शैडोइंग अभ्यास: Chocolate is getting worse. So is everything else. | The Gray Area - वीडियो के साथ अंग्रेजी बोलना सीखें

अभ्यास मोड चुनें

हर मोड पूरी स्क्रीन का अभ्यास कक्ष खोलता है।

642 वाक्य
यदि वाक्य बहुत छोटे या लंबे हों, तो समायोजित करने के लिए Edit पर क्लिक करें।
1
And then I also think people resonate with this idea that these companies, that we are just passively consuming their products,
2
that they genuinely, not only do they not have our best interests at heart, but that they actually are deceiving us.
3
And I think that's resonating with people.
4
People are waking up to the fact that everything around us is getting worse, and they want to know why,
5
and they want to understand how they can inform themselves about it, if there's anything that can be done.
6
welcome to the gray area i'm jonquan hill filling in for sean illing i want you to stop
7
and really think of the last time you had a piece of chocolate.
8
How'd it taste?
9
Was it bland?
10
Maybe not as creamy and delicious as it used to be.
11
That's the experience Rachel Handler had, and it sent her on an epic journey
12
that took her around the country and into some of the darkest parts of 21st century corporations.
13
She wrote all about it for New York Magazine, where she's a staff writer.
14
I asked her to come on the show to talk about what happens when we get late -stage capitalism in our chocolate,
15
and in the rest of our lives, too.
16
Rachel Handler, welcome to The Gray Area.
17
Thank you so much for having me.
18
Okay, so you wrote this expansive piece about why chocolate just isn't doing what it's used to.
19
And it also gets at some larger themes.
20
But before we get into that, when did you first realize chocolate is kind of bad now?
21
I think for a very long time, I had, without sort of verbalizing it to myself, or others noticed that commercial chocolate,
22
like mass -produced chocolate, did not taste the way that I remembered it.
23
But I always had blamed myself.
24
I was like, it's my taste buds, or it's my brain damage, whatever.
25
It's my nostalgia.
26
But a couple of months before this story came about, I had been eating snow caps at the movies.
27
And I'd eaten like 15 of them.
28
And I was like, oh, these taste like nothing.
29
It kind of tastes like a combination of nothing and soap.
30
And I kind of lodged in the back of my mind
31
i think this is like a really common experience in in
32
modern day america right where you're like this tastes weird
33
but it's probably just me and or i'm imagining it a couple months went by
34
and in february on valentine's day to be specific um brad
35
reese who is the heir to the founder of reese's his
36
grandpa founded reese's in the 20s um came out on linkedin
37
saying they've ruined my grand hershey has ruined my grandfather's recipe and hershey bought the brand in 1963.
38
He was accusing them of using cheaper ingredients, of ruining the chocolate, of ruining the peanut butter.
39
And the story got quite a bit of pickup.
40
It was picked up by Colbert.
41
It was picked up by The Post.
42
And my editor reached out and said, are you seeing this?
43
Do you want to look into this further and kind of get at what's, you know, has chocolate changed?
44
What's going on?
45
Is there a bigger story here?
46
So I started looking into it in March and spent the next, you know, seven months just falling deep down this rabbit hole.
47
Okay.
48
So the enchantification of chocolate sends you on this mission.
49
We cannot talk about it without talking about Brad Reese.
50
And, you know, those who pay close attention to the world of chocolate probably heard about it.
51
Like you said, it was on Colbert.
52
It was posted on LinkedIn.
53
but give us a little bit more about him like
54
when did he realize oh y 'all are messing with my family's chocolate
55
I mean to hear him tell it he had been eating
56
he was obsessed with Reese's his whole life he ate a Reese's every single day
57
and was a huge fan of the brand a big brand evangelist
58
which is really funny because he's never worked for them um at all and I think Hershey finds him
59
Initially, I think they thought he was sort of a nuisance, and now I think they're pissed.
60
But he would walk around the streets.
61
He lives in Florida.
62
He lives in a retirement community.
63
And he would walk around the streets of Florida just wearing a Reese's t -shirt, like evangelizing about his family's product.
64
And he was very, very proud.
65
And he would, like I said, he would eat it every day.
66
And then in February, he tried one of the Valentine's Day mini hearts, which is like a seasonal edition of the Reese's Cup.
67
And he said it was inedible.
68
He spit it out.
69
He threw it away.
70
And that sort of led him to, you know, his chosen medium of LinkedIn, where he wrote an open letter to Todd Scott,
71
who does publicity for the brand and was saying, you know, was just coming out swinging, being like, you guys ruined the product.
72
Wow.
73
What should a good peanut butter cup actually taste like?
74
Because if the chocolate is bad and we're out here eating it, we probably don't even realize what we're missing.
75
Yeah, I think this is something that I got into with this woman named Beth Kimmerle, who runs this company called Attribute Analytics out of Chicago.
76
She describes herself as a sommelier for food and not for wine.
77
And she basically takes brands off the shelves, taste tests them.
78
She has a really, really rigorous proprietary system.
79
So I actually went to Chicago to her lab, to her kitchen, and we taste tested the Reese's that's on shelves now with these recreations
80
that she made of ones from the 1940s and ones from the 1960s.
81
And we talked a lot about how the peanut butter cup is a perfect confection, and it should be very blended.
82
You should be tasting everything at once the peanut butter, the chocolate, the textures.
83
And I think in a perfect world, you would be able to taste all those things and it would taste,
84
you know, like chocolate is supposed to taste sort of rounded and rich and not artificially sweet, not cloying, not waxy.
85
And something that
86
Brad hit the nail on the head on and that's her she admits to is that in their seasonal additions,
87
Reese's actually did replace cocoa butter with vegetable oil.
88
They took out the cocoa butter and put vegetable fats in it, which is very standard across the candy industry,
89
but it's gotten way worse in the last few years.
90
And that's why it tastes different.
91
That's a big reason why it tastes different, among other reasons.
92
Brad Reese is on medication that could be impacting his sense of taste.
93
How did you handle that discovery while you were reporting this story and the impact it could have on it?
94
So that came very late in my reporting, and it was really fascinating.
95
So he's on cancer medication.
96
He has non -Hodgkin's lymphoma, and he's had that for 15 years.
97
And we, Beth and I, when she recreated all of the Reese's, she overnighted them to Brad because we wanted to see,
98
okay, does he taste the difference?
99
And he really couldn't taste, he didn't seem to have a strong opinion on any of them, which was really interesting.
100
And Beth sort of halfway through the taste test was like, wait, Brad, are you on medications for your cancer?
101
And he was like, yeah, I'm on 17.
102
And she said, in my experience as a taster, that will affect your taste buds.
103
He's also on GLP -1s, as he revealed.
104
And he was like, kind of nothing tastes good anymore.
105
Nothing really excites me anymore.
106
And to me, that was just another fascinating wrinkle in the story, another layer to it all.
107
This idea that, you know, the consumer and our taste buds and our experience and the things
108
that affect our health and our lives and this like onslaught of Ozempic, there is another side to it, right?
109
Like it's not just that chocolate has changed.
110
It's like we've also changed.
111
And I think that's really interesting.
112
I think it complicated the story, but it didn't negate anything.
113
Yeah, it's interesting because you could almost ask, and I could see companies making the calculus,
114
does it matter what it tastes like if so many people can't really taste it the way they used to anyway?
115
It's so bleak.
116
It's so dystopian.
117
Very.
118
It's so dark.
119
But yeah, I mean, I'm sure that's part of the calculus.
120
I think something that I heard from a lot of my sources is
121
that these companies are always changing their ingredients and tweaking things and hoping consumers don't notice.
122
But they actually, if consumers do notice, they don't care unless it affects sales.
123
That's the time at which they're like, okay, we have to fix what we ruined here.
124
I think it's really interesting because throughout reading this piece,
125
you realize Brad is so invested in Reese's as a brand.
126
More so than it seems like a lot of his other family members are.
127
What does this company mean to him?
128
Why does it mean so much to him?
129
It's very personal for him.
130
And there was this sort of moment when we were doing the taste test
131
and he started riffing and reminiscing about his own father's death.
132
And he was like, when my father died on his deathbed, he started crying and said he didn't want to see his father in heaven.
133
He didn't want to die and be confronted with him.
134
And Brad said, why?
135
Why don't you want to see him?
136
And he said, because he made me promise I wouldn't sell the company.
137
And I did.
138
And I betrayed him.
139
And to me, that was just another just incredible, very American story, right?
140
This man betrayed his father.
141
He's terrified to die.
142
So much of this story is tied up in the financial decisions that men make, right?
143
These are all these men at the top who are, whether they're making $17 million a year because they're the CEO of Hershey
144
or whether they're in private equity or whether they're working very hard to make sure
145
that their shareholders are rewarded or whether they're selling their father's company.
146
There are just so many different layers to that part of it, and I think that was a really fascinating addition to the story.
147
Do you have any idea what
148
Brad's end goal is?
149
Like, what is it?
150
What does he want?
151
What would a solution look like for him?
152
I think he would want Hershey,
153
first off, to sort of admit to having wronged his family with this recipe, which they haven't done.
154
They've been really opaque about.
155
I mean, they claim they haven't changed the original Reese's Cup, I think, in my research and in the taste test.
156
And right there on the label, right, they admit to changing it.
157
And I had a fascinating conversation with them about what change means.
158
But Brad, I think, would want them to change.
159
To go back to the original recipe, which I don't think is even possible at this point,
160
something that Beth and I talked about is there's no real way to do an apples to apples test of what,
161
even though she did her best to recreate the original, there's no way to know what it originally tasted like.
162
It's made on different, it's made in a completely different factory with different, you know, completely different formulation, different products, different time, different era.
163
There's no way to go back.
164
But I do think he would prefer that they do their best to go back.
165
I think this looming question in the piece is, okay, he misses the way these peanut butter cups used to taste.
166
But does he miss that or does he miss the time when they tasted that way? For sure.
167
I mean, that's a component that we can't ignore.
168
And that's something that we talked about and that I get in the beginning, right?
169
It's like, how much of this is nostalgia?
170
And I think initially I wondered, is this really just about nostalgia?
171
Is this really just about our false memories of what things tasted like when we were kids?
172
But it's not.
173
I mean, we substantiated it throughout the piece that it actually has changed.
174
And I do think for him, it's less about going back to his childhood and more about righting a wrong that he sees his father.
175
He described it as squandering the company.
176
He said, I think he felt his father did that, and then Hershey has infinitely squandered, is what he said, the recipe and the company.
177
I want to get a little bit more into the manufacturing of chocolate
178
and how we ended up with this crappy chocolate in the first place.
179
And so I want to start with some definitions.
180
how is chocolate made exactly so chocolate i mean it's roasted the bean is roasted
181
and it's ground and it's grounded to something called chocolate liquor which is made up of cocoa nibs and um
182
and cocoa butter and normally that is combined with things like you know milk
183
and sugar to make what we recognize as as commercial chocolate um
184
but in the case of compound it they extract the cocoa butter and they replace it with vegetable fats, which changes the texture, changes the taste,
185
um, makes it much cheaper overall.
186
Um, and that is sort of what we're dealing with here.
187
And again, compound has been in use for decades and it's not inherently bad.
188
Sometimes it really does have an application.
189
Like when you, when you go to a dairy queen and you get like a dipped cone in chocolate,
190
that's made with coconut oil because it melts more slowly.
191
So it stays hard while you're eating it.
192
Um, but the sort of proliferation of compound and the fact
193
that they're not so on the label it'll say chocolate candy
194
or chocolatey if it's made with compound
195
because it cannot be identified as chocolate um but that's not something
196
that most people know to look for
197
so you pick up a mr good bar
198
and it says chocolate candy you don't know that that's not chocolate wait
199
if it says chocolate candy that's not chocolate no oh okay
200
because i was like oh that wise doing some work
201
but even reading chocolate candy oh my gosh that's that's a lot of candy that is not chocolate, actually.
202
I know.
203
It's very sneaky.
204
It's very sneaky.
205
Oh, my goodness.
206
One of the things that you discovered on this chocolate journey are these TikToks of floppy chocolate bars.
207
Yeah.
208
Why is the chocolate rubbery?
209
What's going on?
210
Well, so Hershey came out saying that that was normal, that if you heat and then sort of cool off chocolate,
211
it's going to behave that way.
212
But there are many chocolatiers, including one I spoke to named Constantine Svigo, who said he thinks that it's the PGPR,
213
which is a synthetic emulsifier and stabilizer that's in Hershey bars
214
and in other chocolates that has made it sort of behave in this uncanny way.
215
So it's not, I mean, you can watch his video.
216
He has a TikTok where he's like, I think it's the PGPR.
217
I'm not quite sure.
218
But, I mean, it's hard to say whether that would happen to a Hershey bar 20 years ago.
219
There's no way of knowing.
220
Oh, my gosh.
221
Yeah, I've made my fair share of s'mores, and I don't remember the chocolate bending.
222
True.
223
That's a good point.
224
That's a very good point.
225
Yeah.
226
On first glance, this may seem like a very basic story, but it really is a rich text.
227
I guess you could say it's a rich and chocolatey text.
228
And one thing that it touches on is how our food gets made and how it's regulated.
229
How is chocolate regulated?
230
So this is really interesting.
231
The FDA has since, for many years now, chocolate has been defined in a really specific way.
232
And it's defined differently in different countries.
233
But in the U .S., chocolate has to have, it has to have cocoa butter.
234
If it doesn't have cocoa butter, it isn't chocolate.
235
And it has to have a certain amount of chocolate liquor in it.
236
So I think, and it depends on the type of chocolate.
237
So milk chocolate, I think, needs 10%.
238
I think bittersweet is 35%.
239
So it varies across the type of chocolate, but there are strict standards.
240
But the FDA doesn't really have the capacity or the staffing
241
or the sort of wherewithal to go in and make sure that every single thing is what it says it is.
242
And during COVID, actually, they issued a reprieve for many food companies that if...
243
They wanted to change their ingredients during COVID.
244
They did not necessarily have to reflect that on the label.
245
So it's really, it really goes deep.
246
It's like, you don't quite know.
247
There is a really strict standard for chocolate, but the FDA is not investigating everything.
248
I do wonder if the FDA has time to monitor our chocolate when salad is giving everyone explosive diarrhea.
249
Exactly.
250
They have bigger fish to fry.
251
They're worried about many other things.
252
Support for the show comes from Cometeer.
253
These days, we've all been trained to appreciate good coffee, whether that's through social media, cooking shows, or just that one specific friend of ours.
254
But it also means that a bad cup of coffee is incredibly disappointing.
255
Cometeer sources coffee from the best roasters in the world, like Intelligentsia, and brews it to perfection,
256
and then flash freezes it at negative 321 degrees Fahrenheit with liquid nitrogen to lock in peak flavor and freshness.
257
It comes on dry ice right to your door in recyclable aluminum capsules.
258
All you have to do is melt it to make hot coffee, iced coffee, or espresso -style drinks like lattes in seconds.
259
No machine or plastic brew path required.
260
I tried Cometeer, and it was super easy and much faster and cleaner than getting my French press out every morning.
261
Try it for yourself.
262
And for listeners of this show, you can get $20 off at cometeer .com slash grayarea use code gray area
263
that's spelled c -o -m -e -t -e -e -r dot com slash gray area or use code gray area
264
support for the show comes from bombas as the days get shorter
265
and the temperatures drop you may find that you're drawn to your winter uniform
266
but no matter how bundled you are up top
267
It won't feel like it unless your feet are cozy and warm.
268
Bombas socks are the perfect addition to your winter wardrobe.
269
They're made with cozy materials like merino wool and cashmere to keep you warm.
270
And if you're looking for gifts this season, Bombas has something for everyone.
271
Socks, slippers, and cushy footwear that can take on the chill.
272
Plus, sports socks for runners and skiers alike.
273
You can even find buttery soft t -shirts, underwear, and base layers.
274
And for every purchase, Bombas also donates an essential clothing item to someone facing housing and security.
275
One purchased equals one donated with over 200 million donations and counting.
276
You can head over to bombas .com slash gray area and use code gray area for 20 % off your first purchase.
277
That's B -O -M -B -A -S dot com slash gray area, code gray area at checkout.
278
out there is an actual dark side to the chocolate industry could you lay
279
that out for us yeah
280
so chocolate is is often made with slave labor child labor um
281
it is not made often in an ethical way there are companies like tony's chocolate only
282
which are making it in an ethical slave labor freeway
283
and also there's you know there are a lot of concerns about deforestation
284
and climate change and all these things that are threatening cocoa itself.
285
So the industry is really in at what many of my sources described as like a crisis point.
286
You know, it's a difficult, it's a very volatile crop and the price will shoot up and go back down, especially in 2024, it went really,
287
really high, which is why we're seeing so much compound right now.
288
Is compound chocolate the ethical choice?
289
Like, I don't know, I think of lab diamonds like is compound chocolate the lab diamonds of candy no
290
because they're still using the cocoa bean they're just extracting the cocoa butter
291
so definitely not no your reporting takes us back to the farmers growing the cocoa
292
and i wonder what the price of cheap chocolate leaves out
293
and who absorbs those costs what happens to cocoa farmers
294
if the industry responds to years of exploiting this labor and they find ways to stop buying it.
295
Well, this is another sort of like rabbit hole that I go down, which is what
296
Beth calls foco, which is basically chocolate that's not made with cocoa at all.
297
And it's sort of an emerging industry where people are trying to replace chocolate
298
and make it with other ingredients like dates or coffee grounds or tofu skins or old beer.
299
And on its face, I think there's something there where initially you think, oh wow that's great they're trying to solve the problem
300
but it's actually really not an actual it's not really a solution i think this man clay gordon
301
that i spoke to who's a journalist
302
he has his own website called thechocolatelife .com
303
he spoke about how you know they're making all these claims about it being more sustainable
304
and more ethical but like none of that is actually
305
substantiated
306
and they have no they've never made it at a mass scale
307
they don't know what kind of environmental impact these things will have also it screws over the farmers
308
so they've been relying on for decades for this crop who just continue to get screwed over every
309
which way on top of that i tried some of it
310
and it tastes like shit it was bad oh yeah
311
it doesn't taste anything like chocolate it made me want the reese's uh
312
if we're living in a world where producing chocolate is expensive
313
producing ethical chocolate is even more expensive are we gonna live in a world where
314
real chocolate is for the wealthy
315
and the rest of us are going to have to eat rubbery bars if we want a sweet little treat?
316
Completely.
317
That is my fear and
318
that is what I came away from this piece being very concerned about is this idea
319
that in a society where everything is already so stratified and so imbalanced, this is just one small example of something
320
that will be reserved for the 1 % or people who can afford to buy a really expensive, nice actual chocolate bar.
321
And then the rest of us are going to be eating, you know, chocolate made from old beer or shitty compound.
322
That is a fear that I have for sure.
323
And it seems likely.
324
There are ways that I think the industry could work to pay farmers appropriately, to charge people maybe a little bit more,
325
but also just stop paying their CEOs $17 million a year and maybe absorb some of the costs there.
326
Were you surprised to see late -stage capitalism come for candy too? like it's in like it seems in everything
327
but yeah this had me like oh my gosh
328
it's everywhere we are in crisis everywhere yeah there are so many products that have
329
degraded that have gotten worse right but the thing about candy
330
and chocolate in particular is
331
that the whole point is its only purpose is to taste good
332
and to bring joy to people it has no other serves no other purpose
333
so for someone for for late stage capitalism to come for something that pure and specific is, to me, sort of the end of the line.
334
It's like, okay, we've completely lost the plot.
335
We've totally lost the plot here.
336
We can't talk about Big Chocolate without talking about Hershey, and you spent some time in Hershey, Pennsylvania for this story.
337
And reading it, it felt like Hershey, the company, the place, they're so reflective of America and the way it's changed over the years.
338
It started as a company town, the initial obsession with quality going off by the wayside for profit.
339
I just wonder how you think of Hershey in relation to America and the American dream and American history.
340
I think there's something very real there.
341
I don't doubt that perhaps Milton Hershey had had a utopian vision for his company town.
342
But already there's something creepy there, right?
343
But then on top of that, I think going there now, there were all these really American,
344
like you say American moments that that really struck me and
345
that I wanted to highlight like these old these old couples who I ran into
346
and I spoke to several elderly couples about how they come to the park
347
because there's a meal plan there where it costs like $150 for the whole summer
348
you can have two meals a day at Hershey Park
349
but um you have to separate the meals by three hours I think
350
so they sit there all day just to get two meals wow bring them home eat
351
that for a few days but they're spending
352
so much time just sitting you know it's 100 degrees out
353
when I went sitting at this hot theme park just to get like a cheese steak right
354
it's not healthy food and that's that's what they can afford
355
and it really devastated that really sent me spiraling
356
that really made me sad I mean I'm glad
357
that there's an option for them
358
but also I was like god we've come to such a dark place as a country
359
that this is how people are having to feed themselves
360
so I think that there are all these sort of moments scattered throughout the piece that, to me, really reflect where we are as a country,
361
where we are at the stage of capitalism, where, you know, how sort of these things I'm speaking about,
362
private equity and billionaires have destroyed the quality of life for so many people.
363
And it's really dark.
364
Yeah, you did so much for this story, including tasting lots of different chocolate formulas.
365
I wonder what you found.
366
What does good chocolate taste like?
367
What makes for good chocolate?
368
The best chocolate that I tried was this woman, Katrina Markoff.
369
She used to have this company called Vosge, and it's run out of Chicago.
370
And now she has a company called Violet Flame, and it's mostly online, but it's carried in some retailers, and it's really luxurious.
371
It's expensive.
372
But her idea is that it's sort of this heart medicine, which is how the Mayans spoke about it,
373
you know, way back when and you're supposed to sort of eat it in this really conscious, slow way, right?
374
Not the way we eat chocolate now where we're like gobbling down a bar.
375
I'm speaking about myself, but - Relatable.
376
But just, you know, you have one after dinner and that's your dessert and you're sort of savoring the experience.
377
And, you know, it is what I'm talking about, right?
378
The luxury 1 % experience.
379
She's like, it's like a yoga class or therapy.
380
You know, you're going to pay for it
381
and it's going to be - spread out over time
382
and it was so rich it tasted very it tasted very real she put
383
so much care into her ingredients she's getting you know stuff from all over the world from all these like really
384
small farms and small producers and I think you know
385
if there was a way to make
386
that more affordable for people I don't I don't know that
387
that is possible but
388
but there's also you know less extreme examples like I think
389
see Gary Guitard who I spoke to for the piece who um has guitar chocolate
390
he they supply chocolate to other companies
391
and also make like the best chocolate chips ever and that's
392
because he puts a lot of he uses small he grinds his chocolate into smaller particles
393
and has to use more cocoa butter and it's richer
394
and it's more decadent
395
so I love his chocolate chips he talked about C's candy as an example of someone
396
that you know stuck to their guns that's how he put it fine
397
and raw in Brooklyn I really like their chocolate
398
there are a lot of small good chocolate makers out
399
there it's just you know that's not what most people are able to buy or know about.
400
I just didn't know about any of this before I looked into this.
401
Is chocolate meant to be as accessible as it is?
402
I think of this idea of really taking the time and luxuriating when the chocolate experience.
403
And I think of the way we also talk about fast fashion, where it's, okay, think of what you need to buy,
404
buy less frequently, save that money so you can pay for something that's more expensive, that's more quality.
405
are we going about candy eating all wrong well i think this is a great question about
406
about life in general right now i think this is something
407
that i'm always like railing against in my in my personal
408
life where i'm like there should be friction in our lives
409
and we should not have everything at our fingertips at all times that's not natural
410
and it's not healthy
411
and it's not good for the earth it's not good for the human experience
412
i think a lot about this i think this anecdote
413
that's shared online all the time of kurt vonnegut going to buy an envelope
414
and his wife is like why are you going to buy it why you just order a hundred envelopes
415
and have them at the house he's like no
416
so much of the human experience i'm paraphrasing is just like going out
417
and being in the world and experiencing
418
that friction you should not be able to order something from amazon anything you want in the world
419
and have it at your house the next day like
420
that is not how we should be living i think absolutely
421
that you that you've hit on something there too
422
that we've we've made our lives so convenient and the cost of
423
that is very very high and I think that's another reason
424
that these chocolates are loaded with these emulsifiers and stabilizers
425
because they have to sit in a warehouse for two years well
426
and then the minute we decide oh I want this chocolate from Amazon it'll come tomorrow
427
but it's been sitting there for two years
428
and like it's absolutely our purchasing behavior
429
that is a problem too like we need to I think
430
we need to get a grip yeah I think about
431
that a lot
432
because it would be very easy to get my groceries delivered I could do it very easily
433
but I do appreciate making my grocery list getting on the train
434
or going for a walk
435
and just walking through the grocery store having to move my
436
cart around all these different things like it it's interaction with people it's it's making life less easy
437
but you're experiencing a little more completely and I feel the exact same way
438
and obviously there are people who can't do for whatever reason can't go get the groceries
439
but I feel the exact same way
440
I'm like I want to go to I I actively
441
I'm always trying to sort of make things a little bit more difficult
442
or complicated in that way because there's so few experiences like
443
that left everything has become so streamlined we're so so
444
so far from the means of production of everything
445
that sort of the height of luxury is having no idea where where you know how something is made
446
or where it's made and it just comes to your house
447
and you open your door
448
and you pull it inside you know i don't i don't want to live like
449
that and i think that we're due for a reckoning for sure in that way
450
support for this show comes from quince okay picture
451
this the new year is within view your loved ones wait expectantly for the perfect gift, and you're coming up empty.
452
We've all been there, but what if I told you there's a company out there
453
that actually makes things our loved ones want?
454
Enter Quince.
455
Quince focuses on high -quality staples made with premium materials, from fine jewelry to leather bags, hotel -quality bedding to chef -grade cookware.
456
Quince has something for everyone this holiday season.
457
The best part?
458
Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80 % less than similar brands.
459
Quince works directly with factories and cuts out the middlemen, so you can give luxury quality pieces without the luxury price tag.
460
I got to try some Quince, and I got one of their Mongolian cashmere tees.
461
A sweater t -shirt like that is perfect for
462
that transitional weather moment we're in when it's cool in the morning and hot in the afternoon.
463
Give the gift of quality this holiday season.
464
Download the Quince app for app -exclusive offers or go to quince .com.
465
Get free shipping on your order and 365 -day returns now available in Canada and the UK too.
466
And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was the gray area.
467
It's the best way to support the show.
468
Support for the show comes from TalkHiatry.
469
Finding the right mental health treatment, one that works for you, can feel overwhelming.
470
TalkHiatry can help you move from I know I need help to actually having a psychiatrist who listens, as well as a clear, personalized treatment plan.
471
Talkiatry is a 100 % online psychiatry practice that provides comprehensive evaluations,
472
diagnoses, and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, and more.
473
Unlike therapy -only platforms, Talkiatry is psychiatry.
474
You're seeing a medical provider that can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication whenever it's appropriate.
475
Insurance can be simple as well
476
because Talkiatry has more than 800 clinicians who are all in
477
network with major insurers with talkiatry your provider takes the time to get to know
478
you they build a personalized treatment plan
479
and offer real support through consistent evidence -based care you see the same person every time
480
so you're not starting over each visit
481
that way as you make progress your treatment can evolve with
482
you go to talkiatry .com gray area to complete the short assessment
483
and get matched with an in -network psychiatrist in just a few
484
That's T -A -L -K -I -A -T -R -Y dot com slash gray area to get matched in minutes.
485
TalkHigherTree .com slash gray area.
486
You've had this very luxurious chocolate.
487
You went to professionals to taste test older versions of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
488
You've also tried other chocolates.
489
But one thing I found interesting is that you didn't love the older versions.
490
Why do you think that is?
491
Oh, I did.
492
I mean, so this is what was confusing is that when we did recreate,
493
when Beth did recreate, I loved the peanut butter in the 1940s version was so good and like gritty, kind of sandy, tasted really, really good.
494
I really liked the chocolate that she used for the 1960s version.
495
It was like a European style chocolate doing like an American chocolate drag.
496
And, you know, when I knew everything that was in front of me day one of the taste test,
497
she was identifying everything and showing me everything.
498
And I really loved the originals and then noticed a huge shift
499
when I got to the one that she pulled off the shelves.
500
I was like, this is chemically and waxy and oily and I don't like it.
501
But then the next day we did a blind taste test
502
and in the field I was not able to really identify a huge difference.
503
So that kind of sent me reeling and I was like, do I like insidification? is my palate trained to like shittier stuff
504
because that's what I've been raised
505
or that's what I've had in the last 10 years yeah it's like do we love the artificial flavors
506
because I think that's the running joke it's like the red dye 40 makes
507
it tasty it doesn't it doesn't add anything
508
but I don't know maybe have we learned to like our crappy chocolate perhaps
509
this is why it's not a simple answer like there's no
510
sort of like it doesn't narrow down to one answer I think there are
511
so many factors at play here and i think it's
512
so interesting how you know i i also talk about how butterfinger a few years ago
513
they shifted it to be made with more natural ingredients
514
and healthier and i think a better quality chocolate and all of
515
that and people got really mad
516
and they didn't like it they they liked their you know their artificial butterfinger
517
and i do think that's fascinating i think people just don't like change no matter what um i think
518
that i wonder if like the consumer will ever be satisfied.
519
And I'm speaking for myself as well.
520
Is there a line when it crosses over from we want to keep quality to, okay, now we're doing nostalgia for nostalgia's sake?
521
Because, you know, there's always going to be progress.
522
There's always going to be new technology.
523
There's always going to be new things.
524
And, you know, I'm not trying to make America candy again,
525
but I do want it to taste the way it's always tasted to be like where's
526
that line well you've touched on something really interesting
527
that i didn't have space to get into in the piece
528
which is the sort of circle of like i care about ingredients i care about quality
529
and suddenly i'm agreeing with rfk and i'm all right yeah um
530
and we have to be very careful not to get
531
that extreme like i don't think i'm not saying
532
that we should be drinking raw chugging raw milk
533
but i do feel like um there is a there is a line
534
i think we can care we want i think
535
we should want to be informed we should want things to be as natural as possible in terms of,
536
like, I don't want to be eating TBHQ when it's shown, you know, negative effects to lab animals.
537
I just, you know what I mean?
538
Like, I don't want to be eating things that are banned in Japan, that are banned at Whole Foods,
539
but I also don't want to be so far down this rabbit hole
540
that suddenly I'm coming out the other side and I'm like, yeah, MAGA all of a sudden.
541
I do think that, like, there's a really interesting, like, dichotomy there.
542
Why do you think this story has resonated with people so much.
543
I think there are different levels to why.
544
I think, number one, it's just literally people saying, oh, my, I've had so many people reaching out saying,
545
oh, my God, I knew it was different, but I didn't know why.
546
And I thought it was just me.
547
That has been the greatest sort of the most prominent response to the piece.
548
And then I also think people resonate with this idea that we're being, you know, being lied to is a little bit dramatic,
549
but that these companies that we are just passively consuming their products, that they genuinely, not only do they not have our best interests at heart,
550
which is a joke I make in the beginning, but that they actually are deceiving us.
551
And I think that's resonating with people.
552
I think people are waking up to the fact that everything around us is getting worse, and they want to know why,
553
and they want to understand how they can inform themselves about it, if there's anything that can be done.
554
I think that's such a good point, because in the piece you write, the problem was not just that chocolate tasted different.
555
It was the added indignity of being told that it didn't.
556
Do you think people would care less if Hershey was like, yeah, girl, we changed the chocolate.
557
It's like this now.
558
This is what it is maybe
559
they would I certainly would there's no story really right you're like oh okay great they changed it
560
and it's shittier and they're admitting it
561
I don't know I think at least
562
there would be a level of like okay we're all
563
we're all being honest with each other we're all being real with each other
564
there's I think there's a there's a deep insult added to the injury of knowing not only
565
that our chocolate tastes worse but that we're being told it doesn't taste worse
566
and everything's fine and I think that's the case for
567
so much of what it feels like to be alive right
568
now at this time in this country is we're being told
569
that things are okay when we know
570
that they're not yeah it's like it's like it's like living in a constant state of being gaslit
571
and i just wonder why whether it's people in power corporations all these institutions why why not be up front
572
i mean i you could even say people may not do anything even
573
if you're honest they how are they going to make 17 million dollars for their ceo
574
you know what i mean like they all they care about is money all they care about is the bottom line.
575
All they care about is, like I said, I keep hitting this private equity shareholder vet.
576
Those are the things they care about.
577
They do not care about the consumer experience.
578
They only care about the consumer experience when it starts to affect sales.
579
So there would be no benefit in them leveling with people.
580
There are lots of stakeholders when it comes to chocolate there's policymakers, there's companies, there's individuals.
581
If we want to live in a world where we have access to good chocolate
582
and it can be an ordinary pleasure and not a splurge
583
or something you have to save for or something for just the 1%, what needs to change?
584
What can those companies do?
585
What can those policymakers do?
586
And what can we do?
587
I think that is the question that
588
Like, if I had the answer to it, you know, I would be the one with the 17 million.
589
I'd be the CEO of Hershey.
590
I think, you know, there are people who have been trying to keep good people like
591
Clay Gordon or people like, you know, who are in the industry,
592
like Gary Guitart, who have been trying to solve for this for a really long time.
593
And Gary, you know, at at the expense of his own bottom line will often like he said, when chocolate went up, like,
594
I don't think for a while they were charging their customers more.
595
They were absorbing that cost.
596
And I absolutely think that companies like Hershey can afford to absorb that cost.
597
I don't know anything about, you know, Hershey's day -to -day operations, but I have to imagine that there's a lot of wiggle room in that.
598
They don't have to be making billions of dollars.
599
You know what I mean?
600
Like, there's a way for them to do this that is far less, you know, financially beneficial for a few people.
601
And I think that is where we need to start.
602
And then I think, obviously, there have to be protections and rules put in place for the farmers and the production.
603
And I just think it will require a lot of different industries and people cooperating in a way that seems highly unlikely.
604
Unfortunately, I think we're more likely to be headed for the snowpiercer, back of the train, front of the train,
605
good chocolate, you know, beer chocolate scenario.
606
What do we lose when we stop expecting these small things to be good?
607
when we stop expecting that chocolate bar that we got as a little treat to be tasty?
608
That's such a good question.
609
I mean, I think it feels like a really demoralizing sort of
610
hope -killing experience to have even the most simple pleasures left to us be false or denied.
611
I think it's like a very—I mean, I don't want to put too dramatic of a point on it, but it feels dehumanizing to be like,
612
you can't even have real chocolate anymore.
613
You can't even have like, the tiniest delight in your day.
614
Okay, I have one question that I was wondering throughout reading this entire article.
615
Did eating all this chocolate make your tummy hurt?
616
Because I would feel so sick by the end of all of this.
617
I am.
618
I'm lactose intolerant, so that was tough.
619
Ah, Rachel!
620
You were playing a dangerous game, girl.
621
Like, I write about it made me break out really bad.
622
Like, I was getting, like, cystic acne on my chin every time I ate the fake chocolate, which is, like, an alarming sign.
623
I think, yeah, I was suffering physically for sure.
624
Like, I feel like I'm 10 % uglier as a result of this story than I used to be.
625
And like, I'm not going back.
626
Like, I'm not bouncing back.
627
It's just something is different in me biologically.
628
My chemical makeup has changed.
629
Rachel Handler, thank you so much for joining us.
630
If people want to find more of your work, where can they find you?
631
New York Magazine.
632
I'm a writer there and at Vulture.
633
So yeah, you can find me there.
634
You can find me on Instagram.
635
I'm somehow still on X.
636
I'm all over the cursed internet.
637
All right.
638
Thank you so much.
639
Thank you.
640
As always, we want to know what you thought of the episode, so drop us a line at the gray area at vox .com.
641
And if you enjoy our reporting and want to hear more from Vox journalists,
642
then consider becoming a member of the Vox community on Patreon at patreon .com slash Vox.

ऐप डाउनलोड करें

धाराप्रवाह बोलने के लिए ज़रूरी सब कुछ

AI उच्चारण स्कोरहर वाक्य का स्कोर
IPA अभ्यासहर ध्वनि में महारत
शब्दावलीअपना शब्द भंडार बनाएँ
शब्द गेमखेलते हुए सीखें
QR स्कैन करें
QR स्कैन करें

उसी चैनल से

FOR YOU

अनुशंसित वीडियो

इस पाठ की शब्दावली और बोलने के सुझाव

यह स्पीकिंग पाठ वीडियो “Chocolate is getting worse. So is everything else” पर आधारित है। इस वीडियो में शैडोइंग के लिए 642 वाक्य और 7802 शब्द हैं। बोला गया हिस्सा 41:31 लंबा है। वक्ता तेज़ बोलता है, लगभग 188 शब्द प्रति मिनट, इसलिए जुड़ी हुई और कमज़ोर ध्वनियाँ ज़्यादा मिलेंगी। 83% शब्द अंग्रेज़ी के 3,000 सबसे आम शब्दों में से हैं; बाकी शब्द अभ्यास से पहले देख लेना अच्छा रहेगा।

इस वीडियो की मुख्य शब्दावली

वीडियो के 15 सीखने लायक शब्द, उच्चारण और अर्थ के साथ:

शब्दउच्चारणअर्थ
butter संज्ञा/ˈbʌtɚ/घी, मक्खन
gray विशेषण/ɡɹeɪ/धूसर
candy संज्ञा/ˈkæn.di/मिसरी, खण्ड
compound संज्ञा/ˈkɑmpaʊnd/मिश्रण
peanut संज्ञा/ˈpiˌnʌt/मूँगफली
ruin संज्ञा/ˈɹuː.ɪn/खँडहर, खंडहर
farmer संज्ञा/ˈfɑɹ.mɚ/किसान
ethical विशेषण/ˈɛθɪkəl/नैतिक
meal संज्ञा/ˈmiːl/भोजन, जेमन
medication संज्ञा/mɛdɪˈkeɪʃən/उपचार, औषधि
capitalism संज्ञा/ˈkæp.ə.təlˌɪzm̩/पूंजीवाद
nostalgia संज्ञा/nɑˈstæld͡ʒə/उदासी, गृहातुरता
label संज्ञा/ˈleɪ.bəl/लेबल
layer संज्ञा/ˈleɪ̯ɚ/परत, तह
inform क्रिया/ɪnˈfɔɹm/सूचित करना, बताना

वीडियो में आने वाली फ़्रेज़ल वर्ब

शब्दअर्थ
pick up क्रियाउठाना
go out क्रियाबाहर निकलना, निकलना

दोहराने लायक वाक्य

वीडियो के छोटे, पूरे वाक्य जिन्हें आप रोज़ की बातचीत में इस्तेमाल कर सकते हैं:

  • Why don't you want to see him?
  • Why do you think that is?
  • I just, you know what I mean?
  • You know what I mean?
  • Did eating all this chocolate make your tummy hurt?

इस वीडियो का व्याकरण

वक्ता जिन संरचनाओं का सबसे अधिक प्रयोग करता है, वीडियो के असली शब्दों के साथ:

संरचनावीडियो में
Present perfect continuous have/has been + -ing — पहले शुरू हुआ काम जो अब भी जारी हैthey've been relying · it's been sitting · have been trying
“used to” used to + क्रिया — बीती आदत या स्थिति जो अब नहीं हैused to be · used to anyway · used to have
Present perfect have/has + past participle — बीता हुआ काम जिसका असर अभी भी हैthey've ruined · has changed · we've also changed
Passive voice be + past participle — ज़ोर इस पर कि क्या होता है, न कि कौन करता हैcan be done · was picked · was posted

ध्यान देने योग्य उच्चारण

वक्ता 160 बार संक्षिप्त रूपों का प्रयोग करता है, जैसे I'm, don't, they're। इन्हें वैसे ही छोटा बोलें जैसा आप सुनते हैं।

  • “th” की ध्वनियाँ: ethical /ˈɛθɪkəl/, clothing /ˈkloʊðɪŋ/, leather /ˈlɛðɚ/, wealthy /ˈwɛl.θi/, threaten /ˈθɹɛt.n̩/
  • “sh” और “zh” की ध्वनियाँ: luxury /ˈlʌk.ʃə.ɹi/, medication /mɛdɪˈkeɪʃən/, shelf /ʃɛlf/, gosh /ɡɑːʃ/, artificial /ˌɑː.tɪˈfɪʃ.əl/
  • लंबे शब्द — बलाघात सही रखें: ingredient /ɪnˈɡɹiːdi.ənt/, medication /mɛdɪˈkeɪʃən/, capitalism /ˈkæp.ə.təlˌɪzm̩/, complicated /ˈkɑm.plɪˌkeɪ.tɪd/, artificial /ˌɑː.tɪˈfɪʃ.əl/

हिंदी भाषियों के लिए मुश्किल ध्वनियाँ:

  • /v/ और /w/ का फ़र्क़ — /v/ में ऊपर के दाँत निचले होंठ को छूते हैं, /w/ में होंठ गोल होते हैं: equity /ˈɛk.wɪ.ti/, vegetable /ˈvɛd͡ʒ.tə.bəl/, solve /sɒlv/, slave /sleɪv/, provider /pɹəˈvaɪ.də(ɹ)/
  • /z/ — इसे “ज” (/dʒ/) न बनाएँ: capitalism /ˈkæp.ə.təlˌɪzm̩/, seasonal /ˈsiːzənəl/, groceries /ˈɡɹoʊ.s(ə.)ɹiz/, anxiety /æŋˈzaɪ.əti/, physically /ˈfɪz.ɪ.kli/
  • शब्द की शुरुआत में s + व्यंजन — पहले “इ” न जोड़ें: slave /sleɪv/, strict /stɹɪkt/, sneaky /ˈsniːki/

इस वीडियो से अभ्यास कैसे करें

  1. पहले बिना बोले पूरा वीडियो एक बार सुनें और जो शब्द नहीं आते उन्हें लिख लें।
  2. 0.75× गति से शुरू करें, एक-एक वाक्य की शैडोइंग करें, और सहज लगने पर सामान्य गति पर लौटें।
  3. अपनी आवाज़ रिकॉर्ड करें और मूल से तुलना करें, ख़ासकर butter, gray, candy जैसे शब्दों पर ध्यान दें।

शैडोइंग तकनीक क्या है?

शैडोइंग (Shadowing) एक विज्ञान-समर्थित भाषा सीखने की तकनीक है जो मूल रूप से पेशेवर दुभाषिया प्रशिक्षण के लिए विकसित की गई थी। विधि सरल लेकिन शक्तिशाली है: आप मूल अंग्रेज़ी ऑडियो सुनते हैं और तुरंत इसे ज़ोर से दोहराते हैं — जैसे वक्ता की छाया 1-2 सेकंड की देरी से। शोध से पता चलता है कि यह उच्चारण सटीकता, स्वर, लय, जुड़ी हुई ध्वनियाँ, सुनने की समझ और बोलने की प्रवाहशीलता में काफ़ी सुधार करता है।

शैडोइंग तकनीक: पूरी चरण-दर-चरण गाइड पढ़ें →