Pratica di Shadowing: Trump’s Post-Midterm Iran Plan Is a Loser | Episode 14 - Impara a parlare inglese con i video

Scegli una modalità di pratica

Ogni modalità apre una sala di pratica a schermo intero.

491 frasi
Se le frasi sono troppo corte o troppo lunghe, clicca su Edit per modificarle.
1
I'll make the basic argument that he has no viable option for winning this war, that the Iranians are effectively in the driver's seat.
2
The West is leading Ukraine down the Primrose path.
3
And the Israelis are executing a genocide in Gaza.
4
It's not China's fault that it wants to be powerful.
5
So if you get into trouble and you dial 911, there's nobody at the other end.
6
Hi, this is John Mearsheimer, and today is Election Day in the United States.
7
The midterm elections are finally here.
8
And President Trump has been saying before the midterms that once the midterms were over with,
9
he has decided that he's going to put an end to the Iran war,
10
that he's going to use some strategy.
11
It's not clear exactly what that strategy is to end this war once
12
and for all in unfavorable terms for the United States.
13
So what I'd like to talk about is the subject of what the possible options are
14
that he has available at this point in time after the midterms to deal with the Iran problem.
15
And before I do that, I have to talk about where we are today.
16
I want to give you a sense of what's happened between February 28th and today,
17
and then talk about what the options are for President Trump after the midterms and moving forward.
18
And I'll make the basic argument that he has no viable option for winning this war, that the Iranians are effectively in the driver's seat.
19
Of course, this is an argument I've been making for a long time, but I'd like to lay it out in detail here.
20
Now, let's talk about what's happened between February 28th and the present
21
and start by looking at the goals that the United States
22
and Israel had going into the war and then focus on what
23
Iranian goals are, what they're trying to achieve.
24
and then finally let's talk about the strategies the different strategies the United States has employed to achieve its goals
25
and then I'll switch gears as I said
26
and talk about moving forward now with regard to the goals of the United States
27
and Israel they went into the war with four main goals.
28
One was to eliminate Iran's ability to enrich uranium.
29
Uranium did not, excuse me, Iran did not have a nuclear weapon, but it had a significant nuclear enrichment capability,
30
and the United States and Israel were committed to eliminating it.
31
Second, the United States and Israel were committed to eliminating Iran's long -range ballistic missiles.
32
And given what's happened since February 28th, it's understandable why both the Americans and the Israelis wanted to eliminate those ballistic missiles.
33
The third goal was to eliminate Iran's support for Hezbollah,
34
Hamas, and the Houthis, to break the links between Iran and those three groups.
35
And the fourth goal, which I think is the most important goal, was regime change.
36
The United States and Israel were committed to changing the regime in Iran.
37
And this, of course, is why they pursued a decapitation strategy where they killed the Iranian leadership in the first day of the war.
38
And the idea was that if you got regime change, then you could achieve the other three goals quite easily.
39
I think it was almost impossible to achieve those first three goals that I described without regime change.
40
The Trump administration and the Netanyahu administration did not explicitly say that, but I think it makes common sense.
41
So anyway, those were the four goals
42
that we went into the war with it's perfectly clear
43
that we have achieved none of those goals and there's really no chance
44
that we're going to achieve any of those four goals i don't know anybody who makes the argument
45
that we are likely or there's a reasonable prospect
46
that will achieve those four goals
47
but in addition to not achieving our four goals we've ended up in a situation Thank you.
48
where the Iranians now effectively control the Strait of Hormuz.
49
Furthermore, they have destroyed, we're talking about the Iranians, large numbers of American bases in the region.
50
And they have done serious damage to America's security architecture in the Gulf.
51
Not just the bases, but our relations with our Gulf allies.
52
One could argue that the alliance structure that we had before the war is in tatters.
53
And then finally, if you look at the state of the international economy, there's all sorts of profound reasons to be concerned about where we're headed,
54
in good part because of what's happened in the Iran war.
55
So the bottom line here is when you look at what the United States
56
and Israel were interested in achieving when they started the war on February 28th,
57
not only did they not achieve any of the four goals that they set out before the war, but they've gotten themselves into,
58
or I should say they've gotten us into all sorts of
59
other kinds of trouble in addition to failing to achieve these goals.
60
Let's switch gears now and talk about the Iranians.
61
The Iranians' goals are quite clear.
62
And they were initially laid out in the Memorandum of Understanding between the United States
63
and Iran that was signed on 17 June of this year.
64
And when I say it was signed, it was signed not simply by the Iranians, but by President Trump as well.
65
And I've made the point on numerous occasions that this was basically a surrender document.
66
And when I say it's a surrender document, what I'm saying is that that deal that
67
President Trump agreed to in the Memorandum of Understanding was basically a victory for the Iranians.
68
They laid out all of their principal goals, and these were goals that if the United States accepted,
69
made it very clear that we were in effect surrendering.
70
So what were some of those goals?
71
Which, by the way, and it's just important to keep this in mind, those goals have not changed.
72
So when we talk about the memorandum of understanding and whether it's dead or not, that's largely irrelevant.
73
What's key here is the set of demands.
74
And as I say, those demands have remained the same over time.
75
There are three key economic demands that you want to keep in mind.
76
One is the Iranian frozen assets.
77
There are over $100 billion in Iranian frozen assets, and the Iranians want those frozen assets unfrozen.
78
Furthermore, they want reparations, over $300 billion in reparations for all the damage that's been done to Iran in this war.
79
And then the third big economic dimension has to do with sanctions.
80
As I'm sure all the viewers know, there are a whole slew of different sanctions on Iran, and the Iranians want those sanctions lifted.
81
And if you just think about those three demands on the part of the Iranians,
82
it's quite clear that if we were to accommodate them on those demands, that it would be a major victory for the Iranians.
83
But the Iranians have a handful of other very important demands that would be painful for the United States to swallow.
84
One is they want American military forces to leave the Persian Gulf region.
85
They also demand that there be a peace settlement, not just between the United States and Iran,
86
but also in Lebanon, where the Israelis and Hezbollah are fighting.
87
Also in Gaza, where
88
Hamas and the Israelis are fighting, and also with regard to the Houthis in Yemen.
89
So the Iranian demands involve not just the U .S.-Iran competition or the U .S.-Israel,
90
I mean, the Iran -Israel competition, but they also involve Lebanon, Gaza, and Yemen.
91
And it's also clear that the Iranians are bent on controlling the Strait of Hormuz forever
92
And placing a toll booth there
93
And this, of course, is unacceptable to the United States up to now
94
But the Houthis demand, excuse me, the Iranians demand that they have control of the Strait of Hormuz Now,
95
very importantly, the one issue that...
96
the Iranians hardly talk about is the nuclear issue.
97
And it's very important to emphasize that before February 28th,
98
the issue that the United States and Israel focused the most attention on
99
when thinking about how to deal with Iran was the nuclear issue.
100
But what's happened here is that the Iranians are slow walking the nuclear issue.
101
They're pushing it to the back of the agenda.
102
And what they want to do is they want to get all those other demands,
103
like the economic demands and the Americans out of the Persian Gulf region and so forth and so on that I described,
104
and then they're willing to deal with the nuclear issue.
105
The Americans fear, for very good reasons, that if you proceed in that fashion, the nuclear issue will never be solved.
106
And the Americans want to move the nuclear issue up to the front of the agenda.
107
But the Iranians, for smart reasons from their point of view, don't want to do that.
108
But you just want to keep in mind here that the nuclear issue is sitting out there.
109
And it's very clear the Iranians are not going to do away with nuclear enrichment.
110
Remember, that was one of the initial American goals, to eliminate Iran's nuclear enrichment capability.
111
That's not going to happen.
112
But the question is, are we going to get meaningful nuclear agreement between the two sides
113
and I think that the Iranians will play hardball on
114
that very issue and it will be difficult for the United States
115
and for Israel to get a deal
116
that they find attractive on the nuclear issue so you can see
117
that the Iranians have a set of demands
118
that are very hard for the United States to swallow and for Israel for sure and this is why after
119
President Trump signed the Memorandum of Understanding on 17 June, he ended up walking away from it.
120
He ultimately just could not accept it because, again, as I said to you, it was a surrender document. But anyway,
121
what I've tried to do here is lay out for you what our initial goals were going into the war
122
and how successful or unsuccessful we have been in terms of achieving them.
123
And then I've tried to lay out by focusing mainly on
124
the memorandum of understanding how the Iranians think about what they want to achieve once this war is over with.
125
And it's quite obvious, I'm sure, that you can see that we have very little room for bargaining
126
because their demands are so hard for us to accept and our demands are so hard for them to accept.
127
So there's very little bargaining space here.
128
But anyway, that's where we are today in terms of the goals of both sides.
129
Let me say a few words now about the different strategies
130
that we've employed to achieve our goals and to get the Iranians to give up on their goals.
131
First of all, we started with an air war, a major strategic bombing campaign on February 28th.
132
And that lasted for 40 days.
133
It ended on April 8th.
134
And it failed to achieve any of those four goals that I described at the outset of this talk.
135
And we ended that 40 -day bombing campaign because it was not succeeding, number one.
136
And number two, because we were running out of precious munitions, and we felt that if the war went on for much longer,
137
it would do serious damage to our inventory of precious weaponry.
138
So after 40 days, we called off the strategic bobbing campaign.
139
And then we went to a blockade on April 13th.
140
We've actually gone to two blockades, but the first one was on April 13th.
141
And basically what we were doing is we were switching from a reliance on air power, strategic bombing, to a reliance on naval power.
142
And here we're talking about the blockade.
143
And that was on April 13th, and that's five days after the air war ends on April 8th.
144
And the blockade goes from about April 13th up until the Memorandum of Understanding is signed on June 17th.
145
And then the blockade ends.
146
And given that the Memorandum of Understanding was signed at that point in time, it looked like the war might come to an end,
147
that it would clearly be an Iranian victory.
148
given the terms laid out in the Memorandum of Understanding.
149
But of course, as I said, that didn't happen.
150
President Trump walked away from the Memorandum of Understanding.
151
It was just unpalatable to him.
152
And then what's happened since then from a military point of view is that,
153
number one, we had two tit -for -tat campaigns.
154
These tit -for -tat campaigns are limited bombing campaigns where the Iranians hit U .S.
155
assets, the United States hits
156
Iranian assets, and then the next day you go back at it again.
157
These are very limited attacks, mainly involving ballistic missiles, cruise missiles,
158
and drones on the Iranian side and aircraft on the American side.
159
And these tit -for -tat campaigns were unsuccessful.
160
They didn't solve the problem for us.
161
The first tit -for -tat campaign went from July 8th to July 29th, and then we shut it down.
162
And the second tit -for -tat campaign went from August 30th to 9th September, September 9th, and then we shut it down.
163
And it's very important to emphasize
164
that the United States has not engaged in using military force in a serious way since September 9th.
165
Remember here, we had the strategic bombing campaign to open the war.
166
That's the 40 -day campaign.
167
Then we had the blockade.
168
And what I'm telling you now is we had two tit -for -tat campaigns.
169
This is limited bombing campaigns and neither one of them produced the desired result
170
and we stopped the second one on September 9th and there has been no tit -for -tat strategy since September 9th.
171
But what we also have done in the meantime is put a second blockade on.
172
So a second blockade was put on Iran on July 14th.
173
It was in the middle of one of those tit -for -tat campaigns.
174
We put a blockade back on Iran.
175
And that blockade, very importantly, is still on Iran.
176
And the blockade, which is a naval blockade, is obviously designed to strangle Iran economically.
177
But the blockade was not doing a sufficient job by itself.
178
So on August 24th, Scott Besant, the Secretary of the Treasury, announced this new strategy,
179
which is one where we were going to strangle the Iranian
180
economy by cutting off all of its economic intercourse with the rest of the world.
181
We were going to completely isolate it, Besant argued.
182
And Besson's argument was that the blockade, and again, we're talking about the second blockade here, the one that's put in place on July 14th,
183
the second blockade coupled with, let's call it the Besson strategy, this is the strangulation strategy,
184
that those two strategies together would force the Iranians to capitulate.
185
okay
186
and as of today that's where we are no bombing campaign no tit -for -tat campaign
187
we're on our second blockade
188
and we went to the best in strategy in conjunction with the blockade
189
because the second blockade by itself wasn't doing the trick so you needed the best in strategy as well.
190
So that's where we are today.
191
And the memorandum of understanding has been overtaken by events.
192
We have not achieved any of our goals.
193
And we don't really have, at this point, what appears to be a viable strategy for winning the war,
194
or we at least haven't had a viable strategy for winning the war or achieving our objectives up to this point.
195
So the question we now want to ask is, where are we headed?
196
Where is this all going?
197
What are the options that
198
President Trump has moving forward?
199
And let me give you the overview, and then we can talk about the specifics.
200
He basically has four options.
201
The three options that everybody's been talking about at great length over the past month or so.
202
Those three options are, number one, a military option.
203
strategic bombing campaign, a new strategic bombing campaign.
204
Number two, an economic option.
205
And the economic option is just to continue the blockade and the Besant strategy.
206
And the third option is the diplomatic option.
207
And the diplomatic option calls for negotiating with the Iranians and shutting this down.
208
In a way, it's like going back to the memorandum of understanding let's sit down work out a deal
209
and end this war diplomatically
210
so again what i'm saying to you is the first three
211
options are number one the military option number two the economic option
212
and number three the diplomatic option but over the past day
213
or two a fourth option has come onto the table
214
and that's the nuclear option and this is the argument that we would use a nuclear weapon against Pickaxe Mountain.
215
So what I'll do is I'll talk about all four of those options, starting first with the military option.
216
Again, you want to keep in mind when you think about what we're going to do moving forward, military option, economic option, diplomatic option,
217
and then the nuclear option.
218
Okay.
219
On the military option, strategic bombing,
220
What the administration is talking about doing is implementing an intensive
221
three -day bombing campaign against a wide variety of targets inside of Iran.
222
And this is much like the 40 -day bombing campaign, only it's for three days instead of 40 days.
223
Now, what are the prospects of this working?
224
The first question you want to ask yourself, which is an obvious question, is if the 40 -day bombing campaign didn't work,
225
how is the three -day bombing campaign going to work?
226
Furthermore, you all understand that the reason we're going to wage a three -day bombing campaign
227
and not another 40 -day bombing campaign is because we're short of munitions.
228
Remember, I said the reason we stopped the 40 -day bombing campaign is we were running out of precious munitions.
229
And that dictates why this is a three -day bombing campaign, an intensive three -day bombing campaign.
230
But if it didn't work with 40 days, does it make sense that it'll work with three days?
231
I don't think so.
232
Furthermore, if this is a war -winning strategy,
233
why did President Trump wait until after the election to employ it?
234
If it's a war -winning strategy, shouldn't he have used it before the election?
235
Just think about it.
236
Why is the Republican Party in trouble in the elections that are taking place today?
237
They're in trouble in good part because of the Iran war and the fact that
238
President Trump has been unable to end it well
239
if he has a war -winning military option wouldn't
240
it have made sense to use it before today rather than after today
241
and of course the reason he hasn't used it so far
242
and is unlikely to use it later after the midterms is because it doesn't work
243
The final point I would make to you on it is
244
that you want to understand that if he is to bomb Iran,
245
the Iranians have made it 100 % clear
246
that they will retaliate in a really serious way there will be an overwhelming retaliatory strike against the United States
247
and its allies if we employ this military option.
248
And the truth is that this scares the Trump administration greatly
249
because they understand that the economic consequences of Iran launching an overwhelming attack against the Gulf states,
250
against U .S assets, against
251
Israeli assets, will be very damaging for the international economy.
252
It's not like we hit Iran and then we see what happens and that's the end of the story.
253
We hit Iran and they retaliate.
254
And then the question is, what are we going to do?
255
Don't you think we'll counter escalate?
256
I think if the Iranians really pound us after we launch this three -day bombing campaign,
257
that we will have little choice but to retaliate.
258
And that is not in our interest, in part because we don't have the precious munitions to engage in another extended or protracted air campaign,
259
but also because it's not going to work.
260
In fact, it's going to be counterproductive.
261
It's going to damage the international economy even further.
262
Just very quickly, it's important to emphasize that the only people who are really in favor of this strategy,
263
this is the military option, the intensive three -day bombing campaign, are Pete Hegseth and Bibi Netanyahu,
264
and maybe Admiral Brad Cooper, who is the principal military commander for the United States in the Middle East but he's not a key player.
265
The two key players here who are in favor of this option are Benjamin Netanyahu and Pete Hegseth.
266
Then there's the economic option.
267
And basically, the economic option says,
268
let's rely on the second blockade and the Besant strategy let's just continue to rely on it.
269
And it hasn't worked yet, but it promises to work.
270
So let's rely on it.
271
And I think that people who are in favor of pursuing the economic option understand that the military option will not work.
272
In fact, the reports are, I'm not 100 % sure this is right, but the reports are that the two principal proponents of this strategy,
273
sticking to the economic option are obviously Scott Besant, but also General Cain, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
274
You would more or less expect
275
General Cain, the military figure, the key military figure in the administration, to be favoring the military option.
276
But General Cain understands that that option is a loser.
277
And therefore, General Cain, along with Scott Besant, are pushing hard to in effect maintain the status quo,
278
maintain an emphasis on the economic option.
279
Two points about that.
280
Number one, it's not working.
281
And the evidence that it's not working is that we're talking about the military option, we're talking about the diplomatic option,
282
and actually President Trump is now raising the possibility of using nuclear weapons.
283
Why?
284
Because this economic strategy isn't working.
285
And anybody who knows anything about the history of economic coercion in warfare
286
and blockades and so forth and so on fully understands that this is not going to work.
287
But let's assume that I'm wrong, and let's assume that it works.
288
Let's assume that we begin to strangle the Iranian economy.
289
The end of the question is, what do you think the Iranians are going to do?
290
You think the Iranians are just going to sit idly by?
291
I think that they'll probably try to take down the international economy with them.
292
They will retaliate.
293
They will initiate a major league war if the Besant strategy plus the blockade is successful.
294
So you're in a sort of damned if you do, damned if you don't, succeeds situation.
295
So that's not very attractive.
296
The third option, which apparently is being pushed hard by Vice President Vance
297
and Steve Whitcoff and our allies in the Gulf is the diplomatic option.
298
I think Vance, Whitcoff, and our allies understand
299
that Iran has won this war and what we have to do is cut the best possible deal.
300
We just have to put an end to this.
301
And the longer this war goes on, the worse shape we, meaning the United States and the Israelis and our Arab allies are in.
302
So let's just end it and let's do it diplomatically.
303
And by the way, I believe that Vance was the key figure in negotiating the June 17th Memorandum of Understanding.
304
You want to remember that Vance was opposed to this war from the get -go
305
and he was in favor of negotiating in June, which led, as I said, to the June 17th memorandum,
306
and he appears to be along with Steve Witkoff,
307
the two key people at the higher echelons of the administration who are in favor of the diplomatic option.
308
But as we all know,
309
there is a lot of opposition to negotiating with the Iranians and to conceding to most of their demands.
310
You want to understand, if we go down the diplomatic road, we're going to end up with something like the memorandum of understanding
311
and that is a hard pill to swallow for anybody in the administration not just president trump
312
but the bottom line here is
313
that we have not yet gone down the military road
314
that's the three -day intensive bombing campaign we are continuing the blockade and and the Besant strategy,
315
but that hasn't worked and is not likely to work.
316
And then there's the diplomatic strategy, which we may end up pursuing in the end, but we're not there yet.
317
So given this situation, the Americans, and here we're talking about the Trump administration, the Americans are desperate.
318
We're desperate to figure a way out of this.
319
And by the way, the Israelis, I believe, were even more desperate.
320
There's very little talk about this in the media, but this war is a disaster for Israel.
321
It's much less of a disaster for the United States.
322
It's going to be a defeat for the United States, but it's a defeat the United States will not have great difficulty swallowing.
323
It is a catastrophic defeat for the Israelis, and especially for Benjamin Netanyahu.
324
And unsurprising, Netanyahu is pushing very hard for us to resume the fighting.
325
And apparently, he is pushing
326
President Trump to use a nuclear weapon against Iran.
327
In other words, if the military option, the economic option, and the diplomatic option I just described don't really work, what are you going to do?
328
And if you're desperate, you begin to think about using a nuclear weapon.
329
And this is Netanyahu.
330
And it apparently is also President Trump.
331
President Trump, according to most reports, has been flirting with this idea for quite a while.
332
And he apparently has gotten quite enthusiastic in the past few days.
333
So let's examine this option.
334
Basically, what we're talking about doing is going after Pickaxe Mountain.
335
Pickaxe Mountain is a new nuclear site in Iran.
336
It is a mountain, obviously.
337
It's called Pickaxe Mountain.
338
And it's 300 feet of solid granite.
339
And there's no conventional bomb.
340
And, you know, we have some huge conventional bombs that we can drop on nuclear sites in Iran, as we did last June.
341
This is in June 2025.
342
Remember that one day we bombed Fordo and Natanz?
343
We dropped huge conventional weapons on those targets.
344
But huge conventional weapons don't buy you much against pickaxe.
345
And that's why they're talking about going after pickaxe.
346
And I believe, by the way, there's not much nuclear infrastructure inside pickaxe.
347
I think this is a threat that the Israelis have largely made up.
348
This is evidence, pickaxe is evidence that Iran is racing to get a nuclear weapon,
349
and therefore we have to take out pickaxe sooner rather than later.
350
This is the argument the Israelis are making, and of course the Trump administration is in part buying.
351
I don't believe that.
352
But anyway, apparently, Trump is thinking about going after pickaxe,
353
this one new nuclear site in Iran.
354
And they're talking about using a nuclear weapon.
355
And it's important to understand that they're talking about using just one nuclear weapon.
356
We're not talking about waging a large -scale nuclear war against Iran or attacking multiple targets in Iran with nuclear weapons.
357
We're talking about using one nuclear weapon against pickaxe.
358
And apparently, and I underline the word apparently, President Trump thinks that he can,
359
in effect, turn Pickaxe Mountain into a pile of rubble and then declare victory and get out, right?
360
This is what is sometimes referred to as a one and done operation, right?
361
We go in, we hit pickaxe with a nuclear weapon, reduce it to rubble, declare victory.
362
And that's, you know, that's the happy ending that
363
President Trump wants.
364
Let me say a few words about how you do this.
365
It's quite clear you would have to do it with a B -2 bomber.
366
And you'd have to put a B -61 -11.
367
That's, I think, the appropriate nuclear weapon you would have to use to stand a chance of destroying Pickaxe Mountain.
368
And that B -61 -11, that nuclear weapon on the B -2, would have to get right over.
369
Pickaxe Mountain, and hit Pickaxe Mountain cleanly,
370
and then hope that the nuclear weapon could cut through 300 feet of solid granite.
371
Now, how easy is this to do?
372
The answer is, it's not easy to do.
373
First of all, you got to get a B -2 bomber up over Pickaxe.
374
And the Iranians know that there's one target here.
375
There's only one target at play.
376
That's Pickaxe Mountain.
377
They know you're coming for Pickaxe Mountain.
378
And they have some air defense capabilities, which they will surely concentrate around Pickaxe.
379
And those air defense assets will be aimed at shooting down the B -2.
380
And in all likelihood, they will see the B -2 coming, even though it's a stealth bomber, because as it gets closer and closer,
381
the Iranians will be able to identify it and shoot at it.
382
So it's not clear that that B -2 bomber with the B -61 -11 on it can actually get to the target.
383
But let's assume it gets to the target.
384
It has a very big warhead.
385
This is a nuclear warhead, it is a warhead that is 40 times,
386
that's 4 -0, 40 times more powerful than Hiroshima, the bomb that we dropped on Hiroshima in 1945, August 6, 1945.
387
This bomb is 40 times more powerful.
388
But still, it is not clear, even given how powerful that bomb is, that it can turn pickaxe into rubble.
389
But let's assume that it gets, that the B -2 bomber gets to pickaxe, it drops the B -61 -11,
390
and let's assume that that B -61 -11 turns pickaxe to rubble.
391
What happens then?
392
Does that mean we won the war?
393
What do you think the Iranians are going to do?
394
You think the Iranians are going to then throw up their hands and surrender?
395
This is the end.
396
We accept the fact we're defeated.
397
Look at what you did to pickaxe.
398
I hardly think there's any chance that's going to happen.
399
They're not going to concede defeat.
400
But you say, President Trump will declare victory and leave.
401
I've never thought that was a plausible strategy.
402
When I was young and we were deeply involved in the Vietnam War, people used to say, what?
403
What President Johnson should do, or later President Nixon should do, is declare victory and leave.
404
This is not a viable strategy.
405
You can't declare victory when it's obvious that you've lost.
406
The Iranians are not going to allow us to declare victory.
407
This gets to the next point that I would make.
408
Don't you think the Iranians are going to retaliate?
409
You think the Iranians are just going to sit there
410
and let us turn pickaxe into rubble with a nuclear weapon and not retaliate?
411
I think they're going to retaliate.
412
I think they're going to retaliate in a really forceful way and cause us really serious problems.
413
So hitting pickaxe doesn't buy you very much.
414
To take this a step further,
415
there are all sorts of other consequences that come from using a nuclear weapon against Iran.
416
First of all, the reputational costs.
417
As a good realist, I think reputation is not an issue of great importance,
418
but it is of some importance in international politics.
419
And this would do enormous damage to our reputation if we were to use a nuclear weapon against Iran.
420
There's no question about that.
421
Furthermore, what are the consequences for other countries who are thinking about nuclear weapons?
422
What does this say to Vladimir Putin
423
if he finds himself in a difficult situation and he wants to use nuclear weapons against the Ukrainians or against the Europeans?
424
Don't you think the fact that we have this precedent now where
425
President Trump has used a nuclear weapon against Iran makes it more likely that
426
President Putin will not hesitate to use a nuclear weapon if he's in a difficult situation?
427
Or if India and Pakistan get into a conventional war, don't you think that one of them, and here we're talking mainly about the Pakistanis,
428
I believe, would think about using nuclear weapons?
429
Because President Trump has indicated it's legitimate to use nuclear weapons if you're in a very difficult situation in a conventional war.
430
So the precedent here would be disastrous, in my opinion.
431
It's not in our interest to create a world.
432
where people are more inclined rather than less inclined to use nuclear weapons.
433
And then there's the whole matter of nuclear proliferation.
434
This is surely going to spur nuclear proliferation.
435
I find it hard to believe that the Iranians wouldn't work overtime to get a nuclear weapon
436
if the United States hit Iran with a nuclear weapon of its own.
437
So I think that when you think about this fourth option,
438
this nuclear option, and you look carefully at what we're talking about doing, it's not clear we can pull it off.
439
In fact, I don't think we can pull it off.
440
But even if we do pull it off, it's not going to end the war on favorable terms for us.
441
And it's going to have all these other consequences that I just described.
442
So basically, where are we today?
443
Well, we have no real military option.
444
If you're talking about a three -day intensive bombing campaign, that won't work.
445
If you're talking about the economic option, as I say, that is in place now.
446
That's really the only game in town at the moment, but that's not working, and it's not likely to work.
447
Then there's the diplomatic option.
448
I think at some point we're going to have to go down that road, just like President Trump did on June 17th.
449
He signed the Memorandum of Understanding.
450
He said he didn't want to be Herbert Hoover.
451
He said we were flirting with a possible economic disaster in the international economy.
452
I think that same basic logic is going to apply again moving forward.
453
So I think that at some point we're likely to sign another agreement, because the military option and the economic option don't buy you very much.
454
And then this brings us back again to the nuclear option.
455
I don't see that as a viable alternative.
456
What is this to say?
457
This is to say that the United States has no viable option.
458
We have not had a viable option since day one.
459
And there is no hidden strategy here that I don't recognize and others don't recognize,
460
but President Trump does recognize.
461
He's desperate.
462
Bibi Netanyahu is desperate.
463
And by the way, it's that desperation that makes people like me very cautious
464
when I talk about the likelihood that we would use military force, this is the three -day bombing campaign,
465
or that we would use a nuclear weapon.
466
I think when leaders get desperate, they sometimes do foolish things.
467
And I think there is a serious chance that
468
President Netanyahu, excuse me, President Trump, being prompted by Prime Minister Netanyahu,
469
would actually try the three -day bombing campaign or use a nuclear weapon against Iran.
470
Because again, the two of them are desperate.
471
But putting the desperation argument aside, I think that it's quite clear that the United States has little choice moving forward,
472
little choice but to sign another memorandum of understanding not altogether different from what
473
President Trump signed on June 17th.
474
In fact, if you think about the circumstances on June 17th that led
475
President Trump to sign the Memorandum of Understanding, and you think about the circumstances he faces today,
476
he was in better shape back then than he is now.
477
Because if you look at how the Iranians are talking, they're talking tougher today than they were back then.
478
They're less accommodating today than they were back then.
479
The Iranians have a much clearer sense, I believe, today that they're in the driver's seat than they had back around June 17th.
480
So it's going to be very difficult to get a deal.
481
But that's, again, to say that
482
President Trump should have stuck to the deal that he signed on June 17th.
483
He didn't, of course, and we are where we are.
484
But my point is, I think the best alternative at this point is not to use a nuclear weapon against pickaxe,
485
and not to use the military option, and not to have much faith in the economic option,
486
because that's not going to work any better than these other options.
487
And really, what the smart strategy at this point in time is, is the diplomatic option.
488
That's all I have to say on this depressing subject,
489
And I hope that people found this episode enlightening and,
490
if not depressing, and I look forward to our next opportunity to talk about another important issue in international politics.
491
Thank you.

Scarica l'app

Tutto ciò che serve per parlare fluentemente

Pronuncia con IAVoto per ogni frase
Pratica IPAPadroneggia ogni suono
VocabolarioCostruisci il tuo lessico
Gioco di vocabolarioImpara giocando

Stesso Canale

FOR YOU

Video consigliato

Vocabolario e note di pronuncia per questa lezione

Questa lezione di conversazione si basa sul video “Trump’s Post-Midterm Iran Plan Is a Loser”. Le parole che ritornano più spesso: option, nuclear, Iranian, Iran, campaign. Questo video contiene 491 frasi e 6181 parole da ripetere con lo shadowing. Il parlato dura 44:57. Chi parla mantiene un ritmo costante di circa 138 parole al minuto, comodo per lo shadowing. Il 85% delle parole rientra nelle 3.000 più comuni dell’inglese; conviene studiare le altre prima di iniziare.

Vocaboli chiave di questo video

15 parole del video che vale la pena imparare, con pronuncia e significato:

ParolaPronunciaSignificato
blockade sostantivo/blɑˈkeɪd/blocco
diplomatic aggettivo/ˌdɪpləˈmætɪk/diplomatico
desperate aggettivo/ˈdɛs.p(ə.)ɹɪt/disperato
viable aggettivo/ˈvaɪəbəl/vivibile
strategic aggettivo/stɹəˈti.dʒɪk/strategico
conventional aggettivo/kənˈvɛnʃənl̩/convenzionale
eliminate verbo/ɪˈlɪm.ɪ.neɪt/eliminare
declare verbo/dɪˈklɛɚ/dichiarare
furthermore avverbio/ˈfɜː(ɹ).ðə(ɹ)ˌmɔː(ɹ)/inoltre
ally sostantivo/ˈæl.aɪ/alleato, alleata
intensive aggettivo/ɪnˈtɛnsɪv/intensivo
bomber sostantivo/ˈbɑmɚ/bombardiere
regime sostantivo/ɹəˈʒiːm/regime
missile sostantivo/ˈmɪs.aɪl/missile
surrender verbo/səˈɹɛndə(ɹ)/arrendersi, capitolare

I phrasal verb che sentirai

ParolaPronunciaSignificato
end up verboandare a finire, finire
do away with verbofare fuori
look forward to verbonon vedere l'ora
make up verbo/ˌmeɪk ˈʌp/comporsi
set out verbo/ˈsɛt‿aʊt/illustrare, esplicare
sit down verbosedersi, accomodarsi
take out verbocavare, cacciare

Frasi da ripetere

Frasi brevi e complete del video che puoi riutilizzare nella conversazione di tutti i giorni:

  • They didn't solve the problem for us.
  • Don't you think we'll counter escalate?
  • We're desperate to figure a way out of this.
  • Does that mean we won the war?
  • I believe, would think about using nuclear weapons?

La grammatica di questo video

Le strutture che chi parla usa di più, con le parole esatte del video:

StrutturaNel video
Present perfect continuous have/has been + -ing — un’azione iniziata prima e ancora in corsohas been saying · I've been making · everybody's been talking
Present perfect have/has + participio passato — un’azione passata che conta ancora adessohas decided · has employed · have achieved
Forma passiva be + participio passato — conta ciò che accade, non chi lo fawere initially laid · was signed · been done
Frasi relative who / which + frase — un’informazione in più su una persona o una cosaanybody who makes · blockade, which is · yourself, which is

Pronuncia a cui fare attenzione

Chi parla usa 108 contrazioni e forme ridotte, come we're, don't, they're. Pronunciale nella forma breve, così come le senti.

  • I suoni “th”: furthermore /ˈfɜː(ɹ).ðə(ɹ)ˌmɔː(ɹ)/, booth /buθ/, altogether /ɔl.tuˈɡɛð.ɚ/, enthusiastic /ɪnˌθjuːzɪˈæstɪk/, stealth /stɛlθ/
  • I suoni “sh” e “zh”: conventional /kənˈvɛnʃənl̩/, regime /ɹəˈʒiːm/, negotiate /nəˈɡəʊ.ʃi.eɪt/, reputation /ˌɹɛpjʊˈteɪʃən/, proliferation /pɹəˌlɪf.əˈɹeɪ.ʃən/
  • Parole lunghe — attenzione all’accento: diplomatic /ˌdɪpləˈmætɪk/, eliminate /ɪˈlɪm.ɪ.neɪt/, negotiate /nəˈɡəʊ.ʃi.eɪt/, capability /ˌkeɪ.pəˈbɪl.ɪ.ti/, reputation /ˌɹɛpjʊˈteɪʃən/

I suoni difficili per chi parla italiano:

  • /h/ — va soffiata, non è muta: likelihood /ˈlaɪklihʊd/, handful /ˈhæn(d)fʊl/, hesitate /ˈhɛz.ə.teɪt/
  • Consonante finale — senza aggiungere una vocale dopo: blockade /blɑˈkeɪd/, diplomatic /ˌdɪpləˈmætɪk/, desperate /ˈdɛs.p(ə.)ɹɪt/, strategic /stɹəˈti.dʒɪk/, eliminate /ɪˈlɪm.ɪ.neɪt/
  • /æ/ — più aperta della “e”: diplomatic /ˌdɪpləˈmætɪk/, ally /ˈæl.aɪ/, granite /ˈɡɹæn.ɪt/, examine /ɪɡˈzæmɪn/, handful /ˈhæn(d)fʊl/

Come esercitarsi con questo video

  1. Ascolta tutto il video una volta senza parlare e annota le parole che non conosci.
  2. Fai shadowing frase per frase a velocità normale, ripetendo ognuna finché il tuo ritmo coincide con quello di chi parla.
  3. Registrati e confronta con l’originale, facendo attenzione a parole come blockade, diplomatic, desperate.

Cos'è la tecnica dello Shadowing?

Shadowing è una tecnica di apprendimento delle lingue supportata da studi scientifici, originariamente sviluppata per la formazione dei traduttori professionisti e resa popolare dal poliglotta Dr. Alexander Arguelles. Il metodo è semplice ma potente: ascolti un audio in inglese di madrelingua e lo ripeti immediatamente ad alta voce — come un'ombra che segue il parlante con un ritardo di solo 1–2 secondi. A differenza dell'ascolto passivo o degli esercizi di grammatica, lo shadowing costringe il tuo cervello e i muscoli della bocca a elaborare e riprodurre simultaneamente i modelli di discorso reale. La ricerca dimostra che migliora significativamente la precisione della pronuncia, l'intonazione, il ritmo, il discorso connesso, la comprensione dell'ascolto e la fluidità del parlato — rendendolo uno dei metodi più efficaci per la preparazione alla prova di speaking dell'IELTS e per la comunicazione reale in inglese.

Tecnica dello shadowing: leggi la guida completa passo dopo passo →