跟读练习: Why you should "steel man" other people - 通过视频学习英语口语
选择练习模式
每种模式都会打开全屏练习室。
73 句
如果句子过短或过长,请点击 Edit 进行调整。
1
A straw man is when you simplify or exaggerate somebody's position to make it an easier target.
2
It's a target that you can then bat down with adversarial ease.
3
For example, if an atheist says that Christianity is just worshipping some bearded man in the sky, that is a straw man,
4
because I've yet to meet a Christian who would accept that as a representation of their religion.
5
Of course, if a Christian then says
6
that an atheist is somebody who does not believe in anything at all
7
or that life has no meaning or that we can just do anything that is also quite likely a straw man.
8
The problem with a straw man argument is
9
that not only does it not address somebody's actual points but it poisons the entire debate.
10
It's a kind of bad faith argument that sees conversations as a brawl
11
and that truth is just one weapon in the arsenal in a war to win at all costs.
12
But there is a better way.
13
The opposite of a straw man is a steel man.
14
This is where you not only try to represent somebody's position as faithfully as you can and with respect, but you do so in the best possible light.
15
You spend a great deal of attention double-checking that what you think somebody's position is, is what that person is actually trying to argue.
16
A great example of this in action, I think, is Alex O'Connor.
17
I've yet to see a video of his where he willfully
18
misrepresent an argument just to make it an easier position to attack.
19
In fact, he'll often spend a great deal of time trying to reach a mutual understanding of the position
20
and only then will he criticise it and only then will he do so politely.
21
In my experience, if you take the time to actually inquire about what somebody actually believes, you'll find a far greater nuance and often far greater agreement than you might have thought at the start.
22
For example, only the most dastardly and venal of politicians are actually doing it for themselves.
23
I think that most politicians want to make society and the world at least a bit better.
24
It's just that the right and the left-wing arguments about how to do that will differ.
25
It's long been pointed out that calling your political opponents the enemy
26
or evil or idiotic without saying what that means is not only childish, but it's bad for philosophy, it's bad for democracy, and it's bad for politics.
27
In his 2013 book, Intuition, Pumps, and Other Tools, the philosopher Daniel Dennett laid out four rules, one of which sounds remarkably like a steel man.
28
These are rules for a good debate, and this is what they are.
29
First and most important is that you should attempt to express your target's position so clearly, vividly, and fairly that your target says things like,
30
well, I wish I had put it like that as well.
31
For example, if somebody says to you that social media is inherently evil, you can say to them, well, do you mean that there is some content that is addictive
32
and dangerous and that young people especially shouldn't be expected to resist that addiction as much as adults?
33
Second, you should list all of the ways that you and your opponent agree on things.
34
You might say that, yes, okay, we both agree that there are aspects of social media that are dangerous, that we should have greater regulation and that the conversation should focus mostly on young people.
35
Third, you might recognize the ways in which your partner has taught you something new.
36
For example, you might say, oh, I didn't know that people today are on average on social media two hours a day.
37
Fourth and finally, only then after all of this can you go on to then try and criticize or reject that position.
38
You might say, I don't actually think that we should ban all social media.
39
In Plato's dialogues, you'll often see Socrates lining up his opponents with a steel man argument.
40
A huge part of the dialogue involves Socrates clarifying, laying out and even strengthening the other person's position.
41
For example, in the Gorgias, Socrates pauses and reframes Callicles' position about strength and domination, often making it sound more coherent than Callicles himself.
42
In Republic, when his opponent argues that justice is nothing more than the interests of the strongest, Socrates doesn't caricature it or simplify the idea.
43
Instead, he builds it up into the best version of itself, before then showing why it might be wrong.
44
Debates today are often about trying to grab the six o'clock headlines or ride the viral wave with an entertaining gotcha moment.
45
But the Socratic method was about understanding fully before disagreeing deeply because that's the spirit of the steel man.
46
Of course, Plato's dialogues are not podcast transcripts.
47
They are fictionalised accounts of Plato's version of Socrates debating Plato's version of his opponents.
48
But the fact that Plato was so willing to present rival opinions in such a strong and positive light, before then pulling them apart,
49
reveals just how far we have drifted in what we call a good discussion.
50
And in fact, this is why Plato was so suspicious about debates.
51
He called debates stupid and dangerous.
52
Because according to Plato, debates are very rarely about truth or philosophy.
53
They are about ego and pride and winning at all costs.
54
Plato often criticises the sophists who, amongst other things, were professional debaters and they would teach other members of the public how they could win at debates.
55
They taught people certain tricks and tactics to speak well, how to argue well and how to make the opponent look a bit silly.
56
Plato hated these kind of debates
57
because it reduced philosophy to a competition where both parties would try to outwit
58
and outspeak each other in a kind of game.
59
The Greeks called it heuristic and the heuristic debater would appeal to the audience.
60
They would mock their opponents.
61
They would resort to any fallacious argument they could so long as it meant they could win.
62
Plato thought that these debates were not just some harmless fun
63
because the big problem with heuristic is that those who are watching the debate confuse the winner with the truth.
64
But just because somebody has won a debate through wit and professional tactics doesn't necessarily mean that they are right.
65
For Plato, truth and philosophy is a much longer collaborative and dialectic process.
66
In many ways, the problem of strawmanning and ridiculing invented beliefs will not go away.
67
Point scoring and cheering to the crowd were present in ancient Greece
68
and they are here in modern primetime TV debates as well.
69
But the steel man is something
70
that we can try to bring back into everyday conversations with the people we interact with weekly.
71
Because what Plato and Dennett both knew is that if you are to actually grow in your beliefs, you have to see debate as a constructive act and with good intentions.
72
Debates are not adversarial opportunities to make your opponent look like an idiot.
73
They are opportunities to become better and to grow.
同频道
FOR YOU
推荐视频
本课的词汇与口语要点
这段视频共有 73 个句子、1211 个单词可供跟读。 讲话部分时长为 6:27。 说话人语速较快,每分钟约 188 个词,会出现较多连读和弱读。 82% 的单词属于英语最常用的 3,000 词,其余的词建议在练习前先学一下。
视频中的重点词汇
视频中 15 个值得学习的单词,附发音和释义:
| 单词 | 发音 | 释义 |
|---|---|---|
| opponent 名词 | /əˈpəʊ.nənt/ | 對方 /对方 |
| straw 名词 | /stɹɔ/ | 稈子 /秆子, 秸秆 |
| argue 动词 | /ˈɑɹ.ɡju/ | 辯論 /辩论, 爭辯 /争辩 |
| dialogue 名词 | /ˈdaɪəˌlɑɡ/ | 對話 /对话, 會話 /会话 |
| belief 名词 | /bɪˈliːf/ | 相信, 信心 |
| tactics 名词 | /ˈtæktɪks/ | 戰術 /战术 |
| politician 名词 | /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/ | 政治家, 從政者 /从政者 |
| criticize 动词 | /ˈkɹɪtɪsaɪz/ | 批評 /批评 |
| atheist 名词 | /ˈeɪ.θi.ɪst/ | 無神論者 /无神论者 |
| necessarily 副词 | /ˌnɛs.əˈsɛɹ.ə.li/ | 必然地, 必定地 |
| trick 名词 | /ˈtɹɪk/ | 詭計 /诡计, 騙術 /骗术 |
| everyday 形容词 | /ˈɛvɹiˌdeɪ/ | 日常的 |
| deeply 副词 | /ˈdi(ː)pli/ | 深, 深深 |
| reveal 动词 | /ɹɪˈviːl/ | 透露, 顯示 /显示 |
| rarely 副词 | /ˈɹɛəɹli/ | 很少, 罕有地 |
视频中出现的短语动词
| 单词 | 释义 |
|---|---|
| go away 动词 | 離開 /离开, 走 |
| point out 动词 | 指, 指出 |
需要注意的发音
说话人用了 10 次缩略和弱读形式,例如 doesn't, I've, you'll。请按听到的简短形式来说。
- “th” 音: atheist /ˈeɪ.θi.ɪst/, strengthen /ˈstɹɛŋ(k)θən/, faithfully /ˈfeɪθfəli/
- “sh” 和 “zh” 音: politician /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/, regulation /ˌɹɛɡjʊˈleɪʃən/, representation /ˌɹɛp.ɹə.zɛnˈteɪ.ʃən/, worship /ˈwɝ.ʃɪp/, addiction /əˈdɪkˌʃən/
- 长单词——注意重音位置: politician /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/, necessarily /ˌnɛs.əˈsɛɹ.ə.li/, regulation /ˌɹɛɡjʊˈleɪʃən/, representation /ˌɹɛp.ɹə.zɛnˈteɪ.ʃən/, collaborative /kəˈlæb.ə.ɹə.tɪv/
如何用这段视频练习
- 先完整听一遍视频,不要开口,记下不认识的单词。
- 先用 0.75 倍速逐句跟读,熟练之后再回到正常速度。
- 录下自己的声音并与原声对比,特别注意 opponent, straw, argue 这类单词。
视频中的语法
说话人最常用的结构,并附上视频中的原话:
| 结构 | 视频中的用法 |
|---|---|
| 现在完成时 have/has + 过去分词 — 过去发生但与现在仍有关联的事 | has taught · have drifted · has won |
| 被动语态 be + 过去分词 — 强调发生了什么,而不是谁做的 | been pointed · be expected · are fictionalised |
| 定语从句 who / which + 从句 — 补充说明人或事物 | somebody who does · those who are |
什么是跟读法?
跟读法 (Shadowing) 是一种有科学依据的语言学习技巧,最初开发用于专业口译员的培训,并由多语言者Alexander Arguelles博士普及。这个方法简单而强大:您在听英语母语原声的同时立即大声重复——就像是一个延迟1-2秒紧跟说话者的影子。与被动听力或语法练习不同,跟读法强迫您的大脑和口腔肌肉同时处理并模仿真实的讲话模式。研究表明它能显着提高发音准确性,语调,节奏,连读,听力理解和口语流利度——使其成为雅思口语备考和真实英语交流最有效的方法之一。





















