シャドーイング練習: How to Rebut An Argument (Ep 02) - 動画で英語スピーキングを学ぶ
練習モードを選ぶ
各モードは全画面の練習ルームで開きます。
87 文
文が短すぎたり長すぎる場合は、Editをタップして調整してください。
1
you Argument Alice, Framework Freddy,
2
Comparison Connie, Structure Sam, Delivery Danny, Rebuttal Rosie are...
3
The Diology Debate Super Team.
4
They are here to help develop your superpowers.
5
Hello everyone, Rebuttal Rosie here.
6
Today I am going to teach you one of the most important things in debate: rebuttal.
7
Rebuttal means to provide some evidence or argument that refutes or opposes an argument.
8
To refute means to prove to be wrong or an error.
9
In simple terms, A rebuttal is when we explain that our opponent's argument is wrong or mistaken.
10
Debate would be very boring without rebuttals.
11
As you learned from Argument Alice, making an argument is like building a house.
12
You need all the crucial components: claim, reasoning, and evidence.
13
A rebuttal is an attempt to deconstruct or tear down what our opponent has built.
14
Now, before we begin your training in rebuttal, you must make a promise to me.
15
You must promise that your rebuttals will always remain friendly and respectful.
16
Even though we are explaining that our opponents are wrong, it is never okay to be mean or aggressive.
17
My shield symbolizes that we are defending against the arguments of our opponents.
18
However, the yin yang signifies that there is a bit of truth in our opponents' arguments.
19
The process of argument and rebuttal helps us all to learn for this reason We respect, and appreciate our opponents and their arguments.
20
Finally, we attack arguments, but never people.
21
Do you promise to respect and value your opponents at all times?
22
Excellent!
23
Then let's get started.
24
Today I will show you the four simple steps of rebuttal.
25
They are: Step 1.
26
Briefly state the argument you are refuting.
27
Step 2: Express disagreement with the argument.
28
Step 3.
29
provide reasons for disagreement.
30
step 4.
31
Brief Conclusion Step 1.
32
My opponent says: "The first thing you need to do is clearly and briefly summarize the argument of your opponent."
33
The audience must know which point you are refuting.
34
Step 2.
35
However, I would like to challenge this argument.
36
In this step, you simply indicate that you will provide reasons why the argument is flawed or wrong.
37
Step 3. Because.
38
In this step, you provide the reasons why you think the argument is flawed or wrong.
39
There could be many reasons why you think the argument is flawed.
40
Remember what Structure Sam says and always enumerate these arguments.
41
In this step, you simply provide a conclusion to your rebuttal.
42
You might say: Therefore, we think that this argument does not stand.
43
Let's look at an example of a refutation in an actual debate.
44
Let's first hear the argument that we will rebut.
45
to refute We need to listen carefully.
46
Listen to the claim, reasoning and evidence before constructing your rebuttal.
47
Let's look at an argument we have heard before on the topic.
48
Kids should not be allowed to have mobile phones.
49
Ladies and gentlemen, my first argument to support the topic that kids should not be allowed to have mobile phones
50
Mobile phones are bad for kids' eyes.
51
Now, Let me explain the reasons why this is true.
52
First of all, mobile phones have a light called a blue light.
53
That's what allows us to see the screen.
54
If kids look at this light too much, it will hurt their eyes.
55
Mobile phones have so many bright colors and images that are too bright for kids eyes.
56
Secondly, most kids cannot stop looking at their mobile phones.
57
Mobile phones have lots of games and videos that kids like to watch.
58
These games and videos are fun and exciting and kids can't stop watching them.
59
The bright colors and images are very attractive to kids.
60
Third, Sometimes parents and teachers cannot control the mobile phone use.
61
Parents and teachers cannot watch their kids at all times because they're busy.
62
This means that kids can look at their mobile phones all day, which is bad for their eyes.
63
Now!
64
Let me introduce some evidence to support this claim.
65
A new study says that smartphones may ruin your eyesight.
66
Researchers at the University of Toledo in Ohio have found that exposure to blue light The glow emitted from most smartphones,
67
tablets, and laptops promotes the growth of poisonous molecules in your eyes leading to macular degeneration. So!
68
Ladies and gentlemen, We believe that kids should not have mobile phones because they are too harmful to kids' eyes.
69
Now, let's look at an example of the four steps in action.
70
My opponent's first argument was mobile phones are harmful to kids' eyes.
71
They explained that the blue light on the phone, along with the inability of kids to control phone use, will damage their eyes and can even lead to blindness.
72
However, I would like to challenge this argument.
73
I think this argument is flawed for two reasons: 1.
74
It is not true that kids cannot control their use of phones.
75
We believe that parents can control phone use through screen control apps.
76
We also think that kids can control their phone use and
77
that they prefer to play with friends and do things other than look at their phones.
78
So it is just not right that if kids have phones, they will look at them like zombies all day long.
79
2. Even if kids do look at mobile phones a lot, we don't think it will be that bad for kids' eyes.
80
The worst case scenario is that kids have to wear glasses.
81
But we don't believe this is such a big deal.
82
Also, reading a lot of books can hurt kids' eyes too, but we would never say that kids should not be allowed to read.
83
Therefore, we think that the effects of mobile phones on kids' eyes are not a reason kids should not have mobile phones.
84
There, we have seen an example of a rebuttal in action.
85
Once you master the four steps, I will introduce you to more refutation techniques.
86
For now, go ahead and respectfully refute each one of your opponent's arguments.
87
Good luck!
アプリをダウンロード
流暢に話すために必要なすべて
AI発音採点文ごとに採点
IPA練習すべての音をマスター
単語学習自分の単語帳を作る
単語ゲーム遊びながら覚える
同じチャンネル
B21
How to Debate (Ep 04)
Daily ConversationHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B21
The Art of Debate Note-Taking (Ep 07)
Daily ConversationUniversity Students
B21
How to Win A Debate (Ep 05)
Daily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
How to Build an Argument with Argument Alice (Ep 01)
TeensDaily Conversation
C12
How to Engage in a Debate Crossfire (Ep 10)
Daily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
How To Deliver A Speech: Volume (Ep 09)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B12
Meet The Dialogy Debate Super Team (Ep 00)
Business EnglishHigh School StudentsUniversity Students
B21
Don't Let Your Arguments Die (Ep 06)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B18
How To Deliver A Speech: Eye-Contact (Ep 08)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
B11
How To Make A Debate Speech (Ep 03)
Business EnglishInterview EnglishHigh School Students
FOR YOU
おすすめ動画
B17
39 文
HOW TO BE SOCIAL - HOW TO NEVER RUN OUT OF THINGS TO SAY
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
A24
39 文
English shadowing | Learning from Criticism | Level A2 | How to improve English
Business EnglishTeensDaily Conversation
A22
194 文
How to Argue in French (A2 | Conversations for Advanced Beginners)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B12
226 文
Don't Overthink in English, Just Listen and Repeat | Listening Practice for A2/ B1 Level
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B25
190 文
How to Talk to Your Parents When You Don't Agree With Them | B2 English Shadowing
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B110
234 文
Learn Easy English with Phrases in Daily Use | English Speaking Practice for Beginners (A2-B1)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B17
367 文
Learn How to Express Your Opinion in English | Real Conversations for Beginners (A2-B1)
TeensDaily ConversationHigh School Students
B11
188 文
Learn To Argue Effectively (1951)
Daily ConversationWorking Adults
A23
48 文
How to make suggestions in English
Business EnglishTeensDaily Conversation
A24
177 文
Repeat-After-Me Shadowing English Speaking Practice
American AccentKidsTeensDaily Conversation
コンテキストと背景
この動画は、ディベートにおける反論の重要性について教えています。スピーカーのRebuttal Rosieは、ディベートスキルを高めるために、どのようにして相手の主張に反論するかを解説しています。反論は、自分の意見を強化するだけでなく、対話を通じて学び合うための重要なプロセスです。このダイアログは、聴衆が主張を理解し、効果的に自分の考えを伝える方法を学ぶためのものです。
日常コミュニケーションのためのトップ5フレーズ
- 反論します。 - "However, I would like to challenge this argument."
- 理由は次の通りです。 - "Because."
- 結論として、私たちはこの主張が成立しないと考えます。 - "Therefore, we think that this argument does not stand."
- 私の相手はこう言っています。 - "My opponent says."
- この点について反論します。 - "I will provide reasons why the argument is flawed."
ステップバイステップ シャドーイングガイド
この動画で紹介される反論の技術をマスターするための効果的な方法は、「シャドーイング」を利用することです。英語の発音を良くするための練習として、以下のステップに従ってください。
- 動画を選ぶ：自分の興味に合ったディベートテーマの動画を選びましょう。例えば、「子供に携帯電話を持たせるべきか」というテーマの動画は良い選択です。
- 聞き取る：スピーカーが話す内容を注意深く聴き、主張のポイントを把握します。動画内で使用されるキーワードやフレーズをメモしておきましょう。
- 反論を練習する：次に、スピーカーがどのように反論を行うかを繰り返し聞き、同じように自分も反論を構築してみます。このプロセスで、英語シャドーイングを行い、発音やリズムを真似します。
- 自分の意見を追加する：反論のフレームワークを参考にしながら、自分自身の意見を加える練習をします。これにより、IELTSスピーキング対策にも役立ちます。
- 録音して確認：自分の声を録音し、再生してみて、発音や流暢さをチェックします。必要に応じて修正を加えましょう。
この方法を実践することで、YouTubeで英語学習を進めながら、自然なディベートスキルと発音を身につけることができます。
この動画の文法
話し手がよく使っている文型を、動画の実際の表現とともに紹介します。
| 文型 | 動画での表現 |
|---|---|
| 条件文 if + 節, will/would + 動詞 — 条件とその結果 | if kids have phones, they will look |
| 受動態 be + 過去分詞 — 誰がするかより、何が起きるかに焦点を当てる | is flawed · should not be allowed |
| 現在完了形 have/has + 過去分詞 — 過去の出来事が今も関係している | has built · have heard · have found |
| 「should」による助言 should + 動詞 — したほうがよいことを伝える | should not be · should not have |
シャドーイングとは？英語上達に効果的な理由
シャドーイング（Shadowing）は、もともとプロの通訳者養成プログラムで開発された言語学習法で、多言語習得者として知られるDr. Alexander Arguelles によって広く普及されました。方法はシンプルですが非常に効果的：ネイティブスピーカーの英語を聞きながら、1〜2秒の遅延で声に出してすぐに繰り返す——まるで「影（shadow）」のように話者を追いかけます。文法ドリルや受動的なリスニングと異なり、シャドーイングは脳と口の筋肉が同時にリアルタイムで英語を処理・再現することを強制します。研究により、発音精度、抑揚、リズム、連音、リスニング力、そして会話の流暢さが大幅に向上することが確認されています。IELTSスピーキング対策や自然な英語コミュニケーションを目指す方に特におすすめです。