シャドーイング練習: 3 Things That Feel Like Progress But Aren't - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ
レッスンを作成中...
1
right today i want to talk about three things
2
that feel like learning they feel productive you do them you finish you tick them off
3
and you feel like you've put the work in
4
and a lot of the time you haven't
5
or at least not nearly as much as it felt like at the time
6
So this video is for you if you've been putting the hours in
7
and you don't feel like you've moved much in the last year in terms of progressing with your English.
8
And if that's you, I'd say the problem almost certainly isn't effort.
9
It's that some of the hours you're counting as study time aren't really doing very much.
10
So today I want to show you the three biggest culprits that I can think of right now.
11
I should say up front
12
that I'm going to have a go at the couple of things that I personally make money from.
13
So in a way, I'm arguing against my own interests here.
14
All right.
15
First one, then don't just watch YouTube.
16
Now, I'm on YouTube.
17
I make videos for English learners on YouTube.
18
I would quite like you to watch my YouTube videos.
19
So this is a strange place to start.
20
But here we are.
21
um the thing i've noticed about youtube is youtube's job is not to improve your english
22
despite there being just endless resources for you to learn english
23
when you go on there its primary job is to keep you on the platform that's it
24
that that's the whole business model right as much time as
25
i can get this individual on this platform the more ads i can give this person to watch
26
and therefore we get more money.
27
And the way you keep somebody on a platform is by giving them things that are easy to watch,
28
nice to look at and rewarding within about 11 seconds.
29
So the algorithm watches what you enjoy,
30
learns it very quickly and then just keeps handing you more of that stuff, which means you end up watching what you want to watch,
31
not what you need to watch.
32
And those two things can sit very, very far apart.
33
What you want is the video where you understand everything, you feel clever.
34
What you need is probably the one where you follow about 70 to 80 percent, have to concentrate properly on the rest,
35
and you come away a bit tired.
36
The algorithm them will never recommend you the tiring one over and over again.
37
Tiring is bad for business for YouTube, if you think about it.
38
To think of a metaphor for this, for watching the easy stuff, it's a bit like getting fully kitted out for the gym.
39
You think, oh, I'm going to go exercise.
40
And you get all the new stuff to go to the gym, new trainers, the shorts, the water bottle, the little towel, you know,
41
the lot walking all the way there in maybe the cold weather.
42
So you've done some sort of challenging things in a way to get to the gym.
43
And then standing in the lobby, you just watch everyone sweat it out through the glass panel and you don't actually do any exercise.
44
I feel like that is what watching English lessons on YouTube can be like.
45
There are some really, really good ones that make you get active as well.
46
But the vast majority, vast, vast majority are ones that metaphor that going to the gym and just staring at people watching.
47
And I want to be clear, I'm not I'm not telling you to quit YouTube.
48
That'd be terrible for my business.
49
Watching English is genuinely useful.
50
And it's how a lot of people stay in love with the language.
51
what I'm saying though is
52
if you do do this of course um what I'm saying
53
is stop treating the video as the whole meal it's it's the ingredients we could say
54
so you watch the thing that's fine but then do something with it
55
if it is a vocabulary video then write those phrases down actually use them in a sentence
56
and think strategically am I actually going to use these phrases of those ones I probably won't use those
57
so I'll use those ones and then go deep with those phrases
58
so learn the nuance learn the context learn the register learn how a native actually uses those phrases
59
and then you'll be confident enough to actually give it a go
60
when those phrases arise
61
or the opportunity to use those phrases arise I mean you
62
could get active at the end of the video in many ways.
63
It's just, I don't think it's good to just treat the video as the end of the process.
64
Because if you watch something and then immediately click to the next thing, you haven't really studied.
65
You've been entertained in English, which isn't nothing, but it isn't the same.
66
And after two years of it, you'll wonder why you're still where you started.
67
okay so that is the first one i'm gonna say try not to do.
68
Try not to just treat YouTube as the be all and end all, right?
69
Have it as the beginning point of your language learning for the day.
70
Okay, the second point I want to make is me having a go at my own industry.
71
So conversation classes, they are brilliant.
72
I've led a lot of them.
73
I love them personally, if I'm learning Spanish, I want to have conversation classes.
74
And I love them.
75
I think most people should have them.
76
But there is a trap sitting inside them.
77
And I've watched a lot of people walk straight into it, myself included, when learning Spanish.
78
And the trap is that you slowly start to believe it's the teacher's job to make you fluent, right?
79
It happens quietly and
80
and you know you book your class it's on thursday you
81
you turn up you have a lovely hour your teacher is
82
encouraging uh you leave feeling good about yourself well done me
83
and then for the next six days there's this little voice
84
in the back of your head going it's fine i've got my class I'm on track
85
so you you occasionally skip the daily exercise
86
that you may have done before
87
because you didn't have those classes um you you might not do
88
so much reading and you don't do the speaking practice either
89
because you know I've got the conversation class
90
because you've already paid you've already paid for the progress and it's scheduled it's scheduled on Thursday and unless
91
you're wealthy enough to have a one-on-one lesson every single day, which, you know, most of us aren't,
92
that means you're doing about one hour a week, maybe two hours a week of English,
93
you know, the lessons, and you're expecting that one to two hours to carry you through to the next level.
94
And even if you are doing that, even if you've got the money and the time
95
and you're in there five days a week with this poor
96
teacher joking i'm sure the teacher would be thrilled to have a lesson with an individual every day um
97
but there's a second problem underneath that um there are whole skills
98
that just quietly never come up in a conversation class
99
because your teacher most most teachers understandably um they feel like
100
they need to give you what you want you know you're paying, you've had a long day at work,
101
you'd like a nice chat about your weekend and a few corrections at the end.
102
So that's what happens.
103
And it's lovely, but it's the exact same problem as the YouTube problem I mentioned before,
104
but just with a human face on it and you're paying for it, right?
105
Because if you think about it, it's actually pretty rare as an adult to have a teacher
106
who will make you do the thing you need to do rather than the thing you fancy doing.
107
Nobody's forcing you in this.
108
There's no exam in September unless you're doing an IELTS or something like that.
109
There's no parents evening where you'll be told off by your parents and your teacher.
110
Nobody's ringing your mum to tell you off, right?
111
You've got a friendly person who wants to enjoy the hour with you
112
and a version of yourself who'd quite like to avoid the uncomfortable bit.
113
Those two people get on very, very well.
114
And between them, they can keep you at the exact same level for years while everyone's just having a nice time.
115
So the way I'd put it, if you want to have conversation classes is the lesson is almost like the exam.
116
It's not the revision.
117
It's where you find out what's working and what isn't.
118
The actual learning happens in all the quiet,
119
unglamorous bits in between when nobody's watching and nobody's charging you for it.
120
And if you want to get more out of the class that you might be paying for, I'd turn up with something specific in mind, not can we just have a chat,
121
something you've been struggling with.
122
Think about that and focus on that for your lessons.
123
Make your teacher's job easier and they'll give you the difficult version, which is the one you need, right?
124
Right, so I've now told you that the two most popular ways to study English are both a bit of a trap,
125
which is a rude thing to do to you, isn't it?
126
But let me explain what's actually going on underneath, because it's the same thing both times.
127
If you didn't know, maybe you do, but you know, we're this far in, I'm going to keep going.
128
Learning has two modes, consuming and creating.
129
You need both.
130
And generally, you consume before you can create.
131
That bit's fine and normal.
132
But almost everybody I meet is wildly overweight on the consuming side with their language learning.
133
So, you know, podcasts, videos, Netflix, articles, more podcasts, this podcast,
134
another podcast, hours and hours of stuff going in and then almost nothing back out.
135
And that's the whole problem with the two things I've just moaned about, though they fail in slightly different ways.
136
YouTube is pure consuming.
137
It goes in, nothing comes out.
138
And it feels like study because English is arriving in your brain at speed
139
and it's all jazzed up to look like this is all good for me.
140
The class though, the class is different
141
and I want to be fair to teachers out there including myself
142
because a good one will have you talking far more than
143
they do that's the actual job right of a conversation class
144
but you can be doing plenty of talking
145
and still not be stretched what usually happens is you get
146
comfortable same friendly person same friendly small talk same handful of subjects all built out of language you already own.
147
So you're creating, absolutely yes you are creating, you're just creating the things you could already say a year ago
148
and not getting pushed anywhere near the bits you find genuinely hard.
149
I am oversimplifying things to some degree
150
but there is a definite valid point in both of these things that I'm telling you.
151
So yes one of them barely asks you to produce anything
152
and the other asks you in only the comfortable places right i want to
153
double down on the fact
154
that classes aren't really the villain in this story the problem is
155
that we hand it the entire job one hour a week
156
and we quietly expect
157
that hour to do all the heavy lifting the the stretching
158
the correcting the new vocabulary the the confidence the accent the lot No single hour can carry all of that,
159
no matter how good that teacher is.
160
Just one hour or two hours a week at your level,
161
intermediate and above, you're not going to get further with just one to two sessions of English practice a week.
162
Sorry to say.
163
I feel like with any skill to really progress, you need to be doing it three times a week.
164
It doesn't have to be three hours, but minimum, at minimum, three sessions a week.
165
So a class works brilliantly sitting on top of a pile of your own stuff that you do.
166
It just can't do very much when it is the pile, right?
167
Now I want to talk about the active versus passive thing, because a lot of people think that active means speaking.
168
it can
169
but it doesn't require you to be with a person it
170
doesn't need to be in a class with an audience
171
or any um it doesn't require courage whatsoever really active just
172
means your brain is putting words together into sentences instead of receiving sentences that are already finished
173
so it could be just thinking right genuinely just thinking in english on the bus
174
that counts just completing a full sentence in your head from
175
start to finish it i mean it could be thinking it
176
could be writing writing is a really good way to get active it could be talking to yourself
177
while you're cooking why not right it could be complaining to a chat bot why your internet provider absolutely sucks.
178
It could be a language partner or your teacher
179
or small talk in a shop or a voice note to a friend or explaining your job to somebody at a party.
180
The list goes on, right?
181
My point here is that a lot of people think, oh, I've got to pay for a speaking class to be able to get active with my English.
182
There are many ways to do it.
183
Those are a few.
184
So I'd say consuming English feels like learning, but creating with English is the actual learning.
185
It's the bit where you're actually in the gym and you're sweating it out.
186
Right.
187
And the rule I'd give you is a small one, but it changes things quite substantially if you actually do it.
188
So consume, then create.
189
Consume, then create.
190
Don't consume, then consume, then consume.
191
After the podcast, say something out loud.
192
After the article, write three sentences.
193
After the video, use four of the expressions.
194
It doesn't need to be long.
195
It just needs to be fairly immediate and it needs to happen every single time.
196
so quickly um don't let the algorithm on youtube pick your homework also i should add
197
if you're using short form like youtube shorts instagram reels tiktoks you're asking for for trouble there
198
because what they're doing is over stimulating you with dopamine
199
so you're getting addicted to the learning videos
200
and really you're not giving yourself enough time to process the actual education
201
and you're certainly going from consumption to consumption to consumption when
202
if you are able to watch a very highly stimulating and rewarding TikTok and then,
203
you know, at the end of it, not just swipe up and go to the next one.
204
You're a better person than me.
205
I would struggle to stop that video and then do the active thing and then come back and do the active thing.
206
If you can, that's good.
207
It's like bite sized learning.
208
but yeah don't let your algorithm pick your homework
209
because it's optimizing for your attention and not for your english
210
and don't hand the whole job to one class
211
or one conversation class a week
212
because no single hour can carry all of the progress needed
213
and underneath both watch the balance between what's going in
214
and what's coming out because for most people out there there is far too much going in
215
and almost nothing coming back so those are the three
216
and the thing about all of them is
217
that they're free you don't need anyone else for any of it you can close this app right now
218
and um yeah start doing every single one of those three this afternoon and if you can do that honestly,
219
off you go with my blessing.
220
If you've got the patience
221
and the willpower to keep finding new ways to get active
222
with your English on a hot sticky Tuesday in August when work's been rubbish and nobody's checking in on you,
223
then you're genuinely a brilliant learner and you'll be absolutely fine.
224
But if you're sat there going,
225
yes, lovely, but I cannot see myself inventing active exercises learning exercises for myself every day
226
and if you know deep down that your motivation turns up in bursts
227
and then vanishes for three weeks at a time
228
which is true for most people by the way including myself
229
um then i really think you should try my academy at least try it okay
230
because those tips i've mentioned aren't separate from what i've built they're the reason it exists.
231
I built the whole thing around exactly this problem,
232
which is that people know they should be getting active and they don't because they're tired and it's boring and nobody's
233
asked them to, right?
234
So inside my academy, everything runs on this loop.
235
You take something in, you do something with it, you find out what went wrong, then you use it with actual human beings and my point being is
236
that you don't have to design any of these exercises each day you just show up
237
and the active bit happens to you
238
and you can try the whole thing for a whole month for five pounds
239
if it clicks with you you'll you'll know within that month and if it doesn't you've Spent about what?
240
The amount you get from a coffee and a pastry, if you're lucky.
241
My coffee the other day was close to five pounds.
242
So, yes, I do want to stress, though, it's ideally a place for upper intermediate to lower advanced learners.
243
But there are plenty of B1 and C2 learners who get a lot out of it, too. So, yeah, that's it.
244
I know you might be thinking, I like to listen to this podcast for my listening practice.
245
Why has he spent that episode telling me what I should be doing
246
and then encouraging me to sign up to his paid membership?
247
And I obviously get that.
248
I really do.
249
But from my side of things, I want to see you improve your English.
250
Like, yes, I do need paying members to be able to afford my life.
251
but I've taught one-to-one lessons created a bunch of self-study courses held immersion courses in person
252
and really the the quickest and best solution
253
that I am seeing people get results from is my academy
254
so I think
255
if you are wanting to improve your English then give the trial a go to see
256
if you like it and I'll say one more thing um this trial I'm offering it actually it actually impacts me negatively.
257
Like I do a lot of individual marking for each student.
258
So if I was paid five pounds for a month of that, I think it's like I'm getting paid one pound an hour.
259
Yeah, not much.
260
So the trial is very much putting me out.
261
And if you stay, it's because you found a community that is helping you improve your English faster. So
262
it's a win-win for both of us there we have it
263
i'll um be releasing a conversational interview with emma from pronunciation
264
with emma next week it was good fun recording it
265
so yeah look out for that one for your listening practice
266
but yeah if you're interested in the trial to the academy head to the britishenglishpodcast.com slash academy trial
267
or click the link in the show notes description box
268
or comments all right you've been listening to me charlie the host of the british english podcast see you next time
📺 同じチャンネル
B2How to Sound Band 9 When Talking About Social Media - IELTS Speaking Part 3
British Accent, en-GBIELTS Prep+2
B21
How to Leave a Conversation in British English Without Sounding Rude
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
B2IELTS Ep 2 - Talking about travel in British English
British Accent, en-GBIELTS Prep+3
B2How Good Is YOUR Part 2 IELTS Answer? Compare It to These
British Accent, en-GBIELTS Prep+3
B27
IELTS Speaking Part 1: Don’t Make These Mistakes When Talking About Your Home
British Accent, en-GBIELTS Prep+4
B21
Want Better English? Stop Trying So Hard!
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
B2Do Brits Really Respect Their Mothers?
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+2
B12
How Brits ACTUALLY Catch Up at the Pub | 5 Real British English Phrases
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
C11
What Brits Say When Ordering at the Pub | Scene 2
British Accent, en-GBDaily Conversation+1
B2A Big Life Update… | Learn English with My Story
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
✨ おすすめ動画
B2661 文
669. How to Learn English
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
B2392 文
If you’re ambitious but lazy, watch this
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+2
B11
81 文
Stop Waiting for Big Results—Do This Instead | American English Listening Practice Podcast USA
University StudentsBusiness English+2
B22
132 文
give me 7 minutes, I’ll change the way you speak on YouTube
University StudentsBusiness English+2
B21
105 文
Video
University StudentsBusiness English+2
B21
389 文
How To Go From B1 To B2 Level of English (What ACTUALLY Works)
High School StudentsUniversity Students+3
B21
159 文
This 10-Minute Video Will Save You 10,000 Hours Of Language Learning
University StudentsBusiness English+2
B23
113 文
After 20 Years Teaching English, Here’s the Truth
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
B26
217 文
Why People Still Don’t Understand Your English (Even If You're Fluent)
British Accent, en-GBUniversity Students+3
B23
150 文
How to Think in English (Stop Translating in Your Head)
British Accent, en-GBHigh School Students+4
B2117 文
POV: you built a $1 million youtube business with no expertise
University StudentsBusiness English+2
B21
412 文
You're procrastinating 80% of your time (here's how I fixed it)
University StudentsBusiness English+2
このレッスンについて
「3 Things That Feel Like Progress But Aren't」を使って、シャドーイングで英語を練習しましょう。
毎日15〜30分の練習で、IELTSスピーキングへの自信と実践的な英会話力が身につきます。
シャドーイングとは？英語上達に効果的な理由
シャドーイング（Shadowing）は、もともとプロの通訳者養成プログラムで開発された言語学習法で、多言語習得者として知られるDr. Alexander Arguelles によって広く普及されました。方法はシンプルですが非常に効果的：ネイティブスピーカーの英語を聞きながら、1〜2秒の遅延で声に出してすぐに繰り返す——まるで「影（shadow）」のように話者を追いかけます。文法ドリルや受動的なリスニングと異なり、シャドーイングは脳と口の筋肉が同時にリアルタイムで英語を処理・再現することを強制します。研究により、発音精度、抑揚、リズム、連音、リスニング力、そして会話の流暢さが大幅に向上することが確認されています。IELTSスピーキング対策や自然な英語コミュニケーションを目指す方に特におすすめです。