Shadowing Practice: Have we really measured gravitational waves? - Learn English Speaking with Video

Bir pratik modu seçin

Her mod tam ekran bir pratik odası açar.

108 cümleler
Cümleler çok kısa veya çok uzun ise, ayarlamak için Düzenle'ye tıklayın.
1
Folks. A few days ago I met a friend on the subway.
2
He tells me he’s been at a conference and someone asked if he knows me.
3
He says yes, and immediately people start complaining about me.
4
One guy, apparently, told him to slap me.
5
What were they complaining about, you want to know?
6
Well, one complaint came from a particle physicist, who was clearly dismayed that I think building a bigger particle collider is not a good way to invest $40 billion dollars.
7
But it was true when I said it the first time and it is still true: There are better things we can do with this amount money.
8
Such as, for example, make better climate predictions, which can be done for as little as 1 billion dollars.
9
Check links below the video for more information on that.
10
Back to my friend in the subway.
11
He told me that besides the grumpy particle physicist there were also several gravitational wave people who have issues with what I have written about the supposed gravitational wave detections by the LIGO collaboration.
12
Most of the time if people have issues with what I’m saying it’s because they do not understand what I’m saying to begin with.
13
So with this video I hope to clear the situation up.
14
Let me start with the most important point.
15
I do *not doubt that the gravitational wave detections are real.
16
But. I spend a lot of time on science communication, and I know that many of *you doubt that these detections are real.
17
And, to be honest, I cannot blame you for this doubt.
18
So here’s my issue.
19
I think that the gravitational wave community is doing a crappy job justifying the expenses for their research.
20
They give science a bad reputation.
21
And I do not approve of this.
22
Before I go on, a quick reminder what gravitational waves are.
23
Gravitational waves are periodic deformations of space and time.
24
These deformations can happen because Einstein’s theory of general relativity tells us that space and time are not rigid, but react to the presence of matter.
25
If you have some distribution of matter that curves space a lot, such as a pair of black holes orbiting one another, these will cause space-time to wobble and the wobbles carry energy away.
26
That’s what gravitational waves are.
27
We have had indirect evidence for gravitational waves since the 1970s because you can measure how much energy a system loses through gravitational waves without directly measuring the gravitational waves.
28
Hulse and Taylor did this by closely monitoring the orbiting frequency of a pulsar binary.
29
If the system loses energy, the two stars get closer and they orbit faster around each other.
30
The predictions for the emission of gravitational waves fit exactly on the observations.
31
Hulse and Taylor got a Nobel prize for that in 1993.
32
For the *direct detection of gravitational waves you have to measure the deformation of space and time that they cause.
33
You can do this by using very sensitive interferometers.
34
An interferometer bounces laser light back and forth in two orthogonal directions and then combines the light.
35
Light is a wave and depending on whether the crests of the waves from the two directions lie on top of each other or not, the resulting signal is strong – that’s constructive interference – or washed out – that’s destructive interference.
36
Just what happens depends very sensitively on the distance that the light travels.
37
So you can use changes in the strength of the interference pattern to figure out whether one of the directions of the interferometer was temporarily shorter or longer.
38
A question that I frequently get is how can this interferometer detect anything if both the light and the interferometer itself deform with space-time?
39
Wouldn’t the effect cancel out?
40
No, it does not cancel out, because the interferometer is not made of light.
41
It’s made of massive particles and therefore reacts differently to a periodic deformation of space-time than light does.
42
That’s why one can use light to find out that something happened for real.
43
For more details, please check the info below the video where I have references.
44
The first direct detection of gravitational wave was made by the LIGO collaboration in September 2015.
45
LIGO consists of two separate interferometers.
46
They are both located in the United States, some thousand kilometers apart.
47
Gravitational waves travel at the speed of light, so if one comes through, it should trigger both detectors with a small delay that comes from the time it takes the wave to travel from one detector to the other.
48
Looking for a signal that appears almost simultaneously in the two detectors helps to identify the signal in the noise.
49
This first signal measured by LIGO looks like a textbook example of a gravitational wave signal from a merger of two black holes.
50
It’s a periodic signal that increases in frequency and amplitude, as the two black holes get closer to each other and their orbiting period gets shorter.
51
When the horizons of the two black holes merge, the signal is suddenly cut off.
52
After this follows a brief period in which the newly formed larger black hole settles in a new state, called the ringdown.
53
A Nobel Prize was awarded for this measurement in 2017.
54
If you plot the frequency distribution over time, you get this banana.
55
Here it's the upward bend that tells you that the frequency increases before dying off entirely.
56
Now, what’s the problem?
57
The first problem is that no one seems to actually know where the curve in the famous LIGO plot came from.
58
You would think it was obtained by a calculation, but members of the collaboration are on record saying it was “not found using analysis algorithms” but partly done “by eye” and “hand-tuned for pedagogical purposes.” For a reference on these quotes, please check the information below the video.
59
Both the collaboration and the journal in which the paper was published have refused to comment.
60
This, people, is highly inappropriate.
61
We should not hand out Nobelprizes if we don’t know how the predictions were fitted to the data.
62
The other problem is that so far we do not have a confirmation that the signals which LIGO detects are in fact of astrophysical origin, and not misidentified signals that originated on Earth.
63
The way that you could show this is with a LIGO detection that matches electromagnetic signals, such as gamma ray bursts, measured by telescopes.
64
The collaboration had, so far, one opportunity for this, which was an event in August 2017.
65
The problem with this event is that the announcement from the collaboration about their detection came *after the announcement of the incoming gamma ray.
66
Therefore, the LIGO detection does not count as a confirmed prediction, because it was not a prediction in the first place – it was a postdiction.
67
It seems to offend people in the collaboration tremendously if I say this, so let me be clear.
68
I have no reason to think that something fishy went on, and I know why the original detection did not result in an automatic alert.
69
But this isn’t the point.
70
The point is that no one knows what happened before the official announcement besides members of the collaboration.
71
We are waiting for an independent confirmation.
72
This one missed the mark.
73
Since 2017, the two LIGO detectors have been joined by a third detector called Virgo, located in Italy.
74
In their third run, which started in April this year, the LIGO/Virgo collaboration has issued alerts for 41 events.
75
From these 41 alerts, 8 were later retracted.
76
Of the remaining gravitational wave events, 10 look like they are either neutron star mergers, or mergers of a neutron star with a black hole.
77
In these cases, there should also be electromagnetic radiation emitted which telescopes can see.
78
For black hole mergers, one does not expect this to be the case.
79
However, no telescope has so far seen a signal that fits to any of the gravitational wave events.
80
This may simply mean that the signals have been too weak for the telescopes to see them.
81
But whatever the reason, the consequence is that we still do not know that what LIGO and Virgo see are actually signals from outer space.
82
You may ask isn’t it enough that they have a signal in their detector that looks like it *could be caused by gravitational waves?
83
Well, if this was the only thing that could trigger the detectors, yes.
84
But that is not the case.
85
The LIGO detectors have about 10-100 “Glitches” per day.
86
The glitches are bright and shiny signals but do not look like gravitational wave events.
87
The cause of some of these glitches is known.
88
The cause of other glitches not.
89
LIGO uses a citizen science project to classify these glitches and has given them funky names like “koi fish” or “Blip.” What this means is that they do not really know what their detector detects.
90
They just throw away data that don’t look like they want it to look.
91
This is not a good scientific procedure.
92
Here is why.
93
Think of an animal.
94
Let me guess, it’s… an elephant.
95
Right? Right for you, right for you, not right for you?
96
Hmm, that’s a glitch in the data, so you don’t count.
97
Does this prove that I am psychic?
98
No, of course it doesn’t.
99
Because selectively throwing away data that’s inconvenient is a bad idea.
100
Goes for me, goes for LIGO too.
101
At least that’s what you would think.
102
If we had an independent confirmation that the good-looking signal is really of astrophysical origin, this wouldn’t matter.
103
But we don’t have that either.
104
So that’s the situation in summary.
105
The signals that LIGO and Virgo see are well explained by gravitational wave events.
106
But we cannot be sure that these are actually signals coming from outer space and not some unknown terrestrial effect.
107
Let me finish by saying once again that personally, I do not actually doubt these signals are caused by gravitational waves.
108
But in science, it’s evidence that counts, not opinion.

Uygulamayı İndir

Akıcı konuşmak için ihtiyacınız olan her şey

AI TelaffuzHer cümleyi puanla
IPA AlıştırmasıHer sesi ustalaştır
Kelime BilgisiKelime bankanızı oluşturun
Kelime OyunuOynarken öğrenin

Aynı Kanal

FOR YOU

Video Öner

Bu dersin kelimeleri ve konuşma notları

Bu konuşma dersi “Have we really measured gravitational waves?” videosuna dayanıyor. En çok tekrarlanan kelimeler: wave, gravitational, signal, Ligo, detector. Bu videoda gölgeleme çalışması için 108 cümle ve 1674 kelime var. Konuşma bölümü 10:23 sürüyor. Konuşmacı dakikada yaklaşık 161 kelimeyle, günlük konuşmaya yakın doğal bir hızda konuşuyor. Kelimelerin yalnızca %79’i İngilizcede en sık kullanılan 3.000 kelime arasında, bu yüzden kelime dağarcığı zorlayıcı.

Bu videodaki önemli kelimeler

Videodan öğrenmeye değer 15 kelime, telaffuzu ve anlamıyla:

KelimeTelaffuzAnlam
collaboration isim/kəˌlæbəˈɹeɪʃən/imece, iş birliği
frequency isim/ˈfɹiːkwənsi/frekans
orbit isim/ˈɔɹ.bɪt/yörünge
particle isim/ˈpɑɹtək(ə)l/parçacık
telescope isim/ˈtɛl.əˌskoʊp/teleskop, ırakgörür
alert sıfat/əˈlɝt/uyanık
announcement isim/əˈnaʊns.mənt/ilan, beyan
confirmation isim/ˌkɑn.fəɹˈmeɪ.ʃən/kiliseye kabul töreni, konfirmasyon
interference isim/ˌɪntəɹˈfɪɹɪns/engelleme, müdahale
trigger isim/ˈtɹɪɡɚ/[4, 5] tetikleme, tetik
cancel fiil/ˈkæn.sl̩/iptal etmek
react fiil/ɹiːˈækt/reaksiyon göstermek
curve isim/kɚv/kıvrım
subway isim/ˈsʌbˌweɪ/metro
locate fiil/ˈloʊˌkeɪt/yerleştirmek

Duyacağınız deyimsel fiiller

KelimeAnlam
throw away fiilatmak
figure out fiilaçığa çıkarmak
find out fiilanlamak, ortaya çıkarmak
hand out fiildağıtmak

Tekrar etmeye değer cümleler

Videodan, günlük konuşmada yeniden kullanabileceğiniz kısa ve tam cümleler:

  • What were they complaining about, you want to know?
  • Wouldn’t the effect cancel out?
  • Let me guess, it’s… an elephant.
  • Right for you, right for you, not right for you?
  • Does this prove that I am psychic?

Bu videodaki dil bilgisi

Konuşmacının en çok kullandığı yapılar, videodaki sözcüklerin aynısıyla:

YapıVideoda
Edilgen yapı be + fiilin üçüncü hâli — kimin yaptığı değil, ne olduğu önemliwas clearly dismayed · can be done · is not made
Present perfect have/has + fiilin üçüncü hâli — geçmişte olan ama şimdi de önemli olan bir eylemhe's been · have written · have had
İlgi cümlecikleri who / which + cümle — bir kişi ya da şey hakkında ek bilgipredictions, which can · people who have · this, which was

Dikkat edilecek telaffuzlar

Konuşmacı don't, I'm, isn't gibi kısaltılmış biçimleri 11 kez kullanıyor. Bunları duyduğunuz gibi kısa söyleyin.

  • “th” sesleri: algorithm /ˈælɡəɹɪðm̩/, orthogonal /ɔɹˈθɑ.ɡə.nəl/
  • “sh” ve “zh” sesleri: collaboration /kəˌlæbəˈɹeɪʃən/, detection /dɪˈtɛk.ʃən/, prediction /pɹɪˈdɪkʃən/, confirmation /ˌkɑn.fəɹˈmeɪ.ʃən/, reputation /ˌɹɛpjʊˈteɪʃən/
  • Uzun kelimeler — vurguyu doğru yere koyun: collaboration /kəˌlæbəˈɹeɪʃən/, confirmation /ˌkɑn.fəɹˈmeɪ.ʃən/, interference /ˌɪntəɹˈfɪɹɪns/, periodic /ˌpɪɹiˈɑdɪk/, electromagnetic /ɪˌlɛk.tɹoʊ.mæɡˈnɛ.tɪk/

Türkçe konuşanların zorlandığı sesler:

  • /w/ — dudaklar yuvarlak, /v/ değil: frequency /ˈfɹiːkwənsi/, subway /ˈsʌbˌweɪ/, wash /wɑʃ/, consequence /ˈkɑn.sɪ.kwəns/, upward /ˈʌpwɚd/
  • Kelime başındaki ünsüz kümesi — araya ünlü eklemeyin: prediction /pɹɪˈdɪkʃən/, frequency /ˈfɹiːkwənsi/, trigger /ˈtɹɪɡɚ/, procedure /pɹəˈsiː.d͡ʒə/, tune /tjuːn/
  • /æ/ — “e”den daha açık: collaboration /kəˌlæbəˈɹeɪʃən/, cancel /ˈkæn.sl̩/, react /ɹiːˈækt/, gamma /ˈɡæ.mə/, electromagnetic /ɪˌlɛk.tɹoʊ.mæɡˈnɛ.tɪk/

Bu videoyla nasıl çalışılır

  1. Videonun tamamını konuşmadan bir kez dinleyin ve bilmediğiniz kelimeleri not edin.
  2. 0,75× hızla başlayın, cümle cümle tekrar edin ve kolaylaşınca normal hıza dönün.
  3. Kendinizi kaydedin ve orijinaliyle karşılaştırın; collaboration, frequency, orbit gibi kelimelere özellikle dikkat edin.

Gölgeleme Tekniği Nedir?

Gölgeleme, başlangıçta profesyonel tercüman eğitimi için geliştirilen ve çok dilli Dr. Alexander Arguelles tarafından popüler hale getirilen, bilim destekli bir dil öğrenme tekniğidir. Yöntem basit ama güçlüdür: ana dili İngilizce olan bir sesi dinler ve hemen yüksek sesle tekrar edersiniz — konuşmacıyı 1-2 saniye gecikmeyle takip eden bir gölge gibi. Pasif dinleme veya dilbilgisi alıştırmalarının aksine, gölgeleme beyninizi ve ağız kaslarınızı gerçek konuşma kalıplarını eşzamanlı olarak işlemeye ve yeniden üretmeye zorlar. Araştırmalar, telaffuz doğruluğu, tonlama, ritim, bağlı konuşma, dinleme anlama ve konuşma akıcılığını önemli ölçüde geliştirdiğini göstermektedir — bu da onu IELTS Konuşma hazırlığı ve gerçek dünya İngilizce iletişimi için en etkili yöntemlerden biri yapar.

Shadowing tekniği: adım adım eksiksiz rehberi okuyun →