ฝึกพูดภาษาอังกฤษด้วยเทคนิค Shadowing จากวิดีโอ: Fear of Forgetting
กำลังสร้างบทเรียน...
1
At best, forgetting is simply inconvenient.
2
At its worst, it can destroy a life.
3
Multiple lives.
4
There are many truly awful ways you can die, but significantly few fates worse than dying.
5
Not to mention that the chances of ever experiencing any of them are astronomically slim.
6
Except dementia.
7
I think dementia is one of those few, and it's one of my greatest fears.
8
While other fears, say, a fear of deep water, cause what is a comparatively innocent distrust, forgetting is unavoidable.
9
Dementia is uncontrollable.
10
We have no way to slow its advancing emptiness.
11
Dementia takes everything from you before, finally, you lose yourself, and while there are suggested ways to outrun it, it's hard to be sure that you've ever truly escaped.
12
Even then, you may still forget large fragments of your life, submit to false memories, or lose important information forever.
13
We are all running out of time.
14
Dementia refers to any sort of memory loss related confusion.
15
It can be caused by a very long list of different diseases.
16
Some of them revolve around simple deficits, such as a vitamin B12 deficiency, but others are a bit more complicated.
17
The most common cause of dementia is Alzheimer's disease.
18
It's currently ranked as the sixth leading cause of death for adults.
19
The disease is caused by abnormalities with two different kinds of protein in the brain.
20
One of them is linked to chromosome 21, which might be why 70% of people with Down syndrome develop Alzheimer's after the age of 40.
21
Down syndrome is caused by an extra copy of chromosome 21.
22
This chromosome contains the instructions for the production of a protein called amyloid precursor protein.
23
But it's what this protein breaks down into that's concerning, amyloid beta.
24
Amyloid beta protein can stick to other amyloid beta proteins, gradually building up into a a hard, insoluble plaque between cells.
25
Healthy brains usually clear out amyloid buildup, but those with Alzheimer's don't seem to be able to.
26
Thus, these plaques never stop accumulating.
27
The other toxic brain abnormality in Alzheimer's has to do with tau proteins.
28
Tau is responsible for preserving the structure of the part of neurons that deliver nutrients to other cells in the brain.
29
In Alzheimer's, these tau proteins become chemically sticky and tangle up together, compromising the delivery network and starving your brain cells to death in the process.
30
There are seven stages to the disease, the first being the only stage in which everything functions normally,
31
but past that, it's only a matter of sinking deeper and deeper into the horror.
32
We used to be entirely unable to offer a diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease before somebody with it died.
33
An autopsy would be performed to reveal what Alzheimer's always leaves behind, an aggressively shrunken brain, and it would be declared that this is what the patient died from.
34
Of course, this was not very consoling.
35
With brain tech capable of amyloid imaging, we now deal with a new dilemma.
36
Now we can tell very far in advance whether or not someone has Alzheimer's, but there's still no cure.
37
It's at this point that some people and their caretaker-to-be are prescribed antidepressants instead.
38
And what's left but a brain subjected to itself?
39
a long unraveling, an insidious disease advancing your synapses' self-destruction.
40
Phenomenology is the philosophy of lived experience, of phenomena.
41
It studies the way consciousness functions as an interpreter of the world.
42
Two ideas from this field in particular can help us understand what it's like to have dementia.
43
For a long time, phenomenologists have been using metaphors to help us understand their arguments.
44
Martin Heidegger saw consciousness as a forced clearing into which things are allowed into the light.
45
Applied to dementia, this metaphor proves especially eerie.
46
The clearing slowly invaded by the encroaching woods until no light shines.
47
There's an ancient Greek word that's repeated a lot throughout his writings, aletheia, meaning truth.
48
Literally, the word means that which is unconcealed, discovered, or even unforgotten.
49
He proposes that truth is, in fact, that which does not escape notice.
50
This way of thinking about truth was very important to Heidegger.
51
He believes that everything possesses its own aletheia, that every phenomenon is capable of revealing itself to us as itself, not disguised as some other thing.
52
We are merely the witnesses to this fundamental process.
53
Consciousness only sets the stage, allows the entities of the world to reveal themselves to us.
54
But Heidegger didn't just see truth as a revealing process.
55
He also understood that it involves an element of concealment.
56
What is hidden is only hidden in relation to what has been revealed.
57
Any phenomenon can be understood in a myriad of different ways, but every way we choose to approach something,
58
every revelation, conceals, if but for a moment, all other interpretations.
59
New discoveries replace what was previously understood.
60
Any sense of deja vu or nostalgia seems to come all of its own, but when we can trace back our memories through time,
61
we cannot deny that it feels as if something hidden in the source of those feelings has now been revealed to us.
62
Through this process of unconcealment, the world as an inert force comes alive, gains fuller meaning.
63
It breathes deep according to the inhale and exhale of your memories.
64
Alzheimer's disease begins as it ends, as a negative gap, a growing void that conceals itself.
65
The second stage of Alzheimer's is when the symptoms of the disease begin to develop.
66
Very mild forgetfulness, a difficulty with words every now and then.
67
You'd never guess it was Alzheimer's.
68
The idea doesn't ever cross your mind.
69
Why should you think that there's anything wrong?
70
We've all got to get old sometime.
71
Isn't that going to have some effect on us?
72
isn't a natural part of aging.
73
It's only by looking back that you can see that the signs were there all along.
74
It's the first weed growing in the clearing.
75
In the Phenomenology of Perception, the philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty pays special focus to the perceptual networks of the body,
76
confronting a strange lack in the previous conversations had by these kinds of philosophers.
77
Our consciousness isn't some detached, distant beholder of the world, he exclaims.
78
It's bound to a body, subject to physical influences.
79
Taking this into account, Merleau-Ponty later called embodied consciousness a chiasm.
80
Chiasms are X-shaped structures, nerves or tendons crossing over each other at a junction.
81
This nomenclature is meant to illustrate the way your body, as the instrument of sensation, can itself be sensed.
82
How with one hand you can feel your other.
83
It's a folding in on itself, and in between.
84
Merleau-Ponty tells us that the world holds within itself a depth of experience, a depth from which the significance of things arises.
85
As the intertwining of past and present, imaginary and immediate, body and world, our existence as Chiasm is that depth.
86
Depth is the dimension of dimensions, a container for the locales of space and time.
87
It is also a dimension in which things or elements of things envelop each other.
88
This tension between them as they compete for our attention is precisely what constitutes this depth.
89
It is surprisingly difficult to keep something buried.
90
In his fascinating book Underland, Robert McFarland describes how ancient structures have begun to emerge from the depths and folds of the earth.
91
Glaciers yield up their frozen bodies, and dying rivers expose old monuments out from beneath their waters.
92
Even when we want to bury something deep into the obscurity of oblivion, desperately try to forget something.
93
It painfully protrudes back into our memory.
94
The depths cough up all that is buried.
95
Merleau-Ponty's example of depth is of a red dress.
96
Its red fabric leaps out.
97
Its color is obvious.
98
But at the same time, it is sieged by a remembering of the past.
99
It is a punctuation in the field of red things.
100
A field which includes graduation robes, southern Utah desert, the paprika and the deviled eggs from that one cafe, and.. and...
101
Our memories exist out there in the world.
102
The tension between the significances of past occurrences and those of the present is lodged within things.
103
As such we do not only look inward to see our past, but outward into the world.
104
This is the chiasm of our existence.
105
To touch is to be touched.
106
The word is so scary.
107
It's a bad word.
108
Alzheimer's disease usually starts in your hippocampus, one of the regions of the brain associated with long-term memory, and your frontal lobe, the seat of higher decision-making.
109
It doesn't have to, though.
110
It could form anywhere in the brain, causing some pretty eerie symptoms.
111
The disease begins to spread.
112
It isn't going to stop, either.
113
It begins to take more than just a moment to work things out in your head, to process what people are saying to you.
114
Then there are the questions.
115
Where are we?
116
What are we doing?
117
But you've already asked that three times already.
118
It's okay.
119
You don't remember doing that.
120
These delays are eerie, uncomfortable.
121
Your family casually throw around your mishaps behind your back.
122
Do you think there's something happening to her?
123
I don't know, but the other day she… You can hear them through the walls while you try to take a nap.
124
The human tragedy is that your existence is wholly confined to the tissue inside of your skull, a lump of electric fat, the consistency of tofu.
125
Now, the same mind that previously expanded outward into infinity can no longer breach those pale domed walls of bone.
126
The skull is an incredibly claustrophobic space, and you can feel it suffocating you as the brain fog sets in.
127
You can feel your finite being, your weakness, but you refuse to believe it.
128
There may be a reason why at the bottom of Pandora's box, greater than disaster and violence and sin, the greatest evil of all lay hope.
129
Aside from forgetfulness, one of the early symptoms most people think of
130
when they think about Alzheimer's is the negative effect it has on language.
131
Patients struggle to find the right words for things they used to be able to name effortlessly.
132
Those that speak more than one language often revert solely to their mother tongue.
133
It's part of their gradual failure to identify the things and people around them.
134
Merleau-Pontyan scholar Glenn Mazis explains that depth, the fight between the past and present world for what something will signify, is not constituted of, say,
135
separate reds, one for the dress, one for the graduation gown,
136
the desert rock, etc, etc. So he says that the red perceived is precisely this play of significances.
137
Depth explains how the mind shuffles meaning, but also describes how that meaning is stored.
138
The world absorbs the significances of our memories and experiences.
139
Every individual instance of a door is one of many doors and has the power to remind us of the others.
140
In this way, every object is a symbol with reference to itself as much
141
as it is a symbol for the totality of its existence as a concept.
142
Both of these symbols are actually two sides of the same coin though.
143
A name.
144
There are two different theories on how names work.
145
One of them, descriptivism, states that names operate according to a description of the object.
146
So if I call something a tiger, I mean something that is a large four-legged cat with orange and black stripes.
147
Saul Kripke, in his book Naming a Necessity, disagrees with this theory.
148
He points out that if we were to take a lion
149
and cosmetically alter it so that it fit every description of a tiger, it wouldn't suddenly be accurate to refer to it as a tiger.
150
The main concern behind Kripke's theory, anti-descriptivism, is finding what makes an object the same object even if all of its descriptive features have changed.
151
The answer, he provides, is that the name takes precedence.
152
Naming something is what identifies it, not describing it.
153
The philosopher Shlavoj Zizek has explored some of the interesting implications behind this idea.
154
For one thing, he points out that what anti-descriptivism shows us, though it doesn't know it, is that it is actually the name itself which creates an identity.
155
Objects need a name to recognize themselves, and that's especially true of people.
156
If a name is what tethers an object to its identity throughout its many changes, then there must be something in the name which represents that object better than the object itself possibly could.
157
A self-referential symbol.
158
Because names radically represent objects this way, they also capture that unattainable something which is in that object more than any given version of it.
159
A redness more red than any particular red.
160
This is how language establishes its connection to depth.
161
also enact a play of significances.
162
The word red could refer to any shade of red, anything that is red, all of it grasping at that unattainable redness.
163
A name unites this given field, ties it together into a knot of meaning.
164
Freud displayed this ability of language with his practice of free association.
165
It was common for him to ask his patients to respond to a prompt with the first word that came to mind.
166
Doing so would assist in therapy by revealing the patient's experiences, their memories.
167
And where there is memory, there is depth.
168
But how to explain the dreaded moment in which a loved one with dementia fails to recognize you?
169
Anti-descriptivism also shows us that without a proper signifier, a name, our understanding of the object itself is lost.
170
Without a name, loved ones become endigmas.
171
We can't tell who they are.
172
What we're left with are only descriptions, a list of attributes sourced from a fading memory.
173
Kripke does not tell us that descriptions cease to be descriptions, only that they are not enough to identify an object the way a name is.
174
Is this inadequacy of description not displayed best of all when someone with dementia calls you someone else's name?
175
Maybe it was the name of one of your parents, or a relative.
176
You likely satisfied some part of their description, but that is not who you are.
177
The clearing is overgrown with thickets and thorns.
178
The true nature of things now conceals itself.
179
Escapes notice.
180
All of this is to say that, philosophically considered, dementia is the total loss of life's symbolic richness, and the world can only be understood symbolically.
181
In fiction and art too, forgetting is linked to this feeling of the symbolic rotting away into tomorrow.
182
You can't discuss dementia like this without mentioning The Caretaker, specifically his work Everywhere at the End of Time,
183
a six-hour collection of albums which together thrust you headfirst into the deteriorating mind of an Alzheimer's patient.
184
Over those six and a half hours, you'll hear old music slow down, reverse, crackle, distort, echo, and die.
185
The albums each correspond to one of the stages of Alzheimer's, and could be summarized by one word,
186
daydream, nightmare, reality, rupture, power, and...
187
They were originally released over six months intervals to give a sense of time passing, but it's recommended that it's listened to all in one sitting.
188
If you haven't ever listened to Everywhere at the end of time and are considering it, you should probably consider your mental health beforehand.
189
On the first listen, the collection feels evil, ominous, or demonic if you're in a particularly sensitive mood.
190
Different sections can evoke dangerously powerful emotions.
191
It is, simply put, devastatingly effective at what it tries to achieve.
192
All that unpleasantness is the point, of course.
193
Leland Kirby, the artist behind the character of The Caretaker, stops at nothing to make you understand.
194
Every stage is accompanied by detailed descriptions and track names, both of which are essential to understanding the emotions that accompany the disease.
195
For example, the tracks Glimpses of Hope in Trying Times, Denial Unraveling, and Surrendering to Despair tell their own story beyond just the music.
196
The genius of Everywhere at the End of Time is how the music it samples, and the memories those samples represent, are used.
197
Certain tunes slowly dissipate into unrecognizable silhouettes.
198
And after a certain point, even when we cannot describe the music playing amidst the confusion, Some people have still been able to name the samples flipping in and out.
199
But knowing they're there does not mean that we can recognize them.
200
That they aren't lost amidst the pandemonium.
201
Out of the many effects Kirby uses to depict the distortion of memory, the most common one is a kind of vinyl static.
202
It echoes explosively in your skull.
203
But static has a dual meaning.
204
It refers to this hissing we associate with the grime lodged
205
into the grooves of aged vinyl records just as much as it does a complete absence of movement.
206
I've always thought the combination of these two definitions was rather unsettling.
207
It reminds me of the decay of Heidegger's clearing, of the drying up of Merleau-Ponty's depth, the hardening of active neurons in the plaque.
208
The end of the project is genuinely incomprehensible.
209
Even though it was all made from pre-existing records, I can't even tell what instruments they're playing at the end here.
210
And then, we're met with a horrible silence.
211
The album covers for Everywhere at the End of Time were done by Ivan Seale, a long-time friend of Kirby's.
212
It isn't the first time they've worked together.
213
He also collaborated with Kirby to create the album covers for An Empty Bliss Beyond This World and Take Care, It's a Desert Out There, amongst others.
214
Seale's paintings are hard to process.
215
It's never obvious exactly what these paintings are actually of.
216
The longer you look at them, the more confusing they get.
217
And just when you think you might have figured it out, there's always that lingering doubt.
218
It's an uncanny rendition of Rorschach's inkblot test.
219
Steele had a collection showcased in 2011 titled The Object Hurts the Space, in which many of these confusing characters of real objects,
220
placed against their usual pale backdrops, were displayed.
221
Some have wondered if Steele didn't construct sculptures for his paintings as a model during of creation, but fittingly enough, he says he paints his imagined objects from memory,
222
with its unavoidable errors.
223
Siegel himself has also created some experimental recordings, playing the tracks during his showings.
224
He uses a computer program to build nonsensical sentences out of a given set of words.
225
Many of the tracks share the theme of free association, an activity reflected in the paintings themselves.
226
but his artwork grows ever more disturbing when paired with Kirby's music.
227
The way these covers precariously grow more violent, abstract, and unidentifiable in relation to Alzheimer's isn't just a metaphor.
228
Take a look at this.
229
Back before there was amyloid imaging, doctors relied on tests such as these to judge whether or not a patient could be diagnosed with Alzheimer's.
230
I'm particularly fascinated by this one, called the clock test, in which patients were asked to draw the numbers on a clock.
231
What fascinates me is the way you can plainly see the cognitive decline, just like in Sio's artwork for the album.
232
The covers to Everywhere at the End of Time remind me, as they do others, of the last self-portraits of artist William Utermolen before he died from Alzheimer's.
233
They document six years out of his eleven-year decline.
234
The series ended when he could barely commit his pencil to paper.
235
But his raw portrayal of Alzheimer's didn't begin with these self-portraits.
236
The early signs of his dementia can perhaps be read in an earlier collection of art he called the conversation pieces.
237
They were a mostly biographical set of artworks, celebrating the life he shared with his wife and the warm companionship of his friends.
238
I get an odd feeling when I look at these paintings, though.
239
A subtle sense that there's something wrong.
240
I feel it in the artist's shifting perceptions of space, objects, and people.
241
All of which may be hints towards the disease that would later take his life.
242
And then he got the news.
243
His last large painting, Blue Skies, depicts William's reaction to his diagnosis.
244
A devastated figure holding onto a table as onto a raft in the blue bleakness of an empty studio.
245
During the meeting with his doctor, William was encouraged to continue painting.
246
He agreed to, and had his work submitted to a nurse to be photographed.
247
Thus the portraits documenting his decline came about.
248
His last portrait was scribbled on the napkin in the year 2002.
249
died in 2007.
250
Sometimes friends, and even family, will abandon someone with dementia.
251
When former US President Ronald Reagan was diagnosed, his ambassador to the UK and very close friend Walter Annenberg thereafter refused to see him.
252
It disturbed him to see Reagan so out of it.
253
Doing so meant denying the entire family his support in the process.
254
For many years it was believed that people with dementia suffered from insanity.
255
Alois Alzheimer first discovered the plaque and tangles related to Alzheimer's disease in 1906, but it wasn't until the late 70s that knowledge of the disease found its way into hospitals.
256
World War I, the rise of fascism in Germany, and World War II halted research and cast a lot of doubt onto the work of German scientists.
257
Alzheimer's research was left unread for decades.
258
of the research today has been trying to make up for that lost time.
259
Meanwhile, the number of patients grows.
260
In his lightning book, The Problem of Alzheimer's, Dr. Jason Karlowish discusses the critical flaws in her history of treating those with the disease.
261
Medical institutions have prioritized funding potential cures over present treatment, even denying Medicare coverage for the costly expense of receiving a diagnosis.
262
However, our failed attempts at a drug for Alzheimer's have time and time again been reliably covered by insurance companies.
263
He explains, The problem then, and still today in America, is that an effective intervention is not a treatment unless it has a business model.
264
Programs and interventions meant to support caretakers are largely without a system to promote or sustain them.
265
Harlowish claims it's this disparity between the financially robust drug industry
266
and the uncoordinated efforts of caretaker programs that's at the heart of the modern Alzheimer's crisis.
267
Caretakers are largely on their own to shoulder the task of caring for the Alzheimer's patients and their families.
268
It's a daunting task, a 24-7 job with an insane financial cost.
269
Some caretakers are left with a choice, retire and watch over their loved one full-time, or take on another job to avoid going broke in the process.
270
I'm seeing this for the first time and yet this is not the first time.
271
The moderate stages of Alzheimer's mark a point of no return.
272
On the outside, we watch the person we love struggle to do simple tasks.
273
It takes them an exhausting amount of effort.
274
Nothing feels right.
275
Everything is slightly off.
276
Laid into the disease, it's even a battle for them to speak in complete sentences.
277
It's depressing.
278
It's awful.
279
It's… embarrassing for them.
280
A total personality change is common in these stages.
281
I read story after story of sweet husbands and wives growing uncharacteristically brutal and violent, even beating their families.
282
There's just this unexplainable rage boiling up inside of them.
283
In very extreme cases they'll get caught in the grip of psychosis, experience wave after wave of hallucinations.
284
But sometimes it isn't all so dramatic.
285
Sometimes it's as understated as stubborn characters growing milder like little children.
286
It isn't uncommon for patients to frequently make sexual, racist, or otherwise derogatory remarks either.
287
Some people with Alzheimer's lose their ability to filter what is and isn't appropriate to say.
288
Many of these curses and slurs might be some of the only words they still remember, deeply encoded into one of the last remaining sections of their brain.
289
But you are still self-aware in these stages, feel despair and embarrassment and shame and question why you're doing what you're doing.
290
You don't know.
291
One guide explains it.
292
You start thinking strange thoughts that don't make sense, but you can't stop them from flooding your consciousness.
293
The static screams now.
294
The static giving birth to static, giving birth to static, giving birth to the...
295
For most of us, forgetting something is nothing more than a trivial annoyance.
296
That's not to say it doesn't still affect us.
297
At times I won't remember why I've entered a room after I walk into it.
298
It's something that happens a lot with my ADHD.
299
It's like I found myself running on autopilot and suddenly become aware that I have no idea what I'm actually doing.
300
It reminds me of the second episode of the sixth season of Doctor Who, Day of the Moon.
301
As a kid, the episode introduced me to the Silence, who I still think is the most fascinating creature from the show.
302
Stephen Moffat, the author of many of the show's most famous aliens, often relies not so much on a terrifying appearance as much as he does a terrifying premise.
303
The same is true for the Silence.
304
Are you ready to hear that premise?
305
They're an alien that you can only remember for as long as you perceive them.
306
The moment you look away, any idea of their existence is thoroughly washed from your memory.
307
But this creepy effect really is pulled off best in this scene from Day of the Moon.
308
In it we watch a woman, Amy Pond, struggle to escape from an orphanage.
309
Walking up the stairs, there's writing on the wall that's said to keep appearing on its own.
310
We watch Amy enter a room, hear the door close.
311
It's locked.
312
And as she grips the door handle, a recorder embedded into her hand relates to her a message in her own voice.
313
She runs through the window, tries to push it open.
314
Tallies begin to run up her arms, light up her face.
315
The entire scene takes up less than 4 minutes.
316
But how much time does each of those tallies represent?
317
Really, how many attempts to leave that Amy can no longer remember and thus aren't shown to us as the audience?
318
All it took was one glance to ruin every single one of them.
319
Some days with ADHD, I swear I spend more time wandering around wondering what I'm
320
supposed to be doing than I do doing the thing I was supposed to be doing.
321
I feel disoriented, distracted, and just like that orphanage scene, I can't help but think about all that lost time trying to do the one task.
322
There is, it almost goes without saying, a link between our memory and the way we orient ourselves.
323
Although my ADHD-related forgetfulness can be inconvenient, eventually I do remember what it is that I was supposed to be doing.
324
Some days, it only takes seconds, because I know something is wrong.
325
I can feel it.
326
And working back from that feeling, I can reorient myself.
327
Exit the room, re-enter it.
328
Sure, it's inconvenient, but lost time is really the worst of it.
329
Dementia, on the other hand, is perhaps more akin to the silence itself.
330
In the end, there is no sense of disorientation attached to the forgetting of one's objective,
331
and so a new, and sometimes delusional, objective is spontaneously invented.
332
The existence of the old one was entirely erased the moment you looked away.
333
A negative gap, a void, that conceals itself.
334
In Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five, we're told the story of Billy Pilgrim, a man who has become unstuck in time.
335
He enters a door in 1995 and finds himself in 1941, walks back through it into 63.
336
He feels an endless sense of stage fright, we're told, because he never knows what part of his life he'll have to act in next.
337
Vonnegut wrote the novel in order to describe his time as a POW during the bombing of Dresden in World War II.
338
As he himself says, all of this happened, more or less.
339
And we do spend time with Billy during the war.
340
A lot of time, actually.
341
Jumping between birth and death and everywhere in between.
342
But there is one scene that I thought a lot about while reading.
343
It feels strangely...normal.
344
Billy sits in the basement writing letters to newspapers about his time as a zoo animal on an alien planet.
345
The heater isn't working, but he hasn't noticed.
346
He's been dozing off, traveling through time every time he falls asleep.
347
That's it.
348
Billy writing, falling asleep, Billy writing.
349
It inspired a sad kind of hope in me as the reader.
350
I hoped that this hellish eternity of walking through doors into the armpits of time was just one big delusion.
351
I yearned for a reasonable explanation.
352
I wanted this to be it, the indisputable reality, as if all the rest of it playing out in his head would make it any less painful.
353
The novel knew, and they liked to toying with me.
354
The structure of Slaughterhouse-Five does somewhat mimic the delusions of those with middle stage Alzheimer's though.
355
People with Alzheimer's sometimes live in the past, are misplaced in time.
356
They'll suddenly grow adamant that their grandpa is coming over, call out for a dead childhood pet.
357
Sometimes they'll just wander off, break out, and walk to work the way they used to.
358
But through this lens, the book grows even more discomforting.
359
Merleau-Ponty tells us that as an embodied being, the depth of your immediate experience doesn't call forth your memories as pure abstractions.
360
Rather, your memories reflect the bodily experience of your past.
361
To use this example of a red dress again, when that dress reminds me of something, say, the graduation robe, I see myself wearing that graduation robe,
362
and I feel the way my body moves hiking through the red terrain of Utah.
363
This is the way your memories are formed, so they're remembered the same way.
364
To relive your past would be to act out this role.
365
In an essay from his memoir, Everything in its Place, Oliver Sacks recites his experience with a particular Alzheimer's patient who used to be a medical director for a hospital.
366
In fact, it was the hospital he was later admitted to.
367
Though he was severely disoriented and agitated for most of that time, there would be moments in which he believed he was once again a medical director for the hospital.
368
Touring the halls, he'd speak to other patients and flip through the charts unless someone stopped him.
369
One time, he spied his own chart, said, Charles M, that's me, flipped it open, read Alzheimer's disease and cried out, God help me, as he began to sob.
370
After that, he could sometimes be heard saying, I want to die, let me die.
371
Sacks likened these moments in which Dr. M believed he was once again a doctor to stepping into a role.
372
Touring the halls, reading charts, and assisting patients were all a part of his habitual body, a role summarized by the experiences of his past.
373
Stepping into this role oriented him forward as freshly as
374
if he were still a doctor because in a certain sense his body remembered as much as his mind did.
375
If you remember Heidegger's metaphor of the clearing, his concept of aletheia, unconcealment, is that all phenomena have the capacity to reveal their true nature to us.
376
As the mind begins to erode, more and more of what reveals itself to us is hidden away.
377
Short term memory fails to function, and so the information of the present world is lost through the shadows of one's ancient forests.
378
Delusions function against the background of our faith in the world.
379
We all place so much trust in Alethea, of a world which autonomously reveals itself, that the delusional never consider that the truth has been concealed from them.
380
Sacks asks the question, alongside many other caregivers, should we therefore tell patients that they are no longer what they used to be?
381
Should we take away their accustomed and well-rehearsed identity and replace it with a reality that, though real to us, is meaningless to them?
382
He answers his own question.
383
To do so would be beyond cruel.
384
For patients with dementia, all of the potential significances of something are confined to the depths of their imagination instead of the present world.
385
The immediate presence of things means nothing.
386
It holds no new significance.
387
We now traverse wholly into the realm of the imaginary.
388
Alzheimer's disfigures your memories beyond recognition before it ever lets you forget them.
389
In the 1995 animated film Ghost in the Shell, a special ops cyborg tracks a mysterious brain hacker with the hopes that it will help her understand her own humanity.
390
The film presents us with a future in which the human body is a mostly outdated piece of technology.
391
Prosthetic manufacturing has advanced to the point where most people have been transplanted into completely new forms, retaining just enough of a margin to call themselves human.
392
Despite the syntheticness of it all, there is still deep down in everyone the thing that you could call the soul.
393
Something that cannot be replicated.
394
Something wholly organic.
395
An elusive, nebulous force called a ghost.
396
Although a ghost can't be replicated, it can still be manipulated.
397
Ever since I first saw this film, there's this scene with a garbage collector that's haunted me.
398
I've even had dreams about it.
399
In the midst of the cops pursuit of the brain hacking puppet master, we're shown a conversation between two garbage men.
400
One of them tells his co-worker that his estranged wife won't let him see his daughter, so he's hacking into her brain to understand why.
401
He even moves to show his co-worker a photo of his daughter.
402
The garbage man, however, has been ghost hacked.
403
Neither his wife nor his daughter are real.
404
The woman whose brain he was hacking into is actually a government official.
405
We're shown the photograph of his daughter again as all of this is being explained to him.
406
Look, this is the photo you showed to your co-worker.
407
Who do you see?
408
I had a picture of her.
409
She was there.
410
She was smiling like an angel.
411
What's her name?
412
How old is she?
413
Where did you meet your wife and when did you marry her?
414
I'm sorry to put you through this, pal.
415
Come on, who do you see?
416
The puppet master works like a parasite, a cybernetic virus, wildly mutating the mind of its host, then sending itself out to breed inside the skulls of others.
417
This man's memories aren't the only thing that's been manipulated.
418
No, the film is insistent.
419
He's been ghost hacked.
420
His very soul has been meddled with, and as such, his identity too.
421
He used to be a husband and a father.
422
Now he understands himself to be neither of those things.
423
Those memories, that emotion, none of it matters now.
424
Despite his pleas, the cops can't tell him who he is.
425
René Descartes' maxim, I think therefore I am, is a large part of the philosophical identity of Ghost in the Shell.
426
It expresses a radical doubt in the existence of everything that happens to us.
427
You can doubt all of this, Descartes says, but you can't doubt the thing doing the doubting.
428
Even if you do doubt your own existence, there is still something doing the doubting.
429
Merleau-Ponty's philosophy of chiasm explores a part of this idea that often goes unexplored.
430
If we can only be certain of our own existence, how can we possibly define ourselves?
431
Because there is a world.
432
We exist in it.
433
And whether or not we believe it's real, it is subject to our perception.
434
Our experiences living in this world construct who we are.
435
Exposing the world as a delusion means to lose oneself in the process.
436
If nothing is real, then how can I be who I am?
437
Who am I really, if anyone at all?
438
Goodbye Worlds Before Your Eyes.
439
A recently deceased soul, fished up out of the inky black sea of Limbo, recounts their life in preparation to be judged.
440
It is also a game in which time jumps forward when you blink.
441
Your eyes are the controller.
442
And now I'm about to spoil the entire game.
443
In an interview, one of the game's developers explained that most games are about empowering you, and this is about taking power away.
444
And And it is sort of about humbling yourself to the fact that you're going to have to blink eventually.
445
But the blinking mechanic isn't the only interesting thing about before your eyes.
446
There are, of course, the key moments in which the game requires you to make a choice or to do something.
447
While these vary in importance from minor choices to pivotal forks, they all contribute to your final sense of self.
448
Yet right at the climax of a life woven together from misery and triumph, There's this moment in which it's revealed that you aren't exactly who you think you are.
449
This was beyond shocking to me.
450
I mean, I guess I should have seen it coming, but I didn't.
451
I almost couldn't believe it.
452
I was so invested in what was happening that I never stopped to think that maybe...
453
Some of the shock of this twist had to do with memories that I skipped by.
454
They seemed boring to me when I was first thrust into them, so I blinked. But it didn't matter.
455
The memories I did see, the ones that really led me toward this radically different sense of self, those could not have been further from the truth of who I was.
456
It led me to doubt even some of the earliest memories.
457
Did those really happen?
458
Or were they just necessary for the greater lie?
459
In Ghost in the Shell, it's implied that the new memories of the garbage collector came at the cost of his old ones.
460
This isn't so far off.
461
Forgetting a memory usually allows a false one to take its place.
462
Filling in details for the events that we more or less still remember reflects real history into nonsense.
463
Ever since I was young, my parents have kept a yearly photo album of our family.
464
I also contributed in documenting my childhood through my love of filming my own movies, but we usually have the same conversation when we discuss what's in them.
465
Would I really remember so much of my childhood if these photos and videos were never taken?
466
There's a problem with the twist in Before Your Eyes that reminds me of this dilemma.
467
You see, the game acts as if the person lying is the same as the person being lied to, but they're not.
468
Because it turns out that the main character of this game knew the truth the whole time, that he was the one who actually came up with this fake life we've just been shot through.
469
So in the context of the game, I was the delusional one.
470
I thought this was my life, but in fact someone I thought was me, had made up these memories for me.
471
It's a really small thing to be critical of, but what follows from this dynamic shapes the entire story the game wants to tell.
472
I'm still not sure who the player is supposed to be in all this.
473
Are we Benjamin Buren or aren't we?
474
But that just makes the story so much more compelling in the context of false memory.
475
It isn't very often that we become adamantly invested in something that never happened, but this vividness is a key part of the false memories in Alzheimer's.
476
It's just another way you lose fragments of yourself to the disease.
477
Dementia isn't brutal only because you lose yourself though, your autonomy and various parts of your identity.
478
The most frightening thing about it to me is the loss of the world, the journey into a realm that evades understanding.
479
This is what the sixth stage of Alzheimer's is known for.
480
Patients have no clue where they are, who they're with, any concept of time, what they're wearing, sometimes can't remember their name, sometimes the names of objects.
481
All of it is distorted, gazed at through a glass darkly.
482
Reality thrashes about angrily, miles away from here in the distance, like a dream.
483
In his consideration of space and time, the philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer makes the remark that our waking life
484
and our dreams represent two different ways of reading the same book.
485
Our systematic reading is real life, the time when everything flows cohesively.
486
But when we're done trying to study, we sometimes continue to flip through the pages, read in a disconnected method, without cohesion.
487
I once had a nightmare I haven't been able to forget since the night I had it.
488
In it, an AI slowly and torturously reversed my consciousness back through time, leaving me nothing more than an empty, unblinking reflex machine.
489
It was chemo for the cancer of thought.
490
Now I could think nothing.
491
Would only ever think nothing.
492
Maybe it was because I had just read I Have No Mouth and I Am a Scream before bed.
493
A book, by the way, whose title quite suits dementia.
494
But if you can't even say to yourself anymore that you can think.
495
If no thoughts run and an uncomfortable silence fills your head, can you use yourself to confirm that you exist with any certainty?
496
Or is life itself then degraded to an inescapable dream, an idol flipping through the pages of space and time?
497
People with dementia are not thoughtless or void of sentience.
498
There's more evidence than not that they haven't fully lost themselves.
499
It's more accurate to say that they cannot express their identity, cannot fully resemble it.
500
Even their body can no longer step into the role.
501
The thoughts they think may be entirely incoherent most of the time, but they're still people.
502
That doesn't necessarily answer the question though.
503
Unlike what Descartes would have me believe, it's not the world I need to doubt, it's my own mind.
504
I reach out to touch this world and get a taste of my undoing.
505
I can only ever question what's happening to my brain because of the way my symptoms manifest themselves in the world,
506
because of the way they culminate into this dreamlike state.
507
The world has always been presupposed.
508
So though I may not be thoughtless, as the world crumbles around me into a dream, I'll ask again, am I certain I really exist?
509
A man's dreams span years, and Junji Ito's The Long Dream, taking up multiple lifetimes in a single night, and when he wakes up the next morning,
510
his body ages as if he had lived those years.
511
When he does wake up, trying to remember where he is is like trying to remember something he did on a random afternoon decades ago.
512
It… well, it takes him a moment.
513
After a while, he can't tell reality apart from his dreams.
514
But as the length of his dreams grow longer and longer, pushing close to a thousand years a night, his body ages far beyond any possible human limit,
515
transforming him into a genuinely tragic kind of being.
516
He fossilizes in his bed during the night, crumbles to dust that morning.
517
The doctors are baffled.
518
But the question I have is, in the end, which to him was really the dream?
519
I think there are several comparisons that can be made between this story and life in a demented state.
520
It probably seems like every strenuous attempt to preserve what's left of an already scrambled mind ages the brain faster
521
and faster as it decays.
522
cannot remember, learn, or understand.
523
But even in these later stages, the constant debilitating confusion can give way to an instantaneous and lucid clarity.
524
They're still in there somewhere, drifting and unable to express themselves properly except for these impossible instances.
525
I bet.
526
I bet you can actually feel the interval of time between every final moment of clarity growing larger and noticeably larger, until you finally had your last.
527
you appreciate it?
528
As we get closer and closer to the end of it all, the decline can be rapid.
529
The final stages of dementia are without description.
530
Without description because all symbolic powers have been lost.
531
First-hand representation is not possible.
532
Late-stage dementia is thus defined by what is lost, the reality of which cannot ever be approached nor comprehended.
533
That you have lost anything at all is not even recognized, and yet it is around that gaping void that every aspect of daily life continually orbits.
534
There's an ancient Greek story that details a competition between two expert painters.
535
One of them paints grapes so convincing that birds swoop down from the sky to try and eat them.
536
But his competitor paints a curtain.
537
After the first painter has displayed his work, he tells the other to move the curtain aside so that he can show off his masterpiece.
538
But there is nothing behind the curtain.
539
The curtain is all there is.
540
The story reminds me of the last album cover for Everywhere at the End of Time.
541
Compared to the other covers, this is perhaps the most distinct.
542
And yet, even now, we cannot define this empty form.
543
A door with tape on it.
544
A blank canvas.
545
A picture frame with nothing to display.
546
Every one of these is a guess, but they all represent a lost medium.
547
There is nothing behind the curtain.
548
Because the depths have now dried up.
549
All that's left of a previously profound world is a barren moonscape with a surface of bedrock.
550
Impenetrable and vast and infinitely shallow.
551
The final year looks pretty much like you'd expect it to.
552
Endless days spent lying motionless in bed, unable to communicate when you're feeling too hot or too cold.
553
Speech limited to slurred gibberish.
554
And then there are the rashes and sweaty blisters, forming along your stiff body next to any unexplainable bruises.
555
The second to last thing to go is the ability to smile. And sometimes that's it.
556
But other times?
557
Well other times it's not.
558
Sometimes there's something more.
559
There's a mind-boggling phenomenon called terminal lucidity.
560
It sometimes happens to those people whose brains have been in decline for many years right before their death.
561
Suddenly they'll regain some level of cognitive ability.
562
This can mean anything from a wordless but knowing exchange to an impossible restoration of all their memories.
563
Then they die, typically within a few hours.
564
This last hurrah could last for minutes, or it could last for days.
565
The phenomenon is spoken of in golden, mythic terms.
566
The effect on ignorant families is devastating.
567
It can feel like they've lost their loved one all over again.
568
But for those in the know, these final moments can provide closure.
569
What's left of their cognitive faculties in this moment are only shadows, dancing the dance of misery.
570
Truth is, they're already gone.
571
All of this is just the afterlight glow of a star gone out in some distant heaven, yet to vanish from our skies.
572
But eventually the light does dim, and then they forget how to breathe.
573
Forgetting sets a limit to the way we experience our existence.
574
Dementia is like a drain at the bottom of the universe.
575
It pulls every part of reality down into it.
576
And yet, even when there is nothing left, even after every experience you've ever had, the ability to experience has been taken,
577
this drain is the one thing that remains.
578
What are we in life but a whisper?
579
A long, drowned out, breathless whisper.
580
Come, let's watch together as that whisper of the world rolls away and enjoy the memory of it while we can.
581
There will be no encore.
582
I'm not sure what you're doing.
📺 ช่องเดียวกัน
✨ วิดีโอแนะนำ
C11
380 ประโยค
A man hiked in the woods. Every brain cell got cooked.
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C12
298 ประโยค
If You Can Understand This News Article, Your English is Excellent!
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C11
114 ประโยค
There's a Giant Hole In Earth's History
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C13
21 ประโยค
The Deadliest Year of Your Life
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C13
89 ประโยค
Contemporary Topics 2 Unit 3 Lecture with Powerpoint
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C122
172 ประโยค
How Is a Memory Stored Inside Your Squishy Brain?
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C11
24 ประโยค
Phát âm chuẩn - Anh ngữ đặc biệt: Low Levels of Vitamin D Might Hurt Brain (VOA)
American AccentIELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C12
274 ประโยค
O, Death!
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
![[Song ngữ - TED Ed] Nếu bạn không ngủ điều gì sẽ xảy ra?](https://img.youtube.com/vi/yXgVSun6Q6I/mqdefault.jpg)
C13
41 ประโยค
[Song ngữ - TED Ed] Nếu bạn không ngủ điều gì sẽ xảy ra?
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
B22
66 ประโยค
Contemporary Topics 3 Unit 11 BIOLOGY The fountain of youth
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C13
86 ประโยค
Who Am I?
British AccentIELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
C15
27 ประโยค
Ted W1
IELTS PrepTOEFL PrepUniversity Students
คำศัพท์และข้อสังเกตด้านการพูดสำหรับบทเรียนนี้
บทเรียนฝึกพูดระดับ C1 นี้ใช้วิดีโอ “Fear of Forgetting” เป็นสื่อ วิดีโอนี้มี 582 ประโยค และ 8076 คำ สำหรับฝึกพูดตาม ช่วงที่มีเสียงพูดยาว 49:13 ผู้พูดพูดด้วยความเร็วเป็นธรรมชาติ ประมาณ 164 คำต่อนาที ใกล้เคียงกับบทสนทนาในชีวิตประจำวัน มีเพียง 79% ของคำที่อยู่ใน 3,000 คำที่ใช้บ่อยที่สุดในภาษาอังกฤษ คำศัพท์จึงค่อนข้างยาก
คำศัพท์สำคัญในวิดีโอนี้
คำที่ยากที่สุด 15 คำในวิดีโอ พร้อมคำอ่านและความหมาย:
| คำศัพท์ | คำอ่าน | ความหมาย |
|---|---|---|
| curtain คำนาม | /ˈkɜɹt(ə)n/ | ม่าน, ผ้าม่าน |
| conceal คำกริยา | /kənˈsil/ | ปิดบัง, ปกปิด |
| symptom คำนาม | /ˈsɪm(p)təm/ | อาการ |
| chromosome คำนาม | /ˈkɹoʊməˌsoʊm/ | โครโมโซม |
| delusional คำคุณศัพท์ | /dɪˈluːʒənəl/ | หลงผิด |
| philosopher คำนาม | /fəˈlɑsəfɚ/ | นักปราชญ์, นักปรัชญา |
| metaphor คำนาม | /ˈmɛt.ə.fɚ/ | อุปลักษณ์, อุปมา |
| diagnose คำกริยา | /ˈdaɪ.əɡˌnoʊs/ | วินิจฉัย |
| orphanage คำนาม | /ˈɔː(ɹ)fənɪd͡ʒ/ | บ้านเด็กกำพร้า, สถานเลี้ยงเด็กกำพร้า |
| robe คำนาม | /ɹoʊb/ | เสื้อคลุม |
| amidst | /aˈmɪdst/ | ท่ามกลาง |
| blink คำกริยา | /ˈblɪŋk/ | กะพริบ |
| imaginary คำคุณศัพท์ | /ɪˈmæd͡ʒɪˌn(ɛ)ɹi/ | จินตภาพ |
| puppet คำนาม | /ˈpʌpɪt/ | หุ่นเชิด |
| premise คำนาม | /ˈpɹɛm.ɪs/ | ข้อตั้ง |
กริยาวลีที่คุณจะได้ยิน
| คำศัพท์ | ความหมาย |
|---|---|
| break out คำกริยา | แหก |
| leave behind คำกริยา | ลืม |
ประโยคที่ควรฝึกพูดซ้ำ
ประโยคสั้น ๆ ที่สมบูรณ์จากวิดีโอ ซึ่งนำไปใช้ในบทสนทนาประจำวันได้:
- Why should you think that there's anything wrong?
- Isn't that going to have some effect on us?
- Do you think there's something happening to her?
- Are you ready to hear that premise?
- Come on, who do you see?
ไวยากรณ์ในวิดีโอนี้
โครงสร้างที่ผู้พูดใช้บ่อยที่สุด พร้อมคำพูดจริงจากวิดีโอ:
| โครงสร้าง | ในวิดีโอ |
|---|---|
| “used to” used to + กริยา — นิสัยหรือสภาพในอดีตที่ตอนนี้ไม่เป็นแล้ว | used to be |
| Present perfect continuous have/has been + -ing — การกระทำที่เริ่มก่อนหน้านี้และยังดำเนินอยู่ | have been using · has been trying |
| Present perfect have/has + กริยาช่อง 3 — เหตุการณ์ในอดีตที่ยังเกี่ยวข้องกับปัจจุบัน | has been revealed · has now been revealed · have begun |
| Passive voice be + กริยาช่อง 3 — เน้นสิ่งที่เกิดขึ้น ไม่ใช่ผู้กระทำ | are suggested · can be caused · is caused |
การออกเสียงที่ควรระวัง
ผู้พูดใช้รูปย่อและรูปลดเสียง 106 ครั้ง เช่น isn't, can't, they're ให้พูดแบบสั้นตามที่ได้ยิน
- เสียง “th”: thoughtless /ˈθɔtləs/, thrust /θɹʌst/
- เสียง “sh” และ “zh”: dementia /dɪˈmɛnʃə/, delusion /dɪˈl(j)uːʒ(ə)n/, graduation /ˌɡɹæd͡ʒuˈeɪʃən/, delusional /dɪˈluːʒənəl/, dimension /daɪˈmɛn.ʃən/
- คำยาว — ลงเสียงหนักให้ถูกพยางค์: graduation /ˌɡɹæd͡ʒuˈeɪʃən/, forgetfulness /fəˈɡɛtfʊlnɪs/, inconvenient /ˌɪn.kənˈviːni.ənt/, delusional /dɪˈluːʒənəl/, philosopher /fəˈlɑsəfɚ/
เสียงที่คนไทยมักออกเสียงยาก:
- เสียงท้ายคำ — ออกเสียงให้ครบ ไม่เปลี่ยนเป็นตัวสะกดแบบไทย: chiasmus /kaɪˈæzməs/, conceal /kənˈsil/, forgetfulness /fəˈɡɛtfʊlnɪs/, delusional /dɪˈluːʒənəl/, crumble /ˈkɹʌmbəl/
- /v/ — ไม่ใช่ /w/ ให้ฟันบนแตะริมฝีปากล่าง: void /vɔɪd/, inconvenient /ˌɪn.kənˈviːni.ənt/, unavoidable /ˌʌnəˈvɔɪdəbəl/, unravel /ˌʌnˈɹævəl/, vinyl /ˈvaɪ.nɪl/
- /z/ — เสียงก้อง ไม่ใช่ /s/: chiasmus /kaɪˈæzməs/, summarize /ˈsʌməˌɹaɪz/, confuse /kənˈfjuːz/, misery /ˈmɪz(ə)ɹi/
วิธีฝึกกับวิดีโอนี้
- ฟังวิดีโอให้จบหนึ่งรอบโดยยังไม่ต้องพูด แล้วจดคำที่ยังไม่รู้จัก
- เริ่มที่ความเร็ว 0.75× พูดตามทีละประโยค แล้วกลับไปใช้ความเร็วปกติเมื่อเริ่มคล่อง
- อัดเสียงตัวเองแล้วเทียบกับต้นฉบับ โดยสังเกตคำอย่าง curtain, conceal, symptom เป็นพิเศษ
เทคนิค Shadowing คืออะไร?
Shadowing เป็นเทคนิคการเรียนรู้ภาษาที่ได้รับการรับรองทางวิทยาศาสตร์ พัฒนาขึ้นสำหรับการฝึกนักแปลมืออาชีพ วิธีการนี้เรียบง่ายแต่ทรงพลัง: คุณฟังเสียงภาษาอังกฤษจากเจ้าของภาษาและพูดตามทันที — เหมือนเงาที่ตามผู้พูดด้วยช่วงเวลาห่าง 1-2 วินาที การวิจัยแสดงว่าเทคนิคนี้ปรับปรุงความแม่นยำในการออกเสียง ทำนองเสียง จังหวะ การเชื่อมเสียง การฟังเข้าใจ และความคล่องแคล่วในการพูดได้อย่างมีนัยสำคัญ