Luyện nói tiếng Anh bằng Shadowing qua video: Do This if You Understand But Can't Speak

Chọn chế độ luyện tập

Mỗi chế độ mở một phòng luyện tập toàn màn hình.

123 câu
Nếu các câu quá ngắn hoặc quá dài, hãy bấm Edit để chỉnh sửa.
1
Today, I want to talk about something that I hear quite often, and that is people who say, I understand well, talking about their ability in a foreign language,
2
but I can't speak.
3
And I hear that a lot.
4
So I want to talk about what can be done
5
and what can be some strategies in order to help people who claim to understand well, to help them to speak better.
6
So it depends on your situation.
7
Obviously, if you're in a situation where you need to speak, then this is quite important.
8
If you're like me learning, you know, Arabic and Farsi as a dilettante or Turkish and I don't need to speak, then it doesn't bother me.
9
I continue with my input activities, building up my capability in the language.
10
But the reason I raised this is because the other day I met someone who is a Canadian politician who, while he's a local politician, but he lives in Ottawa for much of the year.
11
He's involved in national politics therefore he should be able to speak French and he has an opportunity to speak French.
12
But when I asked him about his ability in French, he said, well, I understand well, but I can't speak.
13
So that's kind of my starting off point on this subject.
14
So there's two sides to this.
15
One is that person or people like him have an identity which says, I can understand well, but I can't speak well.
16
That's kind of their vision of themselves.
17
Let's look at the first part of that, which is the I understand well part.
18
My first question is, you know, is that really so?
19
I've always said, you know, in learning a language, I feel I have a good level of comprehension when I can read a book, paper book from cover to cover.
20
When I can understand an audio book, when I can watch movies and understand most of it without subtitles.
21
That's real comprehension.
22
So my question is, first of all, the person, say this person who works as a political operative in Ottawa, he's familiar with certain themes,
23
certain discussions, presumably, which he hears over and over again that are relevant to his work.
24
So he says, I understand, but he doesn't really understand the language.
25
And what I'm going to say here is that when it comes to ramping up your comprehension,
26
which is extremely important, I've always said you need a solid base of comprehension you need a large passive vocabulary.
27
That's your reservoir.
28
That's your knowledge of the language that's going to enable you to ramp up your speaking ability.
29
So the first thing I say about your stated, you know, ability to comprehend the language is broaden it.
30
You have to have a wide level of comprehension.
31
It's not enough to be able to understand a limited range of content with subjects that are familiar to you.
32
You have to challenge yourself.
33
And I mean, the extreme version of this is people who believe that, you know, the teachers who say we're going to teach these scenarios, how to be a clerk in a store.
34
The thing is, it's been my experience that you cannot anticipate what kind of conversation will arise.
35
So actually you need a broader level of comprehension than that narrow level that I'm assuming this person had.
36
It's like I once met with some immigrants here in Vancouver who said, yes, I would like to be able to speak English better,
37
just well enough to communicate with my child's teacher at school
38
or if I get stopped by a policeman while driving my car.
39
Okay, you can't, you cannot anticipate what that conversation will be.
40
You cannot narrow your level of comprehension to such a small bit.
41
You have to broaden your comprehension. And in
42
that regard, you're better off to have an imperfect understanding of a broad range of subject matter where you miss 60,
43
70% of the words, but you expose yourself to, you know, hours of listening and reading.
44
And so you need that broad range of comprehension.
45
That's absolutely important.
46
Number one.
47
However, my next bit of advice is a bit contradictory.
48
And you'll see that when I talk about getting to speaking, you'll see I go the other way.
49
So when it comes to comprehension, you have to have this broad range of comprehension.
50
But then you have to deliberately narrow it down in preparation for speaking.
51
Because when you speak, you're going to use a small subset of the words that you know of your passive vocabulary.
52
And you need to have these handy that they come quickly.
53
certain structures, certain words that get you speaking.
54
You need a smaller subset.
55
And that's why when I'm learning a language, while I listen to, you know, political podcasts in Arabic or Farsi, I also spend time with the many stories.
56
I spend time even doing those political podcasts.
57
I will slow down my listening
58
and reading in order to get myself into sentence mode so that I can mine the material, pay more attention, focus more on specific words and structures.
59
So broaden the base, but at the same time, spend some time focusing in on more specific bits and pieces.
60
Maybe that's 20% of your time.
61
And that's kind of been my strategy.
62
And particularly if I'm getting ready to have a conversation in Arabic, I will then spend more time with the mini stories, even though I've heard them many, many times, because it's that repetition
63
that enables me to start to grab a hold of some of the words that I'll be able to use, hopefully, in a conversation.
64
So you say you understand and speak well.
65
Well, you have to make sure that that base of comprehension is broad.
66
Watch movies even if you only understand 60%.
67
It's that exposure to massive, a wide range of content, even imperfectly understood, which is building up your capability.
68
But then you have to go back in there and mine the nuggets, the bits and pieces.
69
So that's with regard to the I understand well.
70
Let's make sure you do understand well.
71
Now, the second part of that person's identity is that he or she can't speak.
72
We need to change that.
73
If that's your identity that you can understand, but you can't speak, that's not useful if you're in a situation where you need the language,
74
which is not my case as a dilettante language learner here in Vancouver.
75
But if you need the language for your work or for your family relations or whatever, then you can't just continue to be a person who understands and can't speak.
76
You have to change your image of yourself.
77
So here again, the strategy in my view and in my experience is a little different.
78
It's not so much a matter of starting with a widening of your range of material.
79
It's more a matter of beginning with a narrower range.
80
So when I start into speaking in, say, Persian, I will use the mini stories circling questions where I'm given the answer.
81
And so I know what the answer is.
82
I'm asked the question.
83
I'm reading in Arabic and Farsi it's very difficult and I can answer the question because I've heard the answer.
84
So it's not really a genuine, I'm not retrieving meaning.
85
I'm responding to a prompt.
86
So that's sort of the very first, that's your narrowest possible base.
87
The next would be a question, a genuine question about the content that you just finished listening to or reading.
88
And our AIBotItLink does this, asks you a question about the content that you just listened to.
89
Or you could even have it ask a question about the sentence, the specific sentence in sentence mode.
90
So you start narrow.
91
So you're dealing with a limited range of material you have to answer the question.
92
But then you want to move to where you're answering a broader range of questions.
93
Alahe, my Persian tutor, she always saves 15-20 minutes where she asks me difficult questions of history and philosophy and environment, whatever it might be.
94
And I have to really think for an answer and I have to find words to express my meaning.
95
But it's a genuine, authentic conversation.
96
So you'll progress from an almost automatic reflex answer to a question or
97
interaction to one where you are now dredging your knowledge and trying to express your ideas in the language.
98
So you go from narrow to broader.
99
And then if you're able to do that, as you gradually build up your confidence using circling questions
100
or using AI or using the sheltered conversation
101
that you have with a tutor and you start to prove to yourself
102
that actually you are a person who speaks the language now you have to change your habits you have
103
that habit of accepting that your identity is i'm someone who understands
104
but can't speak every time you conform to
105
that image being in a meeting and not interacting not speaking you are confirming
106
that identity and you have to break
107
that through habit you have to start speaking difficult at first
108
but gradually you start to create these habits where your identity becomes i'm someone who understands well
109
and speaks somewhat less well but i'm also a person who speaks the language
110
so you have to change your self-image
111
so i think that's what i would suggest don't sort of with pride say well i understand
112
but i can't speak that's not good enough you probably at some level would like to speak.
113
So you need to make sure that this is your goal.
114
I want to go through these various steps initially somewhat sheltered
115
and eventually I'm going to speak because it's important to me to speak.
116
It's important to the image that I want to have of myself in that language as someone who understands and speaks.
117
And remember every time you speak and you make mistakes you are strengthening your knowledge of the language.
118
You are engaging with the language.
119
So the fact that you make mistakes is not a negative.
120
You have to have that as a part of your identity.
121
I am someone who understands the language, not perfectly, and who speaks the language, not perfectly.
122
So I hope that's helpful.
123
Bye for now.

Tải Ứng Dụng

Mọi thứ bạn cần để nói trôi chảy

Chấm điểm AIChấm từng câu nói
Luyện IPAThành thạo mọi âm
Từ vựngMở rộng vốn từ
Game Từ vựngHọc qua chơi

Cùng kênh

FOR YOU

Video gợi ý

Từ vựng và ghi chú luyện nói cho bài học này

Video này có 123 câu và 1735 từ để luyện shadowing. Phần lời nói dài 9:29. Người nói nói nhanh, khoảng 183 từ mỗi phút, nên sẽ có nhiều chỗ nối âm và nuốt âm. 84% số từ nằm trong 3.000 từ tiếng Anh thông dụng nhất; phần còn lại nên xem trước khi luyện.

Từ vựng quan trọng trong video

15 từ ít gặp trong video, kèm phiên âm và nghĩa:

  • comprehension /ˌkɑmpɹɪˈhɛnʃn̩/ (danh từ) — sự hiểu. A thorough understanding.
  • narrow /ˈnæɹəʊ/ (tính từ) — hẹp, chật hẹp. Having a small width; not wide; having opposite edges or sides that are close, especially by comparison to length or depth.
  • habit /ˈhæb.ɪt/ (danh từ) — thói quen. An action performed on a regular basis.
  • shelter /ˈʃɛltə/ (danh từ) — chỗ che, chỗ ẩn. A place where a person or animal may find protection from the elements (especially rain, storms, or cold) sometimes as a place to sleep (such as a cave).
  • gradually /ˈɡɹæd͡ʒuəli/ (trạng từ) — dần dần. In a gradual manner; making slow progress; slowly.
  • politician /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/ (danh từ) — chính khách, nhà chính trị. One engaged in politics, especially an elected or appointed government official.
  • passive /ˈpæs.ɪv/ (tính từ) — thụ động. Being subjected to an action without producing a reaction.
  • vocabulary /vəˈkæb.jə.lə.ɹi/ (danh từ) — từ vựng. A usually alphabetized and explained collection of words e.g. of a particular field, or prepared for a specific purpose, often for learning.
  • tutor /ˈtjuːtəː/ (danh từ) — gia sư. One who teaches another (usually called a student, learner, or tutee) in a one-on-one or small-group interaction.
  • subset /ˈsʌbˌsɛt/ (danh từ) — tập hợp con, tập con. A set A such that every element of A is also an element of S.
  • audio /ˈɔ.di.oʊ/ (tính từ) — âm thanh, âm tần. Focused on audible sound, as opposed to sight.
  • helpful /ˈhɛlp.fl̩/ (tính từ) — hay giúp đỡ. Furnishing help; giving aid; useful.
  • confirm /kənˈfɝm/ (động từ) — xác nhận. To strengthen; to make firm or resolute.
  • bother /ˈbɑðɚ/ (động từ) — quấy rầy. To annoy, to disturb, to irritate; to be troublesome to, to make trouble for.
  • automatic /ˌɔː.təˈmæt.ɪk/ (tính từ) — tự động. Capable of operating without external control or intervention.

Phát âm cần chú ý

Người nói dùng 44 dạng rút gọn, ví dụ I'm, can't, you're. Hãy nói theo dạng ngắn đúng như bạn nghe.

  • Âm “th”: bother /ˈbɑðɚ/, authentic /ɔˈθɛn.tɪk/, strengthen /ˈstɹɛŋ(k)θən/
  • Âm “sh” và “zh”: comprehension /ˌkɑmpɹɪˈhɛnʃn̩/, shelter /ˈʃɛltə/, politician /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/, exposure /ɪkˈspəʊ.ʒə(ɹ)/, preparation /ˌpɹɛpəˈɹeɪʃ(ə)n/
  • Từ dài — đặt trọng âm cho đúng: politician /ˌpɑ.ləˈtɪʃ.ən/, capability /ˌkeɪ.pəˈbɪl.ɪ.ti/, vocabulary /vəˈkæb.jə.lə.ɹi/, anticipate /ænˈtɪs.ɪ.peɪt/, automatic /ˌɔː.təˈmæt.ɪk/

Cách luyện với video này

  1. Nghe hết video một lần, chưa cần nói, và ghi lại những từ bạn chưa biết.
  2. Bắt đầu ở tốc độ 0,75×, nói đuổi từng câu, rồi quay lại tốc độ bình thường khi đã quen.
  3. Ghi âm giọng mình rồi so với bản gốc, chú ý các từ như comprehension, narrow, habit.

Ngữ pháp trong video

Những cấu trúc người nói dùng nhiều nhất, kèm đúng cụm từ trong video:

Cấu trúcTrong video
Mệnh đề quan hệ who / which + mệnh đề — thêm thông tin về người hoặc vậtpeople who say · people who claim · someone who is
Thì hiện tại hoàn thành have/has + quá khứ phân từ — việc đã xảy ra nhưng còn liên quan đến hiện tạiI've always said · it's been · I've heard

Phương Pháp Shadowing Là Gì?

Shadowing là kỹ thuật học ngôn ngữ có cơ sở khoa học, ban đầu được phát triển cho chương trình đào tạo phiên dịch viên chuyên nghiệp và được phổ biến rộng rãi bởi nhà đa ngôn ngữ học Dr. Alexander Arguelles. Nguyên lý cốt lõi đơn giản nhưng cực kỳ hiệu quả: bạn nghe tiếng Anh của người bản xứ và lặp lại to ngay lập tức — như một "cái bóng" (shadow) đuổi theo người nói với độ trễ chỉ 1–2 giây. Khác với luyện ngữ pháp hay học từ vựng bị động, Shadowing buộc não bộ và cơ miệng phải đồng thời xử lý và tái tạo ngôn ngữ thực tế. Các nghiên cứu khoa học xác nhận phương pháp này cải thiện đáng kể phát âm, ngữ điệu, nhịp điệu, nối âm, kỹ năng nghe và độ lưu loát khi nói — đặc biệt hiệu quả cho người luyện IELTS Speaking và muốn giao tiếp tiếng Anh tự nhiên như người bản ngữ.

Phương pháp shadowing: đọc hướng dẫn từng bước đầy đủ →