Pratica di Shadowing: How to Rebut An Argument (Ep 02) - Impara a parlare inglese con i video
Scegli una modalità di pratica
Ogni modalità apre una sala di pratica a schermo intero.
87 frasi
Se le frasi sono troppo corte o troppo lunghe, clicca su Edit per modificarle.
1
you Argument Alice, Framework Freddy,
2
Comparison Connie, Structure Sam, Delivery Danny, Rebuttal Rosie are...
3
The Diology Debate Super Team.
4
They are here to help develop your superpowers.
5
Hello everyone, Rebuttal Rosie here.
6
Today I am going to teach you one of the most important things in debate: rebuttal.
7
Rebuttal means to provide some evidence or argument that refutes or opposes an argument.
8
To refute means to prove to be wrong or an error.
9
In simple terms, A rebuttal is when we explain that our opponent's argument is wrong or mistaken.
10
Debate would be very boring without rebuttals.
11
As you learned from Argument Alice, making an argument is like building a house.
12
You need all the crucial components: claim, reasoning, and evidence.
13
A rebuttal is an attempt to deconstruct or tear down what our opponent has built.
14
Now, before we begin your training in rebuttal, you must make a promise to me.
15
You must promise that your rebuttals will always remain friendly and respectful.
16
Even though we are explaining that our opponents are wrong, it is never okay to be mean or aggressive.
17
My shield symbolizes that we are defending against the arguments of our opponents.
18
However, the yin yang signifies that there is a bit of truth in our opponents' arguments.
19
The process of argument and rebuttal helps us all to learn for this reason We respect, and appreciate our opponents and their arguments.
20
Finally, we attack arguments, but never people.
21
Do you promise to respect and value your opponents at all times?
22
Excellent!
23
Then let's get started.
24
Today I will show you the four simple steps of rebuttal.
25
They are: Step 1.
26
Briefly state the argument you are refuting.
27
Step 2: Express disagreement with the argument.
28
Step 3.
29
provide reasons for disagreement.
30
step 4.
31
Brief Conclusion Step 1.
32
My opponent says: "The first thing you need to do is clearly and briefly summarize the argument of your opponent."
33
The audience must know which point you are refuting.
34
Step 2.
35
However, I would like to challenge this argument.
36
In this step, you simply indicate that you will provide reasons why the argument is flawed or wrong.
37
Step 3. Because.
38
In this step, you provide the reasons why you think the argument is flawed or wrong.
39
There could be many reasons why you think the argument is flawed.
40
Remember what Structure Sam says and always enumerate these arguments.
41
In this step, you simply provide a conclusion to your rebuttal.
42
You might say: Therefore, we think that this argument does not stand.
43
Let's look at an example of a refutation in an actual debate.
44
Let's first hear the argument that we will rebut.
45
to refute We need to listen carefully.
46
Listen to the claim, reasoning and evidence before constructing your rebuttal.
47
Let's look at an argument we have heard before on the topic.
48
Kids should not be allowed to have mobile phones.
49
Ladies and gentlemen, my first argument to support the topic that kids should not be allowed to have mobile phones
50
Mobile phones are bad for kids' eyes.
51
Now, Let me explain the reasons why this is true.
52
First of all, mobile phones have a light called a blue light.
53
That's what allows us to see the screen.
54
If kids look at this light too much, it will hurt their eyes.
55
Mobile phones have so many bright colors and images that are too bright for kids eyes.
56
Secondly, most kids cannot stop looking at their mobile phones.
57
Mobile phones have lots of games and videos that kids like to watch.
58
These games and videos are fun and exciting and kids can't stop watching them.
59
The bright colors and images are very attractive to kids.
60
Third, Sometimes parents and teachers cannot control the mobile phone use.
61
Parents and teachers cannot watch their kids at all times because they're busy.
62
This means that kids can look at their mobile phones all day, which is bad for their eyes.
63
Now!
64
Let me introduce some evidence to support this claim.
65
A new study says that smartphones may ruin your eyesight.
66
Researchers at the University of Toledo in Ohio have found that exposure to blue light The glow emitted from most smartphones,
67
tablets, and laptops promotes the growth of poisonous molecules in your eyes leading to macular degeneration. So!
68
Ladies and gentlemen, We believe that kids should not have mobile phones because they are too harmful to kids' eyes.
69
Now, let's look at an example of the four steps in action.
70
My opponent's first argument was mobile phones are harmful to kids' eyes.
71
They explained that the blue light on the phone, along with the inability of kids to control phone use, will damage their eyes and can even lead to blindness.
72
However, I would like to challenge this argument.
73
I think this argument is flawed for two reasons: 1.
74
It is not true that kids cannot control their use of phones.
75
We believe that parents can control phone use through screen control apps.
76
We also think that kids can control their phone use and
77
that they prefer to play with friends and do things other than look at their phones.
78
So it is just not right that if kids have phones, they will look at them like zombies all day long.
79
2. Even if kids do look at mobile phones a lot, we don't think it will be that bad for kids' eyes.
80
The worst case scenario is that kids have to wear glasses.
81
But we don't believe this is such a big deal.
82
Also, reading a lot of books can hurt kids' eyes too, but we would never say that kids should not be allowed to read.
83
Therefore, we think that the effects of mobile phones on kids' eyes are not a reason kids should not have mobile phones.
84
There, we have seen an example of a rebuttal in action.
85
Once you master the four steps, I will introduce you to more refutation techniques.
86
For now, go ahead and respectfully refute each one of your opponent's arguments.
87
Good luck!
Scarica l'app
Tutto ciò che serve per parlare fluentemente
Pronuncia con IAVoto per ogni frase
Pratica IPAPadroneggia ogni suono
VocabolarioCostruisci il tuo lessico
Gioco di vocabolarioImpara giocando
Stesso Canale
B21
How to Debate (Ep 04)
Daily ConversationHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B21
The Art of Debate Note-Taking (Ep 07)
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
B21
How to Win A Debate (Ep 05)
Daily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
How to Build an Argument with Argument Alice (Ep 01)
TeensDaily Conversation
C12
How to Engage in a Debate Crossfire (Ep 10)
Daily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
How To Deliver A Speech: Volume (Ep 09)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B12
Meet The Dialogy Debate Super Team (Ep 00)
Business EnglishHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B21
Don't Let Your Arguments Die (Ep 06)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B18
How To Deliver A Speech: Eye-Contact (Ep 08)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B11
How To Make A Debate Speech (Ep 03)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
FOR YOU
Video consigliato
B12
226 frasi
Don't Overthink in English, Just Listen and Repeat | Listening Practice for A2/ B1 Level
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
A28
59 frasi
How to Handle Conflicts in Communication | Level A2 | English shadowing
Business EnglishTeensDaily Conversation
B16
39 frasi
HOW TO BE SOCIAL - HOW TO NEVER RUN OUT OF THINGS TO SAY
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
A22
194 frasi
How to Argue in French (A2 | Conversations for Advanced Beginners)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
A24
39 frasi
English shadowing | Learning from Criticism | Level A2 | How to improve English
Business EnglishTeensDaily Conversation
B110
234 frasi
Learn Easy English with Phrases in Daily Use | English Speaking Practice for Beginners (A2-B1)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B17
367 frasi
Learn How to Express Your Opinion in English | Real Conversations for Beginners (A2-B1)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
A23
48 frasi
How to make suggestions in English
Business EnglishTeensDaily Conversation
A24
177 frasi
Repeat-After-Me Shadowing English Speaking Practice
American AccentKidsTeensDaily Conversation
A27
232 frasi
Episode 21 – Making Complaints Politely in English | Refund, Exchange & Customer Service
TOEIC PrepBusiness EnglishTeens
Contesto e Sfondo
Nel video "Come Ribattere a un’Argomentazione", Rebuttal Rosie e il suo team di esperti discutono l'importanza della ribattuta nel contesto di un dibattito. La ribattuta è un elemento fondamentale che arricchisce il confronto tra idee, consentendo di dimostrare che un argomento può essere sbagliato o fallace. Un approccio rispettoso e costruttivo è essenziale, poiché permette di mettere in discussione le opinioni altrui senza cadere in attacchi personali. È attraverso questo processo che si impara e si cresce, sia come oratori che come pensatori critici.
Le 5 Frasi Chiave per la Comunicazione Quotidiana
- "Il primo argomento che voglio presentare è..." - Usato per introdurre l’argomento che si sta sfidando.
- "Tuttavia, vorrei contestare questo argomento." - Una frase utile per esprimere disaccordo in modo chiaro.
- "Perché..." - Una breve introduzione per fornire le proprie ragioni e sostenere il proprio punto di vista.
- "Ricordiamoci di enumerare questi argomenti." - Un ottimo promemoria per strutturare le proprie idee.
- "Pertanto, riteniamo che questo argomento non regga." - Una conclusione efficace per una ribattuta.
Guida Passo-passo al Shadowing
Affrontare la difficoltà del video attraverso il shadow speech richiede pratica e attenzione. Ecco una guida passo-passo per esercitare la ribattuta e migliorare il proprio inglese:
- Ascolta attentamente: Prima di ribattere, ascolta con attenzione l'argomento che viene presentato. Presta attenzione a tutti i suoi componenti essenziali, come le affermazioni e le prove.
- Inizia con una sintesi: Quando fai pratica di conversazione in inglese, inizia il tuo shadowing sintetizzando brevemente l’argomento dell’avversario.
- Esprimi il tuo disaccordo: Utilizza frasi adeguate per indicare il tuo disaccordo, mantenendo sempre un tono rispettoso.
- Fornisci le tue ragioni: Sii pronto a elencare le ragioni del tuo disaccordo, facendo riferimento a ciò che hai ascoltato nel video. Questo ti aiuterà a strutturare la tua ribattuta in modo chiaro e logico.
- Concludi la tua ribattuta: Utilizza una frase finale forte per chiudere la tua argomentazione, dimostrando così la tua posizione con sicurezza.
Utilizzare il shadowing in inglese con questo video ti permetterà di migliorare notevolmente le tue abilità comunicative. Non dimenticare che attraverso la shadow speech, avrai l'opportunità di apprendere l'inglese con Youtube mentre sviluppi empatia e rispetto per le opinioni altrui.
La grammatica di questo video
Le strutture che chi parla usa di più, con le parole esatte del video:
| Struttura | Nel video |
|---|---|
| Frasi condizionali if + frase, will/would + verbo — una condizione e il suo risultato | if kids have phones, they will look |
| Forma passiva be + participio passato — conta ciò che accade, non chi lo fa | is flawed · should not be allowed |
| Present perfect have/has + participio passato — un’azione passata che conta ancora adesso | has built · have heard · have found |
| Consigli con “should” should + verbo — dire che cosa è meglio fare | should not be · should not have |
Cos'è la tecnica dello Shadowing?
Shadowing è una tecnica di apprendimento delle lingue supportata da studi scientifici, originariamente sviluppata per la formazione dei traduttori professionisti e resa popolare dal poliglotta Dr. Alexander Arguelles. Il metodo è semplice ma potente: ascolti un audio in inglese di madrelingua e lo ripeti immediatamente ad alta voce — come un'ombra che segue il parlante con un ritardo di solo 1–2 secondi. A differenza dell'ascolto passivo o degli esercizi di grammatica, lo shadowing costringe il tuo cervello e i muscoli della bocca a elaborare e riprodurre simultaneamente i modelli di discorso reale. La ricerca dimostra che migliora significativamente la precisione della pronuncia, l'intonazione, il ritmo, il discorso connesso, la comprensione dell'ascolto e la fluidità del parlato — rendendolo uno dei metodi più efficaci per la preparazione alla prova di speaking dell'IELTS e per la comunicazione reale in inglese.