excitatory and inhibitory neuromodulators or neurotransmitters.
451
And what they're doing is pepping you up and calming you down such
452
that you're not too up or too down all day long.
453
And they're always up and they're always on and off.
454
And one of the ones that keeps you groggy or makes you calmer and groggier is adenosine.
455
When you wake up in the morning, there's a lot of circulating adenosine in your brain.
456
It's one of the reasons that you still feel groggy.
457
Now, how does caffeine work?
458
Caffeine works by going in the little sockets that adenosine is ideally suited for because the molecule is shaped the same way.
459
And when it does that, adenosine can't get into the receptor.
460
And so it can't make you groggy.
461
So when caffeine, which very quickly crosses the blood-brain barrier and goes into the receptors.
462
For adenosine, the adenosine has no place to go.
463
And that's why you feel peppy from the coffee.
464
The problem is that if you leave, and this is one of the theories, this is like everything else in neuroscience, this is a highly contested theory.
465
But I find it compelling nonetheless.
466
So take it as you will.
467
These are, by the way, if you're keeping track, these are A2A adenosine receptors.
468
There's a number of different kinds.
469
The problem is that when you block all the adenosine receptors, when there's a lot of adenosine that's circulating in your brain first thing in the morning, the adenosine is going to keep circulating in your brain.
470
When inevitably you metabolize the caffeine, usually at two or three in the afternoon, because it takes a while, there's a half-life for the caffeine,
471
all the adenosine is going to go into the receptors at the same time and it's going to give you a crash.
472
That's one of the explanations that people often give for the caffeine crash, for the coffee crash, or the energy crash that you get in early afternoon.
473
If you wait until you've cleared the adenosine, naturally, you don't get the crash.
474
That's the theory.
475
I've tested it out.
476
It completely works for me.
477
You try it.
478
Delay your caffeine consumption.
479
But more than that, it actually helps mood.
480
A2A adenosine receptors are pretty interesting because you find that people with high stress,
481
high negative affect, they tend to have a lot of A2A receptors.
482
It's one of the reasons that that coffee blocking those receptors makes them feel so much better.
483
But you'll want to do it when you're not going to get a whole bunch of adenosine coming in behind it.
484
Because if you drink your coffee too early and you get the crash in the afternoon, there's a lot of adenosine going into the receptors at two or three in the afternoon,
485
you're going to feel really crummy and your high negative affect is going to come back in a rush.
486
If you're a naturally high negative affect person like me, you get the point that I'm trying to make.
487
So wait, wait, wait.
488
And I like waiting in three hours.
489
It's a really good feeling because I'm not trying to wake myself up.
490
On the contrary, I'm trying to use caffeine to focus.
491
This is where it gets really good.
492
That's step four, the magic bean at 7.30.
493
Now my day is really, really starting at 7.30 in the morning.
494
And you might say, well, when do you eat breakfast?
495
That's when I eat breakfast.
496
And that's when I'm eating my first very high protein meal.
497
I keep a very high protein diet because I want to be able to
498
have a relatively efficient level of muscle protein synthesis, which means I need to eat a much higher protein diet than I would have
499
when I was 50 or 40 or 30.
500
Um, when you can, I mean, you can have a piece of beef jerky and build muscle when you're 20 for Pete's sake, but now you have to eat a lot more protein because your,
501
your body is less efficient at doing that.
502
So I try to eat between 175 and 200 grams of protein a day.
503
My natural body weight is 170 pounds.
504
and I'm trying to stay at that, you know, one gram per pound of body weight or a little bit above.
505
And that's why I start a little margin for error on that.
506
And that means that I'm going to have to eat high protein meals starting absolutely first thing of the day.
507
So my first meal actually does two things for me
508
and that's I eat it just as I'm making my coffee at 7 30 in the morning.
509
And this is step five.
510
I call this tryptophan time.
511
Now I know when you've heard of tryptophan, tryptophan is the thing you get in the turkey, right?
512
I'm not eating a turkey dinner for breakfast, trust me.
513
I'm weird, but I'm not that weird.
514
And that's gross.
515
I eat Greek unflavored nonfat Greek yogurt, which I put a scoop of whey protein into,
516
and then I mix it up with walnuts, which are really good for you, and berries, which have a low glycemic index, and they're really high in antioxidants.
517
So I usually blackberries, blueberries, I like strawberries.
518
And sometimes Sometimes I'll put in a little bit of stevia to make it a little bit sweeter, but that's real high in tryptophan.
519
And I'm usually getting about 60 grams of protein for breakfast with a very, very good nutritional profile.
520
It's low in carbohydrate.
521
It's relatively low in fat as well.
522
And it makes me feel great.
523
It keeps me full all through the morning and fueled up.
524
And I got my first 60 grams of protein out of the way.
525
I'm not hungry until noon or 1230 when I have my next very protein-rich meal, which is generally speaking cottage cheese,
526
chicken, vegetables, or something like that.
527
And I do eat a lot of vegetables to make sure
528
that I get a proper amount of all the other micronutrients that the vegetables are going to bring.
529
So I usually eat five, seven, even nine servings of vegetables a day.
530
I guess I would count the berries in that to start the day as well.
531
Now, one source of protein that's not good for this, by the way, is collagen.
532
Collagen protein is very low in tryptophan.
533
Why am I talking about tryptophan?
534
Because tryptophan actually has a nice effect on your neurochemistry.
535
Most notably, that high tryptophan diet actually will increase the amount of serotonin in your brain, which makes you feel calmer, which is good for your negative affect.
536
And so you eat 60 grams of protein in Greek yogurt, and you're going to say, I think I can face the world.
537
I'm not quite sure why.
538
That's why.
539
Tryptophan, serotonin, calm, and it's better.
540
There's a great paper on this that I'd like you to read if you're wondering about some of these issues.
541
And just for laughs, I'm going to tell you that here's the title of the paper.
542
This is why I love academia.
543
Here's the title of the paper.
544
the bovine protein alpha lactobumin increases the plasma ratio of tryptophan to the other large neutral amino acids
545
and in vulnerable subjects raises brain serotonin activity reduces cortisol concentration
546
and improves mood under stress that's not the article that's the
547
title anyway um it'll go in the show notes go read it okay
548
so where are we that's step five is is tryptophan
549
and man at this point 7 45 in the morning
550
and i'm ready to rock and roll i'm ready to face the I mean, I'm set up, my negative affect is managed,
551
my focus and creativity are really working great.
552
One of the wonderful things about the caffeine that I've ingested, and I'm not embarrassed to tell you that I've probably,
553
at this point, I'm in the middle of about 20 ounces of Starbucks dark roast coffee.
554
I like French roast because it's the most burnt.
555
Is that what that's doing is just vacuuming dopamine into my prefrontal cortex.
556
Most of you know that dopamine is a neuromodulator that's implicated in a lot of different things.
557
Anticipation of reward, for example, wanting, learning, liking, but also creativity and focus.
558
I'm ready to go, and my job is creative stuff.
559
I have to prepare this podcast.
560
I write my column.
561
I'm always working on a book.
562
I'm preparing my lectures for the university.
563
I need creative focus, and I need big ideas.
564
And what I'm coming out of the shoot with in the next two hours is my absolute best work.
565
I promise you that this setup of what I've done about Brahma Muhurta
566
and the hardcore exercise and the metaphysics and then the coffee
567
and the tryptophan
568
and altogether what this is adding up to is the perfect neurochemical milieu where I can do this work
569
that I wouldn't be able to do otherwise.
570
Now, what I've noticed is that a lot of people waste this time.
571
They waste this time by checking email and reading the paper.
572
And it's kind of like, you know, before a dog wants to get into its bed and go to sleep, it kind of circles the bed and circles the bed like 90 times.
573
Don't do that.
574
Don't waste your neurochemistry.
575
Don't waste the dopamine in your prefrontal cortex.
576
You've got to be good to go.
577
Leave all that stuff aside.
578
Don't take any Zoom meetings, friends.
579
Don't take any phone calls.
580
look at your phone once every hour there's nothing good coming in don't read the paper yet go
581
when i do that i can actually get two hours of super high quality creative work
582
and about four hours total of creative work
583
and i can get a lot done i can get more done between eight o'clock
584
and noon with this setup i mean and this requires
585
that nobody bug me and that nobody bug you this is sacred time for you.
586
I can get more done in
587
that time than I would have been able to do when I was a younger man in three days.
588
I'm like superhuman because of the way this whole thing is set up.
589
I'm in the flow.
590
I'm in the flow for the rest of the day.
591
And the neuroscientific benefits of this really are related to what Csikszentmihalyi, the great social psychologist, we call the flow state.
592
I'll throw something on the flow state into the show notes as well.
593
I've got a nice paper here in Horizons of Psychology called the experience of flow and subjective well-being in music students, which I like an awful lot.
594
But you got to set yourself up neurochemically to be in the flow.
595
And part of that is making sure you've managed your negative affect, your high levels of negative affect.
596
This is my morning protocol, my friends.
597
I hope this is useful to you.
598
Does it sound insane?
599
All right, try it.
600
And then experiment on yourself.
601
This is the result of my experiments.
602
you need the result of your experiments.
603
Tell me how you're altering it.
604
Tell me how you're doing it differently.
605
Put it in the show, put it under in the comments on any platform you're looking on this.
606
I'm going to be reading those comments and I want to see what's working for you, what's not working for you, what works better for you, how you interpret the research differently than I do,
607
any objections that you have to this.
608
But if all of this is new for you, use this as a template.
609
You'll see in the show notes that this is all kind of laid out.
610
If you're missing it, you don't have to rewind and watch the whole show again, but you might want to.
611
Hope that's useful.
612
It's a good way for me to start this day.
613
It's how I'm starting tomorrow too, and every day.
614
Let's go to some audience questions.
615
Love it.
616
I've got a couple of really interesting ones.
617
One that came in over YouTube.
618
This is Skeltona, Skeltona, Skeltona1.
619
Interesting question.
620
How do we stay compassionate while protecting ourselves?
621
This is based on something I've done in previous episodes.
622
I'm talking an awful lot about how this is, that the art of happiness is not just about trying to get happier.
623
The real art of happiness is making other people happier, lifting other people up.
624
But in so doing, good question, Skelton Na.
625
One, how do you stay compassionate toward others while still protecting yourself?
626
Now, the way to do this is by understanding the difference between empathy and compassion.
627
Empathy is a very overused emotion.
628
It really is about feeling somebody else's pain.
629
We valorize that a lot because feelings are such a big deal, man.
630
That's how I feel.
631
As a matter of fact, a lot of reasons that people can't follow this protocol I've talked about here is
632
because they're comfy between the sheets at 4.30 in the morning.
633
They don't feel like getting up.
634
Win the day, man.
635
All of us, we should be doing that.
636
And one of the ways that we can do
637
that is by being a little bit skeptical about the overused emotion of empathy.
638
I'm not against empathy.
639
I just think it's incomplete.
640
What I like is compassion.
641
Compassion and empathy are not the same thing.
642
Compassion is an algorithm that contains empathy.
643
It starts with an understanding of what somebody is suffering.
644
Number two is enough feeling of that person's pain for you to deepen your understanding and want to act, but not too much because you don't want to be paralyzed.
645
The third is understanding what to do.
646
And the fourth is having the conviction and the courage to do it.
647
And a lot of the time, compassion is flinty hard.
648
It's something that people don't want.
649
I had three teenagers that I raised, and they made it all the way into their 20s, and they're having their own kids now, and they're struggling with their own toddlers,
650
which is just awesome to watch them struggle.
651
And I say, I'm so sympathetic.
652
I'm almost saying things like, oh, I'm sorry.
653
His diaper exploded on the plane.
654
I'm so sorry.
655
And, you know, I don't think he's possessed by Satan.
656
It's great.
657
I'm having so much shot in front of it.
658
Anyway, I digress.
659
The point is, when I had teenage kids, it was very important to be compassionate and not just empathetic.
660
If you just are empathetic and your kids are doing something they shouldn't be doing, it's bad for them.
661
You're a bad parent.
662
Furthermore, I wouldn't be able to protect myself emotionally.
663
There's an old saying that you're never happier than your unhappiest child.
664
That's bad parenting.
665
Nobody wants an unhappy mother.
666
Nobody wants an unhappy father.
667
Your job is to take care of yourself and give your kids what they actually need.
668
So, skeltonah1, compassion, not empathy.
669
Next question.
670
This is from Eduardo Soria of 638, also on YouTube.
671
A couple of good YouTube questions today.
672
Is there a direct relation between anger and lack of happiness?
673
Yes, yes, there is.
674
And this gets back to what we've talked about with respect to the limbic system and positive and negative emotionality.
675
The four negative emotions are fear, anger, disgust, and sadness.
676
So anger is, you know, implicates the amygdala, part of the limbic system.
677
It's part of your fight or flight response.
678
Fight is anger.
679
Flight is generally associated with fear.
680
Same basic setup, different kinds of reactions.
681
And these are negative emotions.
682
Now, negative emotions, don't forget, these are an indication that something isn't right and you need to react.
683
So thank God for your amygdala and thank God for these negative emotions.
684
You would have been dead a thousand times over were it not for these negative emotions to be sure, but they're not pleasant because they're not supposed to be.
685
So you're not feeling happy when you're angry.
686
That's just a fact.
687
Also, when you're disgusted, sad, or afraid, you're not feeling happy and you're not supposed to feel happy under the circumstances.
688
That's perfect and fine.
689
The problem is when anger is dysregulated, when anger is disequilibrated, when you've got a hair trigger, when you're having to apologize because of your bad temper,
690
or when you simply are not just too fast to anger, but you're angry too much of the time and for too long.
691
There's interesting research that suggests that people who have this hair trigger and they're angry all the time, they literally have a bigger amygdala than the average person,
692
physically bigger amygdala, and you need to take care of that.
693
You need to actually self-regulate.
694
That doesn't mean you need to go on some sort of pharmaceutical regimen, but it means you need metacognitive techniques, count to 10, count to 100, prayer, journaling, meditation.
695
There's a lot of different ways to therapy.
696
There's a lot of different ways to deal with this.
697
But the whole point is that don't worry about your negative emotionality until it becomes dysregulated, at which point you don't want to eliminate it.
698
You want to learn to manage it using many of the techniques that we've talked about right here.
699
Thanks for that question.
700
It's terrific.
701
And we've come to the end of the episode.
702
Ah, the mad scientist morning protocol.
703
Hope it's useful for you.
704
And I can't wait to see your feedback on this as well.
705
Let me know your thoughts at officehours at arthurbrooks.com or leave your comments on any platform that you're using.
706
We will see them.
707
Like and subscribe on Spotify, YouTube, and Apple.
708
Leave a comment.
709
Even if it's negative, we want to see it.
710
We want to make the show as good as it can possibly be.
711
Follow me on Instagram.
712
Arthur C.
713
Brooks is my handle on LinkedIn, all the other platforms.
714
And don't forget to order The Happiness Files, as my latest book, Insights on Work and Life.
715
I hope you have a wonderful week.
716
Tell your friends we need another couple million or billion people watching this so that we can change the world together.
717
Join me in being a happiness teacher.
718
And until next time, stay happy.
📺 Aynı Kanal
✨ Video Öner
B21
93 cümleler
6 Morning Habits That Will Make You Happier
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
B21
259 cümleler
Talk Back: Why Arguing With Yourself Can Help You Flourish
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B21
412 cümleler
Sad to Savage Podcast S4 E7: How to Stop Snoozing Your Alarm & How to Start Waking Up Earlier
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
B21
174 cümleler
Just listen or shadow me. English-speaking practice & motivation.
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
B21
781 cümleler
How Do I Reverse Brain Rot?
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B11
171 cümleler
I Tried Andrew Huberman's Morning Routine for 30 Days
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
B22
48 cümleler
Wake Up at 5AM | Robin Sharma and Lewis Howes
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B2136 cümleler
Are you making yourself miserable?
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
B2504 cümleler
POSITIVE MORNING MOTIVATION - Start Your Day Right! Listen Every Day - Jim Rohn Motivation
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B22
294 cümleler
how to become the best version of yourself (in 6 weeks) | Becoming Her Ep.1
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B23
164 cümleler
stop 'getting through' life. start living it.
Business EnglishUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B21
105 cümleler
3am Dopamine based Morning Routine as a Doctor in Rural UK
Business EnglishDaily ConversationUniversity Students
Bu dersin kelimeleri ve konuşma notları
Bu B2 seviyesindeki konuşma dersi “My 6-Step Morning Protocol for a Better Day” videosuna dayanıyor. Bu videoda gölgeleme çalışması için 718 cümle ve 8662 kelime var. Konuşma bölümü 44:20 sürüyor. Konuşmacı hızlı konuşuyor, dakikada yaklaşık 195 kelime; bu yüzden birbirine bağlanan ve zayıflayan sesler duyacaksınız. Kelimelerin %83’i İngilizcede en sık kullanılan 3.000 kelime arasında; geri kalanına başlamadan önce bakmakta fayda var.
Bu videodaki önemli kelimeler
Videodaki en ileri düzey 15 kelime, telaffuzu ve anlamıyla:
| Kelime | Telaffuz | Anlam |
|---|---|---|
| adenosine isim | /əˈdɛnəˌsin/ | adenozin |
| emotion isim | /ɪˈməʊ.ʃən/ | duygu, his |
| caffeine isim | /ˈkæfiːn/ | kafein |
| receptor isim | /ɹɪˈsɛp.tə/ | reseptör, almaç |
| empathy isim | /ˈɛmpəθi/ | empati |
| compassion isim | /kəmˈpæʃ.ən/ | şefkat |
| intensity isim | /ɪnˈtɛnsɪti/ | yoğunluk |
| beep isim | /biːp/ | düt |
| gram isim | /ˈɡɹæm/ | gram |
| amygdala isim | /əˈmɪɡ.də.lə/ | amigdala |
| cardio isim | /ˈkɑɹ.di.oʊ/ | kardiyo |
| behavioral sıfat | /bɪˈheɪvjəɹəl/ | davranışsal |
| roast fiil | /ɹoʊst/ | kavurmak |
| vegetable isim | /ˈvɛd͡ʒ.tə.bəl/ | sebze, zerzevat |
| dopamine isim | /ˈdoʊ.pəˌmin/ | dopamin |
Duyacağınız deyimsel fiiller
| Kelime | Telaffuz | Anlam |
|---|---|---|
| get up fiil | kalkmak | |
| wake up fiil | /ˌweɪk ˈʌp/ | uyanmak |
| get off fiil | inmek | |
| put together fiil | birleştirmek, bir araya getirmek | |
| figure out fiil | açığa çıkarmak | |
| get over fiil | üstesinden gelmek, yenmek | |
| look forward to fiil | iple çekmek, dört gözle beklemek | |
| run over fiil | çiğnemek |
Tekrar etmeye değer cümleler
Videodan, günlük konuşmada yeniden kullanabileceğiniz kısa ve tam cümleler:
- Is morning hard for you?
- That's my first stop, right?
- No, I don't recommend that.
- Why am I talking about tryptophan?
- How do we stay compassionate while protecting ourselves?
Bu videodaki dil bilgisi
Konuşmacının en çok kullandığı yapılar, videodaki sözcüklerin aynısıyla:
| Yapı | Videoda |
|---|---|
| Present perfect continuous have/has been + -ing — önceden başlayıp hâlâ süren bir eylem | I've been working · I've been drinking · I've been doing |
| Present perfect have/has + fiilin üçüncü hâli — geçmişte olan ama şimdi de önemli olan bir eylem | you've slept · you've gotten · I've learned |
| Edilgen yapı be + fiilin üçüncü hâli — kimin yaptığı değil, ne olduğu önemli | is intended · is based · be left |
| İlgi cümlecikleri who / which + cümle — bir kişi ya da şey hakkında ek bilgi | people who are · probiotics which are · affect, which is |
Dikkat edilecek telaffuzlar
Konuşmacı I'm, you're, I've gibi kısaltılmış biçimleri 320 kez kullanıyor. Bunları duyduğunuz gibi kısa söyleyin.
- “th” sesleri: empathy /ˈɛmpəθi/, empathetic /ˌɛmpəˈθɛtɪk/, synthesis /ˈsɪnθəsɪs/
- “sh” ve “zh” sesleri: emotion /ɪˈməʊ.ʃən/, meditation /mɛdɪˈteɪʃn̩/, compassion /kəmˈpæʃ.ən/, compassionate /kəmˈpæʃənət/, musician /mjuˈzɪʃən/
- Uzun kelimeler — vurguyu doğru yere koyun: adenosine /əˈdɛnəˌsin/, tryptophan /ˈtɹɪptə(ʊ)fæn/, intensity /ɪnˈtɛnsɪti/, amygdala /əˈmɪɡ.də.lə/, metaphysical /ˌmɛtəˈfɪzɪkəl/
Türkçe konuşanların zorlandığı sesler:
- /w/ — dudaklar yuvarlak, /v/ değil: workout /ˈwɝk.aʊ̯t/, awake /əˈweɪk/
- Kelime başındaki ünsüz kümesi — araya ünlü eklemeyin: tryptophan /ˈtɹɪptə(ʊ)fæn/, protocol /ˈpɹoʊtəˌkɑl/, gram /ˈɡɹæm/, groggy /ˈɡɹɑ.ɡi/, creativity /kri.eɪˈtɪv.ᵻ.ti/
- /æ/ — “e”den daha açık: tryptophan /ˈtɹɪptə(ʊ)fæn/, caffeine /ˈkæfiːn/, compassion /kəmˈpæʃ.ən/, gram /ˈɡɹæm/, compassionate /kəmˈpæʃənət/
Bu videoyla nasıl çalışılır
- Videonun tamamını konuşmadan bir kez dinleyin ve bilmediğiniz kelimeleri not edin.
- 0,75× hızla başlayın, cümle cümle tekrar edin ve kolaylaşınca normal hıza dönün.
- Kendinizi kaydedin ve orijinaliyle karşılaştırın; adenosine, emotion, caffeine gibi kelimelere özellikle dikkat edin.
Gölgeleme Tekniği Nedir?
Gölgeleme, başlangıçta profesyonel tercüman eğitimi için geliştirilen ve çok dilli Dr. Alexander Arguelles tarafından popüler hale getirilen, bilim destekli bir dil öğrenme tekniğidir. Yöntem basit ama güçlüdür: ana dili İngilizce olan bir sesi dinler ve hemen yüksek sesle tekrar edersiniz — konuşmacıyı 1-2 saniye gecikmeyle takip eden bir gölge gibi. Pasif dinleme veya dilbilgisi alıştırmalarının aksine, gölgeleme beyninizi ve ağız kaslarınızı gerçek konuşma kalıplarını eşzamanlı olarak işlemeye ve yeniden üretmeye zorlar. Araştırmalar, telaffuz doğruluğu, tonlama, ritim, bağlı konuşma, dinleme anlama ve konuşma akıcılığını önemli ölçüde geliştirdiğini göstermektedir — bu da onu IELTS Konuşma hazırlığı ve gerçek dünya İngilizce iletişimi için en etkili yöntemlerden biri yapar.