Luyện nói tiếng Anh bằng Shadowing qua video: Don't Talk to the Police

Chọn chế độ luyện tập

Mỗi chế độ mở một phòng luyện tập toàn màn hình.

903 câu
Nếu các câu quá ngắn hoặc quá dài, hãy bấm Edit để chỉnh sửa.
1
I was invited to give you a taste of a typical law school classroom experience here today, and I thought I would take advantage of this opportunity to do something that's been on my mind for a while.
2
To stand up and to proudly say, God bless America, God bless the Bill of Rights, and thank God for the Fifth Amendment.
3
I'm not ashamed to say I'm proud of the Fifth Amendment, and I'm proud to admit on camera and on the Internet
4
that I will never talk to any police officer under any circumstances, with all due respect, sir.
5
I'm doing something really extraordinary here today, something you'll almost never see another law professor do as long as you live.
6
I'm really putting myself on the spot here.
7
This was my idea.
8
By my invitation, I have given up half of my time, approximately.
9
I'm giving equal time and the last word to an expert who really knows something about what I'll be talking about.
10
So I'm opening myself up to the possibility that he will contradict me.
11
I was a criminal defense attorney when I was in private practice.
12
So I want to make sure, in fairness to you, if I'm misleading you or giving a slanted or one-sided presentation, you'll be able to get the last word from somebody else
13
and I'm sure he'll have a lot to teach all of us, including myself.
14
The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides, no person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.
15
And this unfortunate amendment has gotten a bad rap in recent times, much of it tragically and unnecessarily through, as you may have heard, the headlines.
16
Let me read to you something that was taken out of the newspaper this morning
17
and I want but you listen to it closely.
18
I'm giving you a heads up.
19
I'm warning you in advance, which is not fair to you.
20
Not fair to me, but I'm giving you a warning that I'll be quizzing you on this in just a few minutes.
21
This will test your aptitude for legal study and legal practice.
22
Listen closely, it won't take long.
23
Last night, agents of the Norfolk Police Department found three victims of an
24
apparent murder dead in an apartment in the East Ocean View area.
25
The apparent victims of a gangland style slaying, and possibly the victims of gang related violence.
26
The police are investigating this as a possible murder and suicide, but right now, suspect that the three were all killed by the same individual.
27
No suspects have yet been identified in the slaying, but veteran police detective George Brook has confirmed
28
that police are following up on evidence pointing to the possible involvement of an off-duty naval officer as the perpetrator.
29
The bodies
30
which were found by the apartment manager at about 8 o'clock
31
in the morning appear to have been slain sometime earlier in the same evening, probably sometime between midnight and 2 o'clock in the morning.
32
That's it.
33
Those are all the facts I'll ask you to remember and it won't be for very long either.
34
Let's see how well you I'll be quizzing you in just a few minutes.
35
Now, here's the easiest question you'll ever get from a client in all the days of your life.
36
Hey, the police are here.
37
They want to talk to me.
38
What should I do?
39
Well, I could give you my answer to that question in case you haven't already guessed it, but why don't we go to a real expert.
40
Justice Robert Jackson, a prosecutor's prosecutor.
41
Like me, he began his private practice in Buffalo, New York, years before I did, and after that he served as general counsel for the Bureau of Internal Revenue, the U.S.
42
Department of Treasury, the Security and Exchange Commission, Commission, Assistant U.S.
43
Attorney General for the Tax Division, later the Solicitor General, and the Attorney General of the United States, and then the Chief U.S.
44
Prosecutor for the Nuremberg Trials.
45
That's an impressive resume.
46
Years later, when he was a Justice on the Supreme Court, Justice Jackson stated, quote, any lawyer worth his salt, today we would say his or her,
47
will tell the suspect, his client, in no uncertain terms to make no statement to the police under any circumstances.
48
There's the title of my talk.
49
I'm here to explain to the surprising and somewhat counterintuitive and admittedly unlikely reasons why Justice Jackson was right.
50
I'm reminded of this because I'm amazed, we're all amazed, by the frequency with which we see newspaper articles coming out all the time.
51
From people who really ought to know better, who say, well, I'll talk to the police.
52
I mean, after all, I'm a senator.
53
I'm O.J.
54
Simpson.
55
I'm an experienced, highly polished individual.
56
I've got a lot of experience with public relations, even criminal defense attorneys criminal defense attorneys.
57
There was a local news story here in the Virginia Pilot
58
just a couple of months ago about an experienced criminal defense lawyer who ended up getting convicted of criminal assault
59
because he talked to the police.
60
He was accused of having assaulted another attorney in the hallway.
61
There were no other witnesses to this.
62
A woman said that he grabbed her by the throat during an argument over a case.
63
He denied it.
64
At trial it was his word against hers.
65
He said, I did not even touch her.
66
But unfortunately for him, when the police had approached him earlier and said, would you be willing to answer some questions?
67
He said, sure, why not?
68
I'm an attorney.
69
I'm a criminal defense attorney.
70
I'm savvy.
71
I'm sophisticated.
72
I've got oratorical prowess.
73
I'm accustomed to dealing with the police, by all means.
74
And then there was a conversation that was not recorded.
75
When the case went to trial, it was no longer his word against hers, because when he testified at trial, I never touched her.
76
The officer took the stand and testified, well, when I met with him, he said he did put his hand on her throat, but just as a joke.
77
Then he had to take the stand again and say, that's not true.
78
I never said that.
79
I never admitted to you that I, now it's his word against two people.
80
Who's telling the truth?
81
We'll never know for sure, but he was found guilty.
82
Now, here's part of the problem.
83
The heart of the problem, as Justice Breyer on the US Supreme Court explained in 1998,
84
is, quote, the complexity of modern federal criminal law codified in several thousand sections of the United States Code
85
and the virtually infinite variety of factual circumstances
86
that might trigger an investigation into a possible violation of the
87
law make it difficult for anyone to know in advance just
88
when a particular set of statements might later appear to a prosecutor to be relevant to some investigation.
89
One expert on criminal law recently noted that estimates of the current size of the body of federal criminal law vary,
90
although it has been reported that the Congressional Research Service can no longer even count the current number of federal crimes.
91
That's right, even the federal government has lost count.
92
These laws are scattered over all 50 pages of the U.S.
93
Code, encompassing roughly 27,000 pages.
94
Worse yet, these statutes often incorporate by reference to the provisions of administrative regulations.
95
Estimates of how many such regulations exist are even less well settled, although the ABA thinks there may be nearly 10,000.
96
Here's one of those 10,000 federal criminal statutes on the book that you probably never heard about.
97
It's called the Lacey Act, 16 U.S.C.
98
Section 3370.
99
It says it's a federal offense for any person to import, export, transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish or wildlife or plant taken,
100
possessed, transported, or or sold in the violation of any law, treaty, or regulation of the United States, or any Indian tribal law,
101
or any state, or any foreign law.
102
People have been convicted in federal court for violating this statute because they brought back a bony fish from Honduras, not knowing that Honduran law, not American, but Honduran law forbade the possession of the bony fish.
103
People have been convicted under the list law because they were found in possession of what's called a short lobster, a lobster that's under a certain size.
104
Some states forbid you from possessing a lobster if he's under a certain length.
105
It doesn't matter if he's dead or alive.
106
It doesn't matter if you killed it or if you died of natural causes.
107
It doesn't even matter if you acted in self-defense.
108
Did you know that?
109
Did you know it can be a federal offense to be in possession of a lobster?
110
Admit it.
111
Raise your hand if you did not know that.
112
There's the problem.
113
And that's only one of 10,000 different ways.
114
You know, the government gets pretty upset when people like me instructs the client, people like me and Justice Jackson.
115
Don't talk to the police.
116
Don't answer any questions.
117
But you know, they can't have it both ways.
118
You people, you've got 10,000 different ways of convicting us.
119
Good for you.
120
But you know, with the bitter comes to the sweet, with the good comes to the bad.
121
10,000 different ways my client might unknowingly implicate himself in some sort of a criminal transaction.
122
One of the reasons I decided to give this talk, I recently received a phone call from a former student of mine, a regional law school graduate, who may be watching this online.
123
We're putting it on the internet.
124
And he told me, hey, I've been approached by the Internal Revenue Service.
125
They want to ask me a couple of questions.
126
They ask if I'd be willing to.
127
But they say that I'm not a suspect.
128
And I know in my heart I don't think I've done anything wrong in violation of the Internal Revenue Service provisions.
129
Lord have mercy.
130
There's no man on earth there's no woman in this country who can honestly say with complete confidence, I know I have never violated any provision of the Internal Revenue Code.
131
He said, but they say I'm not a suspect, and I know I've done nothing wrong.
132
It's okay if I talk to him.
133
I said, no, no, you tell them you will not talk to them without immunity.
134
I explained to him why that was true, and he never heard from them again.
135
Okay, why you should never talk to the police.
136
Let me just spell it out for you.
137
Let me make it plain to all of you.
138
These are the top ten reasons.
139
I don't want to actually really lie to you.
140
I don't really have ten.
141
I don't have time for ten, but I've got time for eight, and that'll be close enough.
142
Number one, and this really ought to be good enough, contrary to what you layman instinctively and naturally suppose, it can not help.
143
There is no way it can help you.
144
Plenty of folks think that it can, and they're always wrong.
145
You cannot talk your way out of getting arrested.
146
Officer Brueck, you've interviewed thousands of criminal suspects.
147
Have you ever, how many times in your experience, have you approached someone, asked if you could ask him some questions, because prior to the interview you had some evidence pointing to his possible guilt?
148
And because of the extraordinary persuasiveness and eloquence with which he articulated his innocence, you said, oh, sorry, never mind.
149
Bad call, my bad, I won't, and he talked you out of arresting him.
150
You know the answer.
151
Never.
152
Never.
153
It never happens.
154
I've often asked other criminal defense attorneys, in all of your experience, have you ever once had a case where you looked back in hindsight and said, thank God my client talked to the police.
155
They laugh at me.
156
They laugh at me.
157
They say, you've got to be kidding me.
158
You cannot help you.
159
You can't talk your way out of getting arrested, and contrary to what you might suppose if you never studied the rules of evidence, what you tell the police, even if it's exculpatory, cannot be used to help you at trial,
160
because it's what we call hearsay.
161
Under the rules of evidence, specifically rule 801D2A, if you want to look it up, everything you tell the police, as the saying goes, can and will be used against you, but it cannot be used for you.
162
From time to time, I've known attorneys who tried to call to the stand of police officers and say, officer, would you tell the jury what my client told you
163
because what my client told him is actually good for my case?
164
If you tried that at trial, the prosecutor will object to that it's hearsay, and the judge will agree.
165
The police will not be allowed, at your request, to tell the jury what your client told him no matter how good it may be for your case.
166
It cannot help.
167
And that ought to be good enough reason.
168
That ought to be reason enough to keep your mouth shut.
169
But if you're not persuaded, let me go talk about a couple of others.
170
Number two, obviously one of the most obvious, if your client is guilty, as many of them are, but even if he's not,
171
even if he's innocent, he may well admit his guilt with no benefit in return.
172
Now, of course, many of you are thinking to yourself, well, what's so wrong about that?
173
I mean, shouldn't guilty people be confessing?
174
Confession's good for the soul.
175
It's good for law enforcement.
176
It's good for the prisons.
177
Yes, yes, sure, all those things are true.
178
And like the rest of you, if I or anyone close to me is ever the victim of some sort of a serious crime, I hope they get the right guy.
179
I hope they convict him.
180
I hope they put him away.
181
We all feel that way.
182
Hey, but watch the rush, friends.
183
You don't got to admit your guilt the first time they come by to meet with you.
184
In federal court, 86% of all defendants plead guilty at some point before trial.
185
If your client is guilty and really ought to punish
186
and really ought to go through some sort of a cleansing act of contrition and fess up and admit his guilt, there'll be plenty of time to do that.
187
They almost always do.
188
No need to rush, no need to tell the police something.
189
Wait and see
190
if perhaps your client can work out some sort of an
191
arrangement where maybe he'll make some sort of compensation to the alleged victim, or maybe he'll be able to get some sort of a discount in his sentence.
192
And he'll be treated fairly then, like everybody else who had the benefit of a good lawyer who said, please do not talk to the police.
193
And don't forget, by the way, even if your client only admits things that the police already knew, You might think, well, what harm can it do?
194
He says he wants to talk to the police.
195
All he wants to do is admit that he was there, but the cops know that he was there.
196
All right, go ahead and tell him.
197
Well, how can it hurt?
198
It might hurt if the police officer becomes transferred to Minnesota
199
or deceased or injured or comatose or cannot be located by the time of trial.
200
The case will be dismissed if there's no confession.
201
But if your client admits two things, that confession is freely admissible against him and can be a basis for getting him convicted all by himself.
202
Senator Larry Craig can explain all of this to you.
203
The Innocence Project of the United States
204
has confirmed that in more than 25% of all the cases where an innocent man was convicted
205
and then later released from prison after he was exonerated by DNA evidence, in more than a quarter of those cases, these innocent people, people we know to be innocent,
206
made incriminating statements, delivered outright confessions, or pled guilty.
207
How do they do that?
208
He'll tell us all about it, I trust.
209
Here's a couple of famous examples.
210
You can just ask them.
211
You don't have to take my word for it.
212
There on the left is Eddie Joe Lloyd.
213
He was convicted in 1984 of the murder of a 16-year-old
214
girl in Detroit after he wrote to police with suggestions on how to solve various recent crimes.
215
During several interviews, police fed details of the crime to Mr. Lloyd, who was mentally ill.
216
And they lied to him and convinced this mentally ill man that by confessing, he might help them smoke out the real killer.
217
He later signed a confession and gave a tape-recorded statement.
218
The jury delivered it less than one hour before convicting him on the basis of this confession.
219
There was no other substantial evidence against him.
220
The judge said I'd hang you if I could, but the death penalty was not available in Michigan at the time.
221
But after almost two decades in prison, he was released after DNA evidence proved that this man was innocent
222
and had falsely confessed to a crime that he did not commit.
223
On the right is Earl Washington, who was released from prison just a few years ago here in Virginia.
224
After spending 18 years behind bars, after being committed of a rape and a murder
225
that we now know he did not commit after having been exonerated by DNA evidence.
226
But this man, Mr. Washington, who was in fact confirmed to be mentally retarded, was able to confess to several crimes at the request of the police,
227
some of which we know he could not have committed.
228
That's the problem.
229
Some of you are thinking to yourself, well, none of this concerns me because I'm not guilty of anything
230
and I never will be and I will never represent people who do.
231
Okay.
232
Let's talk to you people.
233
You innocent folks.
234
Those of you who have never committed a crime and never will, and none of your clients will either.
235
And you wouldn't go out with a girl who did.
236
Fine.
237
You better not talk to the police either, okay?
238
Because number three, we'll put the guilty behind us.
239
Forget about them.
240
Let's talk about innocent people.
241
Number three, even if your client is innocent and he denies his guilt and almost entirely tells the truth, odds are good he will easily get carried away
242
and tell some little lie or make some little mistake that will hang him.
243
This is human nature.
244
He gets in there, it's a stressful situation.
245
Imagine a perfectly innocent client.
246
The police say he's been guilty of a murder.
247
He's totally innocent, as innocent as any one of us.
248
So he goes in there and he meets with the police.
249
He says, I don't know what you're talking about.
250
I was nowhere near there.
251
I didn't kill him.
252
I've never killed anybody.
253
I don't have a gun.
254
I've never had a gun.
255
I've never touched a gun in my life.
256
I was nowhere near Virginia Beach that night.
257
Uh, uh, uh, that last line was a lie.
258
He went over the top.
259
He was getting carried away.
260
He got into this groove.
261
He started saying all kinds of things, almost all of them true, that he knew would tend to exculpate himself.
262
Then he got carried away and just said one thing that wasn't true, and unfortunately for him, they can prove that it wasn't true.
263
He may be convicted on that basis alone.
264
But let's say, well, that's not a problem.
265
I'll tell my client only to tell the truth.
266
I've met with him.
267
I know he won't lie to the police.
268
He won't make any mistakes.
269
Okay.
270
That's still no guarantee you won't be getting into trouble.
271
Because even if your client is innocent and only tells the truth and doesn't say anything that is false.
272
Now, already, mind you, you were pretty well nigh into fantasy land.
273
The odds of this being anybody being able to pull this off are really quite slim, no matter how innocent they may be.
274
But just to the same, let's pretend.
275
Let's assume he gives the police nothing but the truth, and he is totally innocent.
276
He will always give the police some information that can be used to help convict him.
277
Always.
278
For example, suppose you tell this to the police.
279
Here's what your client tells to the police in his denial of guilt.
280
I don't know what you're talking about.
281
I didn't kill Jones.
282
I don't know who did.
283
I wasn't anywhere near that place.
284
I don't have a gun.
285
I've never owned a gun in my life.
286
I don't even know how to use a gun.
287
Yeah, sure, I never liked the guy, but who did?
288
I wouldn't kill him.
289
I've never hurt anybody in my life, and I would never do such a thing.
290
Let's suppose every word of that is true.
291
100% of it is true.
292
What will the jury hear at trial?
293
Officer Brook, was there anything about this, your interrogation, your interview with the suspect that made you concerned that he might be the right one?
294
Yes, there was.
295
He confessed to me that he never liked the guy.
296
And then the prosecutor will put that up in big letters, and he'll say, the jury, it's pretty clear that we've got the right guy here.
297
We've proven that he was in Virginia Beach that night.
298
That's opportunity.
299
And remember Officer Brueck admitted that after extended questioning, he was finally able to get the defendant to admit that he never liked the guy.
300
There's your motive.
301
Motive plus opportunity.
302
Wham!
303
Bam!
304
Please.
305
But juries eat it up.
306
And innocent people get convicted this way sometimes.
307
How often?
308
Hopefully not too often.
309
But we know what happens.
310
The United States Supreme Court, don't take my word for this, in Ohio versus Reiner, the the Supreme Court of the United States said,
311
quote, one of the Fifth Amendment's basic functions is to protect innocent men who otherwise might be ensnared by ambiguous circumstances.
312
Truthful responses of an innocent witness, as well as those of a wrongdoer, may provide the government with incriminating evidence from the Speaker's own mouth.
313
See, it's not just some criminal defense attorney telling you this.
314
Even the Supreme Court says I'm right.
315
Under the facts of that case, by the way, in Ohio versus Rhino, a child tragically was died, apparently the result of shaken baby syndrome.
316
The question was who had shaken this baby to death.
317
And one of the possible suspects was a babysitter who had spent some time with the child that week.
318
The babysitter's story was, I don't know what you're talking about.
319
I did not kill the child.
320
I did not see it happen.
321
I don't know who shook the baby.
322
It was never me.
323
I never did anything of any violent nature to the child.
324
The Ohio State Court said, well, you've got no Fifth Amendment privilege.
325
You, by your own admission, told the investigators that you've done nothing wrong, that you were not involved.
326
So obviously your answers can't incriminate you.
327
The United States Supreme Court reversed and said, well, that's not true.
328
Even though this babysitter denies shaking the child, denies seeing the child die, denies knowing how the child died, this babysitter, by her own admission,
329
apparently was being, the government wanted to ask whether the babysitter might have been with the child at some point that week, during the week prior to the death.
330
And that answer, although by itself not sufficient to convict anybody, could help convict her.
331
That means she's got a Fifth Amendment right to refuse to answer to the question the court held.
332
Because it could be used to help convict.
333
Allman v.
334
United States, which the Supreme Court said more than 50 years ago, eerily prophetic.
335
They said too many Americans, even those who should be better advised, view this privilege as a shelter for wrongdoers.
336
They too readily assume that those who invoke it are either guilty of crime or commit perjury in claiming the privilege.
337
That's not true and it never has been. But it gets worse.
338
Can it get worse?
339
It can.
340
Number five.
341
Even if your client is innocent and only tells her the truth and does not tell the police anything incriminating, which, by the way, is almost impossible to pull this off.
342
I mean, imagine talking to the police for two, three, four hours, and somebody like him can't somehow manage to extract from you something
343
that could be used to help convict you.
344
That would be extraordinary.
345
I don't think anybody's pulled it off.
346
But even if you could pull it off, there's still a grave chance that his answers can and will be used to crucify you in a court of law.
347
If the police, no offense, don't recall his testimony with 100% accuracy.
348
All right, now this brings us back to that pop quiz I warned you about.
349
I told you earlier, remember, it's only been a few minutes, and you weren't up all night, and you weren't the subject of physical duress, you were in the relaxed setting of a classroom here, you were given a heads-up,
350
advance notice that you would be quizzed on this.
351
Question.
352
We'll start with a couple of easy ones.
353
Remember that article I read to you about that?
354
How many people did the police find shot to death last night at that Ocean View apartment that I told you about?
355
A, one, B, two, C, three, D, four.
356
Who says A?
357
B. Get this, get that with a camera.
358
Move that camera around.
359
Look how many hands we've got there for C.
360
Okay, D?
361
You're all wrong.
362
Everybody who raised their hand, everybody who raised their hand, you are the kind of people who should never talk to the police under any circumstances for as long as you live.
363
Why is C not the right answer, by the way?
364
If you know, raise your hand.
365
Yes?
366
Because you didn't say it because of death.
367
Excellent.
368
I didn't say anybody was shot.
369
I didn't say gun, bullet, shooting, firearms.
370
Didn't use any of those words.
371
But I don't blame you if you thought that I did.
372
This is the way the human mind works.
373
We hear things, we fill in details.
374
I said gangland style slang.
375
That may or may not imply something, but it doesn't mean that anybody was shot.
376
And that's the problem.
377
You see, even if your client is innocent, and only tells the truth, and doesn't tell them anything incriminating, and his statement is videotaped, his answers can be used to crucify him him.
378
You might say, wait, how can that happen?
379
I insisted, in my insistence, I called the police and I said, look, if you want to talk to my client, you can talk to him, but only if you videotape the whole thing.
380
I don't want there to be any debate between the two of you over what happened.
381
Okay, we'll videotape the whole thing.
382
If the police don't recall their questions with 100% accuracy, he'll be convicted on that statement alone.
383
For example, suppose a man goes to the police, they say we're investigating a possible murder, a shooting, and the guy says, quote, I don't know who killed Jones, Officer Brooke, with all due respect.
384
It wasn't me.
385
I've never touched or fired a gun in my life.
386
How How can that help incriminate this man?
387
How could that possibly be used against this man to help convict him?
388
You would think it's inconceivable, but it's as easy as pie.
389
All the officer has to do is read this statement to the jury, and then the prosecutor says, Officer Bruch, was there anything about that statement that confused you or surprised you?
390
Yes, there was, he says in a moment of sinister high drama in the courtroom.
391
And what was that?
392
And then Officer Bruch turns to the jurors and he says, I never said anything about a shooting.
393
I said we were investigating a murder.
394
He was the one who brought up a gun.
395
Then you turn to your client, and your client says, that's not true.
396
That's not true.
397
He was the one or one of the cops.
398
I was with them for three hours.
399
One of them in the car said something about they said they had a witness that I was the shooter.
400
Okay, I'll put you on the stand.
401
And then your client testifies, no, no, no, they did tell me shooting.
402
I mentioned it.
403
They mentioned it before I said anything about a gun.
404
They brought it up first.
405
And then the police said, that's not true.
406
And now what?
407
It's your word against theirs? For what?
408
You're gambling with your client's life.
409
And police officers can very easily make a mistake like that, just as so many of you did just a few minutes ago, about whether you recall having heard me say something about somebody actually being shot.
410
Police make mistakes.
411
innocently, inadvertently, unintentionally, any statement, no matter how exculpatory it may seem on its face, can be used to crucify you all by itself.
412
If the police are either willing to lie, not likely, or if they just have an innocent misrecollection of the details as to what they did
413
and did not tell you before you told them what you said.
414
All of these, by the way, all of these problems disappear if you take Justice Jackson's advice and say, thank you very much, officer, but no thanks.
415
How about this one?
416
Here we go.
417
Now, here's the most surprising of all.
418
I've saved the most surprising one for a last.
419
Let's suppose you've got the following scenario.
420
Your client's thinking about talking to the police.
421
He acts like, he says, I've got nothing to hide.
422
They think that I killed somebody in Virginia Beach last night.
423
Well, and this is what your client tells you in confidence.
424
I don't know who robbed that store.
425
It wasn't me.
426
In fact, I've got a pretty good alibi.
427
I wasn't even in Virginia Beach that night, last night.
428
I was four hours away visiting my mother in the Outer Banks.
429
Unfortunately, no, I did not pay for gas with a credit card.
430
I used cash, and so I've got no witnesses that can prove I was there except my word, and of course mama, for what that's worth which is nothing.
431
But so your client says, so the police want to talk to me and I want to seem cooperative, so what I'll do is I'll tell them that I was in the Outer Banks last night.
432
Now, there's nothing on its face incriminating about any of that.
433
Let's assume, by the way, that you believe with all your doubt, you've given your client a polygraph exam, you've known him for years, you've been going to the same Bible study for 30 years,
434
you know beyond a shadow of a doubt that he's telling you the truth.
435
And he's not admitting anything.
436
He's not admitting motive.
437
He's not admitting opportunity.
438
He's not admitting that he was there.
439
How on earth could this come back to haunt us?
440
How on earth could this come back to be used against us? Be honest.
441
Raise your hand if you really think the answer to that question is, I can't see how it could possibly be used against me.
442
You're afraid I'll call on you, right?
443
I won't call on you.
444
Well, you're wrong.
445
You're dead wrong.
446
You're always wrong.
447
Everything you say, every time you talk to the police, you will regret it.
448
You see, the problem is, here it is.
449
This is the last point.
450
I think it's almost to the end.
451
Even if your client is innocent and only tells the truth and doesn't tell the police anything incriminating and the entire interview, questions and answers are videotaped,
452
your, even his truthful answers can be helped to use crucify even an innocent man if the police, through no fault of theirs, end up in the possession of any evidence,
453
even mistaken and unreliable evidence that anything your client told them was false, even if in fact it was true.
454
Again, going back to this example from a moment ago.
455
Let's suppose I tell, I go ahead and I meet with the police.
456
I think I got nothing to hide.
457
I tell them, I was in the Outer Banks last night, officer.
458
How can that be used to convict me? itself, it cannot.
459
It cannot help at all by itself.
460
But what if I later find out to my horror, after I put my cards on the table, that they've got a witness, a girl that I went to high school with, an unimpeachable witness, we've never been enemies, she'd have no reason to lie.
461
She swears, she thinks she saw me in Virginia Beach last night a couple of blocks away from that store, about an hour before it was robbed.
462
Now her testimony by itself isn't going to help the prosecutor.
463
Hell, if she's all they've got, I'll get this case thrown out before trial.
464
But if like an idiot, I talked to the police and I told them the truth, I told them I was in the Outer Banks, and now lo and behold, tragically, it turns out they've got a witness,
465
a false, mistaken, confused, but sincere, incredible witness who could testify that I was here at Virginia Beach, now they're likely to get a conviction.
466
Because what they'll do, I've just turned this cop and this woman into the government's star witnesses.
467
Hell, they'll put Officer Brucon to testify about how my client lied to him about being in the Outer Banks.
468
And then they'll put on this girl, this girl who otherwise would have not even helped with their case at all, who will testify, no, that's not true.
469
That was a lie.
470
I saw Mr. Duane's client here in Virginia an hour before the robbery, not so far from the store.
471
By herself, she would not have helped the government in any significant way.
472
But what I have just done, you see, is given them the other part of the puzzle.
473
And now I'm doomed.
474
Just ask them.
475
I close with this example.
476
So here we have a couple of recent celebrity examples of why it ish
477
that even people who admit nothing always end up denying it.
478
I mean, sorry, they always end up regretting it.
479
On the left, we have Martha Stewart.
480
She was the victim, the subject, of an extensive government investigation that was looking into the possibility that she was guilty of violations of certain federal laws, securities laws, fraud kinds of things.
481
They couldn't pin that on her, but they were able to get a conviction because she denied it.
482
Talking to the police and later to some of the shareholders, she said, no, it's not true.
483
I was not guilty.
484
So they charged her with lying to federal investigators, and they got a conviction, and she was sentenced to five months in prison.
485
Marion Jones on the right side, another person who would still be out today if she had always taken the advice that I'm giving you now,
486
she was asked if she had ever used steroids, a controlled substance.
487
And instead of taking the fifth, she said, no, I never took steroids when I won those Olympic gold medals.
488
Later on, it turned out that she was lying.
489
She worked out a deal.
490
She pled guilty.
491
She admitted that she was lying.
492
And she, over her strenuous, tear-filled objection, even though she has two young children, was just recently sentenced to prison for six months.
493
The guy who sold her the stair rights, the pusher, he got only four months.
494
But she got six months because she lied to the police and said that she did not do it.
495
You see the problem.
496
Michael Vick, who recently pled guilty, as you know, to these charges with respect to the operation of this dog combat sort of operation at his home.
497
At sentencing, like many other criminal defendants, even though he eventually pled guilty at sentencing, one of the reasons his sentence was a little harder than it might have otherwise been,
498
the judge said, was because when he initially met with the police, He lied to them and said, I didn't do anything.
499
I didn't do it.
500
I don't know what you're talking about.
501
Even guilty people, but not only guilty people, will always end up regarding talking to the police.
502
So my advice to you, Justice Jackson was right.
503
Any sane, competent lawyer in his right mind will always tell every client under all circumstances, I don't care if you're innocent.
504
I don't care if it's the truth.
505
If it's the truth, great.
506
We'll tell the jury all about it.
507
There'll be time enough to put our cards on the table.
508
But before we get there, I haven't seen yet what the police got.
509
They may have mistaken and confused witnesses who will contradict even the truthful stuff that you say.
510
We have no way to know, no way to predict whether the information that you give them, even if truthful and reliable, will end up unwittingly dispelling our demise.
511
So keep your mouth shut.
512
Don't answer any questions.
513
Let's take the fifth.
514
You'll be glad that you did.
515
God bless America.
516
God bless the Bill of Rights and the geniuses who bequeathed it to us.
517
But now, in fairness, I give equal time, or what's left of equal time, to a police officer who will explain to the extent to which,
518
If any, he agrees or disagrees with anything I've got to say.
519
I didn't, I have no idea to know what he's going to say, but it'll be interesting.
520
Here, let me give him the microphone.
521
Let's give him a hand.
522
Officer George Bruch, the Virginia Beach Police Department.
523
I cannot talk that fast.
524
Not even interviewing.
525
I'm going to take the podium here, Professor.
526
Because I took notes on some of the things you said.
527
But everything he said was true.
528
And it was right and it was correct.
529
And I'm just going to give you a few ideas.
530
I'm going to tell you a few examples, but first I'm going to give you a little information.
531
As was said earlier, I've interviewed thousands of people.
532
I've interviewed people with foreign police departments.
533
When I was in the Navy, I was in law enforcement and I was a criminal investigator.
534
Thank God we're in the United States because most interviews in Italy, Spain and so forth start out physically.
535
There's no police abuse over there.
536
They can do pretty much what they want.
537
Any time they want, any how they want.
538
Just be aware of that and be thankful for you.
539
Biggest question I was asked when I first...
540
I am a 3L.
541
And there's some of my classmates in here.
542
Best day is coming up May 10th when we get to leave.
543
So those of you that are applying and I told a couple of people this, you think it's hard getting into law school?
544
Try getting out.
545
A couple of things I was asked.
546
How do I quit from getting speeding tickets? easy question, quit speeding.
547
Okay?
548
But something Professor Duane brought up, are any of you guilty of anything?
549
How many of you drove here today?
550
Anybody go above 55 on the interstate?
551
Anybody drive at home and go above 55 on the interstate?
552
Because if you, if you stay...
553
What are you making your hands for?
554
I told you, don't do anything!
555
I know, I know!
556
I remember, but I was doing it anyway.
557
I was doing it anyway.
558
I did it intentionally.
559
And there you go.
560
And people aren't inherently honest, and that's their biggest downfall.
561
They really are.
562
Or they want to tell their story.
563
And if you drive 55 on the interstate where it's 55, the only thing you're going to do is meet the person behind you
564
because they're going to rear-end you and you're going to get run over.
565
So that's a fact.
566
But everybody does something that they can get in trouble for.
567
I can follow as a police officer when I was in uniform.
568
I can follow a car however long I needed to, and eventually they're going to do something illegal, illegal, and I can pull them over.
569
And justifiably illegal to pull them over with.
570
So just be aware of that.
571
Don't think you're so innocent in such a thing.
572
When you get stopped for a traffic ticket, everyone likes to be somewhat honest.
573
And what's the first thing the police officer asks you?
574
Do you know how fast you're going?
575
If the speed limit's 35, you'll say, oh, 38, 40, because you want to be kind of honest even even though you're doing 50.
576
You just said 38 and 40.
577
You just admitted to breaking the law.
578
You just confessed.
579
So they can go to court with that, with a confession that you are exceeding the speed limit.
580
You need to think about those things, and when you do become defense attorneys, which I may, who knows, you need to think about those things for your clients.
581
The other thing you need to think about your clients, and this is going to seem very terse, people are stupid.
582
Your clients are stupid.
583
And I've had defense attorneys come up to me.
584
Matter of fact, one on a motion to suppress just Tuesday come up to me and tell me his client was stupid.
585
Okay?
586
They're very straightforward.
587
They do foolish things.
588
They talk to the police.
589
You guys need to be aware of that.
590
Now, in my past, and it wasn't exaggerated, I've interviewed thousands of people.
591
I've arrested and dealt with over a thousand felonies.
592
Well, actually, more than a thousand felonies.
593
Probably about 20, no, about 1,000 fellows, 2,500 misdemeanors.
594
98% of them conviction rate.
595
80% of them I don't even have to go to court.
596
Why?
597
Because there's confessions. Because they confess.
598
So these people have no problem.
599
The hardened criminals have no problem talking to the police.
600
People like to tell their story.
601
And they'll sit in that room and think about it.
602
You're picked up by the police.
603
You're in a little room.
604
There's one chair here.
605
There's a desk.
606
There's another chair.
607
What's the thing you want the most right at that point?
608
To get out of that room.
609
To be out of that room.
610
Think the police officers.. police officers shift is ending in 15 minutes.
611
Does the police officer want to get out of that room?
612
My overtime rate's $58 an hour.
613
Do I want to get out of that room?
614
I have no problem.
615
I'll stay there for 10 hours.
616
I'll take that $600.
617
So I have no motivation to want to leave.
618
You do.
619
And that's how we get you to try to talk.
620
I have my job.
621
My job is to develop probable cause, develop a good case, a great case is a case with a confession,
622
get it to the Commonwealth's attorney so that they can prosecute the case with little if any effort.
623
And the Commonwealth attorneys love those cases, the little if any effort, because they come with a stack of files that high in court every day.
624
So they love those cases.
625
That's my job.
626
The defense attorney's job is to hope they get to their client before I do.
627
and make sure they don't talk to me, no matter what.
628
I'll give you an example, and this will go right along with what Professor Dwayne was putting up his examples.
629
I had an interview that went something like this.
630
Were you involved in the burglaries?
631
No, I had nothing to do with them.
632
You didn't have anything to do with them?
633
No. You were in a car with all this stolen stuff in it?
634
You had nothing to do about it?
635
No. You knew it was there?
636
Yeah.
637
Okay, now we've got possession of stolen property, felony.
638
Okay.
639
But you had nothing to do with it?
640
No. So what did you need the money for?
641
I had to pay some of my court costs from another thing I got in trouble for.
642
Oh, so he took the money from stealing the stuff.
643
I have enough to charge him now with burglary.
644
Simple as that.
645
Well, did you see the picture on that camera of the house with the Christmas decorations?
646
This is a real case scenario.
647
Yeah, did you go in that house?
648
No, I didn't go into that one.
649
So there's ways around it.
650
There's ways to get around people who try not to talk to you.
651
And again, as Professor Duane said, if you wanted to go and say you wanted to go into a boxing match, $100 if you win.
652
You've never boxed before.
653
You have to face somebody who's an Olympic boxer.
654
You're going to lose.
655
You're going to face somebody who's been interviewing people for, in my case, 28 years.
656
You're going to lose.
657
Unless you're purely innocent.
658
Now on the other side of it, I don't want to put anyone that's innocent in jail.
659
But I try not to bring anyone into the interview room that's innocent.
660
And there are a couple that I have let walk away because they were innocent.
661
Okay, the interviews.
662
How do we approach the interviews?
663
There's a number of ways to approach interviews.
664
There's a number of types of people that I deal with.
665
First thing I do, anyone know what they get told first when they're in an interview?
666
Miranda.
667
Miranda warning.
668
Okay, it's not a right.
669
You don't have a right to Miranda.
670
Those rights have always been there.
671
It's called the Constitution.
672
You're just teaching.
673
You're doing a real quick class on the Constitution for these people.
674
Usually they don't listen to it.
675
And this is the way I give my Miranda warning.
676
Look, I have to tell you this.
677
Just pay attention.
678
Okay.
679
They're usually sitting back or they're very attentive.
680
You have the right to remain silent.
681
Do you understand that?
682
Yes.
683
Anything you say may be used against you in a court.
684
I don't have to say it will be.
685
I say it may be.
686
Okay.
687
And they get that.
688
You have a right to an attorney.
689
and if you can't afford one, one may be appointed to represent you.
690
Got that.
691
You can decide not to quit talking to me at any time and exercise these rights.
692
Do you understand that?
693
Sure.
694
Now, before I do the primary thing that's needed with those rights, and that's to get a waiver, I say, Now, before you say anything,
695
let me tell you what I know.
696
And over all the time I've had to put together what this individual was supposedly involved in, and I only say supposedly because Professor Duane is sitting over there,
697
that this individual was involved in, I will tell the story that I put together, and it will be pretty close to what happened.
698
And I can see that it's pretty close to what happened, because that individual starts slumping down in their chair, they'll put their hand to their face, doing this in their mind,
699
oh my god, I'm going to jail forever, okay?
700
And I can see it.
701
I said, now that you know what I know, do you want to talk to me?
702
And why do I do that?
703
Because if I didn't do that, if I said, do you want to talk to me, they'll say no. So I give them the time to think about,
704
and then comes the next phrase.
705
Now, before you start talking to me, let me tell you the difference between a lie and a truth.
706
If you lie to me, and I get before the judge, and I tell the judge that you were dishonest with me, that's just not going to make them happy.
707
But if I get before the judge and tell them you're honest, straightforward, willing to take responsibility for your actions, that is going to help you.
708
That's not a lie, though.
709
That is true in Virginia Beach courts.
710
It will help them.
711
You know, they may not get five years.
712
They may get three years.
713
They're still going to prison.
714
or they're still going to have a felony, but it will help them.
715
And then I have to determine what kind of person I have.
716
And there's two types.
717
There's the one, like I mentioned to you earlier, where I have to talk to them, talk to them about different things, get into their own skin,
718
as the word is, and try and get them to talk to me and discuss things.
719
I had a sexual assault case.
720
I had to talk to the guy how hot the woman was, and I understand where he was coming from.
721
And when I said that, we were buds.
722
And he started talking to me.
723
And he's still sitting in prison.
724
Okay?
725
So you've got to get in there and you've got to go places.
726
The other side is, I can't try and act like that individual acts.
727
Okay?
728
I can't try and act like what we call lovingly a hood rat.
729
I can't try and act and talk like him.
730
Because I'm an older white guy.
731
We don't talk like that, and that would be an insult.
732
And you can't insult people.
733
It doesn't matter who they are.
734
It doesn't matter where they grew up.
735
It doesn't matter where they're from.
736
You can't insult people like that.
737
You have to be yourself.
738
So you have to get into their mindset and the way they're thinking and have a discussion with them.
739
The other type of person is the one that likes to tell a story.
740
This young man, great man.
741
I love him to death.
742
He didn't go to jail because I went to bat for him because I felt sorry for him.
743
He was newlywed.
744
He was having money problems.
745
Former Marine.
746
I said, tell me what happened.
747
And he told me this beautiful story about what happened.
748
What he had done is he had sold a piece of equipment that his ex-employer had had, that he had stolen.
749
He told me the beautiful story of what happened about him finding it on the side of the road
750
and all that kind of stuff.
751
I didn't even question about him.
752
After he finished his whole story, very unplausible, but very beautiful story.
753
I sat there and listened to it for 15 minutes.
754
I looked at him and I said, you stole the stuff from your boss, didn't you?
755
Yes, sir, I did.
756
I had nothing.
757
I really had nothing except the fact that he had sold it.
758
So there's those types of people.
759
And then the third type, the one who tries to be the hood, who tries to be the criminal, who cries like a baby when they walk in a jail, but when they're on the street, they're as tough as rocks.
760
You go in there with your paperwork, you sit down, and you just start doing paperwork.
761
And usually I have a videotape sitting on top of it.
762
Just for measure, so they think I have a videotape.
763
And you just sit there.
764
Don't tell them, Miranda.
765
Just sit there and wait for them to start talking.
766
Because they will.
767
They want to talk.
768
People want to communicate.
769
They hate silence.
770
That's why when people speak, you hear, uh, hmm, when they're talking, because they need to fill that void with something.
771
People hate silence.
772
So that's the other one. So that's another way.
773
So you see how there's an unlevel playing field here.
774
Even with the most educated individual, there's an unlevel playing field.
775
If you talk to the police, everything's going to be written down.
776
If you get pulled over for a ticket, they give you the ticket, and you pull off.
777
Do you ever see the cop pull off right after you?
778
Usually not.
779
That's because on the back of their ticket, they're writing down everything you said.
780
And it's going to come into court if you go to court.
781
Everything that's said, I write down.
782
Every phone call I make has to have a listening device on it.
783
Is that illegal?
784
How many parties need to know that a phone conversation in Virginia is being recorded?
785
One.
786
Me.
787
I knew it was recorded.
788
I get many, many confessions over the phone.
789
Okay, back to the people.
790
Yes, they're stupid.
791
Okay, people are stupid.
792
I had a young man who told me straight up, I'm going to college, I'm going to law school.
793
I'm too smart, you'll never find out what happened.
794
He was going to Tidewater Community College, the law school of, I suppose, Tidewater Community College.
795
He was the partner to the one who I told you the interview about just a little while ago, where I would ask him what he needed the money for.
796
He was his partner.
797
And he was very smart. So he thought.
798
He thought he was a very intelligent individual.
799
I ended up arresting him five times out of his house.
800
His mother hated me.
801
She liked me the first time.
802
She apologized.
803
She didn't really like me much the second time.
804
It got to the point where she really hated me after that.
805
He's doing eight years upstate.
806
He's very smart because he decided to tell me how smart he was.
807
And in telling me how smart he was, he let it slip that he doesn't sell stolen stuff to pawn shops, he sells it to flea markets because they do not have to report to the state.
808
I know how to drive to a flea market just as good as anyone else
809
and go look for stuff that I'm looking for.
810
So he was trying to impress me with his ability to be smarter than I was, and he confessed.
811
So people are inherently stupid, especially criminals.
812
And don't get me wrong, there are some very intelligent criminals out there, and most of them work in really big office buildings and wore suits.
813
Yep, she went to jail.
814
Is she hurting?
815
No.
816
But there are some very intelligent street criminals out there as well
817
that get other people to do their bidding and so forth and so on, and people are afraid to turn on them there are some very foolish people.
818
Just a couple other things.
819
I do a thing usually with younger people, usually between the age of, I try not to deal too much with juveniles,
820
but between the age of 16 and 25, is once they've talked to me.
821
Now, let's back up a little bit.
822
You don't need a recording in court for a statement.
823
As Professor Duane said, it's his word against my word if he as a defendant.
824
Number one, and this is the way it works, and this is the way the real world works, in case you guys haven't been out there, that's outside the windows out there.
825
The jury looks at a defendant sitting next to a defense attorney.
826
That's strike one, because the jury is already looking at that being someone who did something to put them in that chair.
827
Number two, they get a uniformed police officer up there.
828
They get someone wearing a suit is a detective up there that is a professional witness.
829
That's strike two.
830
So now they have a professional witness against them.
831
And then if they've confessed and that professional witness is going to sit there and read from his or her notes, the confession, that's strike three,
832
go get your orange jumpsuit, do not pass go, do not collect $200.
833
So they have all those strikes against them.
834
And I know you're innocent until proven guilty, but it's jury of your peers.
835
And the perception is if you're sitting next to a defense attorney, you have to prove you're innocent.
836
And that's just the perception of a lot of the jury, no matter how many jury instructions they get, they still perceive that person is a hoodlum, is a criminal.
837
And no matter how hard some defense attorneys try to put their clients in suits
838
and have them sit up at the table, if the trial is a long trial, they fall back to their old ways,
839
and they start acting and speaking in a way that's not very good for their case.
840
So saying that, you don't have to have a recording.
841
My suppression hearing, a statement was trying to be suppressed because when I record a confession or an interview, because we don't do interrogations,
842
the police, we do not do interrogations.
843
That's a bad, mean, Nazi kind of word, okay?
844
We do interviews.
845
Okay?
846
And you'd be amazed how much difference it makes when you use that one word, vice's interrogation.
847
I'll take it off the tape and I'll have my secretary put it to paper.
848
Immediately afterwards, I'll take that tape and I'll scan it over my magnet, throw it in my box so I can use it again.
849
I do not keep the tape, it is not evidence.
850
It's not required to be evidence.
851
It is there.
852
If it's there for the court, it's just extra.
853
You don't have to have that.
854
but it's really good to have.
855
The suppression hearing, he tried to suppress that.
856
After I testified, the defense counsel stood up and said, well, judge, I really don't have anything to say, and the judge, Judge Canada,
857
said motion denied, and let's move on and go to court.
858
So you don't have to have recordings.
859
You don't have to have videotapes.
860
The police videotapes, that's just extra.
861
If you've got that police officer sitting there testifying, you don't have to have that videotape.
862
You've got the guy that was right there to tell you what happened.
863
But it's always nice to have those extra things.
864
And what I do for these young people is I'll say, Look, the person who you broke into their house are very upset.
865
They're very angry because you sold their stuff to the pawn shop.
866
Pawn shop stuff sold them.
867
They don't get their stuff back.
868
They're very angry.
869
They want you to go to prison.
870
Okay?
871
They may be very angry.
872
They want you to go to prison.
873
They may want to.
874
To lessen that, that's the start of what's commonly known as a lie because we are allowed to lie in interviews.
875
to lessen that, you might want to make them happy.
876
And the reason that's a lie is because when it is a felony in Commonwealth of Virginia, the victim has nothing to do with the prosecution
877
or how long the people go to prison or any of that kind of stuff.
878
We're prosecuting them, not the victim.
879
But to lessen
880
that, what I'd like you to do is write an apology letter to the person whose house you broke into.
881
Just write it out.
882
Well, how do I write it?
883
In your own words, just write, you know, I'm sorry for what I did.
884
than say that, you know, when I broke into your house the other night, whatever.
885
They write it out.
886
They sign it.
887
I sign it as a witness.
888
I put the date and the time that it was written.
889
I give it to the Commonwealth's attorney.
890
It's entered as evidence as a written confession.
891
In the person's own handwriting.
892
I don't type it up again and have them sign it.
893
In their handwriting, a written confession.
894
Is that person going to get convicted?
895
I have never seen them not get convicted on that.
896
On an apology letter.
897
So, in support of Professor Duane, everything he says is right.
898
That's what I do.
899
Now to take away the support, I don't try and send innocent people to jail.
900
That's it.
901
That's all I have.
902
Any questions or anything like that?
903
Sir?

Tải Ứng Dụng

Mọi thứ bạn cần để nói trôi chảy

Chấm điểm AIChấm từng câu nói
Luyện IPAThành thạo mọi âm
Từ vựngMở rộng vốn từ
Game Từ vựngHọc qua chơi
FOR YOU

Video gợi ý

Tại sao nên luyện nói với video này?

Video này mang đến cho bạn cơ hội tuyệt vời để luyện nói tiếng Anh trong một ngữ cảnh thực tế và chân thật. Khi xem video, bạn có thể cảm nhận được cách mà một luật sư trình bày ý kiến của mình về quyền lợi của công dân, đặc biệt là quyền im lặng theo Tu chính án thứ Năm. Đây là một chủ đề quan trọng, không chỉ trong luật pháp mà còn trong cuộc sống hàng ngày. Bằng cách luyện theo video này, bạn không chỉ cải thiện khả năng ngôn ngữ của mình mà còn hiểu rõ hơn về các khái niệm pháp lý và xã hội. Qua việc luyện nói tiếng Anh, bạn sẽ cảm thấy tự tin hơn khi giao tiếp và sử dụng tiếng Anh trong các tình huống tương tự.

Cấu trúc ngữ pháp & Biểu thức trong ngữ cảnh

Trong video, người diễn giả sử dụng một số cấu trúc ngữ pháp và biểu thức quan trọng, bao gồm:

  • “No person shall be compelled” - Cấu trúc này thể hiện một quy tắc pháp lý, sử dụng động từ bị động để nhấn mạnh rằng không ai có thể bị buộc phải làm gì.
  • “I could give you my answer” - Câu này sử dụng thì điều kiện, thể hiện một sự lựa chọn hoặc khả năng mà người nói có thể thực hiện.
  • “Make no statement to the police” - Cách diễn đạt này rất quan trọng trong tình huống pháp lý, thể hiện rõ ràng sự khuyến cáo từ luật sư tới thân chủ.

Việc hiểu và áp dụng những cấu trúc này trong giao tiếp hàng ngày sẽ giúp bạn thể hiện ý tưởng một cách rõ ràng và tự tin hơn.

Các cạm bẫy phát âm thường gặp

Khi luyện nói theo video, bạn có thể gặp một số từ ngữ và cách phát âm khó khăn. Một số từ như “compelled” và “statement” có thể gây khó khăn cho người học, đặc biệt là với âm cuối và âm tiết nhấn. Để phát âm tiếng Anh chuẩn, hãy chú ý đến cách nhấn âm và ngữ điệu trong từng câu. Việc sử dụng phần mềm shadowing sẽ rất hữu ích, cho phép bạn luyện tập phát âm tiếng anh chuẩn và điều chỉnh ngữ điệu của bản thân khi nói. Bên cạnh đó, việc thực hành liên tục với shadow speech sẽ giúp bạn cải thiện kỹ năng giao tiếp của mình một cách đáng kể.

Nhớ rằng, luyện nói tiếng Anh không chỉ là việc lặp lại mà còn là việc hiểu và cảm nhận ngữ điệu, từ vựng trong ngữ cảnh thực tế. Hãy sử dụng video này như một công cụ để rèn luyện và phát triển khả năng giao tiếp của bạn.

Ngữ pháp trong video

Những cấu trúc người nói dùng nhiều nhất, kèm đúng cụm từ trong video:

Cấu trúcTrong video
Câu điều kiện if + mệnh đề, will/would + động từ — điều kiện và kết quảif she's all they've got, I'll get · if truthful and reliable, will end · If the speed limit's 35, you'll say
Thì hiện tại hoàn thành have/has + quá khứ phân từ — việc đã xảy ra nhưng còn liên quan đến hiện tạithat's been · have given · has gotten
Câu bị động be + quá khứ phân từ — nhấn vào việc xảy ra, không phải người làmwas invited · be compelled · was taken
Mệnh đề quan hệ who / which + mệnh đề — thêm thông tin về người hoặc vậtadvance, which is · people who really · people who do

Phương Pháp Shadowing Là Gì?

Shadowing là kỹ thuật học ngôn ngữ có cơ sở khoa học, ban đầu được phát triển cho chương trình đào tạo phiên dịch viên chuyên nghiệp và được phổ biến rộng rãi bởi nhà đa ngôn ngữ học Dr. Alexander Arguelles. Nguyên lý cốt lõi đơn giản nhưng cực kỳ hiệu quả: bạn nghe tiếng Anh của người bản xứ và lặp lại to ngay lập tức — như một "cái bóng" (shadow) đuổi theo người nói với độ trễ chỉ 1–2 giây. Khác với luyện ngữ pháp hay học từ vựng bị động, Shadowing buộc não bộ và cơ miệng phải đồng thời xử lý và tái tạo ngôn ngữ thực tế. Các nghiên cứu khoa học xác nhận phương pháp này cải thiện đáng kể phát âm, ngữ điệu, nhịp điệu, nối âm, kỹ năng nghe và độ lưu loát khi nói — đặc biệt hiệu quả cho người luyện IELTS Speaking và muốn giao tiếp tiếng Anh tự nhiên như người bản ngữ.

Phương pháp shadowing: đọc hướng dẫn từng bước đầy đủ →