शैडोइंग अभ्यास: Love is a skill, not a feeling | Alain de Botton: Full Interview - वीडियो के साथ अंग्रेजी बोलना सीखें
अभ्यास मोड चुनें
हर मोड पूरी स्क्रीन का अभ्यास कक्ष खोलता है।
817 वाक्य
यदि वाक्य बहुत छोटे या लंबे हों, तो समायोजित करने के लिए Edit पर क्लिक करें।
1
My name is Alain de Botton.
2
I'm a philosopher, psychotherapist, and founder of the School of Life.
3
Chapter 1.
4
Our Destructive Romantic Culture We know in theory that love matters a lot.
5
It's in every pop song.
6
It's the center of most religions.
7
We sometimes lose sight of what that word actually means.
8
It's really about connection and it is one of the most beautiful and one of the most complicated of all phenomena.
9
Even though we think we've been around on this planet for a long time trying to figure things out,
10
I'd say we were still at the dawn collectively of making sense of this phenomenon we call love
11
and it's no surprise that most people will go to their deathbeds thinking, not quite sure I figured
12
that side of life out at least many of us will
13
still be grappling with some of the complexities of love by the time time runs out on us.
14
The most central kind of love that people are obsessed about, concerned about, is romantic love.
15
That is the intimate connection between two human beings who have a sexual contact.
16
It's worth saying that there are other forms of love.
17
We can love our children, we can love animals, we can love ideas, we can love tables, chairs, clouds, all sorts of things.
18
We are capable of many forms of love but I'd say
19
that when people sing about love and
20
when they cry about love it tends to be the love
21
of one very special person we tend to call our soulmate, our partner.
22
It used to be the case that when people found partners they would do so according to fairly pragmatic considerations.
23
In most nations, in most parts of the world, for most of history, couples were formed not by the individuals themselves but by the wider society,
24
families, the village, the court.
25
There were, if you like, dynastic marriages.
26
You would get together with somebody because they had a plough
27
and you had an ox and it seemed like a good match.
28
Or you were the Duke of Brabant, and they were the princess of Naples.
29
And that was seen as a wonderful union.
30
So you got together for reasons that were nothing to do with emotional compatibility.
31
There were a lot of tears, there was sadness, there was loneliness, but it didn't seem to matter because relationships were seen to be about something else.
32
There was then a momentous change that occurs in towards the end of the 18th century, starting in Britain, France, Germany,
33
parts of Italy, a revolution in feeling that we now know as Romanticism.
34
And one of the central tenets of Romanticism is
35
that each individual should be left to decide on their partner by the movements of their own heart.
36
They should be left to decide for themselves.
37
It's a beautiful idea.
38
It's a very liberating idea.
39
It should make a lot of sense and we have been in the romantic age now for, you know, 200 years, perhaps shorter,
40
perhaps a little longer, that kind of time period.
41
And let's put it plainly, it's been a disaster.
42
We are not any appreciably happier now in a romantic culture
43
than we were in a dynastic culture where marriages were made for dynastic reasons.
44
Why?
45
Because we have failed collectively to focus with enough intent on the difficulties
46
that couples will have when they choose each other according to the movements of their own heart.
47
Look, I think a really key prejudice of the romantic worldview is that if love is working well,
48
it should be following instinct.
49
There's been an enormous veneration, almost a worship of instinct.
50
Love is described as a special feeling, not in a set of ideas, not a sense of rationally observable principles, but a feeling.
51
You either have the feeling or you don't.
52
You must be guided by your feeling.
53
There's even a prejudice against language.
54
You know, true lovers shouldn't talk too much.
55
They should just feel the fluttering of their own hearts.
56
That's why music has a huge prestige, higher than, you know, philosophy.
57
When we're in love, we don't want to read philosophical tracks.
58
We want to hear love songs.
59
That is to do with our sense
60
that emotion should be guiding us not reason reason is the
61
enemy in the romantic world view of truly happy relationships
62
if you follow reason that's cold it may be calculating it's unromantic
63
and you know there are so many things that are considered unromantic
64
and i would love to train our audience
65
that every time something seems unromantic question it is it truly unromantic
66
if we define romanticism as the pursuit of a workable relationship.
67
On that basis, is it unromantic to talk about money?
68
Is it unromantic to think long and hard about childhood patterns of psychological development?
69
Is it anti -romantic to spend a lot of time thinking about families and friends and compatibility at that level?
70
All these things, in my view, belong to a truly adequate way of surveying whether a couple should be together.
71
But I'm also aware that nowadays these things are considered very unromantic.
72
To live in a romantic culture means to live in a culture
73
that has a set of ideas about how good couples should form.
74
They should be formed by instinct, that everybody has a soulmate, that you'll recognize your soulmate by a special fluttery feeling, that you shouldn't be asked to account for that feeling.
75
You should simply go for it and marry in Vegas in two weeks
76
if that's what seizes you and
77
that you should be able to communicate deeply with your partner without using language through that special medium of the heart, through the silence.
78
Also that you shouldn't criticize your partner, that true partners should love each other for who they really are,
79
which means no desire to grow or change.
80
You just accept someone.
81
Couples in romantic culture will sometimes complain, you're trying to change me.
82
And this is seen as really offensive.
83
It's like, what?
84
You know, you complain to your friends.
85
My partner's trying to change me.
86
Oh, what an awful person.
87
It must be awful.
88
You must get out immediately.
89
If you went to an ancient Greek, if you went to Athens in 400 BC and you said to an ancient Greek, what is love and where is the role of criticism,
90
they would say love is a process of education.
91
It's the education of emotion
92
and lovers should of course be able to pick each other up for things
93
that they don't spot in one another
94
and they should be trying to develop into the best version
95
of themselves rather than simply staying stuck in an admiration for
96
who they are today the whole process should be dynamic become
97
who you could be not worship who you happen to be right now all of this sounds very strange in romantic culture,
98
which is why relationships are so difficult in our time.
99
Let's remember that a person's life satisfaction is determined by up to around 70 % by the quality of their personal relationships.
100
A Martian hearing that statistic, visiting planet Earth, would think, well, clearly Earthlings, given the enormous role of love, will be spending 70 % of their money
101
and 70 % of their educational time working out how on earth this business of love works.
102
Is that true?
103
No. We spend hardly any time rationally thinking about it.
104
None of us are made to sit through classes in attachment theory, classes in apology, classes in listening, classes in communication.
105
No, we're, you know, physics is important.
106
Geography is important.
107
Don't get me wrong.
108
But is there no time for this given its role in our lives?
109
Do we really want to leave this to chance?
110
And the answer is yes. And why?
111
Because we live in a romantic culture that sees something adverse in planning
112
and thinking and reflecting too hard on the business of love.
113
It's very deleterious and it's been a serious problem for humanity.
114
One of the most powerful disseminators of romantic culture is art.
115
And by art, I mean all the leading artistic media.
116
Film, definitely.
117
You know, if you were learning about love from films, you would be very confused.
118
And that's why many of us are confused because films, and I include that television shows and other, you know, narrative forms, these things are hugely misleading.
119
They simply do not show what a real relationship is like.
120
I mean, probably you can count on one hand that the number of films that have accurately shown love.
121
I think one of the most accurate representations of love is Richard Linklater's before trilogy
122
which ended up with before midnight it's a wonderful reckoning really with the real complexities of love
123
but you know most films are not
124
that most films are blithe are superficial are not modest enough
125
in showing us what's really going on between couples it's also animated through music
126
and music constantly um gives us little miniature stories about you know how love works
127
and you know the music is terrific but it's not accurate to what's going on and it presses the wrong buttons.
128
Poetry, no one really reads poetry nowadays.
129
If they did, the problem exists in poetry too.
130
So we have so much media around, and yet we're still so much strangers to ourselves.
131
I would say that the single greatest, most misleading disseminator of ideas on love is culture and art.
132
The problem is very heavily located there.
133
chapter two lessons on love from psychotherapy i think we need
134
to split history into phases the phase of the dynastic relationship where people would get together for dynastic
135
and financial and family reasons. That ended.
136
That's behind us.
137
Then we moved into the romantic age, and that caused a lot of problems, and it lasted 250 years or so.
138
We need to draw a line under that.
139
We need to move towards something that I call the therapeutic age, the age of the therapeutic relationship.
140
What on earth is a therapeutic relationship.
141
Let me try and explain.
142
A therapeutic relationship begins with the insights of psychotherapy.
143
Psychotherapy has been with us for 120 years or so.
144
It is the most sophisticated understanding of how human beings function emotionally.
145
It's based on the insights of Sigmund Freud and all those who come after him.
146
It is not going away.
147
Some people say, oh that's isn't that old hat
148
that wasn't freud proved wrong sorry no he wasn't i mean
149
of course many many areas of freudian thought are wrong
150
but the fundamental insight that we have an unconscious
151
that how we love as adults was shaped by our childhoods
152
that there are defenses that we put in place to protect ourselves as children
153
that cause difficulties for us as adults this is indisputably true
154
and that's not going anywhere all of us are the result of a very slow
155
and long process of emotional education that took place between the ages of 0 and 10.
156
This is extremely hard to perceive.
157
Most of us are like, I never went to an emotional education school.
158
I just grew up.
159
You know, my parents lived in Idaho or Milton Keynes or Frankfurt or Yokohama.
160
There's no sense that we've learned anything in particular.
161
But my goodness, we have.
162
All of us reach adulthood having learned very complicated languages of love and relationships,
163
languages that tell us whether a human being can be trusted, whether we are worth something, whether communication is good, what happens when somebody is angry, what happens when we are shy,
164
what happens when we sulk, how do we tell someone something important?
165
All of these things will have been imbibed in us.
166
Let me give you a metaphor.
167
Very few of us, I'd say none of us, remember what it was like to learn language, to learn to speak.
168
And yet most of us know how to speak, but it went in invisibly.
169
While we were in the kitchen drawing buttercups or in the garden doing handstands,
170
all of us will have learned incredibly complex patterns of language, of grammar.
171
We have learned about the pluperfect, we have learned about the subjunctive without even knowing such things exist.
172
We'll have learned tens of thousands of words and all sorts of ways of expressing ourselves and without knowing a thing.
173
I want to say that a similar process goes on at the level of emotional language.
174
In the same way as we learn a grammatical language, we learn an emotional language.
175
As I say, a language about trust, about kindness, about communication, about self -worth,
176
about dialogue, etc. All these things that we take with us into adulthood, we learned, and we learned from one place in particular,
177
our families of origin, our mother and our father, or whoever our caregivers happen to be.
178
These people are immensely, immensely important in shaping our emotional grammar in the same way as they shaped our linguistic grammar.
179
I mean, anyone who's had a parent with a regional accent of one kind or another will know that that sticks.
180
You will pick up that regional accent from your parents and you will, it might stick with you all of your life.
181
Same thing goes on with, as it were, the regional accents of emotional intelligence.
182
You may speak a regional accent where every man is extremely frightening, or every woman has a tendency towards alcoholism,
183
or everyone who is kind is also slightly sadistic, or everyone who you depend on is also depressed.
184
And these are all very, very difficult languages to have been exposed to and to pick up on.
185
Many of us, sadly, have come through childhood with suboptimal language acquisition, emotional acquisition, if you like.
186
And we take that into adulthood unconsciously.
187
We have no clue where we've come from.
188
And because we don't know where we've come from, we don't know how to plot a sensible course.
189
And I'm going to mention something very important, which is attachment theory.
190
One of the most useful tools for working out why relationships work
191
and why they don't was formulated by two researchers of near genus, John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth,
192
two researchers working in the United Kingdom in the 1950s.
193
They had been very marked by a phenomenon that took place in the 40s during the Second World War.
194
In the Second World War, huge numbers of children were separated from their parents at a young age
195
and were sent to families outside London to escape the German bombing of British cities.
196
What researchers soon realized was that this was a catastrophe for the children.
197
The children began to exhibit extremely distressed behavior.
198
They would wet the bed, they would get very angry, they would not be able to eat.
199
They would be in states of almost cataclysmic meltdown.
200
Why was this?
201
Materially, they were well looked after.
202
Psychologically, emotionally, they were bereft.
203
And researchers, this is one of the most moving stories in the history of the Second World War, researchers realized that if this carried on,
204
this would do more damage for the next generation than any number of war dead.
205
That the risks of German bombs were actually smaller than the risks of ruptured emotional attachment.
206
And on that basis, these psychological researchers wrote to the Ministry of Defense
207
and the Home Office and got the children transferred back into their homes in the cities of the United Kingdom.
208
And thereby a great tragedy was averted so that after the height of the crisis,
209
children were returned to their birth families and looked after again by their closest figures of attachment.
210
Why are we talking about this?
211
Because this was the birth of attachment theory.
212
From watching how children were around their close caregivers in childhood, it was discovered that all of us are,
213
in a sense, tethered to a story that we first have in childhood around our caregivers.
214
And the researchers in attachment theory began to divide human beings into categories,
215
highlighting their characteristic ways of behaving around relationships.
216
To give you a few of the categories, they identified something that we now know as avoidant attachment.
217
Avoidant attachment is a way of relating to a troublesome and troubling caregiver, who in some ways lets you down.
218
And by the way, caregivers, it's estimated let down around 50 % of children.
219
So around half of the population of any nation you care to mention has got children wandering around with attachment wounds.
220
It's an important statistic to bear in mind when you go on a date.
221
You know, 50 % chance you've got somebody with an attachment wound.
222
That's not the end of the story.
223
We can work with attachment wounds, but we need to know that those attachment wounds are there.
224
That's how we're going to try and solve the problem, by knowing that the problem is there.
225
An avoidantly attached person is somebody who responds to the insecurities in their relationship with their caregiver by essentially moving away,
226
by pushing away intimacy.
227
The classic sentence that an avoidantly attached person will say to their partner after a few beautiful weeks, a few mini breaks, a few lovely times, they'll go.
228
This is feeling a bit too intense.
229
And then they will withdraw in some way.
230
They'll start causing a problem.
231
They'll say, oh, I need to spend the weekend with my friends or my mother really wants to see me.
232
They'll pull away from a relationship because it's getting too intense.
233
And really what they mean is, I'm so afraid of love.
234
And the way that I deal with my fear of love is to pull away.
235
So that is avoidant attachment.
236
And we see it all over the place.
237
Some of your viewers will be avoidantly attached.
238
Some of your viewers will have recognized this with a partner that they had.
239
It's not that the avoidantly attached person doesn't want love.
240
They want love.
241
They're just terrified of it.
242
Why are they terrified of it?
243
Because it didn't go well for them in childhood.
244
And this is something that we need to really keep in mind.
245
We've got a culture that thinks that everybody's looking for love.
246
They're not.
247
They're ostensibly looking for love, but they're just as busy pushing love away
248
when it comes running away from it and making sure it doesn't succeed why because love is a threat
249
if you've grown up in an environment where love was not possible where relationships between caregivers
250
and children were not safe you will have defended yourself against the risks of disappointment you will have insulated yourself and then
251
when love comes your way in adulthood what you will do
252
against your knowledge against your conscious knowledge is make sure
253
that love does not succeed you will sabotage your own chances
254
of a successful relationship let me give you a metaphor imagine
255
that you've grown up in a prison camp you were never fed
256
or the diet was very meager you didn't have much food
257
and then suddenly one day the gates of prison gates are opened
258
and you get to go to a banquet and you get to eat anything you like.
259
And what might be the response?
260
Panic.
261
You might make yourself sick.
262
You might try and eat the food.
263
It might even kill you or threaten to kill you. Because why?
264
You cannot metabolize the goodness on offer.
265
Because you have learned to function with an emotionally restricted diet.
266
An emotionally restricted diet where you've made do with very little.
267
And so when there's a lot suddenly on offer, you panic and you think this is too intense in the same way
268
that somebody who has been going with almost no food will think it's far too intense to eat a rich chocolate cake.
269
And sometimes healthy love is like a rich chocolate cake, which we cannot bear.
270
And some of your viewers will know the phenomenon whereby you offer somebody love.
271
You love them.
272
You feel that you want to give them a good life.
273
You want to be a good partner to them.
274
And they sort of accept it.
275
And then suddenly they run away.
276
They put dynamite under it.
277
This is a very common occurrence.
278
What's going on?
279
It's not that it's too bad.
280
It's too good.
281
And for some of us who had to get used to very poor relationships, the greatest threat is not a bad relationship.
282
That's fine.
283
It's a good relationship.
284
And you get patterns, horrific patterns, where people have had an unstable and violent father, let's say, an uncaring and absent mother.
285
And you think that these people are going to, you know, get to adulthood and they're really going to make it up for themselves.
286
They're going to find the love they yearn for and they're going to make it work and what happens to them?
287
Maybe a nice lover comes along.
288
Someone kind offers them, you know, a home as it were, you know, an emotional home and Maybe at the beginning they can bear it.
289
It's easier at the beginning.
290
You can bear it at the beginning But then the problem starts setting in
291
when it really becomes clear that love may work that's
292
when the traumatized attachment lover gets their sticks of dynamite out
293
and starts to blow the foundations of the house up so that they can return to the suffering that feels more familiar.
294
What you need to understand is that in love, we don't look for what will make us happy.
295
Absolutely not.
296
We look for what feels familiar.
297
For some people, happiness and familiarity are one.
298
But for many of us, they are not.
299
For many of us, what is most familiar is a sense of not being loved properly, a sense of not being sure where we stand, a sense that someone may threaten us,
300
a sense that someone may abandon us.
301
That is our true home.
302
And if that's our true home, we will be guided with a kind of honing instinct to re -find that,
303
which is why you find again and again that the children of alcoholics do not head for sober partners.
304
They head for people who are struggling with alcohol.
305
Why the offspring of violent parents do not head for calm and kind partners.
306
They head for people who are struggling with their temper.
307
Now, what do we do about this?
308
One optimistic story is to be found in the work of Sigmund Freud, who in many ways, everything returns to him.
309
He observed something which he called the repetition compulsion.
310
He observed that human beings are not guided by a search for pleasure, they are guided by a search to repeat patterns, a repetition compulsion often of pain.
311
And he proposed an ingenious and I think optimistic answer to this.
312
He argued that what many of us are doing when we repeat traumatic experiences, for example, getting back together with a violent partner or an alcoholic partner,
313
what we're really doing there is not simply suffering ad infinitum for no reason.
314
What we're trying to do is to master a challenge that we couldn't master in childhood, and we're trying to master it with the resources of adulthood.
315
In other words, we're trying to get the alcoholic partner to stop drinking in a way
316
that we couldn't when we were children.
317
We're trying to get the distance, emotionally uncommunicative partner to start to talk in the way that our mother or father didn't.
318
We're trying to make it up in the present.
319
And Freud realized that for many of us, we wouldn't find the kind of excitement
320
that we need until we locate a partner who does suggest
321
that they suffer from the very problem that our crucial caregivers suffered from, until we find a little bit of an echo of the original suffering.
322
But the optimistic story is perhaps we can work with them in the relationship to heal the pain.
323
It's a very optimistic story.
324
It works sometimes, and sometimes we may need to cut our losses.
325
You know, love is not always about keeping going.
326
Love is also sometimes about knowing that you are in a pattern and that pattern is driving you to destruction.
327
And when that happens, it's also important to know how to save yourself from sure destruction.
328
Chapter 3.
329
The Playbook for a Successful Relationship.
330
First of all, the idea of a playbook sounds strange.
331
The idea of a playbook that you need to create to get in a relationship sounds really odd.
332
You think, I don't need a playbook.
333
I just need to head on in there get a dating app
334
and off i go and a nice new pair of clothes
335
but isn't it interesting and wouldn't it be lovely to have a playbook
336
that would be trying to guide you to acquire the knowledge um
337
that you need for love so the idea
338
that love is a skill rather than an emotion is a strange one
339
but i think an absolutely essential one in the world view that i'm positing You know, if somebody said, I'm going to climb Mount Everest or K2,
340
you would say, okay, how have you prepared for this?
341
And you'd be expecting them to show up with ropes, with training programs, with oxygen, with specially prepared packs of food.
342
You can get the metaphor.
343
We walk into the mountain of love without sufficient preparation and equipment.
344
And then we're surprised that we routinely tumble off the mountain and we blame the other person.
345
We say we didn't match the right person.
346
We haven't found our person.
347
We go back on the dating app and we go ever further to try and find the right person.
348
Don't get me wrong, dating apps have their role.
349
Sometimes we need to scan and see who's out there
350
and find a person who halfway meets us where we want to be.
351
But once you've found a more or less suitable person, that's when the work begins.
352
And the work is to turn a stranger into somebody that you can understand and who can understand you without bottling it,
353
without panicking, without throwing them in the bin, without saying we can't work this out if after five weeks
354
and a pleasant mini break in Copenhagen we suddenly have a conflict.
355
No, the point is you need to stay where you are and try and figure it out.
356
But most people give up too soon, they say we can't possibly do this and they run for the hills, go back on the dating app
357
and find the next person with whom they will then try
358
out an equally unfulfilling attempt to match their heart with a stranger's.
359
What we need to do is to start to create right people rather than search for them.
360
And what does that mean to create a right person?
361
It means to work on yourself psychologically and therapeutically so
362
that you understand your script from childhood and do not simply play it out onto innocent person after innocent person.
363
That you take responsibility for the problems that you are bringing into a relationship.
364
At the School of Life, which I founded, an institution that is dedicated to emotional growth and development, we tell our people that when they're on a date with somebody,
365
among the first questions is to ask people playfully, how are you crazy?
366
What does that mean, how are you crazy?
367
Why is everybody crazy?
368
They're not necessarily crazy.
369
Well, all of us have stuff that we need to be on top of.
370
And if your person at dinner says to you, yeah, I get the question.
371
Yeah, I've got my crazy, and my crazy is this, my crazy is that, my father, my mother.
372
However, this is turning out to be a safe person.
373
If the person goes, how do you mean, I can't possibly answer that question, that's rude, you think I'm not right or imperfect, run for the hills, you know, drop it right there and then.
374
I'm exaggerating, but this is probably not a person you should be hanging out with
375
because none of us need or can have perfect partners.
376
But what we can have and must search for
377
and must try to become is people who know enough about
378
their patterns to be able to warn their prospective partners of what's going on and take averting action.
379
The beginning of therapeutic relationships is to know that two people,
380
when entering a couple, are not entering without a lot of history.
381
It is essential that couples learn as much as possible about
382
that history so that they are ready for the challenges and perplexities of love.
383
A therapeutic relationship requires that each partner get on top of their dynamics
384
that date back to childhood and are able to discuss them with relative grace, patience, and insight with their partner so that when problems arise,
385
and they will, they can adopt a therapeutic language.
386
It is therapeutic to say, for example, when there is a conflict, I hear your point of view.
387
It may not be mine but i hear
388
that it's yours it is not therapeutic to say you're wrong you're an idiot
389
and you're just like your mother
390
or indeed like your father this is not therapeutic i'm kidding
391
but i'm making a very serious point indeed we do not
392
tend to talk to each other in therapeutically informed language we
393
shout we scream we blame we shape -shift we don't take responsibility we do all sorts of things
394
that doom us in relationships then we stand back
395
and we say we're surprised We are a society that is obsessed with finding the right person without pausing to think, how do I become the right person?
396
How do I work on myself?
397
Understanding that cannot be done simply, and this is paradoxical, by being on your own.
398
This is another unbelievable mystery.
399
You can't understand yourself just by being with yourself.
400
You need other people.
401
Why is that?
402
It's like, why do you need a mirror to see the back of your head?
403
Because we don't have eyes there.
404
We need someone to help us to see the things that are really hard for us to see.
405
And psychotherapy gives us a forum in which we can come, tell the therapist about what's going on in our lives, explain what happened last Monday,
406
explain, you know, what happened when we took that trip to New York or Buffalo, wherever it is.
407
What happened?
408
And then slowly pattern recognition sets in.
409
The therapist is able to go, it's funny.
410
In that last relationship, you did this.
411
This new relationship, you're doing that.
412
And you mentioned that your parent did something that sounds kind of similar.
413
So I wonder what's going on.
414
And then slowly insight comes.
415
We start to put the pieces together.
416
We think I'm up to something, I'm doing something.
417
And that way is liberation.
418
We can start to break the unconscious stories that we're living.
419
Psychotherapy works with this concept known as defences or defense mechanisms.
420
In other words, these are tools that our minds adopt to try and shield themselves from accurate knowledge of their own workings.
421
This could sound really odd, like, why don't we just embrace self -knowledge with open arms?
422
Why do we need to run away from it?
423
The answer is that knowledge of ourselves is frightening.
424
It's really awful to have to learn certain things.
425
It may make us very anxious.
426
It may make us so sorrowful.
427
It may panic us.
428
And so we push away unwelcome information.
429
I think that we still perhaps can't quite bear how complicated we are.
430
You know, we're very squeamish creatures.
431
We don't like to sit with ourselves.
432
We don't like to sit with our emotions.
433
Self -knowledge remains an enormously elusive goal.
434
You know, I think it is the most important goal of life.
435
To understand oneself is literally the meaning of life.
436
The ancient Greeks knew this, you know, know thyself was the most important command in ancient Greek culture and philosophy.
437
Know thyself, most important thing you could do.
438
If you said nowadays, you know, in a conversation with friends or colleagues, you know, what's your goal?
439
Where are you trying to get to next year?
440
What are you, what are you trying to do? say, know thyself, people would go, that's a strange person there.
441
We don't know about this person, right?
442
It's not an acceptable goal.
443
We know that it's good to make money.
444
We know that it's good to travel to foreign countries to learn how to fry garlic and to learn salsa.
445
It's not particularly esteemed to know yourself.
446
And that's why we wander around strangers to ourselves and and therefore enormously confusing, and let's put it frankly, dangerous to other people.
447
Because a person who doesn't understand themselves, if confronted with their behavior will go, it wasn't me, I didn't do it, or I can't think, or ask me tomorrow,
448
they can't account for themselves.
449
They don't know why they do the stuff they do.
450
They will simply, in a relationship for example, bail out of a relationship going, it's getting too intense, and why?
451
They don't know, they don't understand what they themselves are doing even though, you know, they may have spent five years learning, you know, Spanish.
452
They may have taken an advanced degree in Japanese.
453
They may be, you know, very active in all sorts of ways.
454
They may have learned pottery.
455
They may be holding down a great job in marketing, something.
456
But the point is they will not have learned the really true constituents of emotional functioning
457
because they've been able to get away with it.
458
And part of the playbook of becoming a better lover is to dial down your defense mechanisms, to observe them.
459
A typical defense mechanism is to push responsibility onto other people, to say it's your fault.
460
For example, someone tries to tell you something about yourself.
461
Someone says, I think that you're a little bit this when that happens.
462
And rather than going, thank you, let me think about that, you go, why are you being rude?
463
Or this is not a good time for me.
464
Or I can't absorb this now.
465
In other words, you push away information that might have helped you not
466
because it's false but because it's difficult to absorb
467
and that's often what happens to us all of us all
468
of us are involved in defense mechanisms all of us can't
469
quite bear the full truth about ourselves it helps us to go to psychotherapy I know
470
that you know AI is you know delivers some aspects of
471
therapy it can be good at points the good thing about a real human being is
472
that they are not guided just by you They've got their own independent judgment
473
and also you're in a relationship with them and
474
that relationship is part of what heals you
475
Because the relationship with the therapist is a harbinger of the relationship
476
that you can then take out into the world A relationship of trust and mutual understanding.
477
This is something that AI is not going to be able to replace anytime soon So we need to understand ourselves.
478
We need to understand the past and then we need a certain spirit it.
479
One of the things that we need in that playbook of love is a good sense of humor.
480
That could sound superfluous, like what on earth, you know, why do we need a sense of humor?
481
Well, a sense of humor is a modesty about our capacity to understand anything.
482
And if we can signal to our partners that, you know, we're a little stupid, we don't get it, we don't have all the answers, that is a wonderful emollient,
483
it's a wonderful lubricant to love, because it just dials down the temperature.
484
If your partner is able to say, ah, I may not have gone to the this.
485
I may not be getting it.
486
That's brilliant.
487
And if they can make a little joke too, that's great.
488
You know, if two people can learn to see each other as idiots, but lovable idiots, that's a beautiful moment in love.
489
It could sound negative.
490
It's not.
491
It's not.
492
It's the most generous thing you can do.
493
We are two blind people helping each other to find a way forward.
494
If that's the spirit in which we can enter love, that is a spirit of generosity, a spirit of mutual forgiveness.
495
Too often we get on our high horses.
496
This is the way it is.
497
I know the answer.
498
This is what I think that is not a friend of love.
499
So we need, if you like, a modesty, a humorous modesty.
500
Let me give you another idea.
501
Another thing that we need in order to make love work is a certain degree of pessimism.
502
You know, optimism is the enemy of love.
503
If we think that we will have a perfect love story, a love story with no ruffles in it, with no kinks in it, no, it's not going to happen.
504
We need to accept that even a really good relationship has constant moments of crisis.
505
And that's okay.
506
The problem is not crisis.
507
The problem is how do we repair crises?
508
Can we repair them with forgiveness, with understanding, and most of all, with curiosity?
509
Can we get curious about why we had a bus stop?
510
Can we be searching for why our attachment patterns are not compatible?
511
Can we get interested in why we're difficult to love.
512
And that way will become easier to love.
513
So pessimism is not an enemy of love.
514
Knowing that there is no such thing as the right person actually helps you to find a good enough person.
515
You know, a few years ago, I wrote an essay that went viral.
516
I wrote it for the New York Times.
517
It was called Why You Will Marry the Wrong Person.
518
Why did that essay go viral?
519
I think it went viral because people all feel, sorry, let me correct that, not all people, but many,
520
many people feel that they have married the wrong person.
521
And they panic about this and they feel so ashamed.
522
So here's an essay in the New York Times that says, yeah, we're all gonna marry the wrong person.
523
And you know what?
524
It's okay.
525
You don't need to marry the right person.
526
You need to marry a good enough person.
527
You know, compatibility is not a precondition of love.
528
Compatibility is the fruit of love.
529
If we get together with someone and we find that there are differences, right?
530
They have one kind of attachment style, we have another.
531
They like golf, we like tennis.
532
They like the curtains to be green, we like the curtains to be yellow, whatever it is.
533
Too often in modern romantic dating culture, the answer is get out, just get out, find someone else,
534
find someone better and that's why all the technological tools are all about putting new people in front of you.
535
Of course, sometimes you need to find new people, but as much as finding new people, what you need to do is to learn to live with the people who are in front of you, with the people that you found.
536
Many of us have already found a good enough partner
537
and yet we throw them in the bin
538
because we are taught by romantic culture that we can always find a perfect person with whom it will click immediately.
539
And this is such a destructive idea.
540
If you think, you know what, the work starts here.
541
The work starts when you have a problem.
542
Then you roll up your sleeves and you think, okay, well, I know that I, you know, broadly think this person's a nice person.
543
Now we're going to work at making sure that it can work.
544
And so we're going to talk and we're going to take this problem apart.
545
We're going to become like engineers who've got a malfunctioning machine.
546
We're going to sort it out.
547
This sounds unromantic, doesn't it?
548
Imagine, imagine saying, in order to make my relationship work, every evening I've talked for an hour in really patient ways
549
you think oh my god go to vegas find someone easier well good luck to you maybe you'll find that person
550
but for some of us especially some of us who've come
551
through difficult relationships difficult relationships in our past we may need to go
552
and do that kind of excavation maybe that's fine i think
553
that a good enough person is someone who will engage with the business of working towards compatibility
554
that they won't assume that you are wrong just because there are problems.
555
They will know how to repair crises.
556
They will know how to be curious.
557
They will know how to listen.
558
They will know how to be patient.
559
That is compatible with all sorts of problems, sexual problems, relational problems, administrative problems, doesn't matter.
560
You can work through them.
561
So the wrong person is someone who stonewalls, who always blames you, who blanks out, who says, it's not my responsibility,
562
or, you know, it was easier with my ex, and why are you so difficult, et cetera.
563
These people are trouble because they are refusing the work of love.
564
So it doesn't matter if you have many, many difficulties.
565
That's okay.
566
The problem is your attitude to the difficulties.
567
And the solution is an attitude of indulgence, of curiosity, and of calm consideration of the flaws that unite us all.
568
We are all mad monkeys.
569
And so long as we've been kind towards the mad monkey in all of us, we'll be okay.
570
One of the real problems, and you know, there's simply no solution, but we need to accept that there's a real problem,
571
is how long it takes to work out who we are as lovers, as people interested in relationships, who we are.
572
It takes so long, and it takes especially long to try and change our patterns.
573
You know, if we are somebody who sabotages relationships every time that love comes along, how long is that going to take to unwind this?
574
Well, it takes insight, but then it takes, as it were, work, true work.
575
And sometimes people go to therapy for six sessions or 12 sessions and they go, I haven't changed.
576
Therapy doesn't work.
577
And let's come back to my earlier example about language.
578
Imagine that you decided middle age as an English speaker to pick up Korean or Finnish, and you went to six lessons and you tried to learn Finnish and Korean.
579
And by the end of six lessons, you could barely ask for, you know, barely say your own name or say hello.
580
And then you blamed it on the whole process.
581
And you said, I'm not learning this language.
582
It's rubbish.
583
People would say, you're being too impatient.
584
And I think that some of the same holds true for rewiring our emotional language.
585
We can't pick this up in six sessions of 50 minutes.
586
It takes a long time.
587
A pattern that was laid down over decades is going to take many, many years to figure it out.
588
It's, I mean, believe me, it's bad news.
589
I wish it weren't so.
590
Can we do anything in the meantime?
591
Yes, of course we can.
592
We can, you know, we can be learning and walking.
593
We don't to pause and just sit by the roadside.
594
We can be starting on the path of relationships.
595
We can be starting from a relatively young age, but we need to be doing the work alongside and we need to be able to at least do the first thing,
596
which is to say, I'm learning.
597
I'm a learner.
598
There's a real difference between someone who goes, I know it all, and someone who knows that they are still learning.
599
When Socrates, the ancient Greek philosopher, was asked why he was the wisest person in antiquity, he said, because I know what I don't know.
600
In other words, that the birth of true wisdom is associated with a knowledge of your ignorance.
601
I think that's the best way we can proceed also in relation to our love lives.
602
There are lots of questions that we could learn to ask ourselves
603
and our partners in order to try and find a better relationship.
604
One of them is this.
605
When I get close to you, how does that feel, right?
606
To open up a window onto some of the complexities that occur when somebody gets close.
607
If I love you, what part of you might worry, right?
608
That's a good question.
609
Does any part of you worry?
610
Another really useful question is, how do I respond when someone is trying to communicate something to me?
611
Do I stonewall or do I accept?
612
Am I able to pause and think the issue might be with me?
613
Or do I always have to go, I can't answer that.
614
It's the other person.
615
You're being unfair.
616
You're putting me under pressure.
617
What is your level of emotional dexterity?
618
So that's a good question to be asking yourself as well.
619
Also, one of the really good questions in any relationship is to say, how have I annoyed you?
620
How have I frustrated you?
621
You know, a lot of what happens between couples is there are things
622
that are bubbling away beneath the surface that people can't find the courage to say.
623
And because they can't say them, the problem doesn't improve.
624
The problem gets worse.
625
People can't have sex anymore.
626
A lot of the reason why people can't have sex, it's got nothing to do with sex, it's to do with the fact they feel disconnected and angry and misunderstood.
627
You can't have sex with someone who you feel misunderstood by or you feel furious with.
628
What helps desire is trust.
629
And the way to build up trust is to communicate and particularly communicate ruptures of trust.
630
So if you wanna have good sex, don't get a candle, don't go to a hotel, start to ask each other, have I annoyed you?
631
Is there something I've done that you'd like to tell me?
632
And you say this patiently, not in the middle of the night when you're stressed or maybe you've drunk too much, But when you're calm, when there's a sense of, you know, lightness and forgiveness,
633
use the right moment to ask the right question.
634
We're living in a world where therapeutic language and insights have spread for the first time far outside the consulting room.
635
There is mass adoption at a superficial level of therapeutic language.
636
And the area where we find this most obviously is social media and in particular Instagram, which is enormous.
637
It's an enormous force in the world, and it has brought up a generation, I'd say, to speak in pseudo or vaguely therapeutic terms.
638
I don't mean that as an insult.
639
Some of these insights have been fantastic.
640
People are now able to talk about, let's say, attachment theory.
641
You know, the mention of an avoidant attachment theory
642
or an anxious attachment theory in many circles now doesn't create the puzzlement that it was generating 15 years ago.
643
15 years ago, this was not common knowledge that was still in the university, in textbooks, and in the consulting room.
644
Now it's out in the world.
645
And the medium that has changed this, as I say, is social media.
646
What's the problem?
647
I'll tell you one of the problems.
648
One of the problems is whose fault it is.
649
The tone of a lot of social media posting blames the problem for the struggles in relationships fairly
650
and squarely on the partner, not on yourself.
651
There is an obsession with finding borderline people, narcissistic people, avoidance, anxious people out in the world.
652
And of course they exist.
653
But the tone is the problem.
654
The tone says, get out.
655
These are red flags and everybody that you're meeting, the reason why you haven't made a relationship work is because these people are unbalanced psychologically.
656
My answer is this.
657
If you are looking to find a person with no problems at all, with no psychological disturbances, good luck to you.
658
If you're looking to find somebody with no red flags, good luck to you.
659
Everybody has red flags.
660
That's part of what it means to be human.
661
That's the story of Genesis.
662
The story of Genesis is Adam and Eve had some red flags.
663
That's what it is to be human being, is somebody with a red flag.
664
So the problem is not the red flag, it's how you deal with it.
665
And this is what I worry that therapeutic culture on social media doesn't train us to do.
666
It doesn't train us for patience.
667
It doesn't train us to think we might be the problem.
668
It doesn't ask us to think what we've brought to the situation.
669
It doesn't create an atmosphere of forgiveness.
670
The reason is very simple.
671
Outrage sells.
672
It's more fun.
673
It feels more spirited.
674
It's punchier to say, that ex of yours, they're the avoidant.
675
They're crazy.
676
They're narcissistic.
677
It sounds better, and it leaves everybody happier.
678
But long -term, It's not the solution.
679
Chapter 4.
680
Overcoming status anxiety and loneliness.
681
You know, we mustn't forget that one of the sources of love
682
that is most important to us is not just interpersonal romantic love, but the love that you get from other people,
683
strangers, dependent on your standing in the community, your status.
684
You know, status is a really interesting feature of everybody's ambitions.
685
You know, why do we work so hard?
686
We work so hard not just for material rewards, we work hard in order to gain the esteem,
687
the respect, the regard of people whose good affections we rely on to feel good about ourselves.
688
If you said to somebody, you've got a choice.
689
Either we'll give you $10 million a year, but every time anyone sees your face, they'll go, oh my god, I hate that person, they're awful, I despise that person.
690
You could have that option, or we'll give you a minimum wage, absolute minimum, bare minimum to survive.
691
But every time anyone sees you, they'll go, oh my god, that person is amazing, it's just great, etc. We know which one we'd pick.
692
We know that we would pick the love and affection of the stranger
693
and the respect and esteem of our community way over simple material rewards.
694
Now, in our culture, the reason why most of us work
695
so hard and the reason why most of us are so interested in money has nothing to do with the money.
696
It's just that money is the chief conduit towards the love and respect that we stand to gain from our communities.
697
If you change the status system and what it's earned, you know, what you get status for, you will change the incentive structure.
698
There have been periods in history where the number one thing
699
you needed to do in order to have a high status was to worship God really intently.
700
And then if you're good at worshiping God, you'd be considered amazing.
701
And then people did that in droves, and that was considered very, very serious.
702
In other cultures, it was considered very serious to be a good hunter.
703
So people became more and more good at hunting.
704
And that was what you did.
705
And that was the route to getting status.
706
Nowadays, how do we know what the status system is based on?
707
We know it because of a very simple question that any stranger will ask us within normally 30 seconds of meeting us, what do you do?
708
And according to how you answer that question, people are either going to be really pleased to see you.
709
Oh, great, we must hang out.
710
Or they'll leave you alone by the peanuts and they don't want to know you.
711
We're living in a world of snobs.
712
A snob is really anyone who takes a small part of you
713
and comes to a global decision of what you're worth and how much love you're worth.
714
And that That is the reality, the brute reality of the way in which we live in society.
715
We will be judged ruthlessly by our careers, by what is on our business card.
716
And we will be given love, status love, not romantic love, but status love, maybe romantic love too,
717
that's another consideration, but generally status love according to how impressive we are in the field of careers.
718
It's why we work so hard, it's why we're so panicked about careers, and it's why there's such despair when careers don't work out.
719
We're losing not just materially, we're losing our sense of our good name in the eyes of society.
720
It's very brutal.
721
I think older societies, pre -modern societies...
722
had some built -in safety valves to try and protect people from
723
that unitary sense that what you are worth is what you do, that you are what you do.
724
It's always been somewhere there in the system because we are material creatures.
725
We do depend on material goods.
726
So it's always been that as part of the mix.
727
But other cultures have softened this in a way that ours no longer does.
728
They've softened it in a number of ways.
729
Firstly, through religion, through the mass adoption of religion.
730
And the interesting thing about religion is generally the gods that people have worshipped love people not for what they do, but for who they are.
731
They look inside your soul.
732
And that's a vital defense mechanism.
733
You're giving unto Caesar what Caesar wants, and, you know, the rest is up to God.
734
And that gives you a sense of freedom.
735
It's like, well, I may not be performing so well in my career, but I've got an alternative route to love and affection.
736
That's a huge defense.
737
The other thing that really protected people was isolation.
738
You know, we are one of the first societies to be constantly surrounded, 24 -7, by other people.
739
We live in vast cities.
740
Most of the world's population now lives in a city.
741
That wasn't the case until, you know, a minute ago.
742
This is very new.
743
When you don't live in a city, what do you live surrounded by? a very important psychological tool called nature.
744
Trees, rivers, forests, grasses, insects, animals.
745
What on earth has these things got to do with love?
746
Well, what they do is they break
747
that unitary system where you are worth what another human being defines you as being worth.
748
When you're surrounded by nature, you're no longer just defined by other humans.
749
You get to live in a more expansive, a more liberated world where your value is you know up to wider forces
750
and that lends a lot of oxygen and a lot of freedom
751
that we've lost as we've moved towards urban societies and of course as we've gone online.
752
Okay here's another pet idea of mine you know religion disappeared
753
as the guiding force in people's lives around 100 years ago
754
when Nietzsche famously said God is dead he announced the death of God.
755
Now you might say hang on a minute there are lots and lots of believers.
756
There are.
757
Of course there are.
758
Many societies are still defined by religion.
759
However, one can propose that in key ways we are no longer living in religious societies.
760
We are living in modern, secular societies that are based around romantic love, status performance, material goods, a denial of nature,
761
a cutting off from the natural world, and a cutting off from any sense of human agency being limited.
762
We believe in human agency being able to determine everything.
763
Along with that comes a denial, of course, of our own mortality.
764
How would we start to do something about that?
765
Well, I think we need to look to religions for answers.
766
Religions have worked it out.
767
I think that we need to steal from religions
768
and to institute in secular culture many of the manoeuvres and safety valves and genuine insights that religions were brilliant at delivering.
769
For example, we need to break bread together.
770
All religions bring people, strangers, together to break bread from different communities in order to lessen suspicion.
771
We need to get back to a tradition of communal dining and of breaking the barriers that separates strangers from one another.
772
We need also to talk with intelligence and intent about love
773
and about our capacity and possibility of loving better than we do, of reminding ourselves that we need to make an effort around love.
774
Buddhism does this, Christianity does this, all the main religions emphasize not just that love is important
775
but that love is hard and we need a little bit of that.
776
Religions also, almost all of them have created spaces that are separate from the spaces of commerce, spaces that are beautiful, spaces that are peaceful,
777
spaces that bring people together to create a different kind of fellowship, one more guided by a spirit of friendship and kindness and vulnerability.
778
We need to replace our temples and churches with secular buildings
779
that aren't just going to be shopping malls and that aren't just going to be car showrooms, but the places that will bring people together, the most beautiful community centers imaginable,
780
still need to be built.
781
And I'd love to see them built.
782
We think we're alone in being alone.
783
And we think there is shame that attends to admitting how alone we are.
784
The route out of loneliness is to share your loneliness, is to dare to believe that the things you are most ashamed of cannot be,
785
structurally, they cannot be things that exist in your heart alone, that they have to be things that despite the evidence, the surface evidence of other people's cheerfulness,
786
probably exist in other people.
787
Other people are also lonely, are also sad, also feel lost, also feel that they've messed up, also have a hard time in their relationships.
788
The beginning of friendship begins with the capacity to be vulnerable and to admit to loss and sadness.
789
We think that friendship is a mutual club for cheerfulness.
790
It's not.
791
True friendship begins with tears, with the ability to admit to sadness.
792
This is why men, in many ways, have a harder time than women, forming deep friendships, because men, there's still in many societies a real taboo around male tears.
793
Men cannot admit to being sad and weak without feeling that they have lost their masculinity.
794
Extremely unfortunate as a route to friendship, because it means that your friendship will need to be based on posturing and on the recounting of triumph and success.
795
Whereas in fact, of course, true friendship begins with the revelation of vulnerability and fragility.
796
As ever with a problem, self -awareness and mutual awareness is the way through.
797
Once we can see the pattern, we can break the pattern.
798
Once we can see that we're living in a prison defined by material, a material status system that many of us don't value,
799
that we are doing this not because we want to, but because it exists, we can start to find alternatives.
800
I'm not talking about, you know, throwing in your job.
801
I'm talking about evaluating yourself and other people beyond your job.
802
I'm talking about getting back in touch with nature.
803
I'm talking about getting in touch with vulnerability and sharing that vulnerability.
804
These are all tools and mechanisms
805
that we can put in motion to escape an otherwise really oppressive
806
and genuinely loveless environment in which we're forced to live and can't breathe very easily in.
807
You could define love as the quest to overcome isolation and understand someone else and find understanding by someone else.
808
It is the most noble and the most complicated of goals.
809
If anyone can reach the end of their life and say, I have loved, I've loved properly, I've understood and been understood, I've helped and been helped, this is a life well lived.
810
We don't need to achieve that much that is splendid in the material world
811
or in the world of insight in the humanities, insight in the sciences.
812
What we really ultimately need to do to make our time
813
worthwhile is to have built a bridge to another human
814
and to have opened our heart and have seen theirs with respect and humility and generosity.
815
That truly ultimately is the definition of a good life.
816
Want to support the channel?
817
Join the Big Think Members community where you get access to videos early, ad -free.
ऐप डाउनलोड करें
धाराप्रवाह बोलने के लिए ज़रूरी सब कुछ
AI उच्चारण स्कोरहर वाक्य का स्कोर
IPA अभ्यासहर ध्वनि में महारत
शब्दावलीअपना शब्द भंडार बनाएँ
शब्द गेमखेलते हुए सीखें
उसी चैनल से
C12
We can cure almost all human diseases. Here’s how. | Albert-László Barabási
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C13
I study demonic possession dreams. Here’s what we’ve found. | Patrick McNamara
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C12
Why schools of the future will be designed with geneticists | Kathryn Paige Harden
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C14
The shock of doing nothing | Andrew Holecek
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C14
Why sex, food, and shelter aren’t enough for Homo Sapiens | Agustín Fuentes
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C16
Kids don’t always make you happier. Here’s why people have them anyway. | Paul Bloom
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C13
A mind-blowing explanation of symmetry | Frank Wilczek for Big Think
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B21
How evolution works, in 54 minutes | Sean B. Carroll: Full Interview
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C12
Why ‘turning the other cheek’ is fundamentally misunderstood | Bishop Robert Barron
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C15
How many people are in hell? | Bishop Robert Barron
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C14
What kind of atheist are you? | Clay Routledge
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B23
How do elite performers automate their habits? | Wendy Wood
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C12
Where is the evidence for God? | Bishop Robert Barron
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C12
Why I’m against empathy | Paul Bloom
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C11
The famous tree-falling thought experiment has a new answer | Lisa Feldman Barrett
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C14
Become a great strategic thinker | Ian Bremmer
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C12
Would a society based on genetics be… good? | Kathryn Paige Harden
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
C12
The lost art of accomplishment without burnout | Cal Newport for Big Think +
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C113
Supernatural thinking: Your brain’s anti-anxiety mode | Clay Routledge
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C15
How Einstein changed time forever | Jim Al-Khalili for Big Think
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
FOR YOU
अनुशंसित वीडियो
C117
141 वाक्य
Why relationships in 2026 carry impossible expectations | Alain de Botton
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C11
73 वाक्य
TED Ed Vietsub Tình yêu là gì Brad Troeger
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B21
117 वाक्य
love is how you treat someone, not how you feel about them
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
C183
9 वाक्य
D78_ALBRECHT FUND SHADOWING_LOVE
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
B22
221 वाक्य
find your soul first, then your soulmate
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
C18
70 वाक्य
What True Love Really Is
British AccentDaily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C11
229 वाक्य
The love You Attract Reveals Who You Are | Carl Jung
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C11
55 वाक्य
The $100,000 Question That Proves What Love Is Worth🤯
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
C12
281 वाक्य
Virtual love - How dangerous are AI relationships? | DW Documentary
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C11
150 वाक्य
Why We Can't Save Those We Love
Daily ConversationUniversity StudentsWorking Adults
C12
216 वाक्य
What’s In a Name?
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
C12
87 वाक्य
How do I love myself? | Thich Nhat Hanh answers questions
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
वास्तविकता का परिदृश्य
किसी भी व्यक्ति के जीवन में प्रेम की भूमिका अत्यंत महत्वपूर्ण होती है। जब लोग प्रेम के बारे में बात करते हैं, तो वे अक्सर भावनाओं को प्राथमिकता देते हैं, लेकिन वास्तविकता यह है कि प्रेम एक कौशल है, न कि केवल एक भावना। यह वीडियो हमें यह समझाने का प्रयास करता है कि प्यार को समझना और उस पर काम करना आवश्यक है। प्रेम की जटिलता और इसे निभाने के लिए आवश्यक कौशलों के बारे में जानकारी हमें एक बेहतर संबंध बनाने में मदद कर सकती है।
उपयोगी शब्द समूह और संयुक्त शब्द
- प्रेम की जटिलता (Complexity of love)
- भावनात्मक विकास (Emotional development)
- संबंधों की गुणवत्ता (Quality of relationships)
- परिस्थितियों को समझना (Understanding circumstances)
- विश्लेषणात्मक चर्चा (Analytical discussion)
आपकी शैडोइंग चुनौती
अब, आप इस वीडियो में दी गई भावनाओं और विचारों को अपने शब्दों में व्यक्त करने की कोशिश करें। अंग्रेजी शैडोइंग का अभ्यास करें: वीडियो में दिए गए संवाद को सुनें और इसे फिर से बोलने की कोशिश करें। इससे आपकी अंग्रेजी बोलने का अभ्यास बेहतर होगा। जब आप इसे कर रहे हों, तो ध्यान दें कि आप अपनी आवाज़ में shadow speech का उपयोग कर रहे हैं। यह न केवल आपकी उच्चारण में सुधार करेगा बल्कि आपको भावनात्मक अभिव्यक्ति में भी मदद करेगा। अपने विचारों को व्यक्त करने की प्रक्रिया में, आप अपने लिए एक सुरक्षित वातावरण बनाएँ, जिससे आपकी shadowspeaks में विश्वास और बढ़ सके।
इस वीडियो का व्याकरण
वक्ता जिन संरचनाओं का सबसे अधिक प्रयोग करता है, वीडियो के असली शब्दों के साथ:
| संरचना | वीडियो में |
|---|---|
| शर्त वाले वाक्य if + उपवाक्य, will/would + क्रिया — शर्त और उसका नतीजा | if that's our true home, we will be · if confronted with their behavior will go · If we think that we will have |
| Present perfect have/has + past participle — बीता हुआ काम जिसका असर अभी भी है | we've been · have been · it's been |
| Passive voice be + past participle — ज़ोर इस पर कि क्या होता है, न कि कौन करता है | were formed · was seen · were seen |
| Relative clauses who / which + उपवाक्य — व्यक्ति या वस्तु के बारे में अतिरिक्त जानकारी | those who come · everyone who is · important, which is |
शैडोइंग तकनीक क्या है?
शैडोइंग (Shadowing) एक विज्ञान-समर्थित भाषा सीखने की तकनीक है जो मूल रूप से पेशेवर दुभाषिया प्रशिक्षण के लिए विकसित की गई थी। विधि सरल लेकिन शक्तिशाली है: आप मूल अंग्रेज़ी ऑडियो सुनते हैं और तुरंत इसे ज़ोर से दोहराते हैं — जैसे वक्ता की छाया 1-2 सेकंड की देरी से। शोध से पता चलता है कि यह उच्चारण सटीकता, स्वर, लय, जुड़ी हुई ध्वनियाँ, सुनने की समझ और बोलने की प्रवाहशीलता में काफ़ी सुधार करता है।